Advances in Green Energy Systems and Smart Grid
Advances in Green Energy Systems and Smart Grid
Advances in Green Energy Systems and Smart Grid
Jianhua Zhang
Minyou Chen
Zhile Yang
Qun Niu (Eds.)
123
Communications
in Computer and Information Science 925
Commenced Publication in 2007
Founding and Former Series Editors:
Phoebe Chen, Alfredo Cuzzocrea, Xiaoyong Du, Orhun Kara, Ting Liu,
Dominik Ślęzak, and Xiaokang Yang
Editorial Board
Simone Diniz Junqueira Barbosa
Pontifical Catholic University of Rio de Janeiro (PUC-Rio),
Rio de Janeiro, Brazil
Joaquim Filipe
Polytechnic Institute of Setúbal, Setúbal, Portugal
Igor Kotenko
St. Petersburg Institute for Informatics and Automation of the Russian
Academy of Sciences, St. Petersburg, Russia
Krishna M. Sivalingam
Indian Institute of Technology Madras, Chennai, India
Takashi Washio
Osaka University, Osaka, Japan
Junsong Yuan
University at Buffalo, The State University of New York, Buffalo, USA
Lizhu Zhou
Tsinghua University, Beijing, China
More information about this series at http://www.springer.com/series/7899
Kang Li Jianhua Zhang
•
123
Editors
Kang Li Zhile Yang
The University of Leeds Shenzhen Institute of Advanced Technology
Leeds Chinese Academy of Sciences
UK Shenzhen
China
Jianhua Zhang
North China Electric Power University Qun Niu
Beijing Shanghai University
China Shanghai
China
Minyou Chen
Chongqing University
Chongqing
China
This Springer imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd.
The registered company address is: 152 Beach Road, #21-01/04 Gateway East, Singapore 189721,
Singapore
Preface
This book constitutes the proceedings of the 2018 International Conference on Intel-
ligent Manufacturing and Internet of Things (IMIOT 2018) and International Confer-
ence on Intelligent Computing for Sustainable Energy and Environment (ICSEE 2018),
which were held during September 21–23, in Chongqing, China. These two interna-
tional conference series aim to bring together international researchers and practitioners
in the fields of advanced methods for intelligent manufacturing and Internet of Things
as well as advanced theory and methodologies of intelligent computing and their
engineering applications in sustainable energy and environment. The new conference
series IMIOT is jointly organized with the well-established ICSEE conference series,
under the auspices of the newly formed UK-China University Consortium in Engi-
neering Education and Research, with an initial focus on intelligent manufacturing and
sustainable energy.
At IMIOT 2018 and ICSEE 2018, technical exchanges within the research com-
munity took the form of keynote speeches, panel discussions, as well as oral and poster
presentations. In particular, two workshops series, namely the Workshop on Smart
Energy Systems and Electric Vehicles and the Workshop on Communication and
Control for Distributed Networked Systems, were held again in parallel with
IMIOT 2018 and ICSEE 2018, focusing on the two recent hot topics of the integration
of electric vehicles with the smart grid, and distributed networked systems for the
Internet of Things.
The IMIOT 2018 and ICSEE 2018 conferences received 386 submissions from over
50 different universities, research institutions, and companies from both China and UK.
All papers went through a rigorous peer review procedure and each paper received at
least three review reports. Based on the review reports, the Program Committee finally
selected 135 high-quality papers for presentation at the IMIOT 2018 and ICSEE 2018.
These papers cover 22 topics and are included in three volumes of the CCIS series,
published by Springer. This volume of CCIS includes 30 papers covering 5 relevant
topics.
Located at the upstream Yangtze basin, Chongqing constitutes the most important
metropolitan area in the southwest of China. It has a glorious history and culture and
serves as a major manufacturing center and transportation hub. Chongqing is also
well-known for its spicy food and hotpot, attracting tourists and gourmets from around
the world. In addition to academic exchanges, participants were treated to a series of
social events, including receptions and networking sessions, which served to build new
connections, foster friendships, and forge collaborations. The organizers of
IMIOT 2018 and ICSEE 2018 would like to acknowledge the enormous contribution
of the Advisory Committee, who provided guidance and advice, the Program Com-
mittee and the numerous referees for their efforts in reviewing and soliciting the papers,
and the Publication Committee for their editorial work. We would also like to thank the
editorial team from Springer for their support and guidance. Particular thanks are of
VI Preface
course due to all the authors, as without their high-quality submissions and presenta-
tions the conferences would not have been successful.
Finally, we would like to express our gratitude to our sponsors and organizers, listed
on the following pages.
Honorary Chairs
Fusheng Pan Chongqing Science and Technology Society/Chongqing
University, China
Shilong Wang Chongqing University, China
Mark Price Queen’s University Belfast, UK
General Chairs
Ming Kim Lim Chongqing University, China
Kang Li Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Local Chairs
Xuda Qin Tianjin University, China
Fuji Wang Dalian University of Technology, China
Yingguang Li Nanjing University of Aeronautics and Astronautics, China
Adam Clare University of Nottingham, UK
Weidong Chen Shanghai Jiaotong University, China
Rui Xiao Southeast University, China
Furong Li Bath University, UK
Min-Sen Chiu National University of Singapore, Singapore
Petros Aristidou University of Leeds, UK
Jinliang Ding Northeastern University, China
Bing Liu University of Birmingham, UK
Shan Gao Southeast University, China
Mingcong Deng Tokyo University of Agriculture and Technology, Japan
Zhengtao Ding The University of Manchester, UK
Shiji Song Tsinghua University, China
Donglian Qi Zhejiang University, China
Wanquan Liu Curtin University, Australia
Patrick Luk Cranfield University, UK
Guido Maione Technical University of Bari, Italy
Chen Peng Shanghai University, China
Tong Sun City University London, UK
Yuchu Tian Queensland University of Technology, Australia
Xiaojun Zeng The University of Manchester, UK
Huaguang Zhang Northeastern University, China
Shumei Cui Harbin Institute of Technology, China
Hongjie Jia Tianjin University, China
Youmin Zhang Concordia University, USA
Organization IX
Organization Committee
Chairs
Congbo Li Chongqing University, China
Minyou Chen Chongqing University, China
Adrian Murphy Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Sean McLoone Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Publication Chairs
Zhile Yang Chinese Academy of Sciences, China
Jianhua Zhang North China Electric Power University, China
Hongjian Sun Durham University, UK
Trevor Robinson Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Publicity Chairs
Qingxuan Gao Chongqing University, China
Junjie Chen Southeast University, China
Brian Falzon Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Ben Chong University of Leeds, UK
Secretary-General
Yan Ran Chongqing University, China
Dajun Du Shanghai University, China
Rao Fu Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Yanxia Wang Queen’s University Belfast, UK
Registration Chairs
Guijian Xiao Chongqing University, China
Shaojun Gan Queen’s University Belfast, UK
X Organization
Sponsors
Organizers
Co-organizers
Clean Energy
Electric Vehicles
Energy Saving
Energy Storages
Yawen Xi1(&), Junyong Wu1, Chen Shi1, Xiaowen Zhu1, Ran An1,
and Rong Cai2
1
Electrical Engineering School of Beijing Jiaotong University,
Haidian District, Beijing, China
[email protected]
2
ABB China Research Institute, Chaoyang District, Beijing, China
1 Introduction
Load forecasting is an important basis for the safe and stable operation of power system
and is also a basic work of planning and dispatching of power system. Traditional load
forecasting methods include extrapolation, exponential smoothing, correlation analysis,
regression analysis, time series, Kalman filter and gray system. Modern load fore-
casting methods include artificial neural networks [1], support vector machines [2, 3],
wavelet transforms [4, 5], and fuzzy regression. Each method has unique advantages
and obvious shortcomings. Applications of data mining technology to screen historical
data and combine with the existing load forecasting method is a new trend of load
forecasting.
In literature [6], many factors that affect power system load fluctuation are fused by
using multi-kernel function to build support vector machine forecasting model, the
forecasting results show that this method can effectively improve the speed and
accuracy of load forecasting. Literature [7] uses the load similarity date and meteo-
rological similarity day as training samples to reduce the dimensionality of input
variables and eliminate a large amount of redundant data. Literature [8] proposes a
short-term intelligent combined forecasting method for power system based on the
combination of gray model and support vector machine regression algorithm.
In this paper, firstly, the daily attribute law of load is tapped by using data mining
technology, corresponding forecasting models are established for different attribute
dates (different clustering categories) respectively, the load data and weather data such
as humidity and temperature are fused as the input sample of a model. Next, the load
data and weather data used in this paper come from a prefecture-level city in Zhejiang
Province. Since Zhejiang Province is located in the southeast coastal zone and the
summer rain and heat are in the same period, it is necessary to fully consider the local
geographical location and climatic conditions, analyze the correlation between each
influencing factor of the weather and the load, highlight the main weather factors and
ignore the secondary weather factors so as to improve the prediction accuracy. Finally,
the global search of c and g is carried out for the parameters of SVM to find the best
parameters.
where 0 represents the holiday, and 1 represents the day after the holiday, and 2 rep-
resents other dates except these two types.
In the formula, yi is the input sample data after normalization processing, xi is the
input sample data after pretreatment, xmin is the minimum value in the sample after
preprocessing, and xmax is the maximum value in the sample after preprocessing.
130
120
110
100
Load(MW)
90
80
70
60
50
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Time(hour)
the week load, the red lines represent the load curves from Monday to Friday, the blue
lines represent the load curves on weekends, as shown in Fig. 2.
140
130
120
110
100
Load(MW)
90
80
70
60
50
40
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Time(hour)
160
140
120
100
Load(WM)
80
60
40
9.30 10.1 10.2 10.3 10.4 10.5 10.6 10.7 10.8
Time (day)
Fig. 3. Load curves during the National Day in 2010, 2011, 2012
In addition to the regular characteristics of load, the influence of the weather, such as
temperature and humidity, on the load cannot be neglected [9]. The correlation degree
between the influencing factors of weather and load is analyzed quantitatively. Pearson
correlation analysis is used to analyze the correlation from two time dimensions. First,
from the perspective of the whole year, the Pearson correlation analysis is carried out
with the annual load and weather data of a certain region in Zhejiang Province in 2012,
the results of quantitative analysis are shown in Table 1. From Table 1, it can be seen
that the influence of temperature and humidity on load is larger than other factors.
Research on Refined Load Forecasting Method Based on Data Mining 7
Table 1. Correlation analysis of annual load and its influencing factors in 2012
Correlation coefficient Load
Temperature 0.476
Humidity −0.382
Rainfall 0.040
The wind speed of two minutes 0.147
The wind direction of two minutes 0.003
Table 2. Correlation analysis of summer load and its influencing factors in 2012
Correlation coefficient Load
Temperature 0.758
Humidity −0.557
Rainfall −0.115
The wind speed of two minutes 0.074
The wind direction of two minutes 0.083
In fact, in the summer of Zhejiang Province, the early summer is hot and humid
with more rain. And the midsummer is sunny and hot with little rain, which is the
hottest time of the year. That is, the correlation between summer rainfall and load is
also strong, but the results of the analysis are not obvious. Therefore, taking the
summer load and weather data in a certain region in Zhejiang Province in 2012 as an
example, the weather conditions are classified to further analyze the correlation
between summer rainfall and load. The results of the analysis are shown in Table 3.
y ¼ f ðxÞ ¼ ðx xÞ þ b ð2Þ
In the formula, x 2 Rn is the weight, xi 2 Rn are the input samples, and b 2 R is the
threshold.
For linear regression problems, according to the statistical theory, SVM determines
the regression function by minimizing the target, that is:
l
P
Min 2 kxk
1 2
þ C te þ 1
l fi þ fi
i¼1
s:t:ððx xi Þ þ bÞ yi e þ fi ð3Þ
yi ððx xi Þ þ bÞ e þ fi
fi 0; e 0
Research on Refined Load Forecasting Method Based on Data Mining 9
In the formula, e is the non-sensitive loss function, fi and fi are the relaxation
ðÞ ðÞ
factors. For the constraint conditions, ai , ai , gi , gi , b 0, the regression function of
SVM based on Lagrange algorithm is:
X
l
f ðxÞ ¼ ðai ai Þkðxi xÞ þ b ð4Þ
i¼1
In this paper, the radial basis function with relatively good prediction effect is
selected as the kernel function of SVM [13–15].
0.8
0.6
MSE
0.4
0.2
0.2
0.4 0
0.2
0.6
0.4
0.8 0.6
log2g 0.8
1 1 log2c
As can be seen from Fig. 4, in the process of selecting the best parameters c and g,
the c and g can be searched throughout the grid, so that the mean square error can
fluctuate within a range of 0 to 1. The best pair of parameters selected by cross
validation is: c = 1, g = 2.
6 Example Verification
6.1 Input the Sample Data
In this example, the load data and weather data such as temperature and humidity in a
certain region in Zhejiang Province in 2012 are selected as training samples. With
January 9, 2013 as the forecasting date, a corresponding support vector machine load
forecasting model is established for the attribute of the forecasting day.
10 Y. Xi et al.
Li:f Li
Ei ¼ 100% ð5Þ
Li
Table 4. The daily average load forecasting rate of various forecasting methods
Load forecasting methods Weekday Weekend Holiday
ARMA 88.66% 86.55% 87.67%
Traditional SVM 93.57% 92.53% 92.45%
The method proposed in this paper 97.41% 97.24% 97.16%
In the formula, Ei represents the load forecasting deviation rate (%) at i moment,
Li:f represents the load forecasting value (MW) at i moment, and Li represents the
actual load value (MW) at i moment.
Daily average load forecasting accuracy rate Ad :
In the formula, Ad represents the load forecasting accuracy (%), RMSE represents
the daily load forecasting bias root mean square, Ei represents 15-min load forecasting
bias (%) at i moment, n represents the daily actual assessment points.
Because of the limited text, this paper gives a detailed description of the load
forecasting results for the weekday (2013.01.09). The comparison between the pre-
diction results of the three load forecasting methods and the actual load is shown in
Fig. 5.
Fig. 5. Comparison between the prediction results of three kinds of load forecasting methods
and the actual load
From the comparison of the four load curves in Fig. 5, whether the smoothness of
the overall load curve or the predicted value of a single load point which is adopted the
load forecasting method of support vector machine based on historical data and the
real-time influencing factors proposed in this paper is much better than the traditional
support vector machine load forecasting method and time series load forecasting
method.
In order to compare the prediction accuracy of the three prediction methods more
intuitively, as shown in Fig. 6, the curves in this figure show the absolute value of the
load prediction bias of 96 sampling points adopting three different prediction methods.
From Fig. 6, it is clear that for the 96 sampling points load forecasting on January
9, 2013, which adopt the load forecasting method of support vector machine method
based on historical data and real-time influencing factors, the absolute values of the
load prediction deviation rates are mostly below 5%, and concentrate in the vicinity of
3%. The absolute values of the deviation rates of the 96 sampling points prediction
methods of the traditional support vector machine are basically above 5%, which
Fig. 6. Comparison of the absolute values of predicted deviations by three forecasting methods
12 Y. Xi et al.
concentrate near 8%. The absolute values floating range of the load forecast deviation
rates of the 96 sampling points of the time series load forecasting method are larger,
and the mean value is about 13%.
Through the example analysis, it verifies the effectiveness of the load forecasting
method of support vector machine based on historical data and real-time influencing
factors, which improves the prediction accuracy significantly.
7 Conclusion
In this paper, the load data, temperature, humidity and other weather data are fused to
propose a load forecasting method of support vector machine based on data mining,
conclusions are as follows:
(1) According to the multi-source information such as load and weather, using cor-
relation analysis and clustering algorithm, the operation days are divided into
several categories, and the prediction models are respectively established to
effectively improve the accuracy of load forecasting.
(2) Global optimization of the core parameters of support vector machine can also
improve the prediction accuracy.
(3) The results of a practical example show that compared with the traditional support
vector machine and time series load forecasting method, the method proposed in
this paper can improve the load prediction accuracy by about 5% to 10%.
Due to the different load characteristics, geographical locations and weather con-
ditions in different regions, the clustering results and model parameters obtained
may not be the same. Therefore, load forecasting models must be adapted to local
conditions which can effectively improve the accuracy of load forecasting.
References
1. Su, X., Liu, T., Cao, H., et al.: Short-term load forecasting method for multi-distributed BP
neural network based on Hadoop architecture. Proc. CSEE 37(17), 4966–4973+5216 (2017)
2. Luo, N., Zhu, Y., Du, C.: Application of support vector machine method in electric load
forecasting. Power Syst. Technol. 31(S2), 215–218 (2007)
3. Geng, Y., Han, X., Han, L.: Short-term load forecasting based on least squares support
vector machine. Power Syst. Technol. 18, 72–76 (2008)
4. Zhang, P., Pan, X., Xue, W.: Short-term load forecasting based on wavelet decomposition,
fuzzy gray correlation clustering and BP neural network. Electr. Power Autom. Equip. 32
(11), 121–125+141 (2012)
5. Zu, X., Tian, M., Bai, Y.: Short term load forecasting method based on fuzzy clustering and
function wavelet kernel regression. Electr. Power Autom. Equip. 36(10), 134–140+165
(2016)
6. Wu, Q., Gao, J., Hou, G., et al.: Short-term load forecasting support vector machine
algorithm based on multi-source heterogeneous fusion of load factors. Autom. Electr. Power
Syst. 40(15), 67–72+92 (2016)
Research on Refined Load Forecasting Method Based on Data Mining 13
7. Li, B., Huang, J., Wu, Y., et al.: A short-term load forecasting method based on fractal
feature correction of meteorological similar days. Power Syst. Technol. 41(06), 1949–1955
(2017)
8. Tang, J., Liu, J., Yang, K., et al.: Short-term load combination forecasting by grey model and
least square support vector machine. Power Syst. Technol. 33(03), 63–68 (2009)
9. Gao, Y., Sun, Y., Yang, W., et al.: Study on short – term forecast of meteorological sensitive
load based on new human comfort. Proc. CSEE 37(07), 1946–1955 (2017)
10. Huo, J., Shi, T., Chang, J.: Comparison of random forest and SVM for electrical short-term
load forecast with different data sources. In: IEEE International Conference on Software
Engineering and Service Science, pp. 1077–1080. IEEE (2017)
11. Ye, N., Liu, Y., Wang, Y.: Short-term power load forecasting based on SVM, pp. 47–51
(2012)
12. Zhang, M.G., Li, L.R.: Short-term load combined forecasting method based on BPNN and
LS-SVM. In: Power Engineering and Automation Conference, pp. 319–322. IEEE (2012)
13. Selakov, A., Ilic, S., Vukmirovic, S., et al.: A comparative analysis of SVM and ANN based
hybrid model for short term load forecasting. 52(11), 1–5 (2012)
14. Liu, B., Xu, G.: Short-term power load forecasting based on LS-SVM. In: International
Conference of Information Science and Management Engineering, pp. 311–314. IEEE
Computer Society (2010)
15. Zhang, Q., Liu, T.: Application of SVM and wavelet neural network method for short-term
power load forecasting. In: The International Conference on Computer and Automation
Engineering, pp. 412–416. IEEE (2010)
16. Niu, D., Liu, D., Chen, G., et al.: Support vector machine models optimized by genetic
algorithm for hourly load rolling forecasting. Trans. China Electrotech. Soc. 22(06), 148–
153 (2007)
17. Xie, H., Wei, J., Liu, H.: Parameter selection and optimization method of SVM model for
short-term load forecasting. Proc. CSEE 26(22), 17–22 (2006)
Water Level Control of Nuclear Power Plant
Steam Generator Based on Intelligent Virtual
Reference Feedback Tuning
1 Introduction
The steam generator system in the nuclear power plant is a complex control system,
which is non-linear and non-self-balancing [1]. The safe and stable operation of the
steam generator is directly related to the normal operation of the nuclear power plant
[2]. Gu proposed a novel control strategy in combination of active disturbance rejection
technology with multimodel-based control, and the method can quickly eliminate
interference under different load conditions, which can realize accurate dynamic control
for the water level of steam generator [3]. Tan proposed a simple gain-predetermined
water level control system, which has the advantages of simple structure and easy
implementation [4]. Le proposed an adaptive backstepping method and designed a
cascade control structure to reduce the influence of load disturbance in the feedwater
flow on the water level control, which kept the steam generator water level safe [5].
Besides, various advanced methods, such as fuzzy control [6] and neural networks
control [7], were proposed.
However, due to its complex characteristics, it is still difficult for the safe and stable
operation of the steam generator. Moreover, the modelling of the real system needs to
be complemented by various empirical relationships. Consider that, a novel data-driven
control method called IVRFT is integrated with Human Learning Optimization
(HLO) has been proposed in the paper. In the presented IVRFT based on HLO method
(IVRFTH), IVRFT [8] can design the controller directly by using a set of I/O data,
which avoids the necessity of modelling and consequently significantly reduces the
effort of the controller design and dodges the risk of degrading the performance of
controllers caused by the error of the model. Then the introduction of HLO can effi-
ciently find the optimal controller based on IVRFT and achieve the ideal control
performance for the water level system.
The paper is organized as follows. The optimal controller design based on the
IVRFTH is presented in Sect. 2. Then the IVRFTH is applied to the water level control
of the steam generator and its performance is validated in Sect. 3. This paper is ended
with the final conclusion.
Since the controlled object Pðz1 Þ is unknown, the objective function JMR ðhÞ cannot be
directly derived. Assume that a set of I/O data {u(t), y(t)} (t = 1, 2, … L, L is the data
length) of the controlled object is obtained from the field, then virtual input signal
evir ðtÞ can be calculated given a reference model M ðz1 Þ as Eq. (2)
1X N
uðtÞ Cðz1 ; hÞevir ðtÞ2
JVRFT ðhÞ ¼ ð3Þ
N t¼1
Obviously, in the objective function of VRFT, i.e. Eq. (3), there is no control
performance indicator and it is not practical to design an optimal controller. However,
as revealed by Fig. 1, the designed close-loop control system by VRFT approaches the
reference model M ðz1 Þ. Considering the widely used reference model in VRFT as
Eq. (4)
ð1 AÞz1 d
Mðz1 Þ ¼ z ð4Þ
1 Az1
is difficult to manually set an ideal reference model. Thus, IVRFT [8] is used to design
the optimal controller, in which the objective function is re-defined as Eq. (5),
where k is the weight of parameter A. To ensure that Jvrft plays a major role in this
fitness function for the validness of VRFT, the k value should be small enough. The
optimization of the objective function of IVRFT needs meta-heuristic algorithms [8].
Therefore, the choose of meta-heuristics in IVRFT is very important as it directly
determines the performance of the designed controller.
2.2.1 Initialization
HLO is a binary algorithm, and each bit represents a basic component of human
knowledge to be learned. An individual in HLO can be coded as Eq. (6), and each bit is
randomly initialized to 0 or 1.
xi ¼ xi1 xi2 . . . xij xiM 1 i N; 1 j M ð6Þ
where xi is the ith individual, N is the number of individuals in the group, and M is the
dimension of the solution [12].
where ikdi is the individual knowledge database (IKD) of the ith individual, and ikdipj is
the jth bit of the pth best solution stored in the IKD. T represents the IKD size.
(3) Social Learning Operator
In a social environment, humans can significantly improve the learning efficiency
by sharing knowledge. To improve the performance, HLO performs SLO as Eqs. (10)
and (11) to simulate the social learning of humans,
where SKD denotes the social knowledge database (SKD), and skdi represents the ith
best knowledge saved in the SKD.
In summary, HLO generates new candidates by executing RLO, ILO, and SLO as
Eq. (12):
8
< RLO; if 0 \ rl \ pr
Xij ¼ ILO; if pr \ rl \ pi ð12Þ
:
SLO; if pi \ rl \ 1
where rl is a random number between 0 and 1. HLO performs RLO, ILO, and SLO,
with the probability pr, (pi-pr), and (1-pi), respectively.
individual IKD, the new candidate solution is retained. The SKD is updated in the same
way [12].
uðkÞ ¼ uðk 1Þ þ Kp ½eðkÞ eðk 1Þ þ Ki eðkÞ þ Kd ½eðkÞ 2eðk 1Þ þ eðk 2Þ
ð13Þ
Ki
Cðz1 ; hÞ ¼ Kp þ þ Kd ð1 z1 Þ ð14Þ
1 z1
Ki 1 z1 d
uvir ðz1 Þ ¼ ½Kp þ þ Kd ð1 z1
Þ ½ z y ð15Þ
1 z1 ð1 AÞz1
1
up ðtÞ ¼ ½yðt þ d þ 1Þ yðt þ dÞ ð17Þ
1A
1
ui ðtÞ ¼ ½yðt þ d þ 1Þ ð18Þ
1A
1
ud ðtÞ ¼ ½yðt þ d þ 1Þ 2yðt þ dÞ þ yðt þ d 1Þ ð19Þ
1A
With the collected I/O data, and the Kp, Ki, Kd and A given by HLO, the fitness of each
controller, i.e. JIVRFT, can be computed and used for the optimization of the controllers.
The procedure of IVRFTH is as follows:
Step 4: Randomly generate the initial population, calculate the fitness function of
each initial solution, and initialize the IKDs and SKD;
Step 5: Execute the learning operators of HLO as Eq. (12) to generate new
candidates;
Step 6: Calculate the fitness of new candidates, and update the IKD and SKD;
Step 7: Check whether the algorithm satisfies the termination condition; If the
condition is reached, output the optimal solution found by HLO; otherwise,
return to step 5.
When the nuclear power unit is in daily operation, the water level of the steam gen-
erator must be monitored and controlled so that it is within the operating limits. When
the water level deviates from the set normal range, it will directly affect the safety and
economic operation of nuclear power plant [3].
In the paper, IVRFTH is applied to control the water level system of steam gen-
erators as Eq. (20) [16]. Note that IVRFTH, as well as the standard VRTF and IVRFT,
does not need any model information for the design of controller. The model here is
only used to generate the input and output data for IVRFTH and evaluate the perfor-
mance of the designed controllers later.
0:0164
GðsÞ ¼ e9:0234s ð20Þ
8:6663s þ 9:0234
To verify the performance of the IVRFTH, IVRFT [8], the Z–N method [17], and
the model-based optimal PID controller design with HLO (MPID) are used for a
comparison. The fitness function, as Eq. (21) [18], is adopted in MPID,
where Tup stands for the rise time, IAE stands for the integral of absolute error, and OS
stands for the overshoot. w1, w2, and w3 are the weights of rise time, IAE, and over-
shoot in the fitness function, respectively, and the values are set to 1, 1, 5000 as
recommended in [8].
The control performance of all the methods are depicted in Fig. 3, and the per-
formance indexes are shown in Table 1. The results show that the Z-N method cannot
achieve an expected performance on the water lever control system. The studied
IVRFTH has better performance than the standard IVRFT, which has faster rise time
and smaller IAE. IVRFTH is a little inferior to MPID since the latter is designed with
the perfect model and directly by using the performance criteria as the fitness function.
However, the performance of IVRFT is very close to MPID and it is better than MPID
with 1% model error. Considering a perfect model of steam generators is impractical to
be constructed in real nuclear power plants, IVRFTH have its advantages in terms of
the ideal control performance and ease of implementation.
Water Level Control of Nuclear Power Plant Steam Generator 21
4 Conclusions
The water level control is a challenging problem for the steam generator operation in
nuclear power plants due to its complex characteristics. The difficulty of modelling
would cause significant performance loss for the model-based control methods in real
applications. Therefore, IVRFTH is studied and applied to the water level control,
which can directly design the optimal controller with a set of input and output data. The
simulation results indicate that IVRFTH achieves better control performance with the
introduction of HLO. Considering that IVRFTH can easily achieve the ideal control
performance without model information, it is promising to be applied to water level
control of the steam generator and other engineering objects.
22 Z. Han et al.
References
1. Li, C., Ye, J., Zhao, M.: Multi-model control for water lever of steam generator in nuclear
power plants based on linear active disturbance rejection. Autom. Instrum. 32(1), 46–50
(2017)
2. Zhang, Z., Hu, L.: Performance assessment for the water level control system in steam
generator of the nuclear power plant. Ann. Nucl. Energy 45, 94–105 (2012)
3. Gu, J., Ji, N., Sun, Y., Wang, D.: The multimodel-based active disturbance rejection control
for water level of steam generator in nuclear power plants. J. Chin. Soc. Power Eng. 32(5),
373–377 (2012)
4. Tan, W.: Water level control for a nuclear steam generator. Nucl. Eng. Des. 241(5), 1873–
1880 (2011)
5. Wei, L., Fang, F., Shi, Y.: Adaptive backstepping-based composite nonlinear feedback water
level control for the nuclear U-tube steam generator. IEEE Trans. Control Syst. Technol. 22
(1), 369–377 (2014)
6. Thakur, A., Singh, H., Wadhwani, S.: Designing of fuzzy logic controller for liquid level
controlling. Int. J. u-and e-Serv. Sci. Technol. 8(6), 267–276 (2015)
7. Habibiyan, H., Setayeshi, S., Arab-Alibeik, H.: A fuzzy-gain-scheduled neural controller for
nuclear steam generators. J. Ann. Nucl. Energ. 31(15), 1765–1781 (2004)
8. Wang, L., Ni, H., Yang, R., et al.: Intelligent virtual reference feedback tuning and its
application to heat treatment electric furnace control. Eng. Appl. Artif. Intell. 46, 1–9 (2015)
9. Guardabassi, G., Savaresi, S.M.: Virtual reference direct design method: an off-line approach
to data-based control system design. IEEE Trans. Autom. Control 45(5), 954–959 (2000)
10. Formentin, S., Campi, M.C., Savaresi, S.M.: Virtual reference feedback tuning for industrial
PID controllers. IFAC Proc. Vols. 47(3), 11275–11280 (2014)
11. Campi, M.C., Lecchini, A., Savaresi, S.M.: Virtual reference feedback tuning: a direct
method for the design of feedback controllers. Automatica 38(8), 1337–1346 (2002)
12. Wang, L., Ni, H., Yang, R., Fei, M., Ye, W.: A simple human learning optimization
algorithm. In: Fei, M., Peng, C., Su, Z., Song, Y., Han, Q. (eds.) LSMS/ICSEE 2014, Part II.
