Case Studies in Business Ethics and Corporate Governance

Assignment-I Full marks-30 CASE STUDY
Duplicating software for friends, co-workers or even for business has become a widespread practice. All software programs are protected by copyright laws and duplicating them is an offence. How, then, has making illegal copies become such a common and accepted practice in peoples homes and places of work? Part of the answer revolves around the issue that software isnt like some other intellectual property. Intellectual property is that which is developed by someone and is attributable directly to the thinking process. Software is different from a book in that anyone can easily copy it-and an exact replication is achievable. Another reason is related to cultural differences. People dont see copy as stealing. People dont find anything wrong in making a video copy of a hit feature film and selling it or hiring out. People defend their behavior by saying: Everybody does it! I wont get caught! Or no one really loses! The same issue of copyright is involved in the famous Napster case in America. Napster is an online service that allows computer users to share high-quality digital copies (MP3s) of music recordings via the internet. The San Mateo-based company doesnt actually store the recordings on its own computers, but instead provides an index of all the songs available on the computers of members currently logged on to the service. Napster, therefore, functions as a sort of clearing house that members can log on to, search by artist or song title, and identify where songs of their interest are so and download them from another users hard drive. Napster has become one of the most popular sites on the internet, claiming some 15 million users in little more than a year. Indeed, so many students were downloading songs from Napster, that many universities were forced to block the site from their systems in order to regain bandwidth. Napsters service has been almost as controversial as it has been popular. Barely a year after its launch,
it was sued by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), which represents major recording companies such as Universal Music, BMG, Sony Music, Warner Music Group, and EMI. The RIAA claimed by allowing users to swap music recordings for free, Napsters service violated copyright laws. It also sought an injunction to stop the downloading of copyrighted songs owned by its members as well as damages for lost revenue. It argued that song swapping via Napster and similar firms has cost the music industry more than $300 million in lost sales. A few months after the RIAA lawsuit was filed, Metallica, a heavy metal band, and rap star Dr. Dre filed separate lawsuits accusing Napster of copyright infringement and racketeering. Lars Ulrich, Metallicas drummer, told a senate committee that Napster users are basically stealing from the band every time they download one of its songs. The 1998 Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) grants immunity to Internet Service Providers for the actions of their customers. Napster attorneys argued that the company has broad protection from copyright claims because it functions like a search engine rather than having direct involvement with music swapping. However, according to the legal community, Napster does not take the legal steps required of search engines in dealing with copyright violations. Despites its claim, Napster was found guilty of direct infringement of the RIAAs musical recordings. To date, the service has not been shut down, because doing so could violate the rights of artists who have given Napster permission to trade their music. However, the company was required to block all songs on a list of 5,000 provided by the RIAA. Questions:
1. Do
you believe that there is nothing wrong in copying software, music or a video film? [8] should have control over intellectual property- the artists or distributors of their work? How did the legal system answer this question? [8]
2. Based on the facts of the Napster case, who do you think
3. Copying of software, music and films is very common in India.
Is it due to our socio-economic factor? Discuss. [7]

4. As a manager, what guidelines could you establish to direct
your employees behaviors regarding copying software? [7]
Assignment-II Full marks-30

Each question carries equal marks. Attempt all. 1. Explain the Life Insurance Contract. 2. State any two differences between the term plan and the whole life plan. 3. Is mortality a consideration in life insurance underwriting? 4. Explain contract of indemnity. 5. Under which condition does one need to prove insurable interest to buy a life insurance policy?
Business Ethics Assignments given on 27/08/2011 Last date of submission- 15/09/2011 Faculty member: Pradeep Kumar Gupta Course: Ex-MBA III Semester 2010-2012 Batch

Case Studies in Business Ethics and Corporate Governance

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Case Studies in Business Ethics and Corporate Governance

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Case Studies in Business Ethics and Corporate Governance

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

What are the main issues discussed around copyright and intellectual property?

What arguments did Napster make in its defense against the RIAA lawsuit?

Assignment-I Full marks-30 CASE STUDY

2. Based on the facts of the Napster case, who do you think

3. Copying of software, music and films is very common in India.

Is it due to our socio-economic factor? Discuss. [7]

your employees behaviors regarding copying software? [7]

Assignment-II Full marks-30

You might also like