Synthesis Characterization and Bioevaluation of Pa
Synthesis Characterization and Bioevaluation of Pa
Synthesis Characterization and Bioevaluation of Pa
Synthesis, characterization
and bioevaluation of partially stabilized
cements for medical applications
Research Article
2
Department of Microbiology and Immunology,
Faculty of Biology, University of Bucharest,
060101 Bucharest, Romania
Abstract: Materials for dental applications, i.e., white mineral trioxide aggregate (WMTA) and partial stabilized cements (PSC) were obtained
using the sol-gel method. The presence of ZnO or/and CaF2 additions in the starting mixture induced changes in the composition,
morphology and grindability of PSCs as compared with WMTA. The presence of foreign elements (Zn or F) in the crystalline lattice of
mineralogical phases, increased their grindability. Thermal analysis (TG&DTA) was used to assess the kinetics of hydration process in
binding systems based on WMTA/PSCs. The presence of foreign elements in PSCs systems increases the reactivity vs. water of these
materials and consequently, the compressive strength developed after 28 days of hardening at 37°C are higher as compared with WMTA.
The in vitro bioevaluation results (trypan blue staining, eukaryotic cells cycle assay by flowcytometry) accounted for a high biocompatibilty
of the obtained materials demonstrating their potential use for biomedical applications.
Keywords: Partial stabilized cement • Sol-gel synthesis • Hydration and hardening processes • Compressive strength • Cytotoxicity- eukaryotic
cell cycle stages
© Versita Sp. z o.o.
* E-mail: [email protected]
1657
Synthesis, characterization and bioevaluation
of partially stabilized cements for medical applications
been developed [5]. This material consists of a silicate The materials used for the sol-gel synthesis were:
cement in which transition elements (Co, Cr and Zn) are calcium nitrate (Ca(NO3)2•4H2O, >99.0%, Reag.
added in order to create crystal defects and high energy ACS., Sigma-Aldrrich, Germany), aluminium nitrate
state which favours the decrease of the cement setting (Al(NO3)3•9H2O, >98.5%, Reag. ACS, Sigma-Aldrrich,
time. Germany), tetraethyl-orthosilicate (C6H16O3Si, 99.0%,
The synthesis of C3S, C2S and C3A via solid-state Reag. ACS., Sigma-Aldrrich, Germany- TEOS), zinc
reactions consists in the sintering of stoichiometric nitrate (Zn(NO3)2•6H2O, >98%, Reag. ACS., Sigma-
mixtures of oxides or carbonates at high temperatures Aldrrich, Germany) and calcium fluoride (CaF2,
for long time [9,10]. Moreover, this type of synthesis >99.9%, Reag. ACS., Sigma-Aldrrich, Germany). These
implies multiple consecutive thermal treatments and materials were dosed in order to obtain a stoichiometric
intermediary material grinding; these operations mixture corresponding to the compositions presented in
could lead to introduction of material impurities and Table 1.
consequently to its colour and other properties change. The main steps of the sol-gel synthesis were the
Therefore the sol-gel method was used to synthesize following: calcium nitrate, followed by aluminium nitrate,
C2S [13,14], C3A [15], GMTA [16] and WMTA [17,18]. The zinc nitrate or/and calcium fluoride were dissolved in
main advantages of this synthesis route (as compared 180 mL water, under magnetic stirring, until a clear
with the conventional one) are lower thermal treatment solution was obtained. TEOS was hydrolysed using a
temperatures and higher purity of the resulted products molar ratio TEOS: water of 1:4. The two solutions were
[13-18]. mixed and continuously stirred at 60°C for 4 hours, and
Preliminary results showed the possibility to then kept the next 96 hours at 70°C, to facilitate the water
synthesize WMTA with good in vitro biocompatibility evaporation and to accelerate the polycondensation
by a sol gel route [18]. In order to obtain materials with reaction, resulting in the formation of a viscous gel. This
high reactivity vs. water and consequently with a faster gel was then dried at 120°C for 420 hours and the final
development of mechanical strength, two methods were product was a white powder [18].
studied: i) preparation of accelerated portland cement The powders were pressed in pellets and thermally
(APC) by WMTA mixing with CaCl2 addition [19] and ii) treated at 1350°C, for 30 minutes. Rapid cooling was
synthesis by sol-gel route of PSCs with ZnO, CaF2 or performed in air.