CCIS, vol. 462, pp. 56–65. Springer, Heidelberg (2014). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-662-
45261-5_7
13. Wang, L., Yang, R., Ni, H., et al.: A human learning optimization algorithm and its
application to multi-dimensional knapsack problems. Appl. Soft Comput. 34, 736–743
(2015)
14. Li, X., Yao, J., Wang, L., Menhas, M.I.: Application of human learning optimization
algorithm for production scheduling optimization. In: Fei, M., Ma, S., Li, X., Sun, X., Jia, L.,
Su, Z. (eds.) LSMS/ICSEE 2017, Part I. CCIS, vol. 761, pp. 242–252. Springer, Singapore
(2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-10-6370-1_24
15. Wang, L., Pei, J., et al.: A hybrid-coded human learning optimization for mixed-variable
optimization problems. Knowl. Based Syst. 127, 114–125 (2017)
16. Li, C., Ye, J., Zhao, M.: Two-degree-of-freedom model driving control of evaporator water
level in nuclear power plant. Yunnan Chem. Technol. 43(5), 55–60 (2016)
Water Level Control of Nuclear Power Plant Steam Generator 23
17. Åström, K.J., Hägglund, T.: Revisiting the Ziegler-Nichols step response method for PID
control. J. Process Control 14(6), 635–650 (2004)
18. Wang, L., Yang, R., Pardalos, P.M., et al.: An adaptive fuzzy controller based on harmony
search and its application to power plant control. Int. J. Electr. Power Energy Syst. 53, 272–
278 (2013)
Characteristics Investigation for Hydro-
Mechanical Compound Transmission in Wind
Power System
1 Introduction
The research and utilization of new energy has become the focus of attention all over
the world. At present, the cost of wind power is close to the cost of thermal power
generation. However, in the whole wind power industry, it is urgent to optimize the
technology of wind power system to ensure that the initial cost and maintenance cost
are reduced under the premise of high efficiency, sustainability and stability of the
whole system [1].
Doubly fed VSCF wind power system has many shortcomings, such as large
excitation current, high excitation loss, expensive electrical equipment and difficult to
troubleshoot. Some scholars began to turn to the hydraulic transmission chain suitable
for wind power system [2, 3], and put forward hydraulic circuits made up of hydraulic
pumps and motors for the purpose of asynchronous power generation and voltage
stabilization, but the efficiency was only 72.9%. The existing vehicle hydrostatic
transmission is applied to the wind power generation system and the turbine [4].
© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2018
K. Li et al. (Eds.): ICSEE 2018/IMIOT 2018, CCIS 925, pp. 24–35, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2381-2_3
Characteristics Investigation for Hydro-Mechanical Compound Transmission 25
The drawback is the low efficiency. In order to make up for the low efficiency of the
hydraulic circuit, a power diverting transmission system [5], which is composed of the
mechanical branch and the servo branch, is put forward, but the cost of the servo motor
is also high. In order to solve the problem of low efficiency of hydraulic loop, a
mechanical-hydraulic transmission which can be used in wind power system is put
forward, but the efficiency is still low in some stages [6]. In China, the input and output
coupling transmission for wind power is proposed by Zhejiang University, but the
speed range of the input coupling transmission is narrow [7].
The HMCVT proposed in this paper can be applied to wind power, and has
achieved the following points:
1. VSCF. When the wind speed fluctuates, it adjusts the transmission ratio of the
hydraulic branch by adjusting the displacement ratio e of the variable pump, so as to
keep the output shaft speed constant. Based on the dynamic characteristics of the
transmission, it is possible to reduce the capacity of the converter or even replace it.
2. High power and high efficiency. Based on the high power density of the hydraulic
circuit and the high efficiency of the mechanical circuit, the efficiency of the
HMCVT can reach 90%, and it is generally stable at about 87%, which is higher
than the static pressure transmission and hydraulic torque converter.
3. The structure is compact. In view of the high power density of the hydraulic system,
the HMCVT will be more compact than other transmission structures. And it is
cheaper than power electronic converters.
The structure of HMCVT is shown in Fig. 2. It consists of an input shaft n1, two
planetary gear trains (PGT) A1 and A2, a hydraulic circuit and an output shaft n0. There
are 6 types of connection for each PGT. Therefore, the transmission system has 36
26 G. Huang et al.
kinds of structure. The structure shown in Fig. 2 has the advantages of high efficiency,
wide speed range and no power cycle.
np nm
i1
i2
i0 n7 i3
n2 n4 n6
n3 n5
n1 n0
A1 A2
In this system, the energy captured by the wind wheel flows into the HMCVT
through the gear box. After the energy flows through the input PGT A1, the energy
flows into the hydraulic circuit and the mechanical circuit respectively. The energy is
converged by the output PGT A2 and the output shaft n0 is kept at the constant speed.
A1 and A2 are the characteristic coefficient of the two PGT. n1 is the input shaft, n2
is the output shaft, n3 is the connection shaft, n5 is the input shaft of the output PGT, n6
is the output shaft of the output PGT, n4 is the connection shaft.
The speed governing characteristic equation of the HMCVT can be deduced from
the formula (1):
n3 i1 i2 þ A2 ei3
iHM ¼ ¼ ð2Þ
n1 ð1 þ A1 Þði1 i2 þ A2 ei3 Þ A1 ð1 þ A2 Þi0 i1 i2 i3
Characteristics Investigation for Hydro-Mechanical Compound Transmission 27
By adjusting the displacement ratio e of the variable displacement pump and the
quantitative motor, the stepless speed regulation function can be realized.
The efficiency of the HMCVT is defined as the ratio of output shaft power to input
shaft power.
PO M O nO MO
gHM ¼ ¼ ¼ iHM ð3Þ
PI M I nI MI
The efficiency characteristics of the HMCVT can be obtained from the formula (2)
and (3).
Where Dp is the output flow of the pump, xp is the pump input angle speed, Cip and
Cep are the internal and external leakage coefficient of the pump, respectively. ph and pl
are the pressure of high and low pressure cavity, respectively.
The flow continuity equation of the high pressure cavity of the system:
dhm VO dpp
Qp ¼ Cim ðph pl Þ þ Cem ph þ Dm þ ð6Þ
dt be dt
Where Cim and Cem are the internal and external leakage coefficient of the motor, Vo
is the total volume of the pump and motor, pp is the output pressure of the variable
pump, be is the elastic modulus of the hydraulic oil, and Dm is the displacement of the
hydraulic motor.
The balance equation between the motor and the load torque:
d 2 hm dh
Dm ðph pl Þ ¼ J þ Bm m þ Ghm þ T ð7Þ
dt2 dt
Where J is the moment of inertia of the motor, Bm is the viscous damping coeffi-
cient of the hydraulic oil, and T is the output torque of the motor.
28 G. Huang et al.
Combined Eqs. (5)–(7), the transfer function of hydraulic circuit can be obtained
after Laplace transform:
Dp np
DC2m ð1 þ bVeOCsÞT
nm ¼ ð8Þ
Dm
VO J
be D2m s3 þ ðDCJ2m þ Bbme DV2mO Þs2 þ ð1 þ BDm2mC þ bGV 2 Þs þ D2
O
e Dm
GC
m
Where C is the total leakage coefficient of the pump controlled motor system, and
np is the speed of the variable pump. Neglecting some minor factors and using the
displacement ratio e(s) as input, the transfer function of the system can be obtained:
nm ðsÞ np
¼ ð9Þ
eðsÞ s2
x2C
þ 2nx s þ 1
C
C
qffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
Where xc is hydraulic natural frequency, xc ¼ be D2m
Vo J ; nc is damping ratio,
qffiffiffiffi pffiffiffiffi
nc ¼ 2DCm bVeoJ þ 2D
Bm
m
Vo
be J .
1
P ¼ Tx ¼ Cp qpR2 v3 ð10Þ
2
Where P is the power of the wind wheel, W; T is the output torque of the wind
wheel, Nm; x is the angular velocity of the wind wheel, rad/s; q is air density, kg/m3;
R is the radius of the wind wheel, m; V is wind speed, m/s; Cp is the power coefficient
of the wind wheel. Equation (11) can be obtained, because of k = Rx⁄v (k is tip speed
ratio):
Cp
T¼ qpR3 v3 ð11Þ
2k
It is known that the cut-in speed of a wind wheel is vxin = 3.5 m/s, the cut-out
speed is vxe = 25 m/s, and the speed range of wind wheel is 9.0–17.6 r/min [9]. The
output characteristic of the wind turbine can be obtained by power coefficient in article
[8] and formula (10) and (11). The output characteristics of the wind wheel can be
obtained by interpolation method.
The 3D model of the transmission prototype is shown in Fig. 4, and the moment of
inertia of each rotating part is derived by Inventor, and the inertial elements are added
to the Simulink model.
2.2
2
1.8
Speed Ratio iHM
1.6
1.4
1.2
1 Theory i H M
0.8
Simulation i
0.6 HM
0.4
0.2
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1
Displacement Ratio e
The efficiency characteristic curves are shown in Fig. 7, where the theoretical curve
is obtained by formula (4). From the theoretical efficiency characteristic curve, it can be
seen that the efficiency of HMCVT can keep around 87%, when the iHM stay around
0.2–2.14. The efficiency of HMCVT is higher than that of torque converter 80% [3, 10].
In Fig. 7, simulation curves show that the efficiency of the theoretical analysis
decreases with the increase of e, when the displacement ratio is between 0 and 0.27.
The reason is that the hydraulic power diversion ratio increases with the increase of e,
that is, the mechanical circuit power with high efficiency falls down, so the overall
efficiency declines. However, in the theoretical analysis, the volumetric efficiency and
Characteristics Investigation for Hydro-Mechanical Compound Transmission 31
the counter torque caused by load are not considered, so as to there are some different
between theoretical and simulated analysis. In the simulation, when e is very low, the
counter torque of the output shaft passes through the PGT A2 to the hydraulic motor,
which makes the motor have a reversal trend and hydraulic leakage, so there is a certain
amount of energy loss at the motor. However, with the increase of e, the power of the
hydraulic circuit increases gradually, and the load of the motor is constant, so the
influence of the energy loss at the motor is gradually weakened, and the overall
efficiency is gradually rising. When e is between 0.27 and 1, the simulated and theo-
retical efficiency are basically the same, and the efficiency increases slowly with the
increase of e. The reason is that the hydraulic power diversion ratio decreases with the
increase of e, that is, the mechanical circuit power with high efficiency rises, so the
overall efficiency increases.
The static simulation results show that the simulation results of speed governing
characteristics and efficiency curves are basically consistent with theoretical analysis
conclusions. The speed regulation characteristic is not only wide and good linearity, but
also easy to adjust and control speed. The volumetric efficiency and hydraulic leakage
caused by reverse torque make simulation efficiency very low when e is very low.
However, theoretical analysis does not consider hydraulic leakage. The overall devel-
opment trend is still the same. The efficiency of the main work section is about 87%.
Figure 8 shows the dynamic characteristics of the generator’s speed when the
measured wind speed signals are input. At the initial stage of running, there are 1.8%
fluctuations in 51 s. Then the wind speed fluctuates from the initial 3.5 m/s to 27 m/s,
and the maximum peak is 28 m/s. The simulation results show that the fluctuation of
the transmission shaft is kept within 0.57%, and the error is in 0.5 Hz to meet the
standard of grid connected power generation. It shows that wind speed almost has no
effect on speed of output shaft when the wind speed fluctuate between the cut-in and
cut-out.
x 10 3
1.51 36
1.5 32
Generator Speed r/min
1.49 28
Figure 9 is the efficiency curve of the measured wind speed signal. The efficiency
of the whole system are about 88.32% in the low wind speed section (means 3.5–
15 m/s), and about 85.95% in the high wind speed section (means 15–27 m/s). Because
of the gradual increase of wind speed, iHM of the transmission decreases, that is,
e decreases, so the efficiency gradually decreases, which is consistent with the theo-
retical analysis results.
1 40
0.8 32
Generator Speed r/min
0.6 Efficiency 24
Wind Speed
0.4 16
0.2 8
0 0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16
Time h
The simulation results of actual wind speed signals show that the system has good
dynamic quality. The accurate control of rotating parts with large inertia still has a fast
response speed, and its robustness is good in normal operation. Even if the wind speed
fluctuates between 3.5 to 28 m/s, the output shaft can fluctuate within 0.57%, and the
efficiency is stable at about 85.95–88.32%. All simulation results are consistent with
the theoretical analysis conclusions.
The experimental data were measured by the test platform. And the Simulink model
of the hydraulic mechanical composite transmission was established by the same
simulation strategy, and the speed regulation characteristic curve of the output coupling
type was obtained as shown in Fig. 11. The experimental data are generally lower than
the simulation results about 2.64%, because that the influence factors are not fully
considered in the simulation, but the change trend is basically the same.
0.2
0.18
0.16
Speed Ratio iHM
0.14
0.12
0.1
Test
Simulation
0.08
0.06
0.3 0.35 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8
Displacement Ratio e
From the above, the simulation data of the hydraulic mechanical composite
transmission is basically consistent with the experimental data. And the same simu-
lation strategy are adopted in the HMCVT and the hydraulic mechanical composite
transmission. It shows that the simulation strategy can simulate the real test environ-
ment effectively and comprehensively.
4 Conclusion
According to the actual working condition of the wind power system, the design of the
HMCVT is put forward. Based on the principle of compound transmission, the theo-
retical analysis of the HMCVT is carried out. Modeling and dynamic simulation and
analysis of HMCVT wind power system are carried out.
Theoretical analysis and simulation results show that the speed range of the
transmission is large, and VSCF can be realized in the range of cut-in and cut-out wind
speed. The maximum overshoot is 1.8%, which means that the dynamic characteristics
are good. The engine speed can be stabilized at rated speed and the fluctuation is less
than 0.5%, which means that the stability is good. The efficiency of HMCVT at low
wind speed is about 88.32%, and the efficiency is about 85.95% at high wind speed.
This paper proves that the HMCVT can be used in wind power generation and has a
good application prospect. Nevertheless, the reliability of system control is a complex
problem for large inertial systems, which needs further study.
References
1. Marques, A.B., Taranto, G.N., Falcao, D.M.: A knowledge-based system for supervision and
control of regional voltage profile and security. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 20(1), 400–407
(2005)
2. Diepeveen, N.F.B., Laguna, A.J.: Dynamic modeling of fluid power transmissions for wind
turbines. In: Proceedings of the EWEA Offshore 2011 Conference (2011)
3. Tiţa, I., Călăraşu, D.: Wind power systems with hydrostatic transmission for clean energy.
Environ. Eng. Manag. J. 8(2), 327–334 (2009)
4. Silva, P., Antonio, G., Nicola, F., et al.: Performance prediction of a multi-MW wind turbine
adopting an advanced hydrostatic transmission. Energy 64(1), 450–461 (2014)
5. Xueyong, Z., Peter, M.: A novel power splitting drive train for variable speed wind power
generators. Renew. Energy 28(13), 2001–2011 (2003)
6. Shahaboddin, S., Dalibor, P., Amineh, A., et al.: Support vector regression methodology for
wind turbine reaction torque prediction with power-split hydrostatic continuous variable
transmission. Energy 67(4), 623–630 (2014)
7. Chi, Z.: Matching investigation on wind turbine and hydrodynamic torque converter. Master,
Harbin Institute of Technology (2010)
8. Chengdang, Z.: Research on the Power Control Technology for Wind Turbine with Hydro-
mechanical Transmission. Master, Zhejiang University (2015)
Characteristics Investigation for Hydro-Mechanical Compound Transmission 35
9. Chunbao, L., Wenxing, M., Weiwei, M., et al.: Calculation and analysis of wind turbine
transmission system based on hydrodynamic speed adjustment. J. Tongji Univ. (Natural
Science) 41(10), 1584–1588 (2013)
10. Chang, L.: Optimization of power matching on torque-converter with diesel engine for wheel
Loader. Trans. Chin. Soc. Agric. Mach. 41(11), 25–29 (2006)
A Novel Wind Power Accommodation
Strategy Considering User Satisfaction
and Demand Response Dispatch
Economic Costs
1 Introduction
Since the global energy shortage and the environmental pollution continue to
aggravate, it is necessary to change the social energy structure [1]. To solve
the problems, renewable energy has been employed rapidly [2,3], but the inter-
mittent of renewable energy poses a challenge to the safe and stable operation
of large-scale power grids. However, demand response as a highly-controllable
virtual resource is an effective strategy for responding to renewable energy fluc-
tuations. Thus, the paper focuses on demand response strategy to accommodate
wind power fluctuations. With respect to the application of demand response
technology for wind power accommodation, there exist some research results.
For example, a real-time optimal scheduling model is established in [4], which
aims at minimizing the dispatch economic costs on the power grid side. Based
on the objective function of the lowest power cost and minimum load fluctua-
tion, two phases demand response is constructed to optimize the user electricity
where Pl,i0 and ci0 are the load and the electricity price of the ith node before
demand response respectively, Pl,i and ci are the load and the electricity price
of the ith node after demand response [10], and
Pl,i = αi ci + βi , (2)
N N
wind
where N , Nwind are the number of nodes and wind farms, and ΔPwindi is the
wind power fluctuation.
Substituting (2) and (3) into (1), (1) can be re-written as
1 βi − 2Pl,i0
Ci = ΔPl,i
2
+ ΔPl,i . (5)
αi αi
Therefore, demand response dispatch economic costs can be calculated by the
inverse of changes in grid side electricity sales income before and after demand
response:
Cr = −Ci . (6)
Demand response dispatch economic costs (6) will be employed in the fol-
lowing demand response model.
N
|Pl,i0 − Pl,i |
i=1
ε=1− , (9)
N
Pl,i0
i=1
maxS,
N (10)
min Cr , r = 1, 2...NRL ,
r=1
N N
wind
where N are the number of system nodes, Nwind is the number of wind farms,
ΔPwindi is the amount of wind power fluctuation of the ith wind farm, and ΔPl,i
is the amount of interactive response of the ith node.
(2) Constraint of demand response capacity. It shows that the user-side
demand response capability is limited to a certain extent, i.e.,
PDi
min
PDi PDi
max
, (12)
(3) Branch flow security constraints. After demand response, it must ensure
that the flow of each branch is within the allowable safety range, i.e.,
where Pl,i is the power flow of the lth branch, Pl,i min and Pl,i max are the lower
limit and the upper limit of the lth branch, respectively.
(4) Node voltage security constraints. After the demand response is carried
out, the node load changes will cause the node voltage to change. In order to
avoid the occurrence of node voltage threshold crossing, the node voltage after
the demand response must be limited, i.e.,
where Ui is the voltage of the ith node, Ui min and Ui max are the lower and upper
limit of the node voltage of the ith node.
where fi is the objective function, fi min and fi max are the maximum and min-
imum values of the objective function, respectively. According to the order of
magnitude difference between the maximum and minimum of satisfaction and
the difference between maximum and minimum of dispatch economic costs, the
normalized weight of satisfaction function is set to 0.01, and the weight of dis-
patch economic costs is set to 100.
It’s known that demand response dispatch economic costs is a quadratic func-
tion of the amount interactive response, Therefore, the objective function and the
constraint of the demand response are transformed into the objective function
and the constraint with the amount of interactive response as a variable. Further-
more, the bi-objective function is transformed into a single-objective function by
the above normalized method to solve the problem.
A Novel Wind Power Accommodation Strategy 41
(3) Electricity comfort Satisfaction. Substituting (3) into (9), (9) can be re-
written as
N
|ΔPl,i |
i=1
ε=1− . (18)
N
Pl,i0
i=1
(4) Demand response constraints. For nodes with loads: they can be flexibly
increased or decreased on the original basis, i.e.,
For nodes without load: they can not reduce the load and can only increase the
load on the original basis load, i.e.,
N
Pl,i min Pl,i0 + ΔPl,i(j) Pl,i max , (21)
r=1
4 Simulation Example
The calculation model used in this example is an modified IEEE-30 nodes distri-
bution network [10]. The entire solution process is shown in Fig. 1. Four equal-
valued wind farms are connected to the 13th , 20th , 26th , 30th nodes, it is demon-
strated in Fig. 2. The wind farm consists of 30 doubly-fed inductive wind gen-
erators, and each doubly-fed inductive wind turbine has a rated capacity of 600
KW.
All nodal prices of the system are calculated every 3 h at a time interval, and
the time 1 is taken as an example. The other times are similar. According to the
user’s degree of emphasis on two kinds of satisfaction, two kinds of satisfaction
weights are set, e.g., the electricity comfort satisfaction degree weight is set to
0.1 and the electricity expense satisfaction rate is 0.9, respectively. The optimiza-
tion results of two models are obtained under different wind power fluctuation
conditions.
It can be found from Table 1 that when the fluctuation of wind power contin-
ued to increase, it basically remains stable at around 7% in model 1, it’s better
than that in model 2.
It can be seen from Fig. 3 that different nodes have different demand response
elasticity coefficient and demand response capacity, different nodes have different
the amount of interactive response.
A Novel Wind Power Accommodation Strategy 43
Table 1. Comparison of model 1 and model 2 results. (Note: wind power fluctuation
coefficient(WPFC), wind power fluctuation(WPF), user satisfaction(US), DR dispatch
economic cost(DRDEC), power grid income variation(PGIV).)
According to Fig. 4, the load of each node compared with that before the
demand response. The nodal prices such as the 1th , 6th , 11th , 25th , and 28th
nodes in the entire system decrease significantly, and the corresponding node
loads also increase.
It can seen that for model 2, as the capacity of demand response increases, the
maximum degree of user satisfaction also increases, and the amount of power
grid income variation on the grid side also increases in Table 2.
44 J. Hong et al.
Fig. 3. Comparison of node loads for various nodes in the system before and after
demand response
Fig. 4. Before and after demand response, the node electricity prices of each node in
the system
5 Conclusion
In this paper, a novel wind power accommodation strategy by taking the
price-based demand response dispatch economic costs and user satisfaction into
account is proposed. This strategy aims at minimizing scheduling cost and maxi-
mizing user satisfaction, then multi-objective function is transformed into single-
objective function by normalized method, and sequential quadratic programming
method is used to acquire the amount of interactive response. Finally, simulation
results show that demand response capacity will have an effect on the elimination
of wind fluctuations and the proposed strategy can successfully eliminate cer-
tain range of wind power fluctuations. In the future, the detailed classification of
demand-side loads will be considered, and different demand response strategies
will be made for different types of loads.
Acknowledgment. This work was supported in part by the National Science Foun-
dation of China (Nos. 61773253). The Project of Science and Technology Commission
of Shanghai Municipality (Nos. 15JC1401900, 17511107002, 14JC1402200).
References
1. Zeng, M., Wu, G.: Key problems and prospects of integrated demand response in
energy internet. Power Syst. Technol. 11(40), 3391–3398 (2016)
2. Dong C Y, Zhao J H.: From smart grid to energy internet: basic concepts and
research framework. Autom. Electric Power Syst. 38, 1–11 (2014)
3. Tian, S.L., Wang, B.B.: Key technologies of demand response in smart grid. J.
Electric. Eng. 84, 3576–3585 (2014)
4. Zeng, D., Yao, J.G.: Modeling price-based demand response optimization schedul-
ing based on security constraints for wind power accommodation. J. Electric. Eng.
34(31), 5571–5578 (2014)
5. Ding, W., Yuan, J.H.: Peak-valley time-share price decision model based on user
price-based demand response and satisfaction. Autom. Electric Power Syst. 29(20),
10 (2005)
6. Yan, L.W., Yu, C., Tan, Z.F.: Two-phase scheduling optimization model for wind
energy source storage considering demand response. Power Grid Technol. 39(5),
1287–1293 (2015)
7. Yan, L.W., Qin, C., Wu, H.L., et al.: Wind power electricity consumption stochastic
optimal scheduling model considering multi-type demand response. Power Syst.
Technol. 39(7), 1839–1846 (2015)
8. Cao, J., Ma, H.Y., Liu, Y., et al.: Research on demand response strategy based on
nodal price. Power Grid Technol. 40(5), 1536–1542 (2016)
9. Hu, M., Xiao, J.W.: Distributed real-time demand response for energy management
scheduling in smart grid. Int. J. Electric. Power Energy Syst. 1(16), 233–245 (2018)
10. Hu, Y., Xiao, J.W., et al.: Hierarchical control strategy for residential demand
response considering time-varying aggregated capacity. Int. J. Electric. Power
Energy Syst. 1(16) (2017)
Research on Operational Reliability of Digital
Control Device of Nuclear Pressurizer Based
on Dynamic Fault Tree
Keywords: The logic of selecting median from four inputs Dynamic fault tree
Bayesian analysis The evaluation of reliability Digital control device of
nuclear pressurizer
1 Introduction
In the power plant control system, the input of analog quantity generally adopts the
method of multi-point measurement and taking median value. Thermal power plant
adopts the logic of selecting median from three inputs, such as the level measurement
of the deaerator [1] and so on. In nuclear power plants, advanced nuclear reactors
generally use the logic of selecting median from four inputs [2], the digital control
device of Pressurizer, which is equipped with the above logic, was used as the research
object in this article. There are two points to be analyzed, point one is the reliability of
input Module of selecting median from four inputs, point two is about increased
reliability of the entire control device after using the input module.
At present, there are many studies on reliability of digital control device, but most
of them are based on historical data or factory data. In fact, the reliability index of
equipment will change with the rise of running time, so the reliability evaluation based
on the initial index value is inaccurate. Based on the operating data of DCS, Bayesian
analysis is used to obtain more accurate reliability index in this article.
Reliability analysis methods include failure mode and impact analysis, reliability
block diagram, fault tree modeling and so on. Literature [3] verified the feasibility of
Monte Carlo method in fault tree modeling and simulation of nuclear power plant
safety system. Literature [4] used the method of MFM (multi-layer flow model) to
analyze DCS of nuclear power plants. The fault tree was used in literature [5] to model
nuclear power protection system. The above methods don’t apply to the failure mode
related to the sequence of failure of each device. The input module of selecting median
from four inputs adds a backup channel compared with the three-input, the backup
channel enters signal instead of failed preferred channel, but it only replaces one
preferred channel to ensure accuracy, so the failure of the input module must be linked
to the sequence of the failure of each channel. This article introduces a dynamic fault
tree, which takes the sequence of failure into account.
The function of Pressurizer is to maintain the primary circuit pressure of nuclear power
at 15.5 MPa, so that the power plant will not encounter emergency shutdown and
safety valve operation under the condition of normal load transients and the turbine
dumping the entire load. Pressurizer control principle shown in Fig. 1.
According to Fig. 3, the entire logic is divided into two parts of the backup channel
access and two out of three decisions. The first part determines whether backup channel
needs to be put in. First step is to determine whether there are deviation alarms for
signal values of channels. Second step is to determine if the following conditions are
true: one of the three preferred channels is detected a deviation alarm, backup channel
and the other two preferred input channels aren’t detected a deviation alarm, if these
happen, the faulty channel is switched to the backup channel. The second part makes
Research on Operational Reliability of Digital Control Device 49
two out of three decisions for the final three channels. If there are deviation alarms in
two or more channels, the input module is faulty and the operator inputs pressure
measurement from the immediately preceding moment. Otherwise, the median of three
channels or the average of two channels is output.
X
n
MTBFjYj ¼ ½ ðTi þ 1 jYj Ti jYj Þ þ MTBF0 jYj =n ð1Þ
i¼1
(3) Calculate the value of point estimate for reliability R as formula (2).
Pn
0 P n 1 Zi
T i¼0
B i¼0 i C
0 B
R ¼@ C ð2Þ
P
n A
tþ Ti
i¼0
Where t is the given task time. The posterior mean of failure rate is shown in (3).
P
n
Nþ Zi
i¼0
kBayes ¼ Pn ð3Þ
T þ Ti
i¼0
In the formula, T is the number of hours of the n + 1th operation of device and N is
the cumulative number of failures in T hours.
