Eye To Eye - Increasing Parent Involvement Through Collaboration A
Eye To Eye - Increasing Parent Involvement Through Collaboration A
Eye To Eye - Increasing Parent Involvement Through Collaboration A
Capstone Projects and Master's Theses Capstone Projects and Master's Theses
12-2019
Kara Gearring
California State University, Monterey Bay
Recommended Citation
Orozco-Lemus, Liliana and Gearring, Kara, "Eye to Eye: Increasing Parent Involvement Through
Collaboration and Adaptation" (2019). Capstone Projects and Master's Theses. 688.
https://digitalcommons.csumb.edu/caps_thes_all/688
This Capstone Project (Open Access) is brought to you for free and open access by the Capstone Projects and
Master's Theses at Digital Commons @ CSUMB. It has been accepted for inclusion in Capstone Projects and
Master's Theses by an authorized administrator of Digital Commons @ CSUMB. For more information, please
contact [email protected].
EYE TO EYE 1
Liliana Orozco-Lemus
EYE TO EYE 2
Abstract
The focus of this Capstone Project is on parental involvement in education and what can
be done to improve the lack of involvement. This is an important issue for school systems
because of the impact it has on a student’s academic achievement. Both teachers and parents
were interviewed to obtain the perspectives of those who are able to see the effects of a lack of
parental involvement on a student’s academic success, as well as the perspective of those who
have trouble being involved and need accommodations. The results highlighted the challenges
experienced by parents who can not afford to miss work, who struggle with communication, and
do not feel comfortable at school. Collaboration and adaptation are necessary to achieve
The Central Valley has always been home for me growing up, I grew up in a rural area. .
I attended primary and secondary school in Lindsay, California. Agriculture field work played a
big factor throughout my early childhood. My parents worked in the agriculture business for
many years, which took most of their day and most of their time. They were always working,
which led to me being raised by my oldest sister throughout my early childhood. Taking time off
from work to become involved in my schooling was something they could not afford to do.
Also, being non-english speaking parents, when most of my teachers were only English
speakers, communication between my parents and teachers was very hard. This further
Donuts with mom events, talent shows, and even back to school nights were the times
when I resented all those kids whose parents were able to come and join them for these events.
When it was parent teacher conferences, my parents were never available to make it because they
would not be back on time to meet with my teacher. So, my older sister was always the one to go
to my parent teacher conferences. When I would attend parent teacher conferences, I would see
classmates with both parents and I always felt out of place and at times unmotivated and sad.
Talent shows at school were my favorite events and the real truth is my parents never showed up
to watch me; my sister was always the one in the stands watching me. This took a toll on me
because my parents would forget about these events and they never asked me how it went. They
had little to no knowledge about my school curriculum which was very difficult to cope with at
home. There were times when I would need help with homework and they were not able to help
me, they saw that I struggled academically and they would always just mentioned to me that I
EYE TO EYE 4
needed to work harder. This was not the case, I felt like I was placed in a classroom that was
beyond my academic abilities at that time. During this time, I wished my parents’ involvement
was more active. I unfortunately never was placed in another classroom because my parents did
not understand my point of view. Lack of parental involvement took a very personal toll on me. I
began to feel very unmotivated and very insecure about my academics. My behavior and poor
academics at school became concerning to my teachers, which was when my teacher went to my
house to meet with my parents and talk to them about what was going on. They had a very long
conversation about how I was doing academically. This allowed my parents to open up to my
teacher on why they were not very involved with school. It took this extent for my parents to
finally feel the confidence to feel comfortable to be able to reach out to my teachers and become
involved in my school. Throughout my middle school until present day, my parents have been
very active with my education. During my secondary school they were very involved, they
became part of Parent and Teacher Board which they loved to be a part of. They became friends
with many of my teachers and kept in contact with them in regards to how I was doing
academically. Reflecting back to this I am thankful for their parental involvement throughout my
secondary school years, because they motivated me to want to do better and want to pursue
college.
