Obstetrics V13 Obstetric Emergencies Chapter Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage 1682196492
Obstetrics V13 Obstetric Emergencies Chapter Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage 1682196492
Obstetrics V13 Obstetric Emergencies Chapter Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage 1682196492
409603 22/04/2023
This chapter should be cited as follows:
Mehdi M, Chandraharan E, Glob. libr. women's med.,
ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603
Chapter
Diagnosis and
Management of Shock in
Postpartum Hemorrhage
First published: February 2021
AUTHORS
DEFINITION
Hemorrhagic shock refers to a decreased tissue perfusion, leading to insu cient nutrient and oxygen delivery that are
required for the normal functioning of cells as a result of hypovolemia secondary to massive hemorrhage. Reduced
tissue perfusion, which occurs when the demand for oxygen exceeds that of supply, may lead to the development of
metabolic acidosis and multiorgan failure.
PATHOPHYSIOLOGY
Massive blood loss results in the loss of circulating volume, which may trigger an array of compensatory responses
(Figure 1), which are important for systematically diverting the available oxygenated blood away from “non-essential”
organs in order to conserve circulating volume for the vital organs. This ‘centralization’ is essential for survival. Acute
hemorrhage results in reduced pulse pressure as a result of an intense peripheral vasoconstriction and reduced cardiac
output, and these hemodynamic changes are detected by the volume receptors in the atrium and the baroreceptors
located within the aortic arch. When the blood volume is reduced, neural re exes bring about an increased sympathetic
activation in the heart and the rest of the organs. This leads to an intense vasoconstriction, as well as redistribution of
blood ow away from “non-essential” organs, such as the kidneys, gastrointestinal tract, and the skin to the central
organs, coupled with an increase in the heart rate.1
Neural compensatory mechanisms are accompanied by endocrine responses to maintain circulating blood volume.
Corticotropin-releasing hormone (CRH) is immediately released, and this activates the release of beta-endorphin and
glucocorticoid. Vasopressin is also released from the posterior pituitary gland, leading to retention of water at the distal
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 1 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
tubules. When mean arterial pressure is reduced, the renin–angiotensin–aldosterone system is activated, which ensures
water retention, and sodium resorption. Hyperglycemia frequently develops in acute hemorrhage because growth
hormone and glucagon increase the production of glucose through glycogenolysis and gluconeogenesis. In addition,
circulating catecholamines slow down the release and activity of insulin and this causes a rise in the plasma glucose. 1
E ective cerebral autoregulation ensures that the cerebral blood ow is kept constant despite the fall in the systemic
mean arterial blood pressure. The kidneys are capable of tolerating up to a 90% drop in entire blood circulation for a
short period of time. Intestinal blood ow is drastically reduced by splanchnic vasoconstriction after the circulatory
volume is signi cantly decreased. Timely and e ective resuscitation may prevent injury to organs because these
adaptive, compensatory mechanisms are e cient in preserving the hemodynamic stability and perfusion to the vital
organs, until decompensation sets in the loss of both oxygen-carrying capacity and circulating blood volume leading to
the development of hemorrhagic shock. In obstetrics, massive antepartum hemorrhage (APH) and postpartum
hemorrhage (PPH) may lead to hemorrhagic shock.
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 2 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
Figure 1 shows neural and endocrine compensatory mechanisms in massive hemorrhage.
Secondary PPH occurs after 24 h of delivery (usually after 5–6 days of birth) until 12 weeks, and is commonly caused by
retained placenta and membranes with or without infection (endometritis).
Operative delivery
Anticoagulant use
• Coagulation defects
Massive hemorrhage (<30% of blood volume)
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 3 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
shock.3
PHYSIOLOGY
Blood volume of a non-pregnant healthy adult is approximately 7.5% of body weight, or 70 ml/kg. Table 2 highlights the
parameters in a non-pregnant and pregnant woman. The non-pregnant adult cardiac output is 4–6 l/min, and systemic
vascular resistance is 10–5 mmHg/min. The blood volume of the mother increases to 40% more than before pregnancy
by the 30th week of gestation, with an associated smaller (20–30%) rise in red cell volume. Cardiac output rises to 50%
above the pre-pregnancy level at 24th week. There is more variation in systemic blood pressure for a healthy pregnancy,
whereby it slightly drops in the rst and second trimesters and resumes to pre-pregnancy levels by the last trimester.