Zn+ CaF2 mixtures. The choice of these two additions in In order to obtain the cements these materials were
PSC synthesis was based on the fact that Zn, in small grinded for two hours in a laboratory planetary mill.
quantities is generally harmless to human body and is a
key element for bone development [5,17,20], while CaF2 2.2. Materials analysis
is a well known fluxing agent [21,22] and is a caries The white powders resulted by gel drying were
preventing agent [23,24]. analysed by thermal analysis (DTA/TG/DTG) and by
In this paper we present the influence of ZnO or/ X-ray diffraction analysis (XRD). Thermal analysis
and CaF2 additions on the composition, morphology was performed using a Shimadzu DTG-TA-60, in the
and grindability of PSCs synthesized by a sol gel route, 20-1000°C temperature range, with a heating rate
as well as on the hydration and hardening processes of 10°C min-1, in air. X-ray diffraction analysis was
and properties developed by these materials, including performed using a Shimadzu XRD 6000 diffractometer,
in vitro cytotoxicity and influence of the eukaryotic cell with Ni-filtered CuKa radiation (l=1.5406 Å), with scan
cycle. step of 0.02° and counting time of 0.6 s step-1.
The elemental composition of materials (WMTA
and PSCs) obtained from the thermal treatment was
2. Experimental procedure assessed by X ray fluorescence using a Rigaku ZSX
Primus XRF machine. The material’s compositions
2.1. Synthesis of WMTA and PSCs presented in Table 2 are similar to those calculated
One WMTA composition (K) and four PSC compositions based on the designed mineralogical composition
(KZ, KZF and KF) – Table 1, were synthesized using the (Table 1).
sol-gel route, previously described by Voicu et al. [18]. The mineralogical composition was assessed
The advantage of this method, as compared with the by XRD and their morphology by scanning electron
one proposed by Wang et al. [16] is the use of a lower microscopy (SEM) using a HITACHI S2600N equipment.
temperature thermal treatment (1350°C) of shorter The specimens for SEM analysis were covered with a
duration (30 minutes). thin silver layer deposited by dc-sputtering.
1658
G. Voicu et al.
Material 3CaO·SiO2 (C3S) (%) 2CaO·SiO2 (C2S)(%) 3CaO·Al2O3 (C3A) (%) ZnO (%) CaF2 (%)
WMTA K 70 24 6 - -
KZ 70 24 6 1 -
KF 70 24 6 - 0.5
Composition K KZ KZF KF
(%wt.)
Clinker
Calculated
F 0 0 0.24 0.24
Zn 0 0.80 0.80 0
Assessed by XRF
F 0 0 0.24 0.24
Zn 0 0.79 0.80 0
1659
Synthesis, characterization and bioevaluation
of partially stabilized cements for medical applications
25
TG (%) 3. Results and discussion
b DTA, TG and DTG curves of the white powders resulting
20 from gel drying are presented in Figs.1 and 2.
On the DTG curve of WMTA (K), are present the
following processes, correlated with the information
15
provided by DTA curve: calcium and aluminium nitrates
dehydration and decomposition – effect with maximum
10 at 331°C, followed by calcium hydroxide decomposition
– effect with maximum at 497°C, anhydrous Ca(NO3)2
5 KZF melting (effect with maximum at 564°C) and finally
the effect from 849°C attributed to the decomposition
K of calcium carbonate, formed by partial carbonation of
0
calcium hydroxide [9,10,30,31].