With the channel I1 fault as the top event, the state Fa corresponds to the occur-
rence of top event, the state Op corresponds to the nonoccurrence of top event, you can
get two Markov chains as follows, 00—10—Fa/00—01—Op. Among them, “00”
indicates that card I1, I2, and I3 are normal, “10” indicates that card I2 or I3 fails and
card I1 is normal, and “01” indicates that the card I1 fails and I2 or I3 is normal.
1 2
p ¼ k4 =ð2k4 þ k4 Þeð2k4 þ k4 Þt ek4 t þ 2k4 =ð2k4 þ k4 Þ ¼ e3k4 t ek4 t þ ð6Þ
3 3
1 1
f4 ðtÞ ¼ f1 ðek4 t e3k4 t þ Þ ½1 ð1 ek4 t Þ2 g2
3 3 ð7Þ
1 1
f2ðek4 t e3k4 t þ Þ ½1 ð1 ek4 t Þ2 þ 1g
3 3
According to the logic relationship in Fig. 4, the failure probability of the static
fault sub-block G3 can be obtained as (8).
Finally, according to the logical relationship of the entire fault tree, the reliability of
the Pressurizer digital control device can be found as (9).
54 H. Qian et al.
According to online data of the equipment, the failure rate of each equipment is
corrected by the method of Bayesian analysis in real time, it can be concluded as
follows: operator station k1 ¼ 7:3 107 , controller k2 ¼ 2:8 107 , output card
k3 ¼ 6:11 107 , input card k4 ¼ 2:3 106 , power k5 ¼ 6:5 107 .
Research on Operational Reliability of Digital Control Device 55
Substituting the above data into the Eqs. (7) and (5), you can obtain the reliability
versus time function of digital control device and the input module using the logic of
selecting median from four inputs, and you can compare it with the three inputs.
Figure 7 shows the comparison of the reliability of two input configurations.
It can be seen from Fig. 7 that after adding the common backup card, the reliability
of the logic of selecting median from four inputs is significantly higher than before, and
the reliability of the entire digital control device has also been improved.
The importance of the basic event reflects the degree of influence of occurrence of
the basic event on the top event. It can be used to find weak points of the system and
improve the reliability of system. At the same time, the lower the degree of importance,
the lower possibility of the entire system failure caused by the component failure, it
shows that the design is more optimized.
56 H. Qian et al.
According to formula (10), the importance value of input cards can be calculated
and recorded in Table 3.
According to Table 2, the importance value of the input card has been declined after
adopting the logic of selecting median from four inputs compared with the former, it
means that possibility of Pressurizer pressure control failure caused by single input card
failure is declined, it proves that the logic of selecting median from four inputs is more
highly optimized and increases reliability of the entire control device. In addition, as
running time increases, the importance difference between two input schemes becomes
smaller and smaller, because performance of card is degraded, the advantages logically
are no longer significant, but in the first decade of operation, the optimization of the
logic of selecting median from four inputs is much better than the three-input logic.
7 Conclusion
This paper mainly aims at the Control Device of Nuclear Pressurizer, uses the dynamic
fault tree modeling to analyze and evaluate the reliability of logic of selecting median
from four inputs, and studies the influence of the input logic on the reliability of overall
device. For the switching relationship between preferred channel and backup channel,
the priority AND gate are introduced. Then the dynamic fault tree is transformed into a
Markov chain for quantitative calculation. The calculation result compared with the
three-input logic show that the logic of selecting median from four inputs is superior to
the three-input logic in improving reliability of system. In addition, this paper calculate
current failure rate of devices by Bayesian considering operating data to make evalu-
ation result more accurate.
Research on Operational Reliability of Digital Control Device 57
Acknowledgments. This work was partially supported by Shanghai Science and Technology
Committee (Grant No. 18020500900), National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant
No. 61503237), Shanghai Natural Science Foundation (Grant No. 15ZR1418300) and Shanghai
Key Laboratory of Power Station Automation Technology (Grant No. 13DZ2273800).
References
1. Wang, Z.: Improvement of liquid level measurement method for deaerator. Forum Ind.
Technol. 14, 76–78 (2015)
2. Zhang, E.B.: Analysis of the implementation and characteristics of AP1000 regulator pressure
automatic control logic. China Hi-Tech Enterp. 33, 46–48 (2013)
3. Wang, X.K., Yang, X.H., Liu, G., et al.: Application of probabilistic safety assessment in
nuclear power plant protection system. East China Electr. Power 38, 725–729 (2010)
4. Chen, W.Q.: Research on Reliability Analysis Method of DCS in Nuclear Power Plant Based
on MFM. Harbin Engineering University (2013)
5. Zhou, S.L., Liu, Y.Y., Du, W.: Reliability analysis of digital reactor power control system in
nuclear power plant based on fault tree method. Nucl. Sci. Eng. 33, 419–428 (2013)
6. Qian, H., Luo, J.B., Jin, W.J., et al.: Reliability evaluation of DEH system optimization based
on dynamic fault tree. China Electr. Power 47, 92–96 (2014)
7. Li, Y.F.: A New Method of Dynamic Fault Tree Analysis for Complex Systems and Its
Application. University of Electronic Science and Technology of China (2013)
8. Kang, C.Z.: Research on Reliability Modeling and Evaluation of DCS in Thermal Power
Plants. North China Electric Power University (2014)
Electric Vehicles
Research on Torsional Vibration Suppression
of Electric Vehicle Driveline
1 Introduction
In order to improve the power efficiency of driveline, most electric vehicle cancels
clutch and torque converter which is the damping parts of whole system comparing
with traditional fuel vehicle. The experimental results show that sudden increase of
motor torque will cause the shock of transmission shafts resulting in vehicle starting
shaking [1]. For solving such torque ripple problems, researchers carried out a lot of
research on torque transfer characteristics of electric vehicle driveline.
Zhang Lijun studied the shaking phenomenon of a hybrid electric vehicle when
starting, the reason and control method of this vibration are put forward through road
test and modeling experiment using finite element method [2]. Aiming at researching
the abnormal noise of an electric vehicle driveline caused by sudden clutch joining, R
Turnbull studied the effect of vertical load on the noise [3]. Ma proposed a torque ripple
model of permanent magnet synchronous motor through bench test, and analyzed the
mechanism of torque ripple by orders [4]. Considering that hybrid electric vehicle
driveline removed clutch and torque converter, A kind of controller which can control
the output torque of wheel is designed by Syed [5].
The powertrain of electric vehicle is different from that of fuel vehicle, and its
mechanical part has low damping characteristic. Some scholars put forward that on the
basis of synthetically considering the motor performance and vehicle application, the
output torque ripple of motor can be restrained, the robustness of its control system can
be improved, and the power output quality of driveline can be optimized [6].
© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2018
K. Li et al. (Eds.): ICSEE 2018/IMIOT 2018, CCIS 925, pp. 61–69, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2381-2_6
62 Z. Cao et al.
Aiming at optimizing the performance of motor control system, the torque ripple of
electric vehicle driveline was restrained based on Matlab-Simulink, the torsional
dynamics model of vehicle driveline was built, and the simulation experiment was
carried out through studying the relationship between input resistance of driveline and
intention of driver. A PID controller using fuzzy self-tuning method was designed, and
the output curves of driveline using these controllers were compared and analyzed.
PMSM is the power source of electric vehicle powertrain. DC power is supplied from
battery pack, and is converted to 3 intersections by the inverter to drive PMSM
afterwards. After that, the output torque of motor is transmitted through transmission
shaft to wheel. The torsional vibration simulation model of driveline is established by
electro-mechanical coupling method. As shown in Fig. 1, the model includes two parts:
electrical part and mechanical part.
" #2 3
iA
ia 2 1 1
pffiffi2
12
pffiffi 4 i 5
¼ B ð1Þ
ib 3 0 23 23 iC
id cos h sin h ia
¼ ð2Þ
iq sin h cos h ib
can reduce coupling factor between parameters, simplify the mathematical model of
system, and facilitate control and analysis of motor.
3
Te ¼ p wf iq þ Ld Lq id iq ð3Þ
2
Considering electric vehicle needs stable constant torque under starting condition,
equation is obtained when id = 0:
3
Te ¼ pwf iq ð4Þ
2
Under high speed condition, driving resistance is mainly air resistance and rolling
resistance.
64 Z. Cao et al.
1
Fair ¼ v2vehicle cd qA ð5Þ
2
Ff ¼ G f ð6Þ
rtire
Tre ¼ ðFair þ Ff Þ ð7Þ
i
The model does not consider gear clearance, pavement response, tire deformation
and other factors. The stiffness of spring k is 2000 N*m/rad and the damping coeffi-
cient c is 2500 N*m*s/rad.
Mathematical model of mechanical part is as follows:
" € # " #
J1 0 h1 c c h_ 1
þ
0 J2 h€2 c c h_ 2
ð8Þ
k k h1 Te
þ ¼
k k h2 Tre
In order to improve the control performance of system, a fuzzy self-tuning PID con-
troller is designed in the speed loop of motor controller.
du/dt
fuzzy fuzzy reasoning
measure
defuzzification
PMSM
PID controller
system
-
Figure 6 shows the speed tracking of driveline model based on traditional PID
speed loop and fuzzy self-tuning PID speed loop respectively. The target speed of
model is simulated at 2000 r/m, and an additional interference of 100 N*m is set at 0.
1 s. The control system using fuzzy self-tuning PID has advantages of fast speed
feedback and low overshoot. After interference, the tracking accuracy of fuzzy PID is
lower than that of traditional PID due to wide basic domain of deviation E, but tracking
speed of both is within allowable error range.
The control ability of traditional PID speed loop is invariant because of fixed value
of KP and KI. If motor load changes, the output torque will fluctuate greatly. Figure 7
show the output torque of driveline. model based on fuzzy self-tuning PID and tra-
ditional PID in 0-2000 r/m acceleration process and additional interference respec-
tively. Fuzzy self-tuning PID can obviously restrain torque ripple in case of vehicle
load signal mutation. Its peak torque is 142 N*m, which is 17% less than that of
traditional PID controller.
Research on Torsional Vibration Suppression of Electric Vehicle Driveline 67
Figure 8 is phase current in motor controller. It can be seen that phase current
distortion amplitude is smaller and attenuation is faster based on fuzzy self-tuning PID
in case of control signal mutation at 0. 02 s and 0. 1 s.
FFT analysis is used to analyze the torque output data of system after 0. 1 s. The
torque harmonic frequency on drive shaft is mainly concentrated in 0–100 Hz and
3700–4000 Hz. High frequency harmonic is generated by inverter switching signal in
motor controller, while low frequency harmonic is generated by current distortion in
controller. The output torque of model using fuzzy self-tuning PID is 2. 942 N*m at
40 Hz, which is only 78% of that of traditional PID model.
68 Z. Cao et al.
Fig. 8. Controller phase current based on traditional PID and Fuzzy PID
Research on Torsional Vibration Suppression of Electric Vehicle Driveline 69
5 Conclusion
(1) Established simulation model effectively reflects the torsional vibration charac-
teristics of electric vehicle power transmission system and provides a theoretical
basis for further optimization of power output quality of transmission system.
(2) The design of fuzzy self-tuning PID controller can significantly improve speed
feedback and robustness of motor controller, and improve the control performance
of vehicle controller.
(3) The speed loop using fuzzy self-tuning PID can attenuate torque ripple caused by
sudden change of load and control signal, reduce peak torque, and contribute a lot
to solve the problem of torque ripple caused by electrical control.
References
1. Yu, P., Zhang, T., Wang, X., et al.: Powertrain torsional vibration of a central-driven pure EV.
J. Vib. Shock 34(10), 121–127 (2015)
2. Zhang, L-J., Zheng, P., Meng, D-J., et al.: Experimental study and control of longitudinal
flutter during vehicle starting with motor drive mode for hybrid electric car. Automot. Eng. 35
(3), 212–218 (2013)
3. Turnbull, R., Miknas, O.R., Mohammadpour, M., et al.: Combined experimental and flexible
multi-body dynamic investigation of high-energy impact-induced driveline vibration. Proc.
Inst. Mech. Eng. Part K J. Multi Body Dyn. 231, 181–193 (2016)
4. Ma, C., Zuo, S., Yang, D., et al.: Order feature analysis for torque ripple of permanent magnet
synchronous motor for an electric vehicle. J. Vib. Shock 32(13), 81–87 (2013)
5. Syed, F.U., Kuang, M.L., Ying, H.: Active damping wheel-torque control system to reduce
driveline oscillations in a power-split hybrid electric vehicle. IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol. 58
(9), 4769–4785 (2009)
6. Wang, S., Kang, K., Zhong, Z., et al.: Overviews of torque ripple suppression method with
permanent magnet synchronous motor used in electric vehicles. J. Power Supply 14(5), 24–32
(2016)
7. Chen, Y., Zhang, D., Jiang, P.: Simulation analysis of vector control system for asynchronous
motor in electric vehicles. J. Syst. Simul. 19(16), 3761–3765 (2007)
8. Wang, C., Zhou, M., Guo, Q.: Vector Control AC Servo Drive Motor, pp. 1–20. Mechanical
Industry Press, Beijing (1995)
9. Dost, P., Sourkounis, C., Agelidis, V.G.: On influence of deterministic and non-deterministic
modulation schemes in two-level filter-less inverter performance driving a permanent magnet
synchronous motor. In: Conference of the IEEE Proceedings of the Industrial Electronics
Society, IECON 2013 (2014)
Exploring a Sustainable Business Routing
for China’s New Energy Vehicles:
BYD as an Example
1 Introduction
China is experiencing a rapid growth in new energy vehicles sales since 2000.
Chinese government has issued several policies to encourage the production and
purchase of new energy vehicles, planning to expand the new energy vehicles
industry. However, it seems that private households have difficulties in finding
new energy vehicles offerings sufficiently attractive. Therefore, it indicates busi-
ness model innovations which are important complements to technology innova-
tions should also be explored.
Business model innovation provides a potential way to re-conceptualize the
purpose of the firm and the value creating logic, and rethink perceptions of value.
As suggested by Stubbs and Cocklin [1] Porter and Kramer [2], the assertion is
c Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2018
K. Li et al. (Eds.): ICSEE 2018/IMIOT 2018, CCIS 925, pp. 70–80, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2381-2_7
Exploring a Sustainable Business Routing for China’s New Energy Vehicles 71
that with careful business model redesign it is possible to more readily integrate
sustainability into their business for mainstream businesses, design and pursuit
sustainable business from the outset for new start-ups. Therefore, setting up a
sustainable business model of China’s new energy vehicles has been emerged as
an important innovation.
This article uses the triple layer business model canvas (TLBMC) which
builds on Osterwalder and Pigneur [3] original business model and allows for the
incorporation of the triple bottom line in the process of business model design
and innovation to communicate sustainable business model innovation of NEVs
in China. Therefore, the study objectives are the following: establish the triple
layer business model canvas on a specific firm, compare the original business
model canvas and TLBMC, sum up the sustainable route for NEVs firms in
China.
2 Methods
The method of this study sought to analysis sustainable business model by col-
lecting existing cases and extracting necessary rules and conditions. We selected
China’s leader companies in the new energy vehicles industry-BYD as the exem-
plar case study. The steps proposed in Fig. 1 are followed below.
3 Results
The evolution of BYD’s business model innovation has gone through two stages.
The first stage is the fuel vehicle entering the market stage. The second stage is
the new energy vehicle entering the market stage. As a result of the amount of
information, we here summarize the business model canvas (Fig. 2)at the early
stage and the three layer canvas (Figs. 3, 4 and 5) of BYD’s new energy vehicles
at the current stage.
72 Y. Lin et al.
Fig. 3. The triple layered business model canvas’s economic layer of BYD NEVs
Fig. 4. The triple layered business model canvas’s environmental layer of BYD NEVs
Fig. 5. The triple layered business model canvas’s social layer of BYD NEVs
Exploring a Sustainable Business Routing for China’s New Energy Vehicles 73
We believe that to describe a business model on economic layer can be done well
by the nine modules, which demonstrate the logic of a company’s searching for
profit.
Customer segments. This module describes the different target groups and agen-
cies a company wants to obtain and expect to serve. At early stage, When BYD
enters the automotive industry, it uses the low-end car to make up for the gap
in the market. The final customer of BYD’s fuel car is the medium and low-end
individual customer.
Value propositions. This module describes the provision of products and ser-
vices that create value for a customer group. BYD insists on the talent as the
fundamental management mode, with the imitation innovation as the technical
path, with low cost and high quality as the competitive advantage.
Key resources. This module describes the most important assets needed to
ensure the smooth running of a business model. BYD implements humanis-
tic management. In addition, BYD attaches great importance to technological
innovation and has initiated “imitation innovation”.
Key activities. This module describes the most important things that need to be
done to keep your business model up and running. The main business includes the
production of traditional fuel vehicles and related parts. BYD also improves the
convenience and efficiency of automobile manufacturing by vertically integrating
vertical supply chains while effectively reducing manufacturing costs.
74 Y. Lin et al.
Key partnerships. This module describes the network of suppliers and partners
needed to keep a business model running smoothly. BYD’s alliance with core
suppliers to weaken the bargaining ability of suppliers. Safeguarding the rights
and interests of investors has been a priority for BYD since its listing.
Cost structure. This module describes the full cost of running a business model.
The costs of BYD are mainly by research and development costs, manufacturing
costs, labor costs.
Channels. BYD NEVs are still mainly sold through distributors. As the current
company’s new energy vehicle product categories are not yet abundant, BYD
now uses BYD’s traditional car sales channels.
Revenue streams. The revenue of BYD new energy vehicles mainly come from
two sides, one is sales revenue, the other is government subsides. The government
provides strategic support to the NEVs industry through tariffs, subsidies and
tax incentives. However, royalties are also part of the revenue streams.
Exploring a Sustainable Business Routing for China’s New Energy Vehicles 75
Key activities. BYD adhere to its own brand, independent research and develop-
ment (R & D), with a complete industrial chain from R & D and design to create
vehicles. The production of vehicles is still one of the key activities of BYD. With
the development of new energy vehicles, battery production has become a major
part of the new energy vehicle business.
Key partnerships. BYD seek to form a closed cycle for the suppliers’ life cycle
management and create an efficient, collaborative, win-win supply chain plat-
form, and collaborate with customers to meet customer needs. What’s more,
BYD join research and technical cooperation with research institutions or aca-
demics. The government’s subsidies and support for new energy vehicles have
made BYD a partnership with the government.
Cost structure. Same as in the early days, the costs of BYD are mainly by
research and development costs, manufacturing costs, labor costs. However, BYD
invested more money to research and development design for new energy vehicles.
Functional value. The functional value describes the focal outputs of a service
(or product) of the organization being reviewed [4]. It simulates the functional
unit in a life cycle assessment, which is a quantitative description of the service
performance of the product system being investigated [5]. In this paper, the
evaluation of the functional unit is a car driving 600,000 km. New energy vehicles
throughout the life cycle of energy consumption and the main air pollutant
emissions, including CO2 , NOx , SOx , CO, VOC, CH4 [6].
who are engaged in the research and development in the areas of new materials,
automobile, new energy and rail transit and actively promote the progress of the
industry.
Production. The production component captures the actions that the organi-
zation takes to create value [4]. Using the GREET paint production, vehicle
painting, vehicle assembly energy consumption, battery production energy con-
sumption and emissions data, the total energy consumption of the automobile
manufacturing stage are calculated synthetically. For BYD E6, 16.2 million KJ
of energy consumption are produced during the car’s manufacturing phase.
Supplies and out-sourcing. Supplies and out-sourcing represent all the other
various material and production activities that are necessary for the organization
to be functional, but not “core” [4]. For BYD E6, in the available data of the
vehicle manufacturer, most of the impacts of supplies and outsourcing such as
machines and energy were included in the use phase.
Use phase. According to the “Mandatory Vehicle Scrapping Standards”, the car
travel 600,000 km that is scrapped standards, it is assumed that the car life cycle
mileage of 60 million km, regardless of the length of time. For BYD E6, the use
phase consists of two elements, electricity production and vehicle driving. The
use phase generates 13.6 billion KJ of energy consumption, 97.4 million grams
of CO2 ,19.1 thousand grams of CO,48.1 thousand grams of SOx ,57.2 thousand
grams of NOx ,157 thousand grams of dust,125 thousand grams of CH4 , and 8.33
thousand grams of VOC.
End-of-life. When the new energy vehicles reach the retirement age, some of the
materials can be recycled after dismantling. Due to the lack of standard of car
scrapping in China, the data of disassembly energy consumption is poor, so the
data of GREET model is adopted that apart a 1360 kg of small passenger car
required 1,476,090 KJ of energy consumption, dismantling a 2,098 kg of BYD
E6 required 2,277,085 KJ of energy consumption.
Exploring a Sustainable Business Routing for China’s New Energy Vehicles 77
Social value. Social value reflects the aspect of an organization’s mission, and
its focus is more broadly to create benefits for stakeholders and society [4]. BYD
strives to enhance the interest of government, shareholders, customers, employ-
ees, suppliers, partners and other stakeholders through innovative technology,
products and management and sound commercial operation, seeking to earn the
trust and respect of all stakeholders.
Social culture. The societal culture component recognizes the potential impact
of an organization on society as a whole. BYD’s strong corporate environmen-
tal and social responsibility and contribution to industrial development can be
interpreted as a culture of accountability.
78 Y. Lin et al.
Scale of outreach. Scale of the outreach describes the depth and breadth of the
organization’s relationship with stakeholders over time. The global footprint of
BYD new energy vehicles covers 190 cities in 43 countries and regions until
February 29, 2016.
End-users. The end user is the “consumer” value proposition. For BYD, the
end-user often happens to be the taxis, buses, coaches operators, government
business, logistics, storage and transportation and other special areas of users,
and low-end individual users. In the social canvas, BYD seeks to provide value
by meeting the user’s need in terms of energy saving and battery life mileage.
Social impacts. The social impacts partly solve the social cost of the organiza-
tion. The development BYD new energy vehicles may impact on the relationship
with the traditional automobile suppliers. Part of the traditional automobile sup-
pliers is facing transition with the popularization of new energy vehicles.
Social benefits. Social benefits are the active social value creating aspects of the
organization’s action. BYD advocates “creation made man first” concept, pay
attention to the cultivation of the employees, to improve the quality and skills
of the staff.
As shown in Fig. 6, the final results of the business models differ in various
ways. Comparing to BYD fuel vehicles business model, the sustainable business
model of new energy vehicles considers the environmental and social factor. The
environmental layer supports the identification of opportunities to prevent pol-
lution and reduce resource consumption through systematic analyses [5]. Based
on the relationships of the stakeholders, the social layer stronger social bene-
fits through the impact of strategic decision-making. Therefore, the sustainable
business model provides three different interpretations. Furthermore, business
strategies differ at different stages.
In contrast to the BMC of BYD fuel vehicles, where the customers are indi-
vidual users, in the TLBMC of BYD new energy vehicles the combination of the
mass market and public sector represent the impact of different actors on the
business model. In addition, the use phase on the environmental layer includes
some consideration of the client’s material resource and energy saving though
use. End user is the person in terms of energy saving and battery life mileage at
present stage.
BYD, after imitative innovation, will eventually be able to move toward
independent innovation. BYD has established three research and development
systems: Shenzhen Academia Sinica, Electric Power Research Institute and
Automotive Engineering Research Institute. For sustainable business model of
Exploring a Sustainable Business Routing for China’s New Energy Vehicles 79
BYD NEVs, energy for process and machine production support the organi-
zation competitive advantage within the environmental layer. Similar to this,
non-governmental organizations and communities are also considered for social
value. Therefore, the sustainable business model of BYD NEVs not only consider
“core” to the organization but also non-core to support the organization’s value
creation.
The research has shown how BYD concretely put in place different business
strategies at different stages. The case confirms that the correctness of the cur-
rent sustainable business model to implement the sustainable development goals.
The case study demonstrates the applicability of the sustainable business
model on the new energy vehicles, involving economic value, ecological value
and social value. It also enables the other new energy vehicle firms to establish
their business model in an effective and efficient way.
With the unprecedented speed at which customers’ needs and behaviors are
changing, a company’s ability to rapidly adapt or generate innovative business
models is critical to success. At present, new energy vehicles in the promotion
period. The new energy vehicle firms should innovative ecological environment.
Besides, the case confirms that the sustainable business model is valuable
for new energy vehicles firms. Analyzing the sustainable business model of new
energy vehicles should emphasize adding value while reducing costs, reducing
environmental pollution and increasing social benefits.
5 Conclusion
The objective of this paper is to analysis the China’s new energy vehicles sus-
tainable business model with the triple layered business model canvas. The case
study confirms that the sustainable business model is valuable for new energy
vehicles, and suggest that new energy vehicle firms should improve technology to
80 Y. Lin et al.
capture the market, reduce the pollution and increase social benefits. The case
study demonstrates the importance of innovation in order to find the suitable
way of the new energy vehicles in particular period. What’s more, the application
of the TLBMC, a sustainable business model approach, in the case study demon-
strate its applicability and efficacy. In contrast to BMC, the TLMBC offers a
sustainable perspective on business model.
Acknowledgements. This work was supported in part by the National Social Science
Fund of China (Grant No. 18BJY066), Fundamental Research Funds for the Central
Universities (Grant No. 106112016CDJXZ338825), Chongqing key industrial generic
key technological innovation projects (Grant No. cstc2015zdcy-ztzx60009), Chongqing
Science and Technology Research Program (Grant No. cstc2015yykfC60002).
References
1. Robinson, J.: Squaring the circle? some thoughts on the idea of sustainable devel-
opment. Ecol. Econ. 48, 369–384 (2004)
2. Porter, M.E., Kramer, M.R.: The competitive advantage of corporate philanthropy.
Harvard Bus. Rev. 80(12), 57 (2002)
3. Osterwalder, A., Pigneur, Y.: Business Modell Generation. Willey, Hoboken (2010)
4. Joyce, A., Paquin, R.L.: The triple layered business model canvas: a tool to design
more sustainable business models. J. Cleaner Prod. 135, 1474–1486 (2016)
5. Rebitzer, G., Ekvall, T., Frischknecht, R.: Life cycle assessment part 1: framework,
goal and scope definition, inventory analysis, and applications. Environ. Int. 30(5),
701–720 (2004)
6. Gao, Y.B., Mao, X.Q., Yang, S.X.: Analysis and evaluation on energy conservation
and emission reduction of new energy vehicles based on LCA. J. Environ. Sci. 33(5),
1504–1512 (2013)
7. Liu, K.H.: Life Cycle Evaluation of BYD E6 Pure Electric Vehicle. Fujian Agricul-
ture and Forestry University (2016)
Large-Scale Electric Vehicle Energy Demand
Considering Weather Conditions and Onboard
Technology
1 Introduction
Pele ¼ gAC PAC þ gCD PCD þ gNav PNav þ gScr PScr þ gILi PILi þ gELi PELi ð1Þ
84 S. Luo et al.
where g is the usage percentage of each device. The usage percentages can be obtained
from statistics or real-time records.
1
gðd; l; rÞ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffi eðln dlÞ =2r
2 2
ð2Þ
d 2pr
where l is the loge mean and r is the standard deviation of the corresponding daily
travel distance probability density distribution, d [ 0.
Weather conditions include temperature, precipitation and wind. Typical values
from UK statistics of these factors are listed in Table 3 [20]. Reasonable assumptions
[21, 22] have been made due to lack of statistical data for some weather conditions.
Large-Scale Electric Vehicle Energy Demand 85
l and r are not only affected by weather conditions but also by the statistical
uncertainty. For example in 2008, the average (per annum) travel distance of private
cars in Ireland was 16,376 km: in Dublin (capital city) travel distance was 12,886 km,
while in more rural areas of the country, 17,241 km was the average travel [14]. Due to
a lack of available statistical data, this paper has used published national statistical data
for this case study.
where dRR is the actual maximum range and dRR ¼ 1=ð1=dR þ Pele =va EB Þ; Ptra is the
average power consumption for traction; Pele =va EB is the correction factor with respect
to customer-based factors. EB =dR is the energy consumption of an EV travelling per
unit distance; Pele =va is the energy consumption of onboard technology and electronic
devices per unit distance; 1=dR is the SOC consumption of the EV travelling per unit
distance; Pele =va EB is also the SOC consumption of onboard technology and electronic
devices per unit distance. In (3) the power loss is neglected and Ptra is assumed to be
linear negative proportional to time.
Since all the parameters in (5a–5c) are positive, @SOC=@Pele \0, @SOC=@va [ 0,
and @SOC=@d\0.
Therefore, as a brief conclusion, when onboard technology and device consumption
is less, the daily average travel speed is higher and the daily travel distance is shorter.
The longer the trip lasts, the longer the duration of power consumption by electrical
loads, thus the higher the required energy by the electrical devices. In this work, it is
Large-Scale Electric Vehicle Energy Demand 87
assumed that the energy consumption by traction is independent on the vehicle’s speed
within the range given in Table 3. In comparison to raw estimates of travel distance,
often based on vehicle manufacturer’s specifications and published statistical data (e.g.,
Table 1) the effective travel distance of an EV will be shortened. It should also be
noticed that battery degradation, which can influence battery capacity EB , has not been
included in this study, but its inclusion will be the subject of future work.