It is never too late to Become involved in a childs’ education. Parental involvement really
affects education in many positive ways. When you have that support from home it is a different
type of motivation. You want to do better and you are always wanting to succeed in every way
possible. When my parents became very involved in my education, my grades started to improve
and I was in a better place mentally. I began advancing with my reading, which led me to read at
EYE TO EYE 5
grade level. My parents became more comfortable when they had questions regarding my
academics, which also made my teacher knowledgeable when I needed the help. They became
my motivation to want to pursue higher education, which is the reason why I attend a four year
Parent Involvement can be portrayed in many different ways. When a parent is involved
it becomes an opportunity for them to become aware of their childs’ education system they are
currently in. According to McNeal (2014), “Previous research shows inconsistent relationships
between parent involvement and academic achievement and often asks why such inconsistencies
occur.” Which he explains how parental involvement has become a problem. The lack of
parental involvement takes a toll on academic success. When a parent is not involved in the
childs’ education the student becomes unmotivated. Parental involvement becomes important
when wanting to see success in a classroom. Students are not doing well academically and lack
of parental involvement has impacted this issue greatly. All reasonings behind parental
involvement are proven to have positive impacts on academic success. (Coleman 1988, McNeal
1999) state, “Parent involvement can be described as social relations that are imbued with norms
of trust, obligation, or reciprocity”. Which they describe parental involvement as a form of social
capital. Parental involvement is described in many different ways. Parents have their own
personal way of how they portray parental involvement with their children's education. McNeal
(1999) also explains how parental involvement can be viewed in different ways. He explains
how it can be viewed as a parent and child relations, parent and parent relations, and even parent
EYE TO EYE 6
to school relations. Each portrayment of parental involvement has a different view and meaning
behind why it is considered to be parental involvement. There are also many opportunities that
come when parental involvement is seen. Positive changes are seen when parental involvement is
more common in education. Parental involvement is a factor that our educational system today is
lacking. Parents are not aware of the importance of a simple involvement may go a long way in
academics. It is affecting our students academics and it has become a very common issue.
Why is it an Issue/Opportunity
The lack of parenting involvement in school has become a concerning and recurring issue
throughout the years. There are many aspects that tie back with this problem. When a parent is
not involved with their children's school it might look like failure to attend school events, parent
teacher conferences, being active with their children's academic success. When parents fail to
attend school events most of the time it is not because they are not willing to do so. Many times
parents of our learners feel like they are not educated enough or know how to approach school
events which is the reason why they fail to attend. Some parents may even feel that the teacher
and school administration are doing their job because they are professionals and at times might
feel intimidated by the lack of knowledge in comparison to these school professionals who are
knowledgeable and trained to do their job. Finders and Lewis (1994) highlights many reasons
why parents lack involvement within schools. They mention that lack of involvement by latino
parents and low-income parents feel disenfranchised from school setting. When parents begin to
feel this way in their children's school setting it becomes an issue that is carried throughout the
years and it makes it much more difficult to become involved in the future. Parents often times
EYE TO EYE 7
feel intimidated wanting to become involved as a parent. When school administration and
teachers are not very welcoming parents see the unwelcoming environment and do not become
involved. Teachers and school administration should be capable of understanding parental point
of view on why they are not willing to be involved with school. Salin (2017) states many factors
on why parental involvement is a great issue in our educational system today. She explains
challenges that parents face, many parents have shortages of time. Often times parents have to
work to maintain a particular financial standing of the family which leads to parents not having
enough time in the day to become involved. Illiteracy is also another big factor that takes place
on the reasoning behind why parental involvement has become an issue. When a school
administration do not care or put an importance on parental involvement the parent does not
become interested in becoming involved as well. Language barrier also plays a factor on why
many parents are not involved in their childs’ education. Many times in low income districts
there is a lack of bilingual teachers which leads to parent and school communication skills. When
the parent is not able to communicate with school professionals they are not confident enough to
communicate with them which is why they decide it is easier to not become involved. When
parents do not receive a welcoming environment they are shut down which adds on to another
reason why they do not become involved. It is important to create a welcoming and friendly
spaces for our parents, which will help parental involvement in our educational system.
Increasing parental involvement in our educational system has had many techniques that
have been implemented in order to help its growth. Often times many parents are not able to
California Teachers Association (1995) implemented a Family School Partnership Act. This
California law allows parents, grandparents, and guardians to take time off from work and to
participate in their children's school activities. This act was designed to create parental
involvement in schools. It is very detailed with how many hours you are able to ask for off which
according to the article it is forty hours a year. Parent is to communicate with the employer about
time off which should eventually become approved. Under this act parents are safe from
discrimination of employment. This Family School Partnership Act will help students become
more involved and not afraid to ask for time off in order for them to become involved with their
children' school events. Often times many parents are intimidated to ask for time off because
they do not want to be discriminated, however this act is proved to help parents out of this
intimidation.