0 200 400 600 800 1000
The DTA curves of KZ and KF (Fig. 2a) present
DTG (m g/s) K similar effects in the range of 400-700°C. A higher weight
0
loss recorded in this temperature range (see also TG –
849
602
-0,02
JCPDS [27-0087]) in the dry gels is confirmed also
331
-0,025
by the XRD spectra- Fig. 3. CaCO3 assessed on DTA
curves cannot be identified with certainty on the XRD
386
c
-0,03
spectra, most probably due to its low quantity (under
0 200 400 600 800 1000 XRD detection limit).
Tem p.(oC)
The free lime values assessed on WMTA and PSCs
Figure 1. DTA (a), TG (b) and DTG (c) curves of dry gel (white
obtained by thermal treatment at 1350°C for 30 minutes
powders) of K and KZF.
are presented in Table 3. Accepted free lime values are
onto a microscope slide and covered with a coverslip. not greater than 2% as it adversely affects the quality of
Nonviable cells became blue-stained. At least 200 cells cement [9]; as it can be seen from Table 3, all values are
were counted per treatment [26,27]. well below this limit.
The XRD spectra of WMTA and PSCs are presented
2.3.3. Cell cycle in Fig. 4. The main mineralogical compounds formed by
For cell cycle analysis, HDC or HCT8 cell lines were thermal treatment are: calcium silicates (3CaO•SiO2 -
treated with 100 µg cement mL-1, and maintained for JCPDS [42-0551], JCPDS [76-0623], JCPDS [31-0301]
1660
G. Voicu et al.
Specimen K KZ KZF KF
* assessed on materials thermally treated at 1350oC for 30 minutes; ** assessed on cement pastes hardened for 28 days at 37oC
DTA uV TG (%)
50 25
a b
0
KF 20
-50 62
655
KZ 15
KZ
560
647
-100
582
10
-150
KF
574
5
-200
590
-250 0
0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 200 400 600 800 1000
Tem p (oC) Temp.(oC)
Figure 2. DTA (a) and TG (b) curves of dry gels (white powders) of KZ and KF.
1661
Synthesis, characterization and bioevaluation
of partially stabilized cements for medical applications
5000 A - 3CaO.SiO2;
A,B
B - 2CaO.SiO2;
A,B
4500 C- 3CaO.Al2O3;
A
A
A
4000
A
A,B
A
C
C
B
KF
A
A
A
C
B
3500
Intensity (counts)
3000
2500
KZF
2000
1500
KZ
1000
500
K
0
14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 58
2 q (Degrees)
Figure 4. The XRD spectra of materials obtained by thermal treatment at 1350°C for 30 minutes.
900
K -1350
800 KZ -1350
KZF - 1350
700 KF - 1350
Intensity (counts)
600
500
400
300
200
100
51 51,25 51,5 51,75 52 52,25 52,5 52,75 53
2 q (Degrees)
be explained by the incorporation of foreign elements in of crystalline anhydrous phases (C3S, C2S and C3A),
the silicates and aluminate structures, thus affecting the as well as of portlandite (calcium hydroxide), the main
microsymmetry and electrostatic relations, the chemical crystalline product formed by calcium silicates hydration.
bonds or/and coordination of ions in the structure [33]. The small amount of calcium carbonate present in the
The increase of grindability is important in connection pastes hydrated for 28 days is formed by portlandite
with both material reactivity vs. water as well as its carbonation, its sensitivity to CO2 being well known
aesthetical properties – the degree of whiteness of the [9,30].
material increases with the increase of its fineness. The thermal analysis can provide quantitative
The hydration and hardening processes in WMTA information regarding both crystalline hydrates
and PSCs systems were assessed by XRD and DTA/ (portlandite and calcium aluminates hydrates) as well
TG analysis on pastes hydrated for 28 days. The as poorly crystalline hydrates such as calcium silicates
XRD spectra presented in Fig. 8 show the presence hydrates (C-S-H) [9,10,30]. The DTA and TG curves
1662
G. Voicu et al.
(a) (b)
(c) (d)
(e) (f)
(g) (h)
Figure 6. SEM micrographs of: K - a and b; KZ – c and d; KZF - e and f; KF – g and h.