1
hðSOC; l; rÞ ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffi
dRR ð1
n SOCÞ 2pr . o
exp ½lnð1 SOCÞ þ lnðdRR Þ l2 2r2 ð6Þ
where dm is the mean distance. Discussions of the influences of l, r, and dRR on h are
given in Table 4.
From Table 4 it can be determined that the PDF of battery SOC after one day travel
is strongly affected by the parameters of this model as well as the initial SOC. Based on
previous researches, the probabilities are calculated as the sum of the products of h and
the number of EVs. However, the number of EVs is obtained by an optimization
solution [25]. Moreover, the above parameters are usually calculated from statistics or
defaults.
88 S. Luo et al.
4 Case Study
In this case study, a maximum travel distance of approximately 80 miles is assumed for
EVs with a typical 25 kWh lithium-ion battery [24]. Thus, dR ¼ 80 mi and
EB ¼ 25 kWh. Three cases are considered as follows:
(1) Case I: Normal day without usage of onboard technology or electronic devices;
(2) Case II: Normal day with limited use of onboard technology and devices;
(3) Case III: 10% usage of onboard technology and devices under different weather
conditions as follows: III-A: Low temperature; III-B: High temperature; III-C:
Light precipitation; III-D: Heavy precipitation; III-E: Soft wind; III-F: Strong wind;
4.1 Case I
In this case, dRR ¼ dR ¼ 80, Pele ¼ 0. The PDF of initial SOC after one day travel is
shown in Fig. 2(a).
(a) (b)
Fig. 2. (a) PDF of initial SOC in normal day, (b) PDF of initial SOC in normal day with
onboard electronic devices in use
4.2 Case II
In this case, the power levels in Table 2 were set as moderate values. Thus, Pele ¼ 4:28
if g is assumed to be 100% for different devices. Then, dRR ¼ 45:88. The PDF of initial
SOC after one day travel is shown in Fig. 2(b).
From Fig. 2(b) it can be seen that there is a slight curtailment when the SOC is
small. The curtailment indicates that use of onboard technology and devices could
significantly reduce the EV maximum range.
Figure 3 provides the trend of maximum ranges with the change of device usage,
demonstrating the discussion in (5a). It is apparent that air conditioning consumes the
greatest energy, if used throughout a trip; hence the vehicle distance is reduced to 60%
of effective range. Other onboard devices, in comparison, have less impact on con-
sumption rendering 4.6% reduction in vehicle range. Therefore minimizing the use of
air conditioning in particular will limit the reduction of actual EV range.
Cases III-A, D and F have similar performances since the parameters do not vary
significantly. In terms of actual weather conditions, it means that the travel patterns
under low temperature, heavy precipitation and strong wind are similar. There are
slight curtailments when the SOC is small, which can barely be seen from this figure. It
will be illustrated in Fig. 5.
During light precipitation (Case III-C) and soft wind (Case III-E), the PDFs are
close to the PDF in normal day due to similar travel patterns.
Case III-B shows that during high temperature there will be more capacity left in
the EV battery based on the data in Table 3, meaning that people are more likely to use
other transport to substitute EVs, which has the same conclusion in [14].
Figure 4 demonstrates the discussion in Table 4. The integrals of each curve in
Fig. 4 are able to show the EV employment under various weather conditions. For
example, the integral of Case III-B from 0% to 80% is smaller than that of Case III-A.
It means that the initial SOC is higher when the temperature is higher, which also
indicates that there is less EV use.
It should be noted that the different percentages of onboard technology and elec-
tronic device use are not related to different weather conditions in this case due to a lack
of statistical data.
Figure 5 provides the maximum ranges under different weather conditions. Based
on the data in Table 3, the cases are ordered with the increase of va also demonstrating
the discussion in (5b), such that the effective travel distance rises with the increase of
daily average travel speed.
5 Conclusions
The EV is considered a viable solution to offset excess consumption of fossil fuels for
human transport. Many global countries are actively encouraging large-scale EV
provision, though the most significant user concern is the actual range of commercial
EVs. This paper connects the EV battery SOC with daily travel distance and estimates
the EV energy demand by including customer-based factors, such as the level of
onboard technology, electronic devices and prevailing weather conditions. The PDF of
the initial battery SOC and actual maximum range of EV can be obtained. A correction
factor is used in the SOC estimation method to include onboard energy consumption.
Typical values of the parameters for PDFs under various weather conditions are given
based on published statistics and basic assumptions of use. Moreover, the influence of
basic onboard consumption patterns has also been analyzed.
The PDFs of the SOC under various weather conditions and the influences of
customer-based consumption on EV maximum range have been exemplified in a case
study. The results quantitatively show that with inclusion of onboard consumption, the
actual travel range of an EV is reduced. Air conditioning in particular is a dominant
onboard consumer and its use may reduce the maximum practical range to 60% of
projected distance. Thus, minimizing air conditioning usage can extend the actual EV
range. This paper has also established that a reduction in the use of onboard electronic
devices, higher daily average travel speed, and a shorter daily travel distance will result
in a higher (initial) SOC, thus providing a greater range thereafter.
The PDFs under low temperature, heavy precipitation and strong wind are similar,
and the PDFs under light precipitation and soft wind are close to the PDF in a normal
day. This is because the travel patterns under these weather conditions are similar.
Furthermore, other transport is likely to be used to substitute EVs when outside tem-
peratures are hot.
Both onboard technology and weather conditions influence EV daily energy
demand. EV energy demand increases with use of onboard technology and devices.
A shorter effective range results in higher energy demand.
Acknowledgments. This paper was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (61703081), and Natural Science Foundation of Liaoning Province (20170520113).
References
1. Pop, V., Bergveld, H.J., Notten, P.H.L., et al.: State-of-the-art of battery state-of-charge
determination. Meas. Sci. Technol. 16(4), R93–R110 (2005)
2. Williamson, S.S.: Future charging infrastructures and energy management strategies for
electric and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles. In: 2012 25th IEEE Canadian Conference on
Electrical & Computer Engineering (CCECE), pp. 1–3. IEEE Press, New York (2013)
3. Erjavec, J.: Hybrid, Electric & Fuel-Cell Vehicles, 2nd edn. Delmar, New York (2013)
4. Stević, Z.: New Generation of Electric Vehicles. InTech, Rijeka (2012)
5. Liu, W., Xuan, Z., Jian, M.: A new neural network model for the state-of-charge estimation
in the battery degradation process. Appl. Energy 121, 20–27 (2014)
92 S. Luo et al.
6. Xu, J., Mi, C.C., Cao, B., et al.: The state of charge estimation of lithium-ion batteries based
on a proportional-integral observer. IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol. 63, 1614–1621 (2014)
7. Zhang, C., Li, K., Pei, L., et al.: An integrated approach for real-time model-based state-of-
charge estimation of lithium-ion batteries. J. Power Sources 283, 24–36 (2015)
8. Zhang, P., Qian, K., Zhou, C., et al.: A methodology for optimization of power systems
demand due to electric vehicle charging load. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 27, 1628–1636
(2012)
9. Cai, H., Du, W., Yu, X., et al.: Day-ahead optimal charging/discharging scheduling for
electric vehicles in micro-grids. In: 2nd IET Renewable Power Generation Conference (RPG
2013), pp. 1–4. IET, London (2013)
10. Qi, Z.: Advances on air conditioning and heat pump system in electric vehicles – a review.
Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 38, 754–764 (2014)
11. Chukwu, U.C., Mahajan, S.M.: V2G parking lot with PV rooftop for capacity enhancement
of a distribution system. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy 5, 119–127 (2014)
12. Farghal, S.A., Tantawy, M.A., El-Alfy, A.E.: Optimum design of stand alone solar thermal
power system with reliability constraint. IEEE Trans. Energy Convers. EC-2, 215–221
(2009)
13. Chien, J., Tseng, K., Yan, B.: Design of a hybrid battery charger system fed by a wind-
turbine and photovoltaic power generators. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 82, 095106 (2011)
14. Leahy, P.G., Foley, A.M.: Impact of weather conditions on electric vehicle performance. In:
Proceedings of the Irish Transport Research Network Conference 2011, ITRN2011, Cork,
pp. 1–4 (2011)
15. Jayaweera, D., Islam, S.: Risk of supply insecurity with weather condition-based operation
of plug in hybrid electric vehicles. IET Gener. Transm. Distrib. 8, 2153–2162 (2014)
16. Wua, X., Freeseb, D., Cabrerab, A., et al.: Electric vehicles’ energy consumption
measurement and estimation. Transp. Res. Part D Transp. Environ. 34, 52–67 (2015)
17. Engvall, L., Cook, A., Khaligh, A.: A predictive trip-based method for state of charge
maintenance in series PHEVs to boost cold weather efficiency. In: 2012 IEEE Transportation
Electrification Conference and Expo (ITEC), pp. 1–6. IEEE Press, New York (2012)
18. Smith, R., Morison, M., Capelle, D., et al.: GPS-based optimization of plug-in hybrid
electric vehicles’ power demands in a cold weather city. Transp. Res. Part D Transp. Environ.
16, 614–618 (2011)
19. Shams-Zahraei, M., Kouzani, A.Z., Kutter, S., et al.: Integrated thermal and energy
management of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles. J. Power Sources 216, 237–248 (2012)
20. Department for Transport: National Travel Survey 2012. https://www.gov.uk/government/
publications/national-travel-survey-2012
21. National Grid: Historical Demand Data. http://www2.nationalgrid.com/UK/Industry-
information/Electricity-transmission-operational-data/Data-explorer/
22. Tsapakis, I., Cheng, T., Bolbol, A.: Impact of weather conditions on macroscopic urban
travel times. J. Transp. Geogr. 28, 204–211 (2013)
23. Mahmassani, H.S., Dong, J., Kim, J., et al.: Incorporating weather impacts in traffic
estimation and prediction systems. US Department of Transportation. FHWA-JPO-09-065,
EDL# 14497 (2009)
24. Zhou, B., Littler, T., Foley, A.: Electric vehicle capacity forecasting model with application
to load levelling. In: IEEE PES General Meeting 2015, pp. 1–5. IEEE Press, New York
(2015)
25. European commission: Energy Roadmap 2050 Impact assessment and scenario analysis.
SEC(2011) 1565 final (2011)
Large-Scale Electric Vehicle Energy Demand 93
26. Zhou, B., Littler, T., Wang, H.: The impact of vehicle-to-grid on electric power systems: a
review. In: IET Renewable Power Generation Conference 2013, pp. 1–4. IET, London
(2013)
27. Cui, M., Ke, D., Sun, Y., et al.: Wind power ramp event forecasting using a stochastic
scenario generation method. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy 6(2), 422–433 (2015)
28. Cui, M., Zhang, J., Wu, H., et al.: Wind-friendly flexible ramping product design in multi-
timescale power system operations. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy 8(3), 1064–1075 (2017)
29. Cui, M., Zhang, J., Florita, A., et al.: An optimized swinging door algorithm for identifying
wind ramping events. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy 7(1), 150–162 (2016)
Siting and Sizing of Distributed Generation
and Electric Vehicle Charging Station
Under Active Management Mode
Abstract. This paper is concerned with bi-level joint planning model of distrib‐
uted generation (DG) and electric vehicle charging station (EVCS) siting and
sizing under active management (AM) mode. Firstly, the joint planning model
including DG and EVCS is established by taking the lowest annual comprehen‐
sive cost as the upper level objective. Then, the lower level model optimizes DG
output curtailment by taking the uncertainty of load, EVCS charging load, and
the intermittent DG output of wind farm and photovoltaic generator into account.
According to the bidirectional interaction of upper and lower levels, the bi-level
planning model is optimized by biogeography-based optimization (BBO) and
primal-dual interior point method (PDIPM) respectively. Finally, simulation is
operated on the revised IEEE-33 nodes distribution network, and simulation
results show that the joint planning of DG and EVCS can obtain better planning
scheme.
1 Introduction
With the rapid development of the energy market and increasing attention to environ‐
mental protection, distributed generation (DG) and electric vehicle (EV) with clean
advantages are playing an increasingly key role in the distribution network, which is the
development trend of the power industry [1, 2]. A large number of DG and EV are
accessed to distribution network, which present a severe challenge to the existing passive
management model. Consequently, active management (AM) mode is proposed, where
DGs and electric vehicle charging station (EVCS) are treated as part of the distribution
network. However, it is necessary to study the joint optimal planning of DG and EVCS
under AM mode.
Some research works have been proposed to the siting and sizing of DG and EVCS
in the active distribution network (ADN). Considering the uncertainty of intermittent
DWG, optimal planning of batteries in the ADN is presented, and the model is solved
by a hybrid tabu search/particle swarm optimization (TS/PSO) algorithm [3]. It is
assumed that DG can provide the critical loads of the distribution system by reallocating
after some accident, and a hierarchical approach is proposed to assess the impact of
changing of the distribution system in power system risk assessment [4]. The siting and
sizing model of EVCS is established by taking lowest annual comprehensive cost as the
objective considering the service radius of EVCS and environmental factors [5]. A cost-
effective model is proposed to optimal the siting of EVCS, which can provide the best
returns on investment while also meeting critical service requirements [6]. However,
these studies are not concerned with the joint planning of DG and EVCS.
To solve these problems, a bi-level joint planning model of DG and EVCS siting
and sizing under AM mode is established by taking the uncertainties of EVCS charging
load, wind turbine generator (WTG), photovoltaic generator (PVG) and load into
account. The upper planning aims at DG and EVCS joint planning with the goal of
minimizing annual comprehensive cost, and the lower planning optimizes DG output
curtailment. Furthermore, the upper and lower models are solved by biogeography-
based optimization (BBO) and primal-dual interior point method (PDIPM), respectively.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows: the models of EVCS charging load,
WTG, PVG, and load are given in Sect. 2. Section 3 presents the bi-level joint planning
model and solution method for siting and sizing of DG and EVCS. Simulations are given
in Sect. 4, following the conclusion in Sect. 5.
To describe the uncertainty of EVCS charging load, WTG, PVG and load, this paper
divides 24 h a day into 24-time intervals for the accurate description of the input random
variable and uses different models to describe the random variables.
According to the relevant experimental research, the charging and discharging power
of EV can be approximately obeyed normal distribution [7], and the charge and discharge
power can be expressed by normal distribution:
where Pv is the active power of EV charging demand; 𝜇v and 𝜎v2 are the mean and standard
deviation of the EV charging demand, respectively.
Consider that the wind speed and light intensity are subjected to two parameters Weibull
distribution [8] and beta distribution [9], PVG active power output PPVG and WTG active
power output PWTG can be expressed as:
96 W. Shan et al.
{
PPVG,r S∕Sr , S ≤ Sr ,
PPVG = (2)
PPVG,r , S > Sr .
where PPVG,r and PWTG,r are the rated output power of PVG and WTG, Sr is the rated
light intensity, Vci is cut-in wind speed, Vco is cut-out wind speed, Vr is rated wind speed.
The load can be described by normal distribution [10]:
where Pload is the active load, 𝜇p and 𝜎p2 are the mean and standard deviation of the load,
respectively.
The main barrier for reaching the higher levels of DG in distribution network is the node
voltage limit exceeding [11–13]. In order to overcome the above obstacle, two AM
methods are used: (1) DG output controlling. The output of DG is adjusted by load at
various times. (2) On-load-tap-changer (OLTC): OLTC maintains the network voltages
within defined limits by actively changing the tap-changer setting at primary substation.
Then, a bi-level DG and EVCS siting and sizing joint planning model under AM
mode is proposed, and the model takes the minimum annual comprehensive cost of DG
and EVCS as the upper level planning objective. Furthermore, based on the siting and
sizing of DG and EVCS, the lower level model optimizes DG output curtailment.
where Ftotal is the annual comprehensive cost, Finv,DG and Finv,EVCS are the installation and
investment cost of DG and EVCS, respectively, FOM,DG and FOM,EVCS are the annual
operation and maintenance cost of DG and EVCS, Floss is the annual active losses cost
of the distribution network; FAM is the cost of AM and FU is the environmental subsidies
of the renewable DG. Finv,DG, Finv,EVCS, FOM,DG, FOM,EVCS, Floss, FAM and FU can be calcu‐
lated by:
Siting and Sizing of Distributed Generation and Electric Vehicle 97
∑ r(1 + r)n
Finv,DG = Xinv,DG wDG,i , (6)
i∈NDG
(1 + r)n − 1
∑ r(1 + r)n
Finv,EVCS = (Xinv,EVCS
1
+ Xinv,EVCS
2
wEVCS,i ) , (7)
i∈NEVCS
(1 + r)n − 1
∑∑
FOM,DG = 365 XOM,DG PDG,i,t Δt, (8)
t∈T i∈NDG
∑ ∑
FOM,EVCS = 365 XOM,EVCS PEVCS,i,t Δt, (9)
t∈T i∈NEVCS
∑
Floss = 365 Xloss Ploss,t Δt, (10)
t∈T
∑∑
FAM = 365 XAM PDG,i,t Δt,
(11)
t∈T i∈NDG
∑∑
FU = 365 XU PDG,i,t Δt, (12)
t∈T i∈NDG
where NDG and NEVCS are DG and EVCS installation nodes, respectively; Xinv,DG is the
installation and investment cost of unit DG; wDG,i is the installation capacity at the
candidate node i of DG; r is the discount rate, taking 10%; n is the economic life, taking
1 2
20 years; Xinv,EVCS and Xinv,EVCS are fix and variable investment cost of EVCS, respec‐
tively; wEVCS,i is the installation capacity at the candidate node i of EVCS; T = 24h;
XOM,DG and XOM,EVCS are the operation and maintenance cost of unit of electricity by DG
and EVCS; PDG,i,t and PEVCS,i,t are the charging load of the DG and EVCS at the candidate
node i in period t ; Δt is the time interval, taking 1 h; Xloss is the electricity price; Ploss,t
is the electricity losses in period t ; XAM is the AM cost of unit of electricity by DG; XU
is the environmental subsidies of unit of electricity by renewable DG.
The constraints of upper level planning model can be described as:
(1) DG penetration constraint:
∑ ∑
wDG,i = 𝛽 Lj , (13)
i∈NDG j∈Nnode
where, wWTG,i and wPVG,i are the installation capacity at the candidate node i of WTG
and PVG, respectively; 𝛽 is the DG penetration; Lj is the load peak of the load node i .
(2) DG installation constraint:
The lower level model is a typical optimal power flow (OPF), and the objective is to
minimize DG output curtailment, which can be shown as follow:
∑∑
min Pcur,i,t , (17)
t∈T i∈NDG
∑
Qis = Ui Uj (Gij sin 𝜃ij − Bij cos 𝜃ij ), (19)
j∈i
where, Pis and Qis is active power and reactive power of node i respectively; Ui is the
voltage of node i ; j ∈ i represent all the nodes that directly connected with node i ; Gij
and Bij are the real and imaginary part of node admittance matrix; 𝜃ij is phase angle
difference between the nodes i and j; Nnode is a set of system nodes; Sij is the power flow
of branch ij; Nline is a set of system branches.
(2) On-load tap-changer (OLTC) transformer tap adjustment constraint.
Pmin
cur,i,t
≤ Pcur,i,t ≤ Pmax
cur,i,t
, i ∈ NDG . (23)
Siting and Sizing of Distributed Generation and Electric Vehicle 99
Mutation Migration
operator operator
Begin
N
Termination condition reached?
End
The lower level is solved by the PDIPM [16], Monte Carlo simulation (MCS) [17]
is used for the uncertainties sampling of EVCS charging load. Then, WTG, PVG, and
load, then, the DG output curtailment can be calculated by PDIPM, which is the lower
level objective value.
The BBO and PDIPM are used to solve the upper and lower level planning, respec‐
tively, the whole process is shown in Fig. 2.
4 Simulation Results
The case used for siting and sizing of DG and EVCS is IEEE-33 nodes system as shown
in Fig. 3 [18]. The example is a 12.6 kV system and the planning is fixed to 20 years.
The rated wind speed, cut-in and cut-out wind speed are 14 m/s, 3.5 m/s, and 20 m/s
respectively; power factor is 0.95; the rated light intensity is 1000 W/m2; load and EVCS
charging load square variance are both 0.1; MCS hits are 500. Installation and investment
cost of DG and EVCS are set as 400 $/kW and 443 $/kW. Fix and variable investment
cost of EVCS are set as 285.71 and 714.29 $/kW. Operation and maintenance costs of
WTG, PVG and EVCS are set as 0.05 $/kWh, 0.03 $/kWh, and 0.09 $/kWh. Electricity
purchasing price is 0.08 $/kWh, AM cost for WTG and PVG are both 0.01 $/kWh, the
environmental subsidies for WTG and PVG are both 0.04 $/kWh.
19 20 21 22
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18
26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33
23 24 25
There are three candidate nodes of WTG in the distribution system, which are the
nodes 8, 12 and 17. Three candidate nodes of WTG are nodes 5, 25 and 30, and six
candidate nodes of EVCS are the nodes 4, 8, 12, 15, 25, and 30. The rated capacity of
unit DG is 10 kW, access limit is both 10 of WTG and PVG. DG penetration is less than
10%, and the EVCS charging load requirements is 600 kW.
The typical load curve of EVCS is based on the data in [19], and the 1440 charge
load points are normalized and averaged for each hour. The charge load per hour is
shown in Fig. 4.
Siting and Sizing of Distributed Generation and Electric Vehicle 101
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
0 4 8 12 16 20 24
Hour
The relevant expenses of two schemes is shown in Table 3. The annual comprehen‐
sive cost of scheme 1 is 95.92 thousand dollars less than scheme 2, and the annual active
losses cost of scheme 1 is 3.15 thousand dollars less than scheme 2, which show that
joint planning of DG and EVCS can save the total cost of DG and EVCS planning,
reducing the active power loss of active distribution network.
102 W. Shan et al.
Figure 5 compares the node voltage under two schemes at the same time, the
maximum voltage amplitude allowed by each node is 1.1 p.u., and the minimum voltage
amplitude allowed is 0.9 p.u. The node voltage of scheme 1 is better than that of
scheme 2, so the joint planning of DG and EVCS can improve the node voltage of
distribution network.
1.15
Scheme 1
1.1 Scheme 2
Voltage amplitude(p.u.)
1.05
0.95
0.9
0.85
1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25 27 29 31 33
Node number
5 Conclusions
In this paper, a bi-level joint planning model of DG and EVCS under AM mode is
established. The siting and sizing model of DG and EVCS is proposed by taking lowest
annual comprehensive cost as the upper level objective, and the upper level is solved by
BBO. Then, based on the upper level planning, the lower level model optimizes DG
output curtailment, and is solved by PDIPM. The experimental results of the IEEE-33
nodes distribution network show that the joint planning of DG and EVCS can obtain the
better planning scheme.
Siting and Sizing of Distributed Generation and Electric Vehicle 103
The energy storage system access distribution network has put forward the new
challenge to ADN planning, it is necessary to carry on the comprehensive planning from
many aspects such as power grid stability, and the influence on power quality. Therefore,
how to evaluate power quality and put forward measures to improve power quality is
also a worthy research problem in the future.
Acknowledgments. This work was supported in part by the national Science Foundation of China
under Grant No.61773253, and project of Science and technology Commission of Shanghai
Municipality under Grants No. 15JC1401900, 14JC1402200, and 17511107002.
References
1. Du, D.J., Chen, R., Fei, M.R., et al.: A novel networked online recursive identification method
for multivariable systems with incomplete measurement information. J. IEEE Trans. Sign.
Inf. Process. Netw. 3(4), 744–759 (2017)
2. Du, D.J., Chen, R., Fei, M.R., et al.: Malicious data deception attacks against power systems:
a new case and its detection method. J. Trans. Inst. Meas. Control. (2018). DOI:
10.1177/0142331217740622
3. Sedghi, M., Ahmadian, A., Aliakbar-Golkar, M.: Optimal storage planning in active
distribution network considering uncertainty of wind power distributed generation. J. IEEE
Trans. Power Syst. 31(1), 304–316 (2016)
4. Jia, H., Qi, W., Liu, Z., et al.: Hierarchical risk assessment of transmission system considering
the influence of active distribution network. J. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 30(2), 1084–1093
(2015)
5. Liu, Z., Wen, F., Ledwich, G.: Optimal planning of electric-vehicle charging stations in
distribution systems. J. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 28(1), 102–110 (2012)
6. Sheppard, C.J.R., Harris, A., Gopal, A.R.: Cost-effective siting of electric vehicle charging
infrastructure with agent-based modeling. J. IEEE Trans. Transp. Electrif. 2(2), 174–189
(2016)
7. Quevedo, P.M.D., Muñoz-Delgado, G., Contreras, J.: Impact of electric vehicles on the
expansion planning of distribution systems considering renewable energy, storage and
charging stations. J. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid. PP(99), 1 (2017)
8. Aien, M., Fotuhi-Firuzabad, M., Rashidinejad, M.: Probabilistic optimal power flow in
correlated hybrid wind-photovoltaic power systems. J. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 5(1), 130–
138 (2014)
9. Cao, Y., Zhang, Y., Zhang, H., et al.: Probabilistic optimal PV capacity planning for wind
farm expansion based on NASA data. J. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy 8(3), 1291–1300 (2017)
10. Ran, X., Miao, S.: Three-phase probabilistic load flow for power system with correlated wind,
photovoltaic and load. J. IET Gener. Transm. Distrib. 10(12), 3093–3101 (2016)
11. Gill, S., Kockar, I., Ault, G.W.: Dynamic optimal power flow for active distribution networks.
J. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 29(1), 121–131 (2013)
12. Salih, S.N., Chen, P.: On coordinated control of OLTC and reactive power compensation for
voltage regulation in distribution systems with wind power. J. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 31(5),
4026–4035 (2016)
13. Luo, T., Dolan, M.J., Davidson, E.M., et al.: Assessment of a new constraint satisfaction-
based hybrid distributed control technique for power flow management in distribution
networks with generation and demand response. J. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 6(1), 271–278
(2015)
104 W. Shan et al.
14. Dan, S.: Biogeography-based optimization. J. IEEE Trans. Evol. Comput. 12(6), 702–713
(2008)
15. Wang, Y., Li, X.: A hybrid chaotic biogeography based optimization for the sequence
dependent setup times flowshop scheduling problem with weighted tardiness objective. J.
IEEE Access 5, 26046–26062 (2017)
16. Jiang, Q., Geng, G., Guo, C., et al.: An efficient implementation of automatic differentiation
in interior point optimal power flow. J. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 25(1), 147–155 (2010)
17. Torquato, R., Shi, Q., Xu, W., et al.: A monte carlo simulation platform for studying low
voltage residential networks. J. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 5(6), 2766–2776 (2014)
18. Baran, M.E., Wu, F.F.: Network reconfiguration in distribution systems for loss reduction
and load balancing. J. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 4(2), 1401–1407 (1989)
19. Ding, H., Hu, Z., Song, Y.: Value of the energy storage system in an electric bus fast charging
station. J. Appl. Energy 157, 630–639 (2015)
Real-Time Adjustment of Load Frequency
Control Based on Controllable Energy
of Electric Vehicles
1 Introduction
With the implementation of energy saving, emission reduction and low-carbon eco-
nomic policies, renewable energy sources will occupy a larger proportion in the grid.
Due to high climbing rate of traditional regulation unit, power system respond slowly
to the frequency fluctuations caused by intermittent fluctuations of renewable energy.
Therefore, a number of researches about solar, wind energy and energy storage tech-
nology participating in system FR began to arise.
As a branch of energy storage technology, the EV has good prospects for partic-
ipation in system FR due to large-scale development of EVs. The continuous
improvement of V2G technology makes the operability of EVs participating in system
FR increases. By adjusting the charging and discharging power, EVs can suppress the
frequency fluctuations caused by intermittent energy sources such as wind and solar
energy [1]. Efficient frequency support can be provided in smart grid by utilizing fleet
of EVs which act as controllable loads and closely coordinate with aggregators and
charging stations [2, 3]. The controllable energy of EV affected by its own traffic
attributes varies with the time of day, and the varying controllable energy of EV further
affects the system FR at varying times.
Considering the traffic characteristics and state transition characteristics of EVs, this
paper presents a real-time controllable energy calculation method. On this basis, the
real-time allocating scheme of system FR is proposed to analyze the influence of real-
time controllable energy of EVs of different types on participating in the system FR.
With constraints of real-time controllable energy and charging/discharging power, EVs
can share the pressure of traditional regulation unit. Because EV’s participation in FR is
a way to make full use of existing energy storage resources, EV energy storage
resources should be given priority in the allocation of FR tasks. So according to the
real-time changes of EV’s controllable energy, the real-time allocation scheme of
system FR coefficient is proposed to improve the rationality of FR task allocation. The
simulation results show that the proposed methods are correct and effective.
In-controlled state refers to that the EV changes from idle or charging state into
controllable state depending on its SOC, and out-controlled state refers to that the EV
changes from controllable state into idle or charging state. In a day, the controllable
quantity of EVs in the region changes dynamically with the transition of the EV’s state.