Resting heart rate escalates to 15–20 bpm more than the pre-pregnant state. In addition to these cardiovascular changes
in pregnancy, there are other changes that take place in the circulation and the autoregulation of intravascular
capacities. Both these changes in uence the response of the body to blood loss. Examples comprise a diminished
response to angiotensin II, which partially may be as a result of a high cardiac noradrenaline turnover, a low tolerance to
postural changes and a high production of nitric oxide.3
Pregnancy-related diseases and their treatment a ect the body’s ability to compensate for volume loss, the observed
clinical signs of hypovolemia and the circulating volume, and this in uence remains until the early postpartum period.
When compared to the normal peripartum state, for instance, pre-eclampsia can cause a contracted arterial blood
volume secondary to the loss of intravascular volume as a result of endothelial damage. The vascular response is
impaired, and routinely administered drugs such as magnesium and antihypertensive drugs may compromise the
capacity of the body to create compensatory vasoconstriction to combat hemorrhage. There is a failure to achieve a low
systemic vascular resistance as well as in high plasma volume in pre-eclampsia because of insu cient trophoblastic
invasion of the uterine spiral arteries. Therefore, women with pre-eclampsia have a high possibility of developing
pulmonary edema during volume replacement because of left ventricular dysfunction, hypoalbuminemia, and high
capillary permeability.
Normal expected blood loss after birth ranges from 750 to 1000 ml for a cesarean section and 300 to 500 ml for vaginal
deliveries. Apart from blood loss from the body, a considerable volume of blood is transmitted into the systemic
circulation immediately after birth, which is commonly called the “autotransfusion e ect”. About 80% increase in cardiac
output occurs as a result and this continues in healthy women during the postpartum period, progressively returning to
non-pregnant levels by 2–3 weeks.4
Cardiovascular
Respiratory
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 4 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
Tidal volume Increased 40% 700 ml
Conditions Change during pregnancy Normal pregnancy values
Minute ventilation Increased 40% 10.5 l/min
Hematologic
Renal
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 5 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
and circulation.
The classi cation of hemorrhage into four classes has been derived according to clinical signs and percentage of blood
loss. (Table 3).
Mental status Slightly anxious Mildly anxious Anxious, confused Confused, lethargic
MANAGEMENT
There are two main components in treatment of patients with PPH:
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 6 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
2. Identification and management of the underlying hemorrhage cause(s).
These components are separately discussed. It should be noted that successful PPH management necessitates that both
components should be dealt with systematically and simultaneously.
After exhausting all the compensating mechanisms that are meant to maintain the blood pressure and tissue perfusion,
there is often a dramatic fall in the systolic blood. Rapid replacement of blood volume through a large-bore peripheral
access (i.e. 14 or 16 G cannula) as well as surgical intervention and medical therapies should be implemented.
The moment massive hemorrhage is diagnosed, replacement of the lost circulating blood volume has to begin, prior to
the development of signs of considerable hypovolemia. Essential primary measures should include supplemental oxygen,
at least 2 large-bore (14 G) peripheral intravenous access, and an early and thorough clinical assessment. Requesting
timely help from senior members of the team, including the wider multi-disciplinary team comprising of hematology,
anesthesia and intensive care is paramount.
Algorithms may assist in managing the PPH systematically in a sequential and logical manner. An example of such an
algorithm is hemOSTASIS (illustrated in Table 4).5 It has been reported that using this algorithm ‘hemOSTASIS’ was
associated with excellent outcomes as well as a low rate of Peripartum Hysterectomy.
The principal underlying aim of volume replacement during and following massive PPH is to restore and maintain tissue
perfusion to all organs of the body with the aim of maintaining cellular viability and function. Despite the fact that the
rst focus has to be on restoration of the general clinical shock indicators, the clinician has to ensure that multiorgan
failure is averted. Even though all the ‘clinical parameters’ are restored, a woman may still be in ‘shock’ on the basis of
reduced perfusion to tissues and organs. The term often applied in describing the state where conventional
hemodynamic features have been turned to normal is compensated shock. In spite of replacement of adequate volume,
a patient might develop numerous organ dysfunctions, which leads to morbidity and mortality.
When controlling bleeding, replenishing of the lost blood volume has to go on simultaneously. Surgical and medical
attempts to manage bleeding should not be hindered by extended volume resuscitation regardless of continuing blood
loss. Volume resuscitation must be aimed at restoration of circulating blood volume as well as returning the hemostatic
functions and oxygen-carrying capacity to an e ective level, although subnormal.