Challenges of parental involvement in education have been taken into consideration and
there have been different types of accommodations created for these challenges. Salin (n.d) talks
about why parental involvement has become a challenge and also states different reasonings on
how to improve parental involvement. In the article she states how having good communication
with parents can increase parental involvement. When people build good communication trust
begins to form which she implements that schools should have a good form of communication
with parents about the progress of their childs’ education which then they are able to provide
suggestions on how to assist their child academically in order to succeed. Throughout the article,
she also goes into detail about providing workshops for the community. Through these
workshops they will gain skills and knowledge on how to build a better relationship and become
Parental involvement can be seen in six different forms. Epstein’s (n.d) explains his type
of framework of the six different types of parental involvement. Parenting can be simply looked
as a form of parental involvement. In the article Epstein talks about how helping parents
establish a home environment where they are able to support the students. The outcome of this
type of parenting would be that parents would become more confident of their parenting and feel
support from school and other parents as well. Teachers would be able to understand the parents
background, concerns and goals. Throughout the article there are different types of forms of
these different types of parenting boost confidence in parental involvement which allows parents
to feel more confident. It is proven to increase parental involvement when adapting to parental
needs.
Increasing parental involvement in school as in previous research has a big debate behind
why it is a problem in today’s educational system. The National Center for School Engagement
(n.d) strictly focuses on increasing parental involvement. In the article they state, “the
shows that one of the most effective ways to increase student achievement is for parents to be
actively involved in the education of their children. A 2002 National Education Service study
indicates that when parents are involved, students tend to achieve more, regardless of
what parental involvement is and how it can be increased effectively. The article talks about how
parents can become involved as parents. It ties back into the Episens framework and how
communication, learning at home, volunteering and collaboration with the community are
EYE TO EYE 10
established in schools is important in order for parents to feel comfortable when becoming
involved.
Method
For this Capstone Project the researchers will investigate how parents view parent
involvement and what they think could be done to improve it. Based on an analysis of the data
and the relevant research literature, the researchers will use what they have learned to formulate
an action that responds to the focus issue in a way that inspires, informs, or involves a particular
audience.
Context
Informants.
EYE TO EYE 12
Semi-Structured Survey
Parent
4. Are there any obstacles that keep you from doing more or being more involved with your
child’s education ?
5. Is there anything else you’d like to say about being involved in your child’s education?
Procedure
Participants took a survey. All surveys will be done individually . When it is not possible to
interview participants in person, they will be invited to complete a phone interview or paper and
pencil survey of the same questions. Face-to-Face interviews will take less than one hour, be
audio-recorded (with participant consent), and take place in Seaside High School. A
semi-structured interview format will be used for face-to-face interviews, to allow for follow-up
questions to unclear, interesting or unexpected responses. All interviews/surveys will be
scheduled at the convenience of the interviewee and should take approximately 20 minutes to
complete.
Data Analysis
EYE TO EYE 13
EYE TO EYE 14
EYE TO EYE 15
EYE TO EYE 16
EYE TO EYE 17
EYE TO EYE 18
EYE TO EYE 19
EYE TO EYE 20
EYE TO EYE 21
EYE TO EYE 22
Results
For this Capstone Project, parents were surveyed on their experience on parental
involvement in the educational school system as well as what they believe can be done to
improve parental involvement. This is important because of the effects parental involvement may
have in a students academic success. It is also important because parents are aware of their
impact on their childs’ education through involvement which they should be given
accommodations if they are needed. Based on an analysis of the data and the relevant research
literature three themes emerged. Evidence-based decision making required evaluating each
potential Action Option by the following criteria: Amount of time from teachers and schools, the
level of flexibility, and the amount of time needed from parents. Based on each Action Option an
Table 1
AMOUNT OF AMOUNT OF
L TIME TIME
s in other Languages
EYE TO EYE 23
Homework
Availability Requests
[Remember, as you describe each action option below, your reader SHOULD NOT be able to
One of the most common issues mentioned by parents when it comes to being involved with
their child’s education is the language barrier. This is a pattern noticed in the data collected as
well as the research conducted. When developing a resource in other languages it should be
correlated to the demographic that lives in the area. For example, if a school is located in a
predominantly Latino/ Hispanic community the resources should be available in Spanish along :
with English. Resources include: parent workshops, newsletters, emails or even automated phone
calls. This action to involve a wider range of parents could dissolve the school and the staff’s
time because it requires planning and participation. The staff must compose resources,translate
them and then present them to parents. This option has high flexibility because it tailors to the
needs of forgein language speakers and it could be a great tool used by a variety of communities.