1663
Synthesis, characterization and bioevaluation
of partially stabilized cements for medical applications
d
c
b
a
Figure 7. Rosin-Rammler-Sperling diagram of materials grinded for 30 minutes in similar conditions: a- K; b-KZF, c-KZ; d-KF.
4000
A, CH
A, B,CC
CH
CH
CH
A, B
3500
B
A
Intensity (counts)
KF 28 d.
3000
2500
KZF 28 d.
2000
1500
K 28 d.
1000
500
KZ 28 d.
0
15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60
2 q (Degrees)
Figure 8. XRD spectra of pastes hydrated 28 days.
DTA uV TG (%)
60
a 29
40 b
20
K 28 d. 27
0
25
-20
-40 685
142 23
KZ 28 d.
70 856
-60 657
21
-80 KZ 28 d.
-100 19 K 28 d.
-120
487 17
-140
455
-160 15
0 200 400 600 800 1000 0 200 400 600 800 1000
Temp.(oC) Temp.(oC)
Figure 9. DTA (a) and TG (b) curves of K and KZ pastes hydrated 28 days.
1664
G. Voicu et al.
TG (%)
29
b
27
25
23
21
KZF 28d.
19
17 KF 28 d.
15
0 200 400 600 800 1000
Temp.(oC)
Figure 10. DTA (a) and TG (b) curves of KZF and KF pastes hydrated 28 days.
100
(a) 100
(b)
90 90
80 80
70 DHC-Control 70 HCT8- Control
60 60
K,3d K,3d
% 50 % 50
KZ,3d KZ,3d
40 40
KZF,3d KZF,3d
30 30
KF,3d KF,3d
20 20
10 10
0 0
Go/G1 S G2/M Go/G1 S G2/M
Figure 11. Influence of WMTA (K) and PSC (KZ, KZF and KF) pastes hydrated for 3 days on the cellular cycle phases of: a – DHC; b- HCT 8 cells.
recorded on pastes hydrated for 28 days are presented of hydration processes as compared with WMTA (K
in Figs. 9 and 10. Three endo-effects could be seen on specimen). The higher reactivity vs. water of PSCs, as
DTA curve: compared with WMTA, is the direct consequence of the
- the large effect from 70-82°C and the shoulder from modification of crystalline structure, morphology and
142-164°C are most probably due to the superposition grindability induced by the ZnO and CaF2 additions.
of the following processes: loss of humidity and water The compressive strength of PSCs specimens
bound in calcium silicates hydrates (C-S-H) and calcium are higher than those recorded for WMTA (see
aluminate hydrates; Table 3), which is in good agreement with the information
- the endo-effect from 455-487°C is due to the obtained by DTA&TG.
portlandite dehydration, and The dye exclusion test was used to determine the
- the large endo-effect from 657-685°C (and the number of viable cells present in a cell suspension after
shoulder at 856-852°C) is attributed to the decomposition 24 hours treatment with the obtained cements (pastes
of CaCO3, with different crystallinity degrees, formed by hydrated 3 and 28 days). This test is based on the
Ca(OH)2 carbonation during specimens preparation and principle that live cells possess intact cell membranes
curing. that exclude certain dyes, such as trypan blue, eosin,
The results presented in Table 4 for the PSCs (KZ, or propidium iodide, whereas dead cells do not, so that
KZF and KF), show that the weight loss values recorded these substances accumulate inside the cells [31].
between 20-1000oC are higher when compared The cell cytotoxicity was calculated from the tripan
with WMTA (K). Also, calculated portlandite content blue assay on two cellular cell lines, i.e., HCT8 and
considering (or not) carbonation influence, is higher in DHC. The cytotoxicity induced by the tested compounds
PSCs specimens, suggesting an increase of the kinetics on the two cellular lines was reduced, ranging from 7%
1665
Synthesis, characterization and bioevaluation
of partially stabilized cements for medical applications
Table 4.Weight losses recorded on TG curves and calculated Ca(OH)2 content for pastes hydrated for 28 days.