Measuring the serum lactate and base de cit should assess tissues under perfusion, which may continue even after
evident hemodynamic restoration. E orts regarding measuring and enhancing tissue perfusion have to continue until all
such strictures come back to normal.
For oxygen-carrying capacity as well as deliverance to the tissues, it is very important to maintain hemoglobin
concentration. Titrating uid as well as blood products to a precise level of hemoglobin in a rapidly bleeding patient is
not easy. For those with ischemic heart disease, a hemoglobin level of 7–8 g/dl seems to be a suitable threshold in
transfusing in the intensive care population, with achievable advantage for a higher level of 9 g/dl. It is reasonable to
focus on the high end of the target range during resuscitation from hemorrhagic shock, since it can easily drift down. In
the actively bleeding patient, a target of 10 g/dl has been recommended for a reasonable purpose. On the other hand,
when it comes to PPH, the goal is a two-fold cessation of the bleeding in addition to restoring the level of hemoglobin. In
women who refuse blood and blood products, an early recourse to a peripartum hysterectomy and/or interventional
radiological procedures such as pelvic arterial embolization may help save lives.
A Assess (ABC) and resuscitate (crystalloids 2 L, colloids 1 L, oxygen by mask (15 l/min)
E Establish etiology (atonic, traumatic, coagulopathy or trauma), ensure availability of blood and administer
ecbolics (drugs that contract the uterus – oxytocin, ergometrine or syntometrine intramuscularly)
M Massage uterus
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 7 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
T Tamponade balloon/uterine packing- after exclusion of tissue and trauma
Coagulation disorders are mutually consequences of and predisposing factors for massive PPH. Bleeding diatheses from
platelet dysfunction, a coagulopathy or thrombocytopenia may be caused by pre-existing disease, a pregnancy-related
disorder, like eclampsia, or treatment like aspirin. There is also immense blood loss, both thrombocytopenia and
coagulopathy through consumption (i.e. the “washout phenomenon”) and dilution (i.e. “dilutional coagulopathy”).
Proposed algorithm “SHOCK” for the management of hemorrhagic shock (see Table 5).
S Seek HELP (senior obstetric and midwifery/nursing input, anesthetists, intensive care physicians and
hematologists)
Secure ABC and resuscitate with intravenous uids (crystalloids 2 L and /or colloids) and send urgent blood
investigations including full blood count (FBC), urea and electrolytes, coagulation pro le and blood lactate,
urgently
Shock Index – accurately estimate the degree of visible and invisible (i.e. intra-peritoneal or bleeding into
paravaginal tissue) blood loss
H Correct Hypervolemia – rapid infusion of intravenous uids and monitor urine output
Correct Hypoxia – 10–15 L/min of oxygen by mask immediately and ensure urgent blood transfusion (consider O
negative uncross-matched blood) and monitor oxygen zaturation and vital signs
Correct Hypo/hyperkalemia and other metabolic dysfunction – check electrolytes and blood sugar
O Organ support – ensures adequate perfusion and oxygenation to vital organs and shift to intensive care unit if
multi-organ support is needed.
Observations – continuously monitor vital signs and consider arterial line for blood pressure and CVP line
C Identify and correct the Cause of hemorrhagic shock (4 ‘T’s) concurrently as hemorrhagic shock is managed.
Administer tranexamic acid 1 g IV
Diagnose and manage Complications such as Sheehan’s syndrome and acute renal failure
K Keep clear and legible Records and Keep the woman and her family informed.
Initial assessment
The risk factors of a patient as well as the events that lead to the diagnosis of PPH might explain a primary etiology.
However, the understanding that many cases are as a result of uterine atony, and the necessity of being systematic
contends for a stepwise, and logical approach to assessment and management. The patient’s status, the response to rst
management steps and the severity of ongoing bleeding severity determine the activation of the massive PPH protocol.