It provides inclusion for parents who don’t speak english in addition to building trust and
This action is meant to involve parents directly at home. By giving the student work that requires
interaction with parents, it improves communication between parent and student while also
giving the parent a glimpse into what their child is learning. This method could also lead to more
information being given about parents and family background. For example, if a teacher gave an
assignment for the student to do a family tree it could provide reason for parent and students to
communicate and learn about their history. It could also lead to learning where the child and
their family comes from, if their parents speak another language, and insight on who is in a
child’s life to communicate with. All of this information could be used to understand how a
student operates and how to connect with their parents. This option takes a moderate amount of
teachers’ time because all they have to do is create the assignment then analyze the information
given to come up with viable solutions. Flexibility is high because it allows for all students to
participate with their families and a wide range of results can come from it. The amount of parent
time needed is a lot because the action takes place at home. In order for this option to work, a
parent or guardian must be present enough to give good information for their student to hand
This last option is to allow parents the opportunity to give teachers times and days that they are
available to meet or talk on the phone about their child’s progress and/ or what they can do to
increase their student’s academic success. If a teacher hands out or emails availability requests
that parents can give back it will be easier to schedule meetings, make calls or schedule events at
EYE TO EYE 25
different times instead of consistent timeframes so the majority of parents can participate. For
instance, if most parents are available in the evenings on weekdays then create an event that is
during that time. If some parents are available in the mornings then do a morning or during
school event that parents can volunteer for or participate in. Availability requests could also
include questions about transportation and language preference. This option requires a low
amount of teacher time because all they need to do is send out the sheet to be filled out. Parents
are required to fill it out but it should not take up more than 5 minutes of their time to fill out.
Flexibility is high because the option recognizes the varying schedules and situations of parents
Conclusion
effective way of increasing parent involvement through collaboration and adaptation. One
limitation of my critical analysis is the assumption of low parent involvement rates affecting
student’s grades. It was difficult for me to find correlation between parent involvement and
student achievement through statistical analysis that was understandable and viable. This
information could have provided better insight on the importance of parent engagement and how
it affects a child’s success. I believe my assumption to be valid because one can not measure
involvement because there are so many different types that are to be considered and an
resources in other languages is a great way to be more inclusive of other backgrounds and
cultures and gives parents a sense of a school’s willingness to adapt. While it shows great effort
EYE TO EYE 26
on the school’s part, there is still the possibility that parents will not show up to workshops
because of time constraints or parents that do not know how to operate some technology that
requires them to open emails or access the school website to look at newsletters or progress
This option is perfect for trying to get parents to be apart of their child’s learning experience. It
could prove to be ineffective because one can not monitor what goes on at home so a student
could just be doing the work themselves or a parent could be doing it for them. This option
encourages involvement but can not guarantee it and a teacher can not know if parent
I believe that Option 3: is best because it is an easy and quick way to get a better
understanding of a parent and their needs. The option can be altered to get more information. A
teacher could ask the best days and times they are available along with updated contact info
(phone number, email, address,etc.), language preference, transportation most frequently used,
events they would want to be involved with, and if they want to help in the classroom. This
option also shows that the school willing to reach out and work with individual parents based on
their needs and availability and It gives parents a welcome mat into their student’s academic
lives. The questionnaire could be emailed on a google form or handed out on paper for parents
who are not technologically inclined. One limitation of this option is that one may not get results
if parents do not send the questionnaire back or are not given sufficient amount of time to fill it
out. I suggest giving it to parents before the school year starts and on the first day of school
through email and handouts. It will take time to make copies and decide what information is
needed most but the task is not overly time consuming for teachers or parents and is flexible for
EYE TO EYE 27
parents to fill out during their individual free time. I firmly believe this option saves time and
the educational field today there is a lack of parental involvement. Many parents often have
different reasonings why they are not involved in their child’s education. Throughout the
semester we had to privilege to partner up with UC Santa Cruz GEAR-UP Family involvement
program. This program is in a high school located in a low income community. The program
works with parents and provides workshops and resources available for them to become familiar
with different ways to become more involved in their child’s education. After becoming familiar
with this program we came across three different action options. We surveyed parents questions
regarding parental involvement and what they believe can be done to improve it. After looking at
our results our first action option was workshops/resources in different languages. The second
option was to design parent and student interactive homework. Our third option was a parent
availability request. We decided to implement our third option which was the parent availability
request. The reasoning for choosing that option was because it was low in amount of teacher and
school time as well as amount of parent time put into this option. It would be the most
The images below are screenshots of the Availability Request form we created for our Action
flexibility with the parent and school to create events that accommodated best to parent time and
need.