Specimen Weight loss in temperature (oC) range: Ca(OH)2 content* (%) Corrected Ca(OH)2 content** (%)
20-1000 400-575 575-1000
* calculated based on the weight loss recorded between 400-575°C; ** calculated considering also Ca(OH)2 converted in CaCO3 (based on weight loss
between 575-1000°C)
100
(a) 100
(b)
90 90
80 80
70 DHC-control 70 HCT8-control
60 60
K,28d K,28d
% 50 % 50
KZ,28d KZ,28d
40 40
KZF,28d KZF,28d
30 30
KF,28d KF,28d
20 20
10 10
0 0
Go/G1 S G2/M Go/G1 S G2/M
Figure 12. Influence of WMTA (K) and PSC (KZ, KZF and KF) pastes hydrated for 28 days on the cellular cycle phases of: a – DHC; b- HCT 8 cells.
in case of HCT8 to 15% in case of DHC line. However, composition, morphology and grindability of PSCs as
no significant difference was observed between the 3 compared with WMTA.
and 28 days hydrated pastes. For PSCs, the increase of C3S crystallite size and
The eukaryotic cell cycle consists of two basic the shifting of its XRD peaks (as compared with WMTA),
stages: interphase and mitosis (M). The interphase has suggests the presence of foreign elements (Zn or/and
three stages called Gap 1 (G1), Synthesis (S), and Gap F) in the C3S crystal lattice with positive influence on
2 (G2). In the G1 phase, the cell is growing, replicating the materials grindability; the increase of grindability is
cytoplasmic organelles and preparing for replication of important in connection with both material reactivity vs.
its DNA, which is synthesized during S phase. During water as well as its aesthetical properties. The degree of
the G2 phase cells are preparing for division, which whiteness increases with the increase of fineness.
occurs in the M phase of the eukaryotic cell cycle. The Thermal analysis (TG&DTA) showed an increase
influence of different substances on the eukaryotic cell of the hydration rate in the binding systems with PSCs
faith might be cell cycle phase-dependent, which is a (as compared with WMTA) with direct consequences
reason why this test is used for the in vitro assessment on the mechanical strength of synthesised materials.
of the cytotoxicity. Compressive strength increases of 55-68% were
With respect to the influence of the tested substances recorded after 28 days of hardening at 37°C for the
on the cellular cycle of the two lines, no significant studied PSCs as compared with WMTA.
changes were observed in the two tested cellular lines The in vitro bioassays results demonstrate a high
on the pastes hydrated for 3 days (Fig. 11) and for biocompatibilty of the obtained materials demonstrating
28 days (Fig. 12). their potential for biomedical applications.
4. Conclusions Acknowledgements
The results presented in this paper show that white This paper is supported by the Sectoral Operational
mineral trioxide aggregate (WMTA) and partial Programme Human Resources Development,
stabilized cements (PSC) can be synthesized by sol-gel financed from the European Social Fund and by the
method. The presence of ZnO or/and CaF2 additions Romanian Government under the contract number
in the starting mixture determines the modification of POSDRU/89/1.5/S/64109.
1666
G. Voicu et al.
References
[1] M. Torabinejad, T.F. Watson, T.R. Pitt Ford, [19] G. Voicu, A.I. Bădănoiu, E. Andronescu, C. Bleotu,
J. Endod. 19, 591 (1993) Rev. Chim. 63, 1031 (2012)
[2] S.J. Lee, M. Monsef, M. Torabinejad, J. Endod. 19, [20] W-H. Wang, F-H. Lin, Y-L. Lee, C-P. Lin , J. Biomed.
541 (1993) Mater. Res. 81A, 195 (2007)
[3] J. Camilleri et al., Dent. Mater. 21, 297 (2005) [21] I. Teoreanu, T. van Huynh, S. Stoleriu, Rev. Roum.