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 8 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
Uterine atony
Uterine tone and size should be assessed by massaging the uterus and placing a hand on the uterine fundus, so that
any clots that might have been collected in the vagina and uterus are expelled. If the uterus is not well contracted and
boggy, strong uterine massage and oxytocin should be started. Usually 20 IU in 500 ml of crystalloid solution
(intravenously) is used, with the rate of dosage adjusted to the response (usual rate 250 ml/h). Intramuscular
administration of 10 IU brings about a slower onset of action (3–7 min), although with an e ect that is more long lasting
(up to 60 min). Emptying the bladder is recommended for the facilitation of uterine contraction and further therapeutic
management.3
In a situation where the uterus is still atonic, bimanual massage should be commenced. This stimulates uterine
contractions and brings about mechanical constriction of myometrial blood vessels. The following are steps of uterine
massage: rst, a gloved hand is inserted into vagina, then it is pushed up against the uterus’ body; second, the other
hand is placed above the uterine fundus on the abdomen, and then the posterior uterine wall should be compress
against the hand in vagina. Likewise, bimanual compression assists in reducing the ongoing bleeding, and as a result
facilitates rapid resuscitation. For this to be operational, the compression has to go on for approximately 10 minutes that
would enable the blood clot in the uterine vessels.
In case the uterus is still atonic regardless of oxytocin and bimanual massage, other uterotonic agents such as
Syntometrine and carbetocin should be used. Syntometrine can be given intravenously or intramuscularly (1 ampule –
5 IU of syntocinon and 500 mg of ergometrine). In women with hypertension and cardiac disease, syntometrine is
contraindicated. Carbetocin is synthetic oxytocin receptors in the myometrium that is similar to oxytocin. The major
bene t of Carbetocin over oxytocin is that it has a four-fold longer uterotonic activity, which lasts for 2 hours.3
In the treatment of PPH, misoprostol may be used, especially in a low resource setting: 400 μg in powdered form
sublingually or three 20-μg tablets are orally administered. In a dose of 250 μg, prostaglandin F2a is administered IM;
the highest number of doses is eight (15 min apart) (2 mg). In women with cardiac disease and asthma, it is
contraindicated.3
Tranexamic acid 1–2 g hourly (intravenously) will reduce brinolysis as well as stabilizing the clot in the uterus vessels. It
is best applied when prostaglandin is required and in a situation when the bleeding persist regardless of oxytocin.
When uterotonic medications (prostaglandin, oxytocin and ergometrine) and uterine massage have all been unsuccessful
in controling PPH, recombinant factor VIIa (rFVIIa) is applied, although it is very expensive. The dose that is
recommended is 40–6-mg/kg, which is administered intravenously. This drug is clinically used as a last resort owing to its
expense and side-e ects, especially stroke and myocardial infarction.
For women who have failed to respond to treatment with uterotonics, or in a situation where uterotonics are not
available, using an intrauterine balloon is recommended in the treatment of PPH as a result of uterine atony. Uterine
balloon tamponade may be a life-saving procedure and the reported complications such as uterine perforation and
infection are rare. Balloon tamponade should be used subsequent to an atonic PPH and vaginal delivery that is not
responding to uterotonics, preceding surgical interventions or interventional radiology procedures, e.g. B-Lynch suture,
hysterectomy or iliac artery ligation or uterine artery embolization. It can be inserted after or during cesarean section as
well as in a woman with vaginal birth after earlier cesarean section with PPH and after exclusion of rupture.6
When the tamponade test fails to arrest hemorrhage, laparotomy should be considered. Patient’s parity, amount of
blood loss, hemodynamic status and continuing bleeding have to be taken into consideration before trying any
conservative surgical measures. It is essential to avoid “too little being done too late”. Conservative surgical measures
involve compression sutures, which consist of classical B-Lynch, or horizontal or vertical brace sutures with the use of
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 9 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
made and the needle is passed via this opening. The needle is medially passed via the lower uterine myometrium,
approximately 2 cm from the lateral margin, therefore getting a decent “bite” before tying the sutures. On the other side,
a similar procedure is performed.
If bleeding persists, internal iliac artery ligation is optional. This necessitates a surgeon who is experienced and well
knowledgeable of the lateral pelvic wall anatomy. It has been found that bilateral internal artery ligation reduces the
pulse pressure by up to 85% in arteries distal to the ligation.
Interventional radiology
Interventional radiology can be undertaken for women who are not intensely compromised or severely bleeding. The
rates of success may be as high as 85–95% and the whole procedure may take approximately 1 hour. Uterine artery
embolization assists in preserving future fertility and evading radical procedures
SUMMARY
Management of massive obstetric hemorrhage and resultant hemorrhagic shock involves timely recognition and
appropriate management. Algorithms such as ‘hemOSTASIS’ and ‘SHOCK’ may help clinicians to ensure a systematic,
logical and stepwise approach in managing this acute obstetric emergency. Multidisciplinary input and continuous case
reviews and learning from adverse events as well as morbidity and mortality reports are essential to avoid serious
maternal morbidity and mortality.