Image 1 Image 2
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScaD4joHmFi1v9OuJtS5zndNIMo6Sip38nBWH7U
Jx4XFG-ChQ/viewform?usp=pp_url
EYE TO EYE 29
We created an availability request form through google forms as well as a form in paper
based form. It would be a very simple task, parents would fill out this availability form that
would be sent out with their child home. The availability form would consist of questions
regarding the parents availability. It would also ask questions along the line of transportation,
language preference, name, best contact information etc. The child would bring this form back to
school and the school administration would read the information on this form which will help
them create parent school events according to parental response of the availability form. This
action option will help increase parental involvement in children's education. It was successful in
a way that we were able to create the google form but we did not receive as much information as
we would have liked to. Throughout our action option we found ourselves needing to make
modifications in the way that we would have parents access this form in a secure manner. I now
know that getting parents to fill out forms is actually much harder than expected. We realized
that you have to bribe parents to want to do it and also finding ways that will get you a
guaranteed response back from parents. I learned a lot about myself through this action. I see
myself using this option in my future career, parental involvement is very important to me which
Liberal Studies MLOs, the required coursework, and this Action Research Project has
gain knowledge on Liberal Studies MLOs. We gained community experience through being able
EYE TO EYE 30
to partner up with a program that serves our community. Through this experience we were able
to gain a lot of useful tools and new knowledge that we will be able to use in our future careers.
We practiced a lot of research through the required coursework which allowed us to become
more knowledgeable on parental involvement. Our community is very diverse which was
something we were able to see in the eyes of education. Many parents come from familiar
background like my parents which helped me comprehend more of a reasoning why my parents
were not involved in my education growing up. Each MLO has been covered through the
required coursework in Liberal Studies. After reflecting new knowledge that I have gained and
connecting it to these five MLOs it is only right for me to begin thinking of the next steps that
will be taken in order to become the professional that I envision being. I aspire to use the skills I
have learned through these MLOs and implementing them in my future classroom. I am able to
become more aware of the different backgrounds that students will come from and being able to
adapt to them. I am a developing educator that will provide my future students with the skills
10 References
https://www.humanandhopeassociation.org/challenges-parental-involvement-education/.
https://www.cta.org/Parents-and-Community/Family-Involvement/school/Family-School-P
artnership-Act.aspx.
Finders , M., & Lewis, C. (n.d.). Why Some Parents Don't Come to School. Retrieved from
http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational-leadership/may94/vol51/num08/Why-Som
e-Parents-Don't-Come-to-School.aspx.
https://www.humanandhopeassociation.org/challenges-parental-involvement-education/.
Dwyer, D. J., & Hecht, J. B. (1992). Minimal Parental Involvement . Retrieved from
http://www.adi.org/journal/ss01/chapters/Chapter20-Dwyer&Hecht.pdf.
McNeal Jr., R. B. (2014). Parent Involvement, Academic Achievement and the Role of Student
https://files.eric.ed.gov/fulltext/EJ1053945.pdf.
https://www.sps186.org/downloads/table/13040/6TypesJ.Epstien.pdf.
http://schoolengagement.org/school-engagement-services/increasing-parental-involvement/.
Epstein, J. L., & Salinas, K. C. (2004, May). Partnering with Families and Communities .