Combing with the driving rules of EVs [4], the changing characteristics of EV’s
controllable quantity is analyzed.
t0 is defined as the starting time, and the initial number of controllable EVs at t0 is
N0 . The number of controllable EVs at t, Nc ðtÞ, is defined in (1) below,
The cumulative number of EVs under in-controlled state and out-controlled state at
time t, Nin ðtÞ and Nout ðtÞ, can be calculated by (2) and (3),
X
t
0
Nin ðtÞ ¼ Nin ðjÞ ð2Þ
j¼t0
X
t
0
Nout ðtÞ ¼ Nout ðjÞ ð3Þ
j¼t0
0 0
where Nin ð jÞ and Nout ð jÞ is the number of EVs under in-controlled state and out-
controlled state at every moment j, respectively, which can be gained through statistical
analysis of EV’s timetable of transforming into and out of controlled state.
Real-Time Adjustment of Load Frequency Control 107
t1 and T2 are defined as plug-in time into grid and EV’s necessary charging duration
to meet the condition for participating in FR, respectively. Therefore, the time when EV
transforms into controllable state t3 is calculated as (4),
t3 ¼ t1 þ T2 ð4Þ
It can be derived from the Eqs. (5) and (6) that the relation between Pev (kW) and
battery SOC (100%) can be expressed by (7),
8
< 1:36SOC 0 SOC\4:76
Pev ¼ 6:5 4:76 SOC\95 ð7Þ
:
66:69 6:67 103 SOC 2 95 SOC 100
where Eev (kWh) is the battery capacity of single EV and ηev is the charging efficiency.
It is assumed that discharging power is equal to Pev and discharging efficiency is equal
to ηev. The discharging power is set to be positive.
The time when EV leaves controllable state t4 contains two state transition sce-
narios. One scenario is that the EV breaks away from grid directly, changing into
driving state; the other is that when the SOC cannot meet the owner’s driving need, the
EV will transform into charging state before the travel. Considering the time margin, t4
equals to EV’s planned departure time minus charging duration.
Through simulating each EV’s time parameters mentioned above by Monte Carlo
method [6], the controllable quantities of EVs can be calculated.
108 Y. Li et al.
The real-time controllable energy dynamic model of EVs is determined on the basis of
controllable quantity dynamic model of EVs. At time t, the real-time controllable
energy of EVs in the region, Ec ðtÞ (MWh), can be calculated as follows,
where E0 (MWh) is EV’s initial controllable energy at time t0 and Ein ðtÞ (MWh) is the
energy increment brought by EVs under in-controlled state as shown in (10) and (11)
respectively, and 1/1000 is the unit conversion coefficient,
1
E0 ¼ SOCm N0 Eev ð10Þ
1000
1
Ein ðtÞ ¼ SOCm Nin ðtÞEev ð11Þ
1000
Eout ðtÞ (MWh) is the energy reduction brought by EVs under out-controlled state.
As the synchronization control method of SOC in [7] is adopted, the SOC of each EV
battery is approximately equal to the average SOC of all controllable EVs. Thus, Eout ðtÞ
can be calculated by (12),
Nout ðtÞ
Eout ðtÞ ¼ ðE0 þ Ein ðtÞ ELFC ðtÞÞ ð12Þ
N0 þ Nin ðtÞ
ELFC ðtÞ (MWh) is the energy change brought by controllable EVs participating in
system FR during the period from t0 to t, as shown in (13),
Z t
1
ELFC ðtÞ ¼ Pa ðsÞds ð13Þ
3600 t0
where DPa ðtÞ (MW) is the actual FR power output of all controllable EVs, and the
discharging/charging power is set to be positive/negative.
To sum up, the model of the total controllable energy of all controllable EVs in this
region is shown in Fig. 1.
where Kevd
ðtÞ=Kevc
ðtÞ is the ratio coefficient of EV’s discharging/charging power output
for FR; Pdev ðtÞ (MW) is obtained from system frequency deviation signal Dƒ(t) through
PI control, representing the power output required for FR; DPev ðtÞ (MW) is the FR task
allocated to EV by the system; Ecmax ðtÞ is the upper limit of real-time controllable
energy of EVs, as shown in (18),
1
Ecmax ðtÞ ¼ SOCmax Nc ðtÞEev ð18Þ
1000
where Pdlim ðtÞ (MW) is the limit of controllable EVs’ discharging power, as in (20),
1
Pdlim ðtÞ ¼ Nc ðtÞPev =gev ð20Þ
1000
DPV2G2 ðtÞ (MW) is EV’s power output of for down-regulation, as in (21),
DPV2G2 ðtÞ ¼ max DPev ðtÞ; Pclim ðtÞ ð21Þ
where Pclim ðtÞ (MW) is the limit of controllable EVs’ charging power, as in (22),
1
Pclim ðtÞ ¼ Nc ðtÞPev gev ð22Þ
1000
Traditional units and EVs coordinate to participate in FR. DPg ðtÞ (MW) is the FR
task allocated to traditional units, as shown in (24),
Pdev ðtÞ Kg ðtÞ Kev ðtÞ 6¼ 0
DPg ðtÞ ¼ ð24Þ
0 Kev ðtÞ ¼ 0
where Kg ðtÞ is the ratio coefficient of traditional unit’s FR power output, as in (25),
1 Kev ðtÞ Df 6¼ 0
K g ðt Þ ¼ ð25Þ
0 Df ¼ 0
3
Bus
Controllable number of
2.5
Official vehicle
EVs/ten thousand
2 Private car
Total EVs
1.5
1
0.5
0
12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 2:00 4:00 6:00 8:00 10:00 12:00
Time
350 200
Controllable energy of
official vehicles(MWh)
300
150
250
200 100
150 withV2G 50 withV2G
100 withoutV2G withoutV2G
50 0
12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 2:00 4:00 6:00 8:00 10:00 12:00 12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 2:00 4:00 6:00 8:00 10:00 12:00
Time Time
(a)Scenario1 (c)Scenario3
250 300
Controllable energy of
electric buses (MWh)
Controllable energy
of total EVs(MWh)
0.03 0.04
The FR output of EVs(p.u.)
0.02
traditional units(p.u.)
0.02
The FR output of
0.01
0
0
-0.02
-0.01
-0.02 -0.04
-0.03 -0.06
12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 02:00 04:00 06:00 08:00 10:00 12:00 12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 02:00 04:00 06:00 08:00 10:00 12:00
Time Fixed allocation Real-time allocation Time Fixed allocation Real-time allocation
(a) Private Electrical Vehicles (b) Traditional units
System FR power output and system frequency deviation are shown in Figs. 5 and
6, respectively. The fixed allocation in Fig. 6 means that the allocation ratio between
the private EV and the traditional unit is fixed and it is set to 3:7. The real-time
allocation means adopting the real-time adjustment strategy proposed in this paper. In
the period of 22: 00–02: 00 (the next day) in Fig. 6, under the fixed ratio allocation
mode, the power output of EVs is much lower than it under the real-time allocation
mode, while the power output of traditional units is more than it under the real-time
allocation mode. In the corresponding time period of Fig. 5, both Ke ðtÞ and Kg ðtÞ keep
around 0.8 in half of the time, respectively. Therefore, private electric cars are able to
provide a large amount of power output. However, private electric cars only provide
30% of the FR power output under fixed allocation mode, less than that under real-time
allocation mode, which means that the power output of the traditional unit needs to
increase correspondingly. In the corresponding time period of Fig. 6(a), the system
frequency deviation under the real-time allocation mode is less than under the fixed
allocation mode, indicating that the FR effect under the fixed allocation mode is worse
than that under the real-time allocation mode. In addition, the root mean square value of
the system frequency deviation with and without V2G in Fig. 6(b) are 0.01022 Hz and
0.01263 Hz, respectively, which indicates that the FR effect is obviously better when
EVs participate in FR.
System frequency deviation(Hz)
System frequency deviation(Hz)
0.04 0.04
0.02 0.02
0 0
-0.02 -0.02
-0.04 -0.04
12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 02:00 04:00 06:00 08:00 10:00 12:00 12:00 14:00 16:00 18:00 20:00 22:00 24:00 02:00 04:00 06:00 08:00 10:00 12:00
Time Fixed allocation Real-time allocation Time With V2G Without V2G
(a) Fixed Allocation and Real-time allocation (b) Real-time Allocation
6 Conclusion
The basic function of an EV is as a driving tool used by people, so the utilizing of EVs
must take into account the randomness and convenience of EV users. Only EVs in the
controllable state are able to respond to the system FR control signal and provide FR
service to the grid. In this paper, the dynamic characteristics of EV’s real-time con-
trollable energy are discussed, and the system frequency control model considering the
dynamic changes of EV’s controllable energy is established, and the effect of EVs
114 Y. Li et al.
Acknowledgment. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (51507022).
References
1. Zhao, J., Xue, L., Fu, Y., Hu, X., Li, F.: Coordinated microgrid frequency regulation based
on DIFG variable coefficient using virtual inertia and primary frequency control. IEEE
Trans. Energy Conv. 31(3), 833–845 (2016)
2. Kaur, K., Rana, R., Kumar, N., Singh, M., Mishra, S.: A colored petri net based frequency
support scheme using fleet of electric vehicles in smart grid environment. IEEE Trans. Power
Syst. 31(6), 4638–4649 (2016)
3. Rana, R., Singh, M., Mishra, S.: Design of modified droop controller for frequency support
in microgrid using fleet of electric vehicles. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 32(5), 3627–3636
(2017)
4. Luo, Z., Hu, Z., Song, Y., Xu, Z., Lu, H.: Optimal coordination of plug-in electric vehicles in
power grids with cost-benefit analysis-part ii: a case study in china. IEEE Trans. Power Syst.
28(4), 3556–3565 (2013)
5. Qian, K., Zhou, C., Allan, M.M., Yuan, Y.: Modeling of load demand due to ev battery
charging in distribution systems. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 26(2), 802–810 (2011)
6. Sarabi, S., Davigny, A., Courtecuisse, V., Riffonneau, Y., Robyns, B.: Potential of vehicle-
to-grid ancillary services considering the uncertainties in plug-in electric vehicle availability
and service/localization limitations in distribution grids. Appl. Energy 171, 523–540 (2016)
7. Shimizu K., Masuta T., Ota Y., A. Yokoyama.: A new load frequency control method in
power system using vehicle-to-grid system considering users’ convenience. In: 17th Power
System Computation Conference, pp. 1–7. Technical Program Committee, Stockholm
(2011)
8. Shinji, T., Sekine, T., Akisawa, A., Kashiwagi, T., Fujita, G., Matsubara, M.: Reduction of
power fluctuation by distributed generation in micro grid. Elect. Eng. Japan 163(2), 22–29
(2008)
Real-Time Adjustment of Load Frequency Control 115
9. Vachirasricirikul, S., Ngamroo, I.: Robust LFC in a smart grid with wind power penetration
by coordinated V2G control and frequency controller. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 5(1), 371–
380 (2014)
10. Takagi M., Yamaji K., Yamamoto H.: Power system stabilization by charging power
management of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles with LFC signal. In: IEEE Vehicle Power
and Propulsion Conference, pp. 822–826. IEEE Press, Dearborn (2009)
An Orderly Charging and Discharging
Scheduling Strategy of Electric Vehicles
Considering Demand Responsiveness
1 Introduction
Under the background of the world’s energy crisis, environment and economic crisis,
EVs have been highly valued by various countries and social enterprises because of the
obvious advantages of low pollution and low carbon emissions [1]. With the increase in
the number of EVs, The V2G technology has been introduced. With the rational
schedule of EVs, the power grid not only reduces the negative impact of EVs on grid,
but also gains economic benefits [2–4].
A lot of researches were about how the EV aggregator played a role in the power
grid scheduling. It’s unrealistic to dispatch all the vehicles directly by dispatching
center of the power grid. The concept of EV aggregator and the hierarchical control
method reduce the number of EVs that the power grid needs to dispatch directly [5].
However, most of the studies remain on the level of the EV aggregator, but the rational
and orderly scheduling strategy of the individual behavior of each vehicle needs to be
formed. Therefore, it is of great significance to further study the rational and orderly
arrangement of all EVs in the aggregator to participate in the power grid scheduling
(V2A) [6].
On the other hand, the concept of demand side response can be applied to optimize
the interaction between users and the power grid [7]. This paper also analyzes the
impact of demand side response on EV charging and discharging schedule.
This paper aims at the problem of orderly schedule of individual EVs participating
in the dispatching interaction plan in the EV aggregator, then analyzes the influence of
the user’s declaration information on the dispatching plan for the vehicle aggregator. At
the same time, the impact of demand side response on EV charging and discharging
schedule is analyzed. Based on this, considering the real time tariff, the EV evaluation
system with multiple indicators is established. Then the weight of the system is solved
by the optimal combination weighting method. Finally, an ordered control strategy of
EV aggregator considering demand side response is proposed.
where SB:max and SB:min indicate maximal and minimal energy of an EV during an
schedule respectively, which can be calculated based on the state of charge
(SOC) limits set by the user and the battery capacity of the EV.
(2) The Credit of Electric Vehicles Participating in the Dispatching Plan
In order to take the situation of electric vehicles that violate the dispatching plan
into account, the concept of credit membership is introduced into the schedulable
capacity calculation. If an EV suddenly connects or leaves the grid outside of the plan,
its declaration capacity will be included in the schedulable capacity based on the
proportion of the credit degree of the user. The specific expression of the credit degree
is as follows:
118 W. Xie et al.
8
Sd < 1 q qup
q ¼ ¼ Sd qdown q qup ð2Þ
Sh : Sh
0 q qdown
where Sh means day-ahead average declaration capacity, and S d means day-ahead
average actual scheduled capacity. When the credit degree is large enough, the value is
1, and if it is too small, the value is 0.
(3) The Demand Response of EV Users
The charging or discharging behavior of EVs is a kind of demand response. EV
users can make their own consumption according to the price signal or incentive
mechanism. Therefore, this paper considers the economic benefits of EVs participating
in V2G to describe the degree of responsiveness of EV users.
① The Response of EV to Electricity Price Mechanism
The response to the electricity price refers to the user’s choice of period, and the
transfer of the electric load from the high-price period to the low-price period to reduce
the cost of electricity [8].
The change of electricity price will cause the change of the demand of the user, so
the electricity price elasticity is adopted to express the response degree of the user to
the electricity price mechanism. That is, the ratio of the degree of electricity price
change to the degree of electricity change in a certain period, as shown in Eq. (3).
where S, DS respectively indicates the amount of electricity and its relative increase. p,
Dp respectively indicates the amount of price and its relative increase. The higher the
price, the lower the electricity.
② The Response of EV Users to The Grid Incentive Mechanism
Sometimes the system cannot satisfy user’s charging requirements, or the discharging
capacity cannot meet the grid dispatching plan. The grid will compensate and adjust the
load through incentives, which means that EVs will charge or discharge out of the
dispatching plan.
Users can voluntarily choose whether to respond to the incentive of the system.
If EV users are willing to participate in demand side response, the response of EV users
to the grid incentive mechanism can be defined:
Ce ðtÞ Cp ðtÞ
d¼ ð4Þ
Cp ðtÞ
where Cp ðtÞ means the charging cost of EVs, and Ce ðtÞ means the income of incentive
mechanism.
An Orderly Charging and Discharging Scheduling Strategy 119
For the charging plan, when the required charging capacity is not reached, the
incentive income includes the interruption compensation and the price difference after
the transfer to a lower price period. For the discharging plan, the incentive income is
consist of battery compensation, extra discharging income and compensation.
Thus, the degree of demand responsiveness that defines the participation of EV
users in grid dispatching plans is:
l ¼ ae þ ð1aÞd ð5Þ
where a is proportion factor and can be calculated by the entropy weight method.
Equation (5) indicates the degree of response of the EV user to the electricity price
signal or the incentive mechanism.
In order to eliminate the dimension effect of each evaluation index and make the
modeling universal, the index should be normalized. Suppose xij is the evaluation value
of the j object for the i index, and rij is the value after the normalization of xij . The
resulting R ¼ rij KN can be used as a fuzzy evaluation matrix
120 W. Xie et al.
8 xmax xij
< Cost index: rij ¼ xmax
ij
xmin
ij ij
xij xmin ð6Þ
: Benefit index: rij ¼ ij
ij xij
xmax min
ij =xij
where xmax min
refers to the maximum/minimum value of the same index.
Each index will be weighted to obtain the basis of EV scheduling. Among them, the
larger the schedulable capacity, the higher the user credit, the higher demand
responsiveness and the smaller the battery loss will be scheduled first.
X
K
Uj ¼ Wci rij ; j ¼ 1; 2. . . ð8Þ
i¼1
In order to determine the attribute combination weight vector Wc , the absolute value
of the deviation is introduced:
djn ¼ Wci wni rij ð9Þ
where djn denotes the absolute value of the deviation between the weight of the nth
weighting scheme and the weighting of the combined weighting method for the jth
evaluation object.
In order to comprehensively utilize the subjective and objective weights of each
evaluation index the deviation between the evaluation result under the optimal com-
bination weights and the evaluation result under subjective and objective weights is
supposed to as small as possible for all indicators of all evaluation targets. So, by
An Orderly Charging and Discharging Scheduling Strategy 121
solving the minimization of the absolute sum of the weighted deviations to estimate the
optimal combination weights, the following model can be constructed:
N X
X K
minf ¼ min ajw1 ðiÞ Wci jrij þ ð1 aÞjw2 ðiÞ Wci jrij ð10Þ
j¼1 i¼1
X
K
s:t: Wci ¼ 1; Wci 0 ð11Þ
i¼1
where Pn ðtÞ is the actual power of the nth EV at period t; Nt is the total number of
scheduled EVs; PEV ðtÞ is the dispatching plan at period t.
8
>
> Nc ðtÞ Ncmax ðtÞ ; Ndc ðtÞ Ndc max
ðtÞ
>
> NPc ðt Þ
max
NcPðtÞ
>
>
>
< Pc;n ðtÞ Pc;n ðtÞ
s:t: n¼1 n¼1
max ð13Þ
>
> NP
dc ðt Þ Ndc ðtÞ
P
>
> P ð t Þ Pdc;n ðtÞ
>
> dc;n
>
: n¼1 n¼1
Ncmax ðtÞ þ Ndc max
ðtÞ Ntmax
4 Case Studies
In order to verify the superiority of the proposed strategy, this strategy is applied to the
6-node system in [9]. The optimal first-level plan of grid-side are obtained using the
model in [10].
The node 4 in certain period which requires EVs to discharge 3.98 MW as an
auxiliary service is selected as the case with the priority scheduling strategy. Assume
the number of EVs participating in the schedule in node 4 is 265. For ease of man-
agement, the aggregator organizes the day-ahead information for each EV and divides
the EVs participating in the schedule into 30 fleets. EVs in the same fleet have the
similar characteristics. The real-time declaration information can be obtained through
the declaration information. The Monte Carlo method is used to simulate the SOC
information of 30 fleets, and the declaration information is based on a variety of actual
situations that may occur.
With the EV fleet’s day-ahead participation information under dispatching plan
provided by aggregator, users’ participation degree can be calculated at time 17
through the entropy weight method, so the participation degree in the period is:
l ¼ 0:5541e þ 0:4459d
The subjective weights and objective weights of each index are obtained according
to the weighting methods, then the comprehensive weighting coefficient of each
indicator is obtained by the optimized combination weighting method based on
accelerated genetic algorithm. The weight of sd , q, l, Br is 0.1583, 0.3198, 0.3322,
0.1897, respectively.
Then the result of priority dispatching plan of 30 eV fleets of node can be obtained,
as shown in Table 2. Through the Table 2, the value of dispatching priority of each EV
fleet can be obtained. Combining the results of Table above, we can see that:
(1) If EVs’ declaration capacity is too low, the grid will give them a low priority in the
initial stage of the plan (e.g. the fleets numbered 2, 4, 9, 10, 12, etc.).
(2) The comprehensive weight coefficient of the two indicators of user credit and
responsiveness is higher, so the fleets whose comprehensive evaluation value in the
Table 2. Priority and schedulable capacity of EV fleets (kW)
Schedule order 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Uj 0.743 0.737 0.720 0.707 0.696 0.679 0.675 0.660 0.657 0.654
EV fleets 16 25 19 28 20 11 22 21 6 1
Declaration capacity 123.051 170.495 143.706 205.942 125.900 150.72 193.2 130.8 119.82 91.44
Schedulable capacity 112.132 170.495 137.471 192.516 115.880 134.416 178.026 107.025 110.691 90.799
considering q
Schedule order 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20
Uj 0.639 0.637 0.605 0.604 0.603 0.590 0.583 0.580 0.572 0.552
EV fleets 15 3 5 23 29 8 24 7 30 13
Declaration capacity 132.715 99.429 102.413 138.928 205.942 96.297 132.550 97.120 218.634 120.445
Schedulable capacity 126.075 89.728 69.556 126.009 192.516 94.869 75.429 89.995 209.600 114.063
considering q
Schedule order 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30
Uj 0.530 0.489 0.436 0.416 0.403 0.356 0.337 0.276 0.076 0.005
EV fleets 27 14 17 2 4 26 12 18 10 9
Declaration capacity 187.293 104.554 130.176 67.564 86.539 145.779 87.705 111.870 88.096 82.129
Schedulable capacity 169.754 31.356 84.665 63.601 45.086 123.863 51.650 80.027 11.371 0.000
considering q
An Orderly Charging and Discharging Scheduling Strategy
123
124 W. Xie et al.
above two indexes in declaration information is more than 0.5 will be scheduled in
advance (e.g. the fleets numbered 16, 25, 19, 28, 20 and so on).
(3) If EVs actively participate in scheduling, their battery loss will be slightly higher.
Although they will get more V2G compensation, the grid and EV users should be
aware that in order to protect the EVs, it is not appropriate to participate in
scheduled charging and discharging frequently.
When EVs participate in power grid dispatching plan, their declaration information
and day-ahead participation record are the key to determining the real-time dispatching
order. Then the real-time schedulable capacity in each period can be obtained, and
further adjusted according to the dispatching plan of the power grid to reduce the
impact of large-scale EVs connecting to grid and finally realize real-time orderly
scheduling strategy. The priority and schedulable capacity of EV fleets can be calcu-
lated, also shown in Table 2.
250
150
Capacity / kW
100
50
0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30
EV fleet number
From Table 2, it is known that the total schedulable capacity of the aggregator
considering credit is 3.134 MW, which cannot meet the grid dispatching plan capacity
(3.98 MW). in this case, the demand response is used to guide high-priority vehicles to
continue to provide electricity within their own acceptance margins, so it is necessary
to further adjust the schedulable capacity and the actual scheduled situation of EVs to
achieve the consistency with the grid dispatching plan as much as possible. The results
are shown in Fig. 2.
The actual schedulable capacity after adjustment is 3.681 MW, which is closer to
the dispatching plan. The shortage is reduced from 0.846 MW to 0.299 MW.
Combined with Table 2 and Fig. 2, we can get:
(1) Although some EVs have more declaration capacity during the period, if their
credits are too low, they will not be invoked basically when considering credit.
An Orderly Charging and Discharging Scheduling Strategy 125
(e.g. fleets numbered 9, 10). Some less creditworthy EVs (e.g. fleets numbered 12,
17 and 24) are incompletely scheduled.
(2) At the same time, some fleets (e.g. number 25, 28, 22, 30 and 27) have a slightly
higher actual scheduled capacity than their declaration capacity. Users’ EV are can
voluntarily choose to schedule more capacity than the declared capacity within the
accepted range to obtain more profits.
(3) In fact, the EVs located behind schedule have lower priority. When there are large-
scale EVs, these EVs will not be considered in the scheduling process. This is
consistent with the results shown in Fig. 2.
Due to the large number of vehicles and longer scheduling periods, the present
example only selects a node for a certain period as an example to simulate the orderly
scheduling strategy proposed in this paper to verify its feasibility. Actually, the
aggregator collects EV declaration information for multiple periods and has different
scheduling arrangements for each period. Therefore, when there are a lot of mature data
of EVs participating in the grid scheduling strategy, continuous real-time dispatching
plans can be obtained.
5 Conclusion
This paper aims at the problem that in order scheduling strategy of large-scale EVs,
each EV can’t be scheduled by grid directly, considers the EV’s characters, and pro-
poses an orderly scheduling strategy for EV aggregator under the condition of real-time
electricity price. The strategy uses the declaration scheduling capacity, credit degree,
battery loss, and users’ participation degree as the evaluation indexes to establishes the
evaluation index system of EV aggregator. The comprehensive weight of each index is
determined by the optimization combination weighting method, which is based on the
accelerated genetic algorithm. Then each EV’s scheduling priority in the aggregator
can be obtained, and the actual scheduling capacity of the aggregator at different
periods is determined. Finally, combined with the power grid scheduling plan, adjust
each EV schedule in the aggregator to be consistent with power grid dispatching plan
as much as possible, and reduce the impact of large-scale EV integration on the
stability of power system.
Acknowledgment. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (51507022).
References
1. Wirasingha, S.G., Emadi, A.: Classification and review of control strategies for plug-in
hybrid electric vehicles. IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol. 60(1), 111–122 (2011)
2. Rotering, N., Ilic, M.: Optimal charge control of plug-in hybrid electric vehicles in
deregulated electricity markets. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 26, 1021–1029 (2011)
126 W. Xie et al.
3. Han, S., Han, S., Sezaki, K.: Estimation of achievable power capacity from plug-in electric
vehicles for V2G frequency regulation: case studies for market participation. IEEE Trans.
Smart Grid 2(4), 632–641 (2011)
4. Clement-Nyns, K., Haesen, E., Driesen, J.: The impact of charging plug-in hybrid electric
vehicles on a residential distribution grid. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 25(1), 371–380 (2010)
5. Ma, J., Yang, H.: Distributed parallel coordinated control strategy for provincial regional
grid based on subarea division of the power system. In: 2012 China International Conference
on Electricity Distribution, vol. 16(2), pp. 130–137 (2012)
6. Zhang, Q., Cai, J., Liu, C., et al.: Optimal control strategy of cluster charging and
discharging of electric vehicles based on the priority. Trans. China Electrotech. Soc. 30(17),
117–125 (2015). (in Chinese)
7. Wang, L., Sharkh, S., Chipperfield, A., et al.: Dispatch of vehicle-to-grid battery storage
using an analytic hierarchy process. IEEE Trans. Veh. Technol. 66(4), 2952–2965 (2017)
8. Kumar, K.N., Tseng, K.J.: Impact of demand response management on chargeability of
electric vehicles. Energy 111, 190–196 (2016)
9. Cai, Q., Wen, F., Xue, Y., et al.: An SCUC-based optimization approach for power system
dispatching with plug-in hybrid electric vehicles. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 36(1), 38–46
(2012)
10. Qian, Z., Chao, L., Lin, Z., et al.: A bi-level economy dispatch model considering temporal
and spatial optimal distribution of electric vehicles. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 38(20), 40–
45 (2014). (in Chinese)
Energy Saving
Technological Updating Decision–Making
Model for Eco–Factory Through Dynamic
Programming
Abstract. As the key subject of the green manufacturing system, the con-
struction of eco–factory has become an important content in order to achieve the
sustainable development of enterprises. In this paper, a technological updating
decision-making model is established based on dynamic programming (DP) for
eco–factory. Firstly, the evaluation index system for eco–factory is established.
Secondly, the local weight and global weight of each index are calculated based
on analytic network process (ANP) and Delphi method. Finally, the decision–
making model of eco-factory is established to find the optimal investment plan
by using the method of logarithmic fitting and DP. The ANP and Delphi method
present a great potential in solving complex and ambiguous problems and the
decision-making based on DP can obtain the better ecological benefits through
an example of a foundry factory, therefore the feasibility of the proposed method
is proved.
1 Introduction
A plenty of non–renewable resources are used in the economic construction and it leads
to the increasing exhaustion of resources and serious environmental pollution in
developing countries. Therefore, the green manufacturing is the inevitable trend of
sustainable development. The technologies of green manufacturing is important
research areas with significant potential impact on human lives today and even more in
the future [1].
The eco-factory is a key part of building the green manufacturing system.
According to “Made in China 2025”, the eco-factory is defined as “the factory that
realizes the intensive use of land, harmless raw materials, cleaner production, waste
recycling and low–carbon energy”. The eco-factory concept with clean manufacturing
solutions for green products represents the present high end in factory design [2]. In the
current competitive and regulated landscape, manufacturing enterprises struggle to
improve their performances, encompassing environmental as well as economic
© Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2018
K. Li et al. (Eds.): ICSEE 2018/IMIOT 2018, CCIS 925, pp. 129–138, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2381-2_12
130 E. Chen et al.
objectives, toward sustainable manufacturing and the future eco–factories [3]. Research
on eco-factory will help to set the benchmark in the industry, guide and standardize
factories to implement green manufacturing, and take the social responsibility for green
development. Eco–factories will enable the quantum leap in integrating environmental
issues in factory planning and factory operations [4].
Evaluation is the basis of decision-making, and selection of evaluation method is
crucial. In the introduction of ecological concept to manufacturing, many evaluation
methods are presented. An integrated analytic hierarchy process is used for eco –
industrial parks to multi–objective optimization for resource network synthesis [5].
May G pointed that the energy management will become a way toward eco-factory of
the future and research should focus more on the opportunities that human participants
in a manufacturing system can foster change toward eco–factories [6]. The single
simulation model combined discrete event simulation, material flow analysis, and life
cycle assessment was presented in eco-factory for sustainable decision-making [7].