[4] H.W. Roberts, J.M. Toth, D.W. Berzis, D.G. Charlton, Chim. 48, 947 (2003)
Dent. Mater. 24, 149 (2008) [22] L. Kamici, A. Seimenon-Masseron, A. Ghomari,
[5] F.H. Lin, W.H. Wang, C.P. Lin, Biomaterials 24, 219 Z. Derriche, C.R. Chimie. 9, 154 (2006)
(2003) [23] H.U.V. Gerth, T. Dammaschke, E. Schafer,
[6] T.R.P. Ford, D.J. McKendrey, Oral Surg. Oral Med. H. Zuchner, Dent. Mater. 23, 1521 (2007)
Oral Pathol. 79, 756 (1995) [24] H.T. Dean, Publ. Health. Rep. 53, 1443 (1938)
[7] S.K. Vasudev, B.R. Goel, S. Tyagi, Endodont. 15, [25] Romanian Standard, SR EN 196-2:2006, Methods
12 (2003) of testing cement - Part 2: Chemical analysis of
[8] S.J. Song, F.K. Mante, W.J. Romanov, S. Kim, cement (2006) (in Romanian)
OOOOE(Oral Surg. Oral Med. Oral Pathol. Oral [26] A.M. Grumezescu, A.M. Holban, E. Andronescu,
Radiol. Endod.) 102, 809 (2006) A. Ficai, C. Bleotu, M.C. Chifiriuc, Lett. Appl.
[9] H.F.W. Taylor, Cement Chemistry (Academic Press, NanoBioScience. 1, 77 (2012)
London, 1997) [27] C. Saviuc, A.M. Grumezescu, C. Bleotu, A. Holban,
[10] M. Georgescu, A. Bădănoiu, Cement Concrete C. Chifiriuc, P. Balaure, V. Lazar, Biointerface Res.
Comp.19, 295 (1997) in App. Chem. 1, 111 (2011)
[11] S. Asgary, M. Parirokh, M.J. Eghbal, S. Stone, [28] A.M. Grumezescu, E. Andronescu, A. Ficai,
F. Brink, J. Mater. Sci Mater. Med. 17, 187 (2006) C. Bleotu, M.C. Chifiriuc, Biointerface Res. in App.
[12] T. Dammaschke, H.U.V. Gerth, H. Züchner, Chem. 2, 438 (2012)
E. Schäfer, Dent. Mater. 21, 731 (2005) [29] O. Banu, C. Bleotu, M.C. Chifiriuc, B. Savu,
[13] D. Stephan, P. Wihelm, Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem. 630, G. Stanciu, C. Antal, M. Alexandrescu, V. Lazǎr,
1477 (2004) Biointerface Res. in App. Chem. 1, 72 (2011)
[14] G. Voicu, C.D. Ghiţulică, E. Dinu, E. Andronescu, [30] A. Bădănoiu, J. Paceagiu, G. Voicu, J. Therm. Anal.
Rev. Rom. Mater. 41, 229 (2011) Calorim. 103, 879 (2011)
[15] G. Voicu, C.D. Ghiţulică, E. Andronescu, Mater. [31] A. Migdal-Mikuli, J. Hetmanczyk, L. Hetmanczyk,
Characterization, 73, 89 (2012) J. Therm. Anal. Calorim. 89, 499 (2007)
[16] W-H. Wang, Y-L. Lee, C-P. Lin, F.-H. Lin, J. Biomed. [32] H.P. Klug, L.E. Alexander, (Eds.), X-Ray Diffraction
Mater. Res. 85A, 964(2008) procedures for polycrystalline and amorphous
[17] F. Ndong, S. Sadhasivam, F-H. Lin, S. Savitha, materials (John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1974)
W-H. Wang, C-P. Lin, International Endod. J. 45, 687
557 (2012) [33] L. Opoczy, V. Gavel, Int. J. Miner. Process. 74,
[18] G. Voicu, A.I Bădănoiu, C.D. Ghiţulică, S129 (2004)
E. Andronescu, Digest J. Nanomat. Biostruct. 7, [34] W Strober, Current Protocols in Immunology,
1639 (2012) A.3B.1–A.3B.2 (2001)
1667