PRACTICE RECOMMENDATIONS
• A more precise “clinical” definition of massive hemorrhage should be “any blood loss, which results in
hemodynamic instability and endangers the life of a woman”.
• Shock refers to a reduction in tissue perfusion, which is insufficient to meet the metabolic requirements of
tissues and organs. Insufficient blood flow may be clinically noticeable as the development of lactic
acidosis, altered mental status, oliguria, pallor, tachycardia, or all these changes combination.
• Young healthy individuals can compensate for the loss of significant volumes from the circulation with few
visible clinical signs. This may pose a diagnostic dilemma and may result in a delay in diagnosis of massive
obstetric hemorrhage.
• In a pregnant population, obstetric shock index (OSI) >1 (that is pulse rate > systolic blood pressure) has
been shown to increase the likelihood of blood transfusion. OSI may, therefore, act as an adjunct in
minimizing errors as a result of visual estimation of blood loss.
• The use of logical, stepwise algorithms such hemOSTASIS (Table 4) have been reported to be associated
with excellent outcomes as well as a low rate of peripartum hysterectomy.
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 10 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
The author(s) of this chapter declare that they have no interests that con ict with the contents of the chapter.
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 11 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
REFERENCES
FURTHER READING
1 Chandraharan E, Arulkumaran S. Surgical aspects of postpartum haemorrhage. Review Article. Best Pract Res Clin Obstet Gynaecol
2008;22(6):1089–102.
2 Krishna A, Chandraharan E. Management of Massive Obstetric Haemorrhage. Invited Article. Women’s Health Reviews.Current Women's
Health Reviews 2011;7(2):136–142(7).
3 Varatharajan L, Chandraharan E, Sutton J, et al. Outcome of the management of massive postpartum hemorrhage using the algorithm
"HEMOSTASIS". Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2011;113(2):152–4.
4 Le Bas A, Chandraharan E, Addei A, et al. Use of the "obstetric shock index" as an adjunct in identifying signi cant blood loss in patients
with massive postpartum hemorrhage. Int J Gynaecol Obstet 2014;124(3):253–5.
5 Pinas Carillo A, Chandraharan E. Management of massive postpartum hemorrhage and management of coagulopathy. Review Article.
Obstet Gynecol Reprod Med 2014;24(10):291–5.
6 Chandraharan E, Krishna A. Diagnosis and management of postpartum haemorrhage. BMJ 2017;358:j3875.
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 12 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
STUDY ASSESSMENT
Question 1
(a) The primary PPH (postpartum hemorrhage) refers to the blood loss of at least 500 ml, from the genital tract within
48 hours of delivery (more than 1000 ml in cesarean section) True
(b) Secondary PPH refers to an excessive blood loss from 24 hours to 12 weeks after birth
True
(c) Massive PPH refers to a blood loss of more than 2000 ml (>30% of the blood volume)
True
(d) In women with low BMI (body mass index) or women who are severely anemic, even the loss of 250 ml of blood
may cause hemodynamic instability and rapid decompensation True
Question 2
(a) Acute hemorrhage results in reduced pulse pressure as a result of an intense peripheral vasoconstriction and
reduced cardiac output True
(b) Women with pre-eclampsia have a high possibility of developing pulmonary edema during volume replacement
True
(c) Cardiac output rises to 25% above the pre-pregnancy level at 24th week
True
(d) Systolic blood pressure usually drops only after the loss of approximately 30% of blood volume
True
Question 3
Question 4
Which of the following statements is incorrect as regards assessment of estimated blood loss during PPH?
(a) Shock Index (SI) together with Rule of 30 are important tools that may aid clinicians in an emergency to determine
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 13 of 14
The Continuous Textbook of Women\'s Medicine Series ISSN: 1756-2228; DOI 10.3843/GLOWM.409603 22/04/2023
the amount of blood loss and the degree of hemodynamic instability True
Question 5
Question 6
(d) Subtotal hysterectomy should be performed in women with postpartum hemorrhage due to placenta previa
invading the cervix True
Obstetrics - V13 - Obstetric emergencies - Chapter - Diagnosis and Management of Shock in Postpartum Hemorrhage Page 14 of 14