There are more evaluation methods for eco–industrial parks and manufacturing sys-
tems, and less research on eco-factory.
The decision-making is very important in order to establish the eco-factory. The
dynamic programming was applied to calculate optimal decision sequence and maxi-
mum total profits in resource allocation of factory production line [8]. Aiming at the
reliability allocation problem of series manufacturing system’s reliability design, the
dynamic programming (DP) method was adopted to solve the reliability allocation
problem under the existing constraints [9]. The DP model is adopted by addressing the
division of investment allocations of production lines [10]. However, few scholars have
studied the investment decision based on DP in the construction of eco-factory.
In this paper, the ecological benefits evaluation and investment decision of eco-
factory are combined to find the investment decision plan when the ecological benefits
are greatest. The weight of each indicator is determined through the analytic network
process (ANP) and Delphi method based on the reasonable evaluation index system.
The ecological benefits as the comprehensive index are calculated quantitatively by DP
in order to put forward the optimal investment decision scheme to update the factory.
In order to describe and evaluate the green manufacturing ability and level of the
factory scientifically and quantitatively, as well as to strengthen the decision man-
agement, it is essential to establish a set of evaluation index system which can be
designed reasonably and practically.
The evaluation index system for factory was constructed according to the opinions
provided by experts from relevant fields, some standards, and policies of the govern-
ment, which includes green manufacturing technology (B1), green manufacturing
process (B2) and resources and environment effect (B3), along with eight quantitative
sub–criteria, and the ecological benefits (A1) is target. The ecological benefits evalu-
ation index system is illustrated in Fig. 1.
B1 reflects the green level of the factory relative to the early production technology,
and mainly includes the green technology (C1) and green processes (C2). C1 indicate
Technological Updating Decision–Making Model for Eco–Factory 131
Green Technologies
Green Manufacturing
Technology
Green Processes
Green Materials
Green Manufacturing Ecological
Cost Green equipment
Process Benefits
Green Products
Energy Consumption
Resources and Environment
Water Consumption
Effect
Main Pollutants
the imported number of energy saving and emissions reduction technology. C2 indicate
the number of process transformation during establishing the factory.
B2 reflects the green degree in the process of factory production, mainly including
green materials (C3), green equipment (C4) and output of green products (C5). C3
indicate the quantity of green materials used. C4 indicate the quantity of high efficiency
and energy saving equipment used. C5 indicate the value of green products.
B3 reflects the comprehensive green level about resources and the ecological
environment during factory production process, and the energy consumption (C6),
water consumption (C7) and the main pollutants (C8) are used as secondary indicators.
C6 indicates energy consumption per unit product, including electricity, natural gas,
and compressed air and so on. C7 indicates water consumption per unit product. C8
indicate the environmental pollutants produced by the unit product, mainly including
waste solid, waste water and waste gas and so on.
The framework of ecological benefits evaluation index system is constructed in this
paper, which can calculate the ecological benefits of the factory after obtaining the
global weight of each index.
3 DP Decision-Making Model
Since the ecological benefits evaluation index system has been established for by
considering the characteristics of factory, the method of decision-making is employed
which consists of two parts. The first part is the weight determination using ANP and
Delphi. The second part is the optimal resource allocation through DP method.
In Eq. (1), xpq represents the dimensionless value of the index q relative to the
0
sample p. xpq represents the original value and xsum
pq represents the total value.
There are positive and negative indicators in the ecological benefits evaluation
index system of the factory. For instance, the ecological benefits will be improved
when C2 becomes big and C6 becomes small, so C2 is a positive index and C6 is a
negative indicator. Therefore, in order to make the later data processing easy and
convenient, a unified index is needed through the Eq. (2).
xpq positive index
x00pq ¼ 1
negetive index : ð2Þ
xpq
AN as a criteria and the importance of each element set is compared to other element
sets, also then a weighted matrix is formed, as shown in expression (4).
2 3
a11 a1N
A ¼ 4 5: ð4Þ
aN1 aNN
¼ W
Building a matrix W ij , whose elements are denoted by W
¼ aij Wij : W
is
the weighted supermatrix.
Technological Updating Decision–Making Model for Eco–Factory 133
Super Decision (SD) is used to input the judgment matrix and output the weighted
supermatrix and the limit supermatrix [14]. The weights of ecological benefits evalu-
ation indexes under the respective criteria are obtained from the limit supermatrix.
The state variables of k + 1 are written according to the state variables and decision
variables in the kth phase, namely:
s k þ 1 ¼ s k xk : ð6Þ
The optimal index function fk (sk) represents the maximum ecological benefits
obtained by allocating investment of sk to casting plant from the kth one to the nth one.
The basic equations of DP are listed below:
(
fk ðsk Þ ¼ max ½vk ðsk ; xk Þ þ fk þ 1 ðsk þ 1 Þ
0 xk s k : ð8Þ
fn þ 1 ðsn þ 1 Þ ¼ 0
Calculations are based on the reverse algorithm, the maximum ecological benefits
of the factory is expressed in the equation f1 (s1).
4 Case Study
In this paper, an example of a casting factory is analyzed. The green upgrade of the
casting factory is expected to cost 50 million. The investment decisions are made for
eco–factory according to the ten–year capital investment and the ecological benefits of
three casting plant.
ANP is used to establish the network structure model of the ecological benefits
indicator system with SD software, and its detail specifications as shown in Table 1.
Table 2. The former ten years of investment and ecological benefits for casting plant
Casting plant (D1) Casting plant (D2) Casting plant (D3)
Investment A1 Investment A1 Investment A1
(104 RMB) (104 RMB) (104 RMB)
2007 364.13 5.1053 224.04 3.2027 458.39 6.5528
2008 455.57 5.528 276.78 3.3776 535.41 6.746
2009 617.83 6.1495 380.14 3.7219 588.74 7.1655
2010 756.45 6.7062 467.53 4.1971 777.77 7.8151
2011 823.12 6.9156 556.27 4.3839 827.28 8.1087
2012 904.08 7.2113 627.96 4.6369 1138.12 8.9863
2013 1023.83 7.5472 741.19 4.8983 1256.45 9.3798
2014 1204.63 7.961 856.91 5.2706 1290.32 9.5702
2015 1392.71 8.5662 920.42 5.2283 1516.47 9.9219
2016 1592.62 8.9535 1039.42 5.4082 1753.24 10.6837
136 E. Chen et al.
The growth rate of ecological benefits is gradually slowing down through com-
paring the data in Table 3, so the relationship between investment and ecological
benefits is obtained based on logarithmic fitting by MATLAB, and the corresponding
ecological benefits can be obtained, as shown in Table 3.
It can be seen from Fig. 6 that the optimal solution is obtained when x*1= 2, x*2= 1,
x*3=2. In other words, the investment of D1 is 20 million RMB, the investment of D2 is
10 million RMB, and the investment of D3 is 20 million RMB. Its optimal value of
ecological benefits is 25.59.
6 Conclusion
(1) The local weight and global weight of each index in ecological benefits evaluation
index system are calculated based on ANP and Delphi method. The method can
effectively deal with the complex relationship between each element group and
indexes, and improve the accuracy and reliability of evaluation for eco-factory.
(2) The decision-making model of eco-factory is established to find the optimal
investment plan by logarithmic fitting and DP. The optimization of ecological
benefits problem is divided into three stages, and the global optimal allocation plan
is obtained through finding the optimal solution for each stage, respectively. This
method presents the higher theoretical value and practical significance.
(3) An example analysis shows that 50 million funds are divided into 20 million, 10
million and 20 million to D1, D2, and D3 respectively. Its optimal value of eco-
logical benefits for the factory is 25.59. This distribution scheme can improve the
ecological benefits of the factory, so the feasibility of this method is verified.
References
1. Ahn, S.H.: An evaluation of green manufacturing technologies based on research databases.
Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf.-Green Technol. 1(1), 5–9 (2014)
2. Kai, S., Leino, T., Joutsiniemi, A.: Sustainable manufacturing and eco-factories within
sustainable industrial areas within fast growing eco-cities sustainable manufacturing and
eco-factories within sustainable industrial areas within fast growing eco-cities. In: Flexible
Automation and Intelligent Manufacturing, FAIM (2011)
3. Fantini, P., Palasciano, C., Taisch, M.: Back to intuition: proposal for a performance
indicators framework to facilitate eco-factories management and benchmarking. Proce-
dia CIRP 26, 1–6 (2015)
4. Taisch, M., Stahl, B.: Requirements analysis and definition for eco-factories: the case of
EMC2. In: Emmanouilidis, C., Taisch, M., Kiritsis, D. (eds.) APMS 2012. IAICT, vol. 397,
pp. 111–118. Springer, Heidelberg (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-642-40352-1_15
5. Leong, Y.T., Lee, J.Y., Tan, R.R., et al.: Multi-objective optimization for resource network
synthesis in eco-industrial parks using an integrated analytic hierarchy process. J. Clean.
Prod. 143, 1268–1283 (2017)
6. May, G., Stahl, B., Taisch, M.: Energy management in manufacturing: toward eco-factories
of the future–a focus group study. Appl. Energy 164, 628–638 (2016)
7. Reinhard, J., Zah, R., Wohlgemuth, V., et al.: Applying life cycle assessment within discrete
event simulation: practical application of the Milan/EcoFactory material flow simulator
(2013)
8. Wen, J.H., Jiang, H.L., Zhang, M., et al.: Application of dynamic programming in resources
optimization allocation of factory production line. Key Eng. Mater. 474–476(1), 1632–1637
(2011)
9. Jia, J., Yang, Y., Yang, T., et al.: Research on dynamic programming of the series
manufacturing system reliability allocation. J. Converg. Inf. Technol. 7(7), 17–25 (2012)
10. Abdul-Zahra, In, Abbas, I.T., Kalaf, B.A., et al.: The role of dynamic programming in the
distribution of investment allocations between production lines with an application in the
(men’s clothing factory in Najaf holy). Int. J. Pure Appl. Math. 106(2), 365–380 (2016)
11. Kabak, M., Dağdeviren, M.: A hybrid approach based on ANP and grey relational analysis
for machine selection. Tehnicki Vjesnik 24, 109–118 (2017)
138 E. Chen et al.
12. Ayağ, Z., Özdemir, R.G.: Evaluating machine tool alternatives through modified TOPSIS
and alpha-cut based fuzzy ANP. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 140(2), 630–636 (2012)
13. Saaty, T.L., Vargas, L.G.: Decision Making with the Analytic Network Process. Springer,
Berlin (2013). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4614-7279-7
14. Li, H., Tao, M., Sun, Z.: Research on the process evaluation of green university based on
concordance analysis. In: International Conference on Chinese Control and Decision
Conference, pp. 3642–3646. IEEE Press (2009)
15. Ullah, S.M.S., Muhammad, I., Ko, T.J.: Optimal strategy to deal with decision making
problems in machine tools remanufacturing. Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf.-Green Technol. 3(1),
19–26 (2016)
A Configurable On-Line Monitoring System
Towards Energy Consumption of Machine
Tools
1 Introduction
The machine tools are composed of energy consumers, and different energy consumer
has different energy characteristic in different state of machining processes. The
requirements towards monitoring machine tools are decided by the types of machine
tools and the demands of the users.
In this paper, the state of machine tools during machining is divided into three
parts, the air-cutting state, basic state, cutting state. The basic state is state of readiness,
which is that the machine tool is turned on, the control system, spindle system is in a
A Configurable On-Line Monitoring System Towards Energy Consumption 141
state of readiness. The air cutting state is the state that includes spindle rotation and
feeding, cutting without load. The cutting state is the state of cutting with material
remove [14]. This division is to better understand the energy composition of machine
tools.
Different machine tools have different energy consumers. Table 1 shows an
example for the energy-consumed components of a typical of three-axis CNC machine
tools [13]. As shown in Tables 2 and 3, the energy consumers of CK6136C and
YD31125CNC6 are very different. For CNC machine tools, the cutting energy for
material removing is only 15%–25% of the total energy, most of energy are consumed
by spindle motor, tool change systems, cooling systems, servo systems, fan systems,
etc. [15, 16]. According to the ISO14955-1, the total energy consumption of the
machine tools is obtained by the sum of the energy consumed by all of the energy
consumed components.
According to the description about energy monitoring of machine tools, the con-
figurable monitoring system are required to be developed, which can be used to acquire
energy data from different energy consumers in different states and satisfy different
requirements by different users.
sensors are determined according to the type and number of the energy consumer as
well as the requirements of the users.
(2) Data collecting and processing
The voltage and current data are collected by the power sensor, which mount on the
energy consumers. The protocol of the data transmission is modularized according to
transmission protocol of the sensors, and the current data and voltage data are resolved
according to corresponding rules of the modular, in order to make sure the other types
sensors could be used. The real time power is obtained by filtered data and kept in the
database. The state of machine tools is obtained through multi-sensor data fusion,
including the state of power off, basic state, cutting state, the results can support the
analysis of energy consumption in different state during machining process.
(3) Power data analyzing
The power data from multiple energy consumers are analyzed, in order to obtain
energy consumption information of machine tools, such as total energy consumption
and energy consumed by specific energy consumers, the results can support different
users to make energy reduction strategies.
144 P. Wu et al.
Z
Ei ¼ Pi dt ð1Þ
Where Eks is the energy consumption; tks is the running time of the specific state; s is
specific state;
(4) Energy consumption of material removing
Energy consumption of material removing means the energy consumed during
material remove process. The energy, which consumed in the cutting state, is supplied
by the spindle motor. However, the energy consumed by the main spindle mainly have
two parts, the first part is maintaining the rotate speed of the main spindle, the second
part is consumed in the material remove process. So the energy consumed in the cutting
state is obtained by Eq. 4.
Z Z
Ec ¼ Es Es0 ¼ Ps dt P0s dt ð4Þ
Ec
Ef ¼ 100% ð5Þ
Eall
4 Case Study
The system is conducted on the lathe tools CJK6136C, the power sensor is
EDA9033, the machining process is machining the workpiece of intake shaft. At first,
the structure and energy consumers of the machine tools are analyzed, the spindle
motor, feed X axis motor, feed Z axis motor and the total input are the place that are
chosen to mount the power sensor. The real time power of the machine tools and
energy consumption information of the energy consumers are obtained by the system,
and the results are shown in the system’s GUI.
The energy consumption information of machining the intake shaft is obtained by
the analyzed power data, which collected from the multiple energy consumers based on
the developed system. The results are shown in Table 5. The total energy consumption
is 68.3 W . h, 15.9 W . h is used for turning process, and the energy efficiency of the
machine tool is 23.3%.
Feed Z axis
motor:3.2%
Spindle
Feed X axis
motor:69.7%
motor:0.4%
The energy consumed in the different state is obtained by further analyzing the
energy consumption of the energy consumers. The results are shown in Table 6. The
energy consumed in the air-cutting state is 8.1 W . h, and the energy consumed in the
cutting state is 60.2 W . h.
In order to identify the adaptability of the developed system, the system is applied
to the machining center HAAS VF5/50, the energy consumption of the pallet during
the milling process have been monitored, as shown in Fig. 5. The analyzed results are
shown in Table 7, the energy consumed by the spindle motor is 281.1 W . h, which is
the largest energy consumption during the process. The second largest energy con-
sumption is the energy consumed by the fan and servo system, the energy consumed by
the fan and servo is 124.2 W . h.
5 Conclusions
could not only obtain the total energy during machining process, but also it can make
the energy consumed by the specific energy consumer transparent. The results can
provide a refined energy management to the users.
The main energy consumers are identified by analyzing energy consumption of the
energy consumers, this analyzed results can help the designers to optimize the design of
machine tools. For example, the designer could choose the high energy-efficiency
motor for the main energy consumer.
The obtained energy efficiency and the energy consumed by the specific energy
consumer can support the operators to make an energy reducing plan. The obtained
total energy consumption and the energy consumed in the different state can support
the management to make schedule in the factory.
Acknowledgements. The authors would like to thank the support from the National Natu-
ral Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51575072), Chongqing Research Program of Basic
Research and Frontier Technology (No. cstc2015jcyjBX0088).
References
1. Park, C.W., Kwon, K.S., Kim, W.B., Min, B.K., Park, S.J.: Energy consumption reduction
technology in manufacturing—a selective review of policies. Int. J. Precis. Eng. Manuf. 10,
151–173 (2009)
150 P. Wu et al.
1 Introduction
To address energy crisis and environment issues, the integration of multiple energy
sources has become a hot topic in academia and industries in recent years, which is
expected to improve the comprehensive energy utilization efficiency and help solve
major concern of sustainability in many countries around the world [1]. The
The paper is supported in part by National Key R&D Program of China (2017YFB0903300);
National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) (51777105); Science and Technology
Program of State Grid Corporation of China (Research and Application of Micro-grid Planning
and Operation); and project SKLD17KM03 of China State Key Lab. of Power System.
construction of the multi-energy system of industrial park has recently been considered
as a feasible approach scholars and enterprises. For example, in June 2017, the National
Energy Administration of China announced the first batch of “Internet+” smart energy
demonstration projects, out of which twelve projects are for park-level multi-energy
systems [2]. At present, constructing high energy efficiency multi-energy system for
industrial parks is considered to be one of the effective ways to solve the energy
demand problem in China at this stage [3–5].
Many scholars have studied the energy efficiency of the distributed energy CCHP
(Combined Cooling Heating and Power) system. There are many studies based on the
first law of thermodynamics; e.g., some studies [6, 7] evaluate the performance of the
CCHP system based on the energy analysis method using the first law of thermo-
dynamics. The research based on the second law of thermodynamics generally uses
exergy efficiency as an evaluation index. Some studies [8, 9] reveal the energy uti-
lization status of the CCHP system from the perspective of the second law of thermo-
dynamics. Some other studies [10, 11] analyze in detail the exergy efficiency and
primary energy efficiency, and point out that the efficiency of the gas turbine has a great
influence on the optimization of the operation of the CCHP system.
In this paper, based on the first and second law of thermodynamics analysis and
utilization rate of renewable energy, the specific evaluation indices of energy efficiency
for multi-energy system of industrial park is constructed. Secondly, the information
entropy principle is used to determine the weight of each index, and to form an energy
efficiency assessment method of the multi-energy system. Finally, through the opera-
tion process simulation of the multi-energy system in an industrial park, the compre-
hensive energy efficiency of the park is evaluated to verify the proposed method.
Electric load
power plant
transformer
energy storage batteries
Heat load
natural gas
CHP
Cooling load
refrigerator
domestic water
Fig. 1. Input and output energy flow diagram of multi-energy system for an industrial park
Eep
Q1in ¼ Qgas þ ð1Þ
g
Qe Qc Qh
Q0in ¼ þ þ ð2Þ
g COPg gh
where g means the total efficiency of the traditional coal-fired power plant delivering
electric energy; COP means the refrigeration coefficient of an electric refrigerator; gh
means heating efficiency; Qe , Qc and Qh are the electricity, cooling, and heat load
energy consumption quantity in the industrial park. For example, g = 0.3348,
COP = 3.6 in this paper.
Primary Energy Ratio. PER refers to the ratio of system output energy to primary
energy consumption under the combined cooling, heating, and electricity power supply
mode [13].
Qe þ Qc þ Qh
PER ¼ ð3Þ
Q1in
154 C. Shi et al.
Primary Energy Saving Rate. The primary energy saving rate refers to the ratio of
the primary energy consumption saved by the park operating in the combined cooling,
heating, and electricity power supply mode relative to the operation under the separated
supply mode to the total primary energy consumption.
Q0in Q1in
Dq ¼ ð4Þ
Q0in
Q1re
Rre ¼ ð5Þ
Q0re
Exergy Efficiency. Exergy efficiency refers to the ratio of the total exergy output by
the entire system to the total exergy input by the system. Exergy efficiency reflects the
degree of energy conversion in the system [14].
where e0 , eQh and eQc respectively means the natural gas energy quality coefficient, the
thermal energy quality coefficient, and the cold energy quality coefficient; Egas means
the natural gas consumption; To ,TQh and TQc respectively means the environment
temperature, heat source temperature, and cold source temperature.
this paper summarizes five scenarios of the multi-energy system of a typical industrial
park as shown in Table 1.
After standardization and dimensionless treatment, and the evaluation index matrix
X is specified as a matrix V. The characteristic proportion pij of the i-th evaluation
scenario is calculated under the j-th index, and form the normalized matrix P.
Vij
Pij ¼ Pm ð9Þ
i¼1 Vij
1 X m
ej ¼ pij lnpij ð10Þ
lnðmÞ i¼1
dj 1 ej
wj ¼ P
n ¼P
n ð11Þ
dj 1 ej
j¼1 j¼1
X
n
vi ¼ wj Pij ð12Þ
j¼1
4 Case Studies
4.1 Load Demand
This paper takes the multi-energy system of an industrial park in Beijing as an example.
The park serves commercial centers, industrial manufactures, and residential buildings.
Each kind of user has demand for cold, heat, and electricity loads. There are a wind
turbine and photovoltaic generation in the park. The distributed renewable energy and
natural gas generation in the park is grid-connected but no back-feed is allowed to the
grid. The main equipment capacity in the park energy system is shown in Table 2.
Through DeST software simulation, the typical daily cooling, heating and electrical
load curves of the park in summer, winter and transition seasons are obtained, as is
shown in Figs. 2, 3 and 4.
Research on a Multi-Scenario Energy Efficiency Evaluation Method 157
5
electrical load
4.5 heating load
Power(MW)
3.5
2.5
1.5
0 5 10 15 20 25
Time (h)
5
electrical load
4.5
cold load
4
3.5
Power(MW)
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0 5 10 15 20 25
Time (h)
4
electrical load
3.5
3
Power MW
2.5
0 5 10 15 20 25
Time (h)
9
wind power generation
8 photovoltaic power generation
CHP power generation
7
gross generation
6 electrical load
HP
5 abandoning wind and light
BESS
4
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25
Fig. 5. Typical electricity consumption under the “Electric Load Following” strategy during the
winter season
5
total heat production
4.5
CHP heat production
4 heating load
HP heat production
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 6. Typical calorific figure under the “Electric Load Following” strategy during the winter
season
9
wind power generation
8 photovoltaic power generation
CHP power generation
7
gross generation
6 electrical load
abandoning wind and light
5
BESS
4
-1
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 7. Typical electricity consumption under the “Thermal Load Following” strategy during the
winter season
5
total heat production
4.5
CHP heat production
4 heating load
HP heat production
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 8. Typical calorific figure under the “Thermal Load Following” strategy during the winter
season
Research on a Multi-Scenario Energy Efficiency Evaluation Method 159
8
wind power generation
7 photovoltaic power generation
CHP power generation
6 gross generation
electrical load
5 abandoning wind and light
HP
4
BESS
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 9. Typical electricity consumption under the “Electric Load Following” strategy during the
summer season
5
total heat production
4.5 CHP heat production
heating load
4
HP heat production
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 10. Typical calorific figure under the “Electric Load Following” strategy during the
summer season
-1
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 11. Typical electricity consumption under the “Thermal Load Following” strategy during
the summer season
5.5
total heat production
5
CHP heat production
4.5 heating load
HP heat production
4
3.5
2.5
1.5
0.5
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 12. Typical calorific figure under the “Thermal Load Following” strategy during the
summer season
160 C. Shi et al.
9
wind power generation
8 photovoltaic power generation
7 CHP power generatio
gross generation
6 electrical load
abandoning wind and light
5
BESS
4
-1
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24
Fig. 13. Typical electricity consumption under the “Electric Load Following” strategy during
the transition season
S2 adopts the “Thermal Load Following” operation strategy. The heat of the CHP
is fully utilized, so the exergy efficiency is high. S2 produces more electricity while
meeting the higher heat load demand, which results in obvious curtailment of wind and
PV power, and lower renewable energy consumption rate than S1.
When S3 adopts the operation strategy of the “Electric Load Following”, in order to
avoid the frequent start and stop of CHP, CHP still runs at the minimum power though
CHP does not need to generate electricity, during the period from 0 to 10 o’clock,
which causes wind curtailment. So the rate of renewable energy consumption is lower
than S1.
S4 adopts the “Thermal Load Following” operation strategy. As the cooling load
demand increases rapidly between 6 and 9 o’clock, the amount of electricity generated
by CHP is redundant, so that the wind and PV power abandoning is obvious, and the
rate of renewable energy consumption is very low.
Research on a Multi-Scenario Energy Efficiency Evaluation Method 161
For S5, the wind power in the transitional season is relatively large. Between 0 to 8
o’clock, the amount of wind power generated even exceeds the electric load demand,
resulting in the wind power curtailment. Due to the lack of cooling and heating load
requirements in the transition season of S5, the heat of CHP is wasted, making the
energy efficiency not high.
According to the index information entropy and index weights, the comprehensive
evaluation value of each system scheme can be calculated, as shown in Table 5.
According to the evaluation results, CHP chooses the operation strategy of “Electric
Load Following” in the heating season, cooling season and transition season.
5 Conclusion
References
1. Ma, Z., Zhou, X., Shang, Y.: Exploring the concept, key technologies and development
model of energy internet. Power Syst. Technol. 39(11), 3018–3022 (2015). (in Chinese)
2. Announcement of the National Energy Administration on Announcement of the First
“Internet+” Smart Energy (Energy Internet) Demonstration Project. http://zfxxgk.nea.gov.cn/
auto83/201707/t20170706_2825.htm
3. Cheng, L., Liu, C., Zhu, S., et al.: Study of micro energy internet based on multi-energy
interconnected strategy. Power Syst. Technol. 40(1), 132–138 (2016). (in Chinese)
4. Cheng, L., Zhang, J., Huang, R., et al.: Multi-energy complementary based on multi-scenario
planning case analysis of integrated energy system. Electr. Power Autom. Equip. 37(6), 282–
287 (2017). (in Chinese)
5. Wang, W., Wang, D., Jia, H., et al.: Review of steady-state analysis of typical regional
integrated energy system under the background of the energy internet. Proc. CSEE 36(12),
3292–3305 (2016)
6. Kong, X.Q., Wang, R., Huang, X.H.: Energy efficiency and economic feasibility of CCHP
driven by Stirling engine. Energy Convers. Manag. 45(9–10), 1433–1442 (2004)
7. Li, H., Fu, L., Geng, K., et al.: Energy utilization evaluation of CCHP systems. Energy
Build. 38(3), 253–257 (2006)
8. Cai, R.: Heating supply criteria and basic analysis of heat supply for gas turbine. Eng.
Thermophys. 8(3), 201–205 (1987). (in Chinese)
9. Lin, F., Yi, J.: Energy analysis of a combined heating, cooling and electricity system from
the viewpoint of the second law. Energy Technol. 9(3), 142–147 (2000). (in Chinese)
10. Jia, M., Ling, C.: An analysis of several main evaluation models of combined heating
cooling and power production. Refrigeration Air Cond. 4(4), 34–38 (2004). (in Chinese)
11. Huangfu, Y., Wu, J.Y., Wang, R.Z., et al.: Evaluation and analysis of novel Micro-scale
Combined Cooling, Heating and Power (MCCHP) system. Energy Convers. Manag. 48(5),
1703–1709 (2007)
12. Xue, Y., Guo, Q., Sui, H.: Energy comprehensive utilization index for multi-energy
collaborative parks. Electric Power Autom. Equip. 37(6), 117–122 (2017). (in Chinese)
13. Wang, Q., Fang, F.: Optimal configuration of CCHP system based on energy, economical,
and environmental considerations. In: Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on
Intelligent Control and Information Processing, ICICIP 2011, pp. 489–494 (2011)
14. Guo, Y., Cheng, L.: Efficiency-based energy efficiency analysis model for integrated energy
system. Renew. Energy Resour. 35(9), 1387–1393 (2017). (in Chinese)
15. Zhang, X., Chen, Z.: Energy consumption performance of combined heat cooling and power
system. Proc. CSEE 27(5), 93–98 (2007). (in Chinese)
16. Sun, S.N., Nie, X.T.: Assessment of agent system project risk based on entropy method. In:
International Conference on Management and Service Science, Piscataway, pp. 1–4. IEEE
(2010)
17. Zhang, T., Zhu, T.: Optimization design and multi-criteria comprehensive evaluation method
of combined cooling heating and power system. Proc. CSEE 35(14), 3706–3713 (2015). (in
Chinese)
Green Supply Chain Management Information
Integration Framework and Operation Mode
Analysis
Abstract. So far, the connotation and system of Green supply chain Manage‐
ment (GSCM) have already had quite a lot of content, and its theoretical research
has also achieved fruitful results. However, at present, the connotation and system
of Green supply chain Management still lack the support of information founda‐
tion, so it is difficult to monitor, analyze and evaluate the implementation of Green
supply chain Management. Based on the connotation and system of green supply
chain management, this thesis discusses how to build the information base of
Green supply chain Management, and puts forward a new information integration
framework and operation mode of green supply chain. It lays a foundation for
realizing the connotation and system of Green supply chain Management and the
integration of enterprise management information system, and provides a way to
solve the problem that the Green supply chain Management system is difficult to
monitor, analyze and evaluate.
1 Introduction
“Green supply chain Management (GSCM)”, as a feasible way to solve the problem of
not only economic benefit but also saving environmental protection in manufacturing
industry, has been paid more and more attention and research by many scholars. For the
GSCM, domestic and foreign scholars have carried out a lot of research: Anne Touboulic
and Helen Walker have studied the theoretical development and present situation of
sustainable supply chain, and put forward that integration and comprehensive under‐
standing of the concept of “sustainable” will be the main challenge facing the develop‐
ment of sustainable supply chain in the future. Based on the analysis of a large number
of literatures with high recognition at present, it is pointed out that more microscopic
and multi-level methods should be used to study the sustainable supply chain in the
future [1]. Stephan Vachon conducted a survey of North American packaging and
printing plants (USA and Canada) using statistical probabilistic models to analyze the
data, indicating that there is a link between environmental management in supply chains
and the quality management norms used by factories. It is speculated that the
By supplementing and integrating the management systems of each link in the internal
supply chain, a complete green supply chain management system within the enterprise
can be constructed completely. A complete green supply chain management system
oriented to the internal enterprise should be the different management information
systems involved in the production and operation of the enterprise. The functions of
each department are integrated and planned rationally and effectively, and the indicators,
processes, standards and systems of the green supply chain management are integrated
into it, thus a new, more complete and completely new green supply chain management
system which combines the functions of each part of the system is built.
The GSCM system has the basic information of the whole enterprise and the business
data generated in the operation of the enterprise, and these quantitative data can be
extracted by technical means. And these data are stored in the enterprise database.
Therefore, the GSCM system can solve the problem that the green supply chain manage‐
ment lacks the information support and the green supply chain management is difficult
to quantify. Following is an analysis of the GSCM integration framework to illustrate
how to address these two issues in detail.
In order to solve the problem that green supply chain management lacks information
support and is difficult to quantify, three key points must be grasped: (1) GSCM should
be integrated according to what technical route, the business data involved in the oper‐
ation of the enterprise should be preserved to the maximum extent, to ensure the integrity
of the data, and make it become the information support of the enterprise. (2) which
management systems should be integrated in GSCM to ensure the overall coverage of
the main business of manufacturing enterprises; (3) In view of the problem that the
evaluation of green supply chain management is difficult to quantify, what evaluation
indexes should be set up in the GSCM system to evaluate the degree of green supply
chain management? The following three problems are discussed in detail.
From the technical level, GSCM system should be based on business system, through
database integration planning, business logic integration planning and business process
redesign to ensure data integrity. Realize the goal of unified access and unified business
collaboration.
Therefore, the technology integration framework of green supply chain management
system is divided into four levels: application system layer, data layer, logical abstraction
layer, business process layer and access layer. As shown in Fig. 1:
166 Z. Zhou et al.
Unified
access Unified access Sub-user display Customized
business
layer entry information report form
collaboration
Business
process
integration
Logical
abstraction Include Yes Judge No Return ……
layer
applicati
PDM/CAD CAPP ERP MES
on layer
Application layer Integration Framework for GSCM explains what the GSCM system
should contain from the concept level, the relationship between each module and how
they work to form a complete system.
Different from the technology integration framework of GSCM, the technology
integration framework of GSCM provides the technical route and integration strategy
Green Supply Chain Management Information Integration Framework 167
for the implementation of the application layer integration framework of GSCM. The
application layer integration framework of GSCM indicates which aspects of enterprise
operation and which management information system should be involved in GSCM
system. The technology integration framework of GSCM is the theoretical foundation
of GSCM application layer integration framework. The application layer integration
framework of GSCM is the concrete content of GSCM system. Both of them constitute
the whole integration framework of GSCM system, which is indispensable.
The application layer integration framework of GSCM is an important foundation.
What is different from the common enterprise information integration system is that the
application system integration framework of GSCM must be combined with the conno‐
tation and system of green supply chain management. By controlling several important
stages in the product life cycle, the design is carried out.
(1) Product design stage
In the design phase, through the secondary development of the PDM system, we can
identify and identify the materials that need to be under key control, including hazardous
substances, controlled substances and recycled materials, etc. At present, the country
has clearly defined the environmental pollution materials and recyclable materials. The
concrete classification may refer to the national standard “green production enterprise
green supply chain management guideline” appendix C. Do not allow or restrict
designers to use environmentally hazardous materials, in the system for controlled
materials for clear color or marking. For recyclable materials, it should be arranged in
advance in the system to make it the first choice for product designers.
(2) Acquisition phase
In the procurement process, the purchasing and warehousing module of the ERP
system needs to be developed in a second time, and the material audit and warehousing
workflow in the system is modified. In the supplier management of purchasing module,
the supplier should be given green supplier rating according to the environmental
protection degree of the material provided in a supplier evaluation cycle, which can be
used in the future business of the enterprise to select the supplier with higher rating. In
the process of material audit, in addition to the quality and quantity of materials, it is
also necessary to audit their environmental protection to ensure that the materials
purchased by enterprises meet the requirements of the green supply chain management
system. In addition, in the storage module, It is also necessary to identify and mark all
kinds of materials to facilitate managers to check and count all kinds of materials that
need to be controlled.
(3) Process planning stage
In the process planning, we need to improve and expand the CAPP system, add the
green characteristic evaluation module into the hybrid CAPP system, and evaluate the
green performance of the processing process from the aspects of resource consumption
and environmental pollution and so on. The results of process planning and evaluation
are fed back to PDM system or PLM system, so that the designer can get enough infor‐
mation to improve and optimize the product design.
168 Z. Zhou et al.
Practice shows that the economic benefit and management height of the same system
are completely different under different operating modes. Therefore, how to reasonably
design and plan the operation mode of GSCM to achieve the system requirements of
high cohesion and low coupling, It is crucial and important problem to realize the
efficient operation of the whole supply chain management system and to embody the
green supply chain management system in the operation of the system. Next part will
carry on the discussion and the analysis to the GSCM operation pattern.
The essence of the GSCM system is firstly the existence of the production and oper‐
ation management system of the enterprise. Therefore, the first consideration of the
operation mode of green supply chain management system is to design according to the
operation mode of enterprises. From product research and development to product
design, raw material procurement, production, accumulation of enterprise material
information database to product sales. After that, the third party system manages the
transportation and recycling of the products. Figure 3 is the operation mode of the green
supply chain management system designed according to the production and operation
mode of the enterprise:
170 Z. Zhou et al.
The product design system according to the green design standard design product
style, build a product BOM list. Determine the required materials, transfer the relevant
documents and materials to the process management system, the process management
system according to the green production process standards to arrange the appropriate
processing process and process, Then the raw material information needed to be
purchased can be transferred to the ERP system according to the demand of the enter‐
prise, and the information can be selectively transferred to the ERP system in order to
support the function of quota material collection and so on. At the same time, the product
drawings, processing technology, BOM list and so on are passed to the MES system.
The raw material inventory status information in the warehouse is passed to the MES
system by the ERP system. If the stock is sufficient, it is ready to produce, if the stock
is insufficient, then the raw material is waited to complete the production after the raw
material purchase. In the production process, the MES system carries on the production
management and the each production process monitor according to the green production
standard, guarantees the production smoothly, finally hands the product to the third party
system to carry on the management.
The operation mode of GSCM system designed according to the above model
accords with the production operation of the enterprise and can support the normal
production operation management of the enterprise. However, this mode belongs to the
“propulsive” mode of operation. Although it can normally carry out various business
blocks, it lacks feedback to form a closed-loop information flow, and it is difficult to
improve the management level of an enterprise. Secondly, there is a lack of quantitative
indicators to evaluate and improve the operation model, which will limit the flexibility
of the GSCM system, once the implementation is completed, it is difficult to improve
and improve. Therefore, in order to make up the shortcomings and shortcomings of the
“advanced “ operation mode, this paper puts forward the operation mode of the improved
operation green supply chain management system, as shown in Fig. 4:
Green Supply Chain Management Information Integration Framework 171
In view of the problems in the “propulsive” operation mode, the improved GSCM
system adds the data feedback flow monitored and collected from the production process
to the improved GSCM system, thus realizing the closed-loop flow of information.
Through the quantitative data such as pollution situation and material utilization rate
collected in the process of product manufacture and each process, the system of product
design and process management is fed back to the product design system and the process
management system. Facilitate designers and process managers to better analyze the
causes of pollution, pollution and raw materials are fully utilized. Thus, the pollution
treatment methods or product and process solutions are given, and the new generation
of products and corresponding process processes are designed. At the same time, the
designers feed back to the R & D department the parts of the next generation products
that need to be improved and optimized. So that R&D department has targeted R&D.
This process is repeated in the process of production and manufacture of the new gener‐
ation of products, and a continuous improvement and innovation of the enterprise oper‐
ation mode is formed.
The two operational models are compared here in one year using the evaluation
indicators mentioned above, thus illustrating the improved operational model being
more refined and mature, as shown in Table 1:
5 Conclusion
Green supply chain is a new mode and inevitable trend of the development of our manu‐
facturing industry in the future. Based on the connotation and system of green supply
chain management, this paper further expounds the integrated framework and two oper‐
ation modes of green supply chain management system. The two operation modes are
analyzed and compared. The GSCM system after planning and integration has solved
the problem that traditional supply chain management system lacks systematic support
and is difficult to quantify.
The GSCM system after planning and integration has solved the problem that tradi‐
tional supply chain management system lacks systematic support and is difficult to
quantify. Through the practical application in a certain equipment manufacturing enter‐
prise, this model provides a supporting platform for the system realization and quanti‐
tative evaluation of the GSCM system of the enterprise. The logistics and information
flow of the enterprise are unified effectively, which improves the management level of
the enterprise and the ability of the GSCM.
References
1. Touboulic, A., Walker, H.: Theories in sustainable supply chain management: a structured
literature review. Int. J. Phys. Distrib. Logist. Manag. 1(2), 16–42 (2015)
2. Vachon, S., Klassen, R.D.: Environmental management and manufacturing performance: the
role of collaboration in the supply chain. Int. J. Prod. Econ. 2, 299–315 (2008)
3. Green Jr., K.W., Zelbst, P.J., Meacham, J., et al.: Green supply chain management practices:
impact on performance. Chain. Manag. 3, 290–305 (2012)
4. Formentini, M., Taticchi, P.: Corporate sustainability approaches and governance
mechanisms in sustainable supply chain management. J. Clean. Prod. 112, 1920–1933 (2014)
5. Sun, T., Xi, D., Wang, Y.: Suggestions on the implementation of green supply chain
management in manufacturing enterprises. Stand. China 03, 77–81 (2017)
6. Zhang, J.: Analysis of operation framework and information integration model of green
supply chain management. Inf. Sci. 32(12), 105–108+114 (2014)
7. Yang, J., Han, Q., Shui, H.: Three-dimensional Integration of enterprise environment
management, innovation management and supply chain management-construction and
application of supply chain sustainable innovation system. Sci. Technol. Prog. Count.
Measures 32(08), 18–23 (2015)
8. Yi, S., Xue, Q.: Green supply chain management and green innovation-an empirical study
based on Chinese manufacturing enterprises. Manag. Res. Dev. 37(06), 103–110 (2016)
9. Sauvé, S., Bernard, S., Sloan, P.: Environmental sciences, sustainable development and
circular economy: alternative concepts for trans-disciplinary research. Environ. Dev. 17, 48–
56 (2016)
10. Bai, C., Tang, J.: The game analysis of green supply chain cooperation in manufacturing-
sales enterprises. J. Syst. Eng. 32(06), 818–828 (2017)
11. Liu, Y., Wang, T.: Green supply chain management: development process, foreign experience
and enlightenment. Ecol. Econ. 32(06), 138–141+204 (2016)
12. Dubey, R., Gunasekaran, A., Papadopoulos, T., Childe, S.J., Shibin, K.T., Wamba, S.F.:
Sustainable supply chain management: framework and further research directions. J. Clean.
Prod. 142, 1119–1130 (2016)
Design of Temperature Monitoring System
with Low Power Consumption for High
Voltage Electrical Equipment
1 Introduction
Nowadays fire or explosion caused by high voltage electrical equipment or their poor
installation quality is common, which results in hidden danger for major public projects
and infrastructures. Therefore, the temperature monitoring system for high voltage
electrical equipment is an important measure to ensure the power networks safely
operating [1].
There are three ways about the temperature monitoring of high voltage electrical
equipment: surface temperature induction strips, infrared temperature measurement,
and optical fiber grating temperature measurement [2, 3]. Surface temperature induc-
tion strips used widely in electric power industry have low cost, easy installation and
maintenance, but its disadvantage is artificial observation. So it could not achieve
temperature alarm in time or constitute a monitoring network. The infrared equipment
is complicated, and it has high power consumption. In particular, infrared signals can’t
penetrate obstacles [4]. The optical fiber is not used widely because of its disadvantage
of insulation performance, which would be greatly reduced in rainy season or humid
climate, and be easy to snap and no-resistant to high temperature.
This paper develops a temperature monitoring and warning system with low power
consumption based on wireless communication, which is designed to provide a solu-
tion for temperature monitoring for high voltage electrical equipment.
2 System Constitution
Figure 1 shows the system structure. Slave machine (signal transmitter) uses high-
temperature lithium battery for power supply, which is installed on the electrical
equipment for testing. The slave machine collects temperature data and sends it to the
host machine (wireless signal acquisition unit) through wireless communication. The
host machine receives and stores the temperature data, and communicates with the data
processing system through the RS485 bus. Data processing system sends host machine
instructions and delivers the alarm information to the operator for electric power net-
works in time by SMS, and synchronizes data to the central server through internet.
The management for power networks masters each testing point’s situation by the data
center server. This paper will mainly discuss the design of the slave and host machine.
The host and slave machine are all composed of main control unit, wireless commu-
nication unit and power unit. Since the host machine communicates with the data
processing system and collects information to display timely, the hardware is more
Design of Temperature Monitoring System 175
complicated than that of slave machine. The slave machine’s PCB board is the same as
one in host machine, and some electronic components didn’t require welding.
interface, and its communication frequency band can cover 425–525 MHz with duplex
sending and receiving mechanism. In addition, the shutdown current is only 30 nA, the
standby current is only 50 nA, and the receiving sensitivity is −124 db (@500 bps),
which extends the transmission distance for wireless transmission and provides reliable
communication link [9]. Figure 3 shows the si4438’s schematic.
Since the working environment is various, the power supply for host machine has
four modes: battery power supply; USB power supply; debugging interface C2 power
supply and AC adapter thought USB. The mode of power supply works conveniently
through the switch.
Design of Temperature Monitoring System 177
The key of software design is low-power consumption and reliable to communicate. The
low-power consumption is important to slave machine design, and there are two keys to
solve it: using the MCU’s suspend mode reasonably and planning the temperature data
launch time intervals. C8051F930 has a 32-bit real-time clock with dedicated 32 kHz
oscillator, and it works normally in 0.9–3.6 V voltage without any external resistance or
load capacitance in the MCU’s lowest-power consumption mode [10–13]. Considering
the reduction of power consumption, slave machine acquires temperature data every
10 min and then judges that whether the temperature value exceeds its limit or not. The
salve machine uploads temperature data every 4 h without exception, and uploads
temperature data’s time interval according to the different situation with exception.
The MCU of slave machine suspends when acquiring or uploading temperature data.
The software procedure of slave machine is shown in Fig. 5.
length frame, data frame, verification frame and terminator frame. Each element is
consisted of a number of bytes. When the host machine detects the data frame, the
length of the packet is checked firstly, and then the frame head, the frame tail and the
frame length are checked.
The frame information is preserved when all information is right. If temperature
exceeds its limit, the host machine uploads alarm information for displaying or storing
in PC via a serial port. In addition, the users can modify temperature limit.
5 Performance Testing
The experimental test is performed, as shown in Fig. 6. The test environment is divided
into normal temperature, high temperature and low temperature. The communication
frequency is set to 433 MHz and the communication distance is set to 100 m. The data
is transmitted every 10 min. The system is powered by 4.2 V and 1200 mA in a single
lithium battery. Table 1 shows the reliability of test data, and Table 2 shows test data
about the power consumption of system.
Based on the testing results, the system works well in all the test conditions, and
can meet the actual requirements. Furthermore, we find that each data time is short,
which is tested within 100 ms. The average current is very small, and transmit interval
is far longer than 10 min in practice. By theoretical calculation, the system can con-
tinue to work more than five years with a single lithium battery.
Design of Temperature Monitoring System 179
This paper show that the proposed system can be applied to the wireless temper-
ature measurement for high voltage equipment in power industry, and it can effectively
solve the problem of untimely manual inspection.
References
1. Sun, Y.H., Li, Y.F., Liu, Z.Y., Dou, W.J.: Research on diagnosis technology of insulation
performance of high voltage electrical equipment. In: 2017 Chinese Automation Congress,
pp. 5398–5403. IEEE Press, New York (2017)
2. Liu, T., Zhang, Q., Li, G.L., Ma, Z.L., Zhang, M.S.: Design and implementation of the
temperature monitoring system of infrared rotary kiln shell. In: 12th IEEE Conference on
Industrial Electronics and Applications, pp. 253–257. IEEE Press, New York (2017)
3. Roy, A., Das, P., Das, R.: Temperature and humidity monitoring system for storage rooms of
industries. In: 2017 International Conference on Computing and Communication Tech-
nologies for Smart Nation, pp. 99–103. IEEE Press, New York (2017)
4. Zhang, Y., Tian, J., Ye, F.: Development of temperature real-time monitoring network for
high voltage switch cabinet on IR sensor. High Volt. Apparatus 41(2), 91–94 (2005)
5. Zhang, Y., Liu, R.: Remote pipeline temperature and pressure monitoring system based on
C8051F930. Electron. Des. Eng. 18(10), 83–85 (2010)
6. Barth, N.D., Bender, V.C., Marchesan, T.B.: An analysis of frequency response on OLED
for lighting applications. In: Industry Applications Society Annual Meeting, pp. 1–5. IEEE
Press, New York (2017)
7. Kundrata, J., Baric, A.: Application of ferrite layers in low-profile OLED drivers. IET Power
Electron. 11(2), 92–99 (2018)
8. Shu, Y.F., Wei, X.C., Yu, X.Q., Liu, C.J.: Effects of grounded-lid apertures for package-
level electromagnetic interference (EMI) shielding. In: 2017 IEEE International Symposium
on Electromagnetic Compatibility and Signal/Power Integrity, pp. 345–348. IEEE Press,
New York (2017)
9. Si4438 datasheet. https://www.silabs.com/documents/public/data-sheets/Si4438.pdf
10. C8051F92X-C8051F93X. https://www.silabs.com/products/mcu/8-bit/c8051f92x-f93x
11. C8051F2xx Small Form Factor Microcontrollers. https://www.silabs.com/products/mcu/8-
bit/c8051f2xx
180 H. Wang et al.
12. Wang, P.: Design of temperature and humidity intelligent control system based on C8051F.
In: Proceedings of 2011 International Conference on Electronics and Optoelectronics,
pp. 63–66. IEEE Press, New York (2011)
13. Sui, T., Teng, J.Z., Li, B., Du, Z.T.: The application of multi-serial-interface system in small-
scale monitoring device based on C8051f020. In: 2009 WASE International Conference on
Information Engineering, pp. 389–390. IEEE Press, New York (2009)
14. The multi-function watt-hour meter communication protocol. https://wenku.baidu.com/view/
b25c61eff80f76c66137ee06eff9aef8941e48f4.html
15. Li, L., Hu, X., Huang, J., He, K.: Design of new architecture of AMR system in smart grid.
In: 6th IEEE Industrial Electronics and Application Conference, pp. 21–23. IEEE Press, New
York (2011)
Energy Storages
FRA and EKF Based State of Charge
Estimation of Zinc-Nickel Single Flow
Batteries
1 Introduction
Batteries have become increasingly popular in smart grid and electric vehicles
(EV) applications for energy storage. The redox flow battery (RFB) is char-
acterized by the long life cycles and high charging/discharging efficiency, and
has undergone rapid development in recent years [1]. Cheng and Zhang et al.
[2] have proposed a novel RFB system, namely the single flow zinc-nickel bat-
tery system. Zinc-nickel single flow batteries (ZNBs), known as electrochemical
energy storage sources, have attracted a lot of attention due to their advantages
of high energy density, safety, and low cost [3]. The advantages of ZNBs include
moderate cost, modularity, transportability and flexible operation [4]. Similar to
solid batteries and other type of flow batteries, the battery management system
(BMS) is vital for zinc-nickel flow batteries to ensure the optimal, reliable and
c Springer Nature Singapore Pte Ltd. 2018
K. Li et al. (Eds.): ICSEE 2018/IMIOT 2018, CCIS 925, pp. 183–191, 2018.
https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-13-2381-2_17
184 Y. Li et al.
efficient operation, and to provide accurate battery internal state information for
the energy management modules is an important issue to address in the BMS
[5]. In particular, the battery state of charge (SOC) estimation is an essential
part of a BMS, it provides fundamental knowledge about the real-time remaining
capacity and energy of the battery.
During the last decade, a large number of real-time SOC estimation methods
have been developed. The methods can be classified into four groups, includ-
ing the looking-up table based methods, ampere-hour integral method, model-
based estimation methods, and data-driven estimation methods [6]. Among these
groups of methods, the looking-up table based approach is more suitable for lab-
oratory environment. While the reliability of the ampere-hour method is affected
by measurement errors and available capacity. The data-driven methods are very
sensitive to their identified parameters extracted from the training data, though
they may achieve high prediction accuracy. Contrary to model-free methods,
the model-based estimation methods require accurate battery models. Electro-
chemical model (EM), equivalent circuit model (ECM) and black-box model are
among the most commonly used models. These models often require to incor-
porate state estimation algorithms and adaptive filters to estimate and infer
the internal states of batteries, such as open circuit voltage (OCV), the state
of charge (SOC), and the state of health (SOH), etc. Among these methods,
the extended Kalman filter (EKF) and other Kalman filter variants are widely
adopted for SOC estimation.
In this work, the fast recursive algorithm (FRA) [7] is applied for battery
model identification. The relationship between battery terminal signals and SOC
is first interpreted by a linear-in-the-parameters model, then EKF based SOC
estimation is presented.
This paper is organized as follows. A brief review of the FRA is presented
in Sect. 2. Then the battery state equations deduced by FRA is introduced in
Sect. 3, and the EKF based battery SOC estimation method is also described in
details. Section 4 validates the efficacy of the SOC estimation and the proposed
batteries models. Finally, Sect. 5 concludes the paper.
2 Preliminaries
The accuracy of battery SOC estimation heavily depends on the accuracy of the
battery model. This section first gives a brief introduction to the state of charge
(SOC) of batteries, followed by the fast recursive algorithm used for the model
identification.
Mk = ΦTk Φk (3)
Rk = I − Φk M−1 T
k Φk (4)
where Φk contains the first k columns of the full regression matrix Φ, addi-
tionally, k = 1, ..., n, and R0 = I. When {ϕi , i = 1, 2, ..., n} in Φ are mutually
linearly independent, the recursive matrix Rk will has the following distinguished
properties [9]:
Ek = yT Rk y (9)
186 Y. Li et al.
To simplify the formulas and decrease the computational complexity, three quan-
tities are consequently defined as
⎧ (k)
⎪
⎪
(0)
ϕi Rk ϕi , ϕi R0 ϕi = ϕi
⎪
⎨ T
, a1,i ϕT1 ϕi
(k−1) (k−1)
ak,i ϕk ϕi (10)
⎪
⎪ T T
⎪
⎩ ak,y ϕ y = ϕT1 y
(k−1) (0)
k y, a1,y ϕ1
By calculating the net contribution of each term, the model terms with maximum
contributions will be selected. Then an effective formula will be given for model
parameters identification procedure as follows:
k
aj,y − i=j+1 θ̂i aj,i
θ̂j = , j = k, k − 1, ..., 1 (12)
aj,j
Equations (11) and (12) constitute the FRA, which solves the least-squares prob-
lem recursively.
error in SOC estimation [11]. The black-box models describe the relationship
between the voltage and SOC using nonlinear functions, and do not require
detailed first principle knowledge of the battery. FRA is an effective method to
build a mathematical model. In this paper, the state space model of the battery
is deduced using the coulomb counting equation for the SOC and FRA, where
the SOC is an model state and its relationship with readily measurable terminal
voltages and terminal currents are established. The state equation is expressed
as follows:
SOCk+1 = f (SOCk , Ik ) + wk
(14)
Zk+1 = h(SOCk+1 , Ik+1 ) + vk
where function f (SOCk , Ik ) is the nonlinear state transition function and func-
tion h(SOCk , Ik ) is the nonlinear measurement function. Vector wk and vk are
uncorrelated zero-mean white Gaussian noise with covariance matrixes Q and R
respectively.
At each time step, the function f (SOCk , Ik ) and h(SOCk , Ik ) are linearized
using Taylor-series expansion, assuming that they are differentiable at all operat-
ing points, the elements of the state vector matrix are defined as:
∂f (SOCk , Ik )
Ak = |SOCk =S ÔC − (15)
∂SOCk k
∂h(SOCk , Ik )
Ck = |SOCk =S ÔC − (16)
∂SOCk k
188 Y. Li et al.
To start filtering, the first step is to set initial values, the initialization of the state
and error covariance at k = 0 are made as follows:
ˆ 0 = E[SOC0 ]
SOC
ˆ 0 )T ]
ˆ 0 )(SOC0 − SOC (17)
P0 = E[(SOC0 − SOC
Then using Eqs. (18) and (19) we can predict the state and error covariance at time
instant k:
S ÔCk− = f (S ÔCk−1 , Ik−1 ) (18)
P− T
k = Ak Pk−1 AK + Q (19)
According to the predictions and the measurements, the Kalman gain can be cal-
culated, and the state and error covariance are corrected:
−1
Kk = P− T − T
k Ck Ck Pk Ck + R (20)
S ÔCk = S ÔCk− + Kk Zk − h(S ÔCk− , Ik ) (21)
Pk = (I − Kk Ck ) P−
k (22)
Vk − 1.0053Vk−1 + 0.0282ln Vk−1 = 0.0031sin(SOCk ) − 0.0041sin( SOCk )
(23)
FRA and EKF Based SOC Estimation 189
The results are shown in Fig. 1(a), the model output fits well to the measured ter-
minal voltage, and the error is acceptable. Use the same model in the discharging
procedure, it also fits well, as shown in Fig. 1(b).
This model is compared with the model established by orthogonal matching
pursuit (OMP) algorithm, which selects model terms from an over-complete dic-
tionary. We use ‘wmpdictionary’ function in Matlab to generate a dictionary for
OMP, this dictionary contains the shifted Kronecker delta subdictionary, polyno-
mial subdictionary, cosine and sine subdictionary, and discrete cosine transform-ii
orthonormal basis, etc. The ‘wmpalg’ function is then used to directly return the
approximation of terminal voltage in the dictionary. The comparison of these two
models is shown in Fig. 2 with absolute error on the horizontal and time on the
vertical. The mean square error (MSE) for this model is 6.4378e-05, while for the
FRA-based model is 9.2432e-06. It is clear that the error of the model identified by
FRA is less than that of the model identified by OMP. Considering the accuracy
of the FRA method and its ability to describe the relationship between terminal
voltage and SOC, FRA is a good choice for battery model identification.
In Eq. (23), we use Zk to represent the left side of this equation, the battery
state-space model are:
SOCk+1 = SOCk + ηΔt Q Ik + wk (24)
Zk+1 = 0.0031sin(SOCk+1 ) − 0.0041sin( SOCk+1 )
The EKF algorithm is then used for SOC estimation. Figure 3 depicts the perfor-
mance of the proposed method. It can be found that the SOC value estimated by
the EKF method is very close to the reference values. The absolute error between
these two values is less than 2%, even when the estimation tend to steady, the error
is less than 0.7%. By setting the initial value to 20% while the actual initial value is
0, the robustness of this algorithm is verified, as Fig. 3 shows, the estimated SOC
converge to the actual value quickly.
5 Conclusion
In this paper, an accurate terminal voltage model of flow battery has been built for
EKF-based SOC estimation by applying the fast recursive algorithm (FRA), which
is a computationally efficient and stable model identification method. The model
performs well and is used as a measurement equation in EKF-based SOC estima-
tion. Future works will both focus on improving model accuracy and improving
the estimation method. Some advanced algorithms, such as neural networks and
support vector machines, will be studied for further improvement of model accu-
racy, while dual estimation methods and other methods will be studied to decrease
the SOC estimation error.
Acknowledgments. YH. LI would like to thank the China Scholarship Council (CSC)
for sponsoring her research. S. LI, YX. LI and K. LI would like to thank the Macao Science
and Technology Development Fund (FDCT) s support with the project (111/2013/A3)-
Flow Battery Storage System Study and Its Application in Power System and Dr. CK
Wong to provide the data and experimental resource.
References
1. Li, Y.X., et al.: Modeling of novel single flow zinc-nickel battery for energy storage
system. In: 2014 IEEE 9th Conference on Industrial Electronics and Applications
(ICIEA), pp. 1621–1626. IEEE (2014)
FRA and EKF Based SOC Estimation 191
2. Cheng, J., Zhang, L., Yang, Y.S., Wen, Y.H., Cao, G.P., Wang, X.D.: Preliminary
study of single flow zinc-nickel battery. Electrochem. Commun. 9(11), 2639–2642
(2007)
3. Zhang, H., Li, X., Zhang, J.: Redox Flow Batteries: Fundamentals and Applications.
CRC Press (2017)
4. De Leon, C.P., Frı́as-Ferrer, A., González-Garcı́a, J., Szánto, D., Walsh, F.C.: Redox
flow cells for energy conversion. J. Power Sources 160(1), 716–732 (2006)
5. Rahimi-Eichi, H., Ojha, U., Baronti, F., Chow, M.Y.: Battery management system:
an overview of its application in the smart grid and electric vehicles. IEEE Ind. Elec-
tron. Mag. 7(2), 4–16 (2013)
6. Xiong, R., Cao, J., Yu, Q., He, H., Sun, F.: Critical review on the battery state of
charge estimation methods for electric vehicles. IEEE Access 6, 1832–1843 (2018)
7. Li, K., Peng, J.X., Irwin, G.W.: A fast nonlinear model identification method. IEEE
Trans. Autom. Control 50(8), 1211–1216 (2005)
8. Gregory, L.P.: Extended kalman filtering for battery management systems of lipb-
based hev battery packs, part 2: modeling and identification. J. Power Sources
134(2), 262–276 (2004)
9. Li, K., Peng, J.X., Bai, E.W.: A two-stage algorithm for identification of nonlinear
dynamic systems. Automatica 42(7), 1189–1197 (2006)
10. Gregory, L.P.: Extended kalman filtering for battery management systems of lipb-
based hev battery packs: part 1. background. J. Power Sources 134(2), 252–261
(2004)
11. Lin, X., Qin, J.: Joint estimation of single flow zinc-nickle battery state and param-
eter using unscented kalman filter. IEEE Power Energy Soc. General Meet. (2015)
An Approach to Propose Optimal Energy
Storage System in Real-Time Electricity
Pricing Environments
1 Introduction
In recent years, the role of clean energy and optimized allocation of all kinds of energy
is presented in our view to address the issue of resource constraints, environment
pollution and climate change. Although the growth of the renewables penetration is
increasing rapidly, large scale clean energy cannot be applied unless it is transformed
into electricity directly. Regions rich in renewables are usually located far from energy
This work was supported by the State Grid Technology Project: Research and Application on
Flexibility Improvement of Power Distribution System Based on Distributed/Mobile Energy
Storage (SGTJDK00DWJS1800008), the National Natural Science Foundation of China
(51707129) and the National Key Research and Development Foundation of China
(2017YFB0903300).
consumption users. The energy storage systems (ESS) could be a feasible solution
dealing with these issues. Furthermore, the utility of energy storage, like batteries, as an
energy power buffer, on the other hand, could be able to smooth the power demand
flections. Thus, it is important to conduct research on how to utilize different kinds of
energy storage to sustainable develop the environment.
Integrated energy system has received a wild of attention these years and has been
studied on components, structure, regulation even operation and other aspects. In the
paper [1], the concept of integrated energy system was proposed, which coupled and
interacted with different energy systems at all kinds of level. Combined heat and power
(CHP) plants play a vital role in the integrated energy system, which simultaneously
produce electrical and thermal energy from a single input fuel. Integrated energy
systems directly connect to various energy consumers and couple different forms of
energy carriers with flexible topological structure [2]. This concept not only makes
these subsystems interdependence, but also effectively improves energy efficiency. Ref.
[3–7] constructed an optimal energy flow model for integrated energy system including
both inequalities and equalities constraints. However, the participation of energy
storage system should get more attention, which could be a significant part in the
integrated energy system. In addition, there should be a kind of research that focus on
the planning of energy storage system based on real-time pricing under different sea-
sons. This work could provide strategies to engineers for choosing the most appropriate
facilities for an integrated energy system.
Main contributions of this paper state as follows: an energy storage system model
has been applied in an integrated energy system; a varying pricing participation model
has been proposed to help calculate the optimal power flow in an integrated energy
system. Case studies are simulated to demonstrate the application of varying pricing
participation model, the approach of calculating the optimal power flow with an energy
storage system and the proposed strategies for an integrated energy system.
2 Model Description
The integrated energy system could be able to contain a lot of sub-units. This paper will
focus on the model of photovoltaic power generation, combined heat and power plant
and energy storage.
30R
Tcells ¼ Ta þ ð1Þ
1000
0 is the temperature of the solar cells, Ta is the temperature of the environment, R is the
solar radiation absorbed by solar cells.
194 S. Ma et al.
1 þ k ðTC TR Þ
PPV ¼ PSTC I ð2Þ
ISTC
Where PSTC represents the maximum test power based on standard test conditions;
I represents the intensity of light; k represents the power temperature coefficient; TC
represents the temperature of working solar cells; TR represents the reference tem-
perature; ISTC is the intensity of light under standard test conditions.
Where QMT is the remaining amount of the exhaust excess heat in gas turbine; ge is
the efficiency of electricity generation; g1 is the coefficient of the heat loss for gas
turbine; Qhe and QCO are the amount of heat and cooling provided by the exhaust
excess heat in gas turbine, respectively; Khe and KCO are the heating efficiency and the
cooling efficiency of the Li-Br Absorption Chiller; VMT is the total amount of natural
gas that consumed by gas turbine during its operation; Dt represents the operation time;
L is the gross heat value(GHV) of natural gas.
Pch;t Dt
Soc ðtÞ ¼ Soc ðt 1Þð1 rÞ þ gc ð4Þ
Ebat
Pdis;t Dt
Soc ðtÞ ¼ Soc ðt 1Þð1 rÞ ð5Þ
Ebat gd
Where Soc ðtÞ is the state of charge of the energy storage at the moment of t, r is the
rate of discharge of the energy storage itself; gc and gd are the charging efficiency and
discharging efficiency, respectively; Pch;t is the power of charging of the energy stor-
age; Pdis;t is the power of discharging of the energy storage; Ebat is the capacity of the
energy storage.
Nt X
X NDG
min fDG ¼ Cf PGi;t þ COM PGi;t þ Cdp PGi;t þ Ceav PGi;t ð6Þ
t¼1 i¼1
X X
Nt N CHP
X
Nt
min fgrid ¼ Cpp ðPgrid;t Þ ð8Þ
t¼1
196 S. Ma et al.
s.t.
X
NDG
PGi;t þ PCHPe;t þ Pgrid;t þ PES;t ¼ PLe;t ð9Þ
i¼1
X
NMT
Hi;t ¼ PLh;t ð10Þ
i¼1
4 Case Studies
Case studies are performed on a real integrated energy system, which involve photo-
voltaic power generation system, combined heat and power plant, electrical load and
heat load. Parameters of this system are obtained from [6].
An Approach to Propose Optimal Energy Storage System 197
Under this circumstance, the distributed generation, CHP plants and energy grid
devote to meet the load demand in the IES.
198 S. Ma et al.
Figures 4 and 5 show the output variation of each energy source of the IES within
energy storage system under real pricing within and without the varying pricing par-
ticipation method, respectively.
Through those figures and the data of real-time pricing, it is clear that the varying
pricing participation method will provide a better strategy for electricity grid to par-
ticipate the energy generation process during the lower price, which will benefit the
whole system to some extent.
4.3 Total Cost for the IES Under Different Energy Storage System
The origin IES in this case is going to install the energy storage system actually.
Therefore, this study investigates the total cost for one-year and ten-year separately,
under different capability of the energy storage system in order to obtain the most
beneficial investment point.
Figures 6 and 7 illustrate the total cost for the IES under different capability of the
energy storage system in the season of winter and summer, respectively.
An Approach to Propose Optimal Energy Storage System 199
Fig. 6. Total cost in winter for the IES under different energy storage system
Fig. 7. Total cost in summer for the IES under different energy storage system
From the prospective of load, the amount of electrical load in summer is far more
than electrical load in winter due to the utility of air conditioner in the IES. This is the
reason that the one-year cost of electricity is higher in summer. Besides, it is clear that
the amount of heat load will be in a higher level during winter. Natural gas, the energy
source of CHP plant, is going to be consumed more in winter because of meeting the
demand of heat load.
Although the investment of the energy storage system is seemly like a burden to the
whole system, it will reduce the total cost in the long run and benefit to the environment
dramatically. This is because the amount of pollution will decrease under the utility of
energy storage system.
Combining the simulation results of Figs. 6 and 7, we proposed that the capacity of
energy storage system for the IES could be from 300 kW to 600 kW.
5 Conclusions
This paper proposed a varying pricing model strategy to calculate a more meaningful
operation point for the whole system under real-time pricing. Through the calculation
of optimal energy flow in the integrated energy system, this paper analyzes the benefits
200 S. Ma et al.
of energy storage system and give a range of an optimal capability of the energy
storage system for the given integrated energy system.
References
1. Moein, M.A., Ali, A., Mahmud, F.F., Ehasn, H.: A decomposed solution to multiple-energy
carriers optimal power flow. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 29(2), 707–716 (2014)
2. Xu, X., Hou, K., Jia, H., et al.: A reliability assessment approach for the urban energy system
and its application in energy hub planning. In: IEEE Pes General Meeting, Denver, CO, USA
(2015)
3. An, S., Li, Q., Gedra, T.W.: Natural gas and electricity optimal power flow. In: Transmission
and Distribution Conference and Exposition Conference, Dallas, TX, USA (2003)
4. Wang, Y., Kai, H., Jia, H., et al.: Decoupled optimization of integrated energy system
considering CHP plant based on energy hub model. In: International Conference on Applied
Energy (2017)
5. Lei, Y., Hou, K., Wang, Y., et al.: A new reliability assessment approach for integrated energy
systems: using hierarchical decoupling optimization framework and impact-incensement
based state enumeration method. Appl. Energ. 201, 1237–1250 (2018)
6. Wang, Y., Hou, K., Jia, H.: A computational approach for modeling, evaluating and
optimizing the reliability of integrated community energy systems. In: 1st IEEE Conference
on Energy Internet and Energy System Integration, Beijing, China (2017)
7. Wang, J., Gu, W., Lu, S., et al.: Coordinated planning of multi-district integrated energy
system combining heat network mode. Autom. Electri. Power Syst. 40, 17–24 (2016)
The Electrochemical Performance and
Applications of Several Popular Lithium-ion
Batteries for Electric Vehicles - A Review
1 Introduction
Due to the concerns on the pollutant emissions and the climate change due to
large consumption of fossil fuels to support a variety of anthropogenic activities,
electrification of the transport sector has been included as one of the national
strategies by many countries. As an alternative to the internal combustion engine
(ICE) vehicle, Electric Vehicle (EV) has become increasingly popular in recent
years due to the improvement of performance in acceleration and endurance.
Comparing to the ICE vehicles, the advantages of EVs can be summarised as
following aspects:
(1) Higher efficiency: Generally, the average Tank-to-wheel efficiency of ICE cars
are around 30% and even lower than 15% if stop-and-start behaviour occurs
frequently [1,2]. However, ICEs do not work in high-efficiency region in most
cases, especially when the vehicles are running at a low speed in urban areas.
In contrast, the average battery-to-wheel efficiency of EVs can be up to 87%
which is much higher than ICE based vehicles [1].
As the power source of the electric motor and other electric systems, battery
plays an very important role to ensure the EVs can operate effectively and
reliably. Several popular types of batteries are used in EVs, such as lead acid,
nickel-cadmium, nickel-metal hybrid and Lithium-ion battery. Table 1 presents
the key characteristics of these batteries [5–9].
battery, LiN iM nCoO2 (NMC) battery, LiN iCoAlO2 (NCA) battery, LiF eP O4
(LFP) battery and Li4 T i5 O12 (LTO) battery. These five types of lithium-ion
battery have their unique advantages. As the power source of EVs, the battery
must meet the specific safety and performance requirements with an appropriate
cost. This paper presents a review and comparisons of these five lithium ion
batteries over two aspects, namely the electrochemical performance and their
applications in EVs.
2 Electrochemical Performance
These five types of lithium-ion battery have various electrochemical perfor-
mances due to the adoption of different chemical materials. In this section, the
comparisons of their structure, nominal voltage, energy density, high current rate
capability, thermal stability, cyclabilty and safety performance are presented.
2.1 Structure
LMO has a three dimensional spinel structure which improves the diffusion of
lithium ions [12–14]. The electrochemical reactions are associated with the inser-
tion and extraction of lithium ions between the cathode (LiM n2 O4 ) and the
anode (lithium) [15–17]. NMC battery is one of the most successful lithium-ion
batteries which balances the specific features of Lithium Cobalt Oxide (LCO)
battery and LMO battery. NMC contains a layered structure and the bat-
tery cathode is compounded by three chemical elements (Nickel, Manganese
and Cobalt) with a certain ratio. The difference ratios of these three chem-
ical elements lead to variant battery performances [18–21]. In order to bal-
ance the electrochemical performance, stability and cost, NMC-111 (the ratio
of Nickel:Manganese:Cobalt equals to 1:1:1) battery has been developed and
widely adopted in EVs. NCA battery has similarities with NMC battery, which
replaces manganese with aluminium in order to improve specific energy and life
span [22,23]. LFP battery has an ordered olivine structure, the F eO6 octahedras
share the common corners [24]. Unlike the lithium-ion batteries with graphite
anode, LTO battery adopts Li-titanate as the anode to offer a zero-strain spinel
structure [25].
when the charge current remains 1 C and discharge current increases to 50 C, the
reversible capacity decreases to 78% of its initial capacity; when the charge and
discharge current both change to 20 C, the reversible capacity still remains 58%
of its initial capacity [29]. These experimental results strongly suggest that LMO
battery has low cell resistance and excellent capability at high current rate.
In order to improve the energy density, some researchers doped other chemical
materials, such as N i in LMO battery cathode to form a doped spinel, and the
doped spinel battery can provide a higher theoretical gravimetric capacity of
150–160 mAh/g [30–34]. However, some high energy derivatives of LiM n2 O4
have not been adopted in large-scale in EVs yet due to the limitation of thermal
stability and cyclability.
As a possible alternative of LiCoO2 battery, NMC battery offers an average
working voltage of 3.6 V and a theoretical gravimetric capacity of 280 mAh/g
[35]. However, the actual commercial gravimetric capacity in commercial cells is
around 170 mAh/g [35]. The reversible capacity of a NMC-111 battery decreases
to 78–80% of initial capacity at 4 C discharge current rate [36,37] and the capac-
ity decreases to 73–74% of initial capacity at 8 C discharge current rate [38,39].
This indicates that NMC battery contains high specific energy and good capa-
bility at high current rate.
NCA battery and NMC battery have relatively similar electrochemical perfor-
mance. A typical NCA (LiN i0.8 Co0.15 Al0.05 O2 ) battery offers an average oper-
ation voltage of 3.7 V, and theoretical gravimetric capacity of 279 mAh/g [35].
The actual gravimetric capacity in commercial cells is around 200 mAh/g [35].
The capacity of a NCA battery decreases to 93.3% of the initial capacity at the
discharge current rate at 0.5 C, and there is no extra capacity loss when the
discharge current rate increases to 3 C [40]. It obviously can be found that both
NCA and MNC batteries have high specific energy and can provide satisfactory
performance at high current rate.
LFP has low electrical conductivity (10−9 to 10−10 S/cm ) due to its ordered
olivine structure [24,41–44]. A typical LFP battery offers an average operational
voltage of 3.3 V [9] and a theoretical gravimetric capacity of 170 mAh/g [24]. The
capacity of a LFP battery decreases to 96% of its initial capacity at a discharge
current rate of 1 C; the capacity decreases to 82% and 76% at discharge current
rate of 3 C and 5 C respectively [45]. The specific energy of LFP battery is lower
than the above three lithium-ion batteries. The capacity fades significantly at
high current rate.
Unlike the four types of lithium-ion batteries above, LTO battery replaces
the graphite in the anode with Li4 T i5 O12 to form a zero-strain spinel structure
[25]. As an anode, the operation voltage is 1.5 V for Li/Li4 T i5 O12 battery cell
[46]. When the Li4 T i5 O12 anode couples with cathodes like LMO, NMC, NCA,
the operating voltage is 2.1–2.5 V [47]. The theoretical gravimetric capacity of
Li4 T i5 O12 anode battery is 175 mAh/g [25]. Although the specific energy of LTO
battery is low, it has an excellent capability when operates at high current rate,
the capacity decreases to 87% of the initial capacity at 11.4 C charge/discharge
current rate [48].
A Review of the Five Common Types of Lithium-ion Batteries Used in EVs 205
Comparing the operational voltage and energy density of these five lithium
ion batteries, it can be found that LMO, NMC and NCA batteries enable the
EVs to gain a longer mileage on single charge due to the higher energy density.
LFP and LTO batteries have low energy density which means the EVs need to
bring more battery cells to achieve the energy requirement. However, this results
the increasing of vehicle weight, the mileage one a single charge still cannot be
improved in essence. On the other hand, more batteries are adopted in EVs leads
the Battery Management System (BMS) to face greater challenges.
Apart to the energy and power requirements, safety is another important issue in
EV management. Many factors may cause battery failures, such as over voltage,
under voltage, short circuit, over charge/discharge, overheat and collision, etc.,
and a few accidents due to battery failures have been reported in the public
media. However, the most common factor is the generation of heat and gas
[5,10,50]. Thus, to have desirable thermal stability is another important aspect
in assessing the battery quality. Good thermal stability of a battery enables an
EV to operate in a wider temperature range, and reduces the difficulty of the
thermal management in an EV.
Thermal stability is a key that directly determines the safety of the battery
operation. A typical LMO battery can operate safely at 55 ◦ C, but the capacity
decreases to 75% of its initial capacity [26]. The main reason of the capacity
fading of a LMO battery during cycling is the M n dissolution into the elec-
trolyte [51]. The Solid Electrolyte Interphase (SEI) breaks at 90.5 ◦ C and the
thermal runaway occurs at 250 ◦ C, then O2 is released due to the decomposition
of LiM n2 O4 [52].
A typical NMC battery loses 7.5% capacity at 85 ◦ C after 26 cycles (0.29%
capacity loss per cycle) and loses 22% capacity at 120 ◦ C after 29 cycles [53]. At
206 X. Liu et al.
80 ◦ C, the SEI has no obvious change but it becomes thicker and forms spherical
particles at 120 ◦ C [53]. Flammable and toxic gas (H2 and CO) are released
when the temperature reaches 170 ◦ C and the thermal runaway occurs at 220 ◦ C
[54].
For a typical NCA battery, the anodic reactions occur at 90 ◦ C and the SEI
film breaks at 120 ◦ C; the cathodic reactions occur at 140 ◦ C and the thermal
runaway occurs when the temperature reaches 180 ◦ C [55]. Moreover, thermal
runaway could occur at 65 ◦ C if the NCA battery is overcharged. [56]. NCA bat-
tery has a drastic behaviour when the temperature reaches thermal runaway, a
large amount of gas (317mmol) are released [56]. Oxygen gas is released when
N i4+ is reduced to N i2+ , and the thermal runaway may be caused by the reac-
tion of oxygen and flammable electrolyte [57,58]. As a Ni-rich cathode, NCA
battery has higher specific energy than NMC-111 battery but lower thermal
stability [59].
A typical LFP battery reaches its maximum capacity in a temperature range
of 20 ◦ C–30 ◦ C and the capacity decreases to 95% when the temperature reduces
from 20 ◦ C to 10 ◦ C [60]. The discharge capacity measured at −10 ◦ C shows that
25.8% loss after 600 cycles but 1.9% gain after 300 cycles from the initial capacity
[61]. When the temperature reaches 45 ◦ C, the capacity decreases to 92.7% after
300 cycles and decreases to 85.7% after 600 cycles [61]. When the temperature
reaches to 60 ◦ C, 37% of the initial capacity loss after 100 cycles and 45% of initial
capacity loss after 110 cycles [62]. The thermal runaway occurs at 260 ◦ C [63]
and the thermal runaway occurs at 140 ◦ C for an overcharged LFP battery [56].
The amount of gas is released of a LFP battery at thermal runaway temperature
is 61mmol, which is much less than NCA battery [56].
The capacity of a typical LTO battery decreases to 91.3% after 280 cycles
(0.25% capacity loss per cycle) at 60 ◦ C, the thermal runaway occurs when the
temperature exceeds 260 ◦ C [64]. The research [47] shows that graphite anode
produces large amount of C2 H6 and C2 H4 at 100 ◦ C, but there is no generation
of gaseous decomposition products of LTO anode.
Therefore, the thermal stability and safety level of these five types lithium-ion
batteries can be summarised in Table 3.
3 Applications
All of these five types of lithium-ion battery have been widely adopted in EVs
due to their own specific advantages. The application examples of these five types
of lithium-ion battery in EVs are provided in Table 4 based on the information
available in the public domain.
Apart from the electrochemical performance of the batteries, cost and market
trend are another two important factors which determine the battery application
capability in EVs. In this section, the application capability of these five types
of lithium-ion battery are reviewed and compared from the aspects of cost and
market trend.
3.1 Cost
The cost of a lithium-ion battery contains the following components: materials of
cathode and anode, electrolyte, separator, assembly of cell and module, labour,
etc. [65]. Due to the different raw materials adopted and the manufacturing
processes, the cost of the mentioned five types of Li-ion battery are also different.
Table 5 compares the key properties and cost of the several popular types of
lithium-ion used in EVs. [65–68].
Due to the high cost of Co and T i raw materials and the complex process of
manufacturing, the cost of NMC, NCA and LTO batteries are much higher than
LMO and LFP batteries. It also should be noted that when LTO is selected as
the anode material, the cathode material may be chosen from NMC or NCA, the
cost of NMC/LTO or NCA/LTO battery will be much higher. Even though the
cost of LTO battery is high, the battery replacement frequency can be reduced
for the EVs which require to be recharged often. In contrast, although LMO
208 X. Liu et al.
Table 5. The key properties and cost comparison of the lithium-ion batteries
battery has a lower cost, the drawback of poor cyclability and thermal stability,
the total operation cost may increase for the EVs to be recharged frequently.
Sometimes LMO battery and NMC battery are combined to power an EV in
order to enhance the performance and also decreases the battery cost. LMO can
be used to improve the acceleration performance with the benefit of high current
boost, and the NMC brings good cyclability and thermal stability to the entire
power system. LTO battery is generally applied to the price-insensitive and low
energy requirement vehicles. Due to the properties of high safety, long life and
fast-charge, LTO batteries are favoured by electric buses.
Fig. 1. The market share of different lithium-ion batteries in 2015 and 2025
Figure 1 summarises the market share of lithium-ion battery in 2015 and 2025
respectively [70]. It indicates that NMC, NCA and LTO batteries have a huge
potential market in the next few years. Moreover, although the market share of
LFP and LMO may decrease, the total market volume is showing a climbing
trend [70].
4 Conclusion
LiM n2 O4 , LiN iM nCoO2 , LiN iCoAlO2 , LiF eP O4 and Li4 T i5 O12 batteries
have been adopted in EVs successfully with their specific features. LiM n2 O4
battery has low resistance due to the spinel structure, this allows LiM n2 O4 bat-
tery to offer an excellent performance at high current rate in applications. The
extremely low cost makes it highly favoured by the market. Poor performance
at high temperature and limited cyclability are the downsides. LiN iM nCoO2
battery has a satisfactory overall performance especially for the high specific
energy. A variety of derivatives of LiN iM nCoO2 enable this type lithium-ion
battery to face different applications. The extremely high specific energy and
moderate life span allows LiN iCoAlO2 to be a good candidate for EVs. High
cost and low level of safety are the negatives. The key benefits of LiF eP O4
battery are the long life span and low cost. It has good thermal stability when
it operates at high temperature but the capacity is greatly attenuated at low
temperature. Low specific energy and elevated self-discharge are the main dis-
advantages. Li4 T i5 O12 battery has the best thermal stability, cyclability and
safety performance among these five lithium-ion batteries. No lithium plating
at high current rate supports Li4 T i5 O12 battery for fast charging. However, the
low specific energy and extremely high cost are the major disadvantages.
Acknowledgements. Xuan Liu would like to thank The Department for the Economy
Northern Ireland and W-Tec Centre, Queen’s University Belfast for sponsoring his
research.
References
1. Campanari, S., Manzolini, G., Garcia De la Iglesia, F.: Energy analysis of electric
vehicles using batteries or fuel cells through well-to-wheel driving cycle simulations.
J. Power Sour. 186(2), 464–477 (2009)
2. Williamson, S.S., Emadi, A.: Comparative assessment of hybrid electric and fuel
cell vehicles based on comprehensive well-to-wheels efficiency analysis. IEEE Trans.
Veh. Technol. 54(3), 856–862 (2005)
3. Sandberg, U., Goubert, L., Mioduszewski, P.: Are vehicles driven in electric mode
so quiet that they need acoustic warning signals. In 20th International Congress
on Acoustics (2010)
4. Japan JASIC. A study on approach warning systems for hybrid vehicle in motor
mode. Informal document No. GRB-49-10, 49th GRB (2009)
5. Wang, Q., Jiang, B., Li, B., Yan, Y.: A critical review of thermal management
models and solutions of lithium-ion batteries for the development of pure electric
vehicles. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 64, 106–128 (2016)
210 X. Liu et al.
6. Hua, A.C.C., Syue, B.Z.W.: Charge and discharge characteristics of lead-acid bat-
tery and LiFePO4 battery. In: 2010 International Power Electronics Conference
(IPEC), pp. 1478–1483. IEEE (2010)
7. Ruetschi, P.: Review on the lead-acid battery science and technology. J. Power
Sources 2(1), 3–120 (1977)
8. Hadjipaschalis, I., Poullikkas, A., Efthimiou, V.: Overview of current and future
energy storage technologies for electric power applications. Renew. Sustain. Energy
Rev. 13(6–7), 1513–1522 (2009)
9. Hannan, M.A., Lipu, M.S.H., Hussain, A., Mohamed, A.: A review of lithium-
ion battery state of charge estimation and management system in electric vehicle
applications: challenges and recommendations. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 78,
834–854 (2017)
10. Languang, L., Han, X., Li, J., Hua, J., Ouyang, M.: A review on the key issues
for lithium-ion battery management in electric vehicles. J. Power Sources 226,
272–288 (2013)
11. Etacheri, V., Marom, R., Elazari, R., Salitra, G., Aurbach, D.: Challenges in the
development of advanced Li-ion batteries: a review. Energy Environ. Sci. 4(9),
3243–3262 (2011)
12. Thackeray, M.M., Johnson, P.J., De Picciotto, L.A., Bruce, P.G., Goodenough,
J.B.: Electrochemical extraction of lithium from LiMn2O4. Mater. Res. Bull. 19(2),
179–187 (1984)
13. Thackeray, M.M., David, W.I.F., Bruce, P.G., Goodenough, J.B.: Lithium insertion
into manganese spinels. Mater. Res. Bull. 18(4), 461–472 (1983)
14. Choa, J., Thackeray, M.M.: Structural changes of LiMn2O4 spinel electrodes during
electrochemical cycling. J. Electrochem. Soc. 146(10), 3577–3581 (1999)
15. Lazzari, M., Scrosati, B.: A cyclable lithium organic electrolyte cell based on two
intercalation electrodes. J. Electrochem. Soc. 127(3), 773–774 (1980)
16. Guo, D., et al.: Synthesis and electrochemical properties of high performance poly-
hedron sphere like lithium manganese oxide for lithium ion batteries. J. Alloys
Compd. 632, 222–228 (2015)
17. Ouyang, C.Y., Shi, S.Q., Wang, Z.X., Li, H., Huang, X.J., Chen, L.Q.: Ab initio
molecular-dynamics studies on LixMn2O4 as cathode material for lithium sec-
ondary batteries. EPL (Europhysics Letters) 67(1), 28 (2004)
18. Li, D.-C., Muta, T., Zhang, L.-Q., Yoshio, M., Noguchi, H.: Effect of synthesis
method on the electrochemical performance of LiNi1/3Mn1/3Co1/3O2. J. Power
Sources 132(1–2), 150–155 (2004)
19. Dolotko, O., Senyshyn, A., Mühlbauer, M.J., Nikolowski, K., Ehrenberg, H.: Under-
standing structural changes in NMC Li-ion cells by in situ neutron diffraction. J.
Power Sources 255, 197–203 (2014)
20. Choi, J., Manthiram, A.: Role of chemical and structural stabilities on the electro-
chemical properties of layered LiNi1/ 3Mn1/ 3Co1/ 3O2 cathodes. J. Electrochem.
Soc. 152(9), A1714–A1718 (2005)
21. Ohzuku, T., Makimura, Y.: Layered lithium insertion material of
LiNi1/2Mn1/2O2: a possible alternative to LiCoO2 for advanced lithium-ion
batteries. Chem. Lett. 30(8), 744–745 (2001)
22. Tran, H.Y., Greco, G., Täubert, C., Wohlfahrt-Mehrens, M., Haselrieder, W.,
Kwade, A.: Influence of electrode preparation on the electrochemical performance
of LiNi0. 8Co0. 15Al0. 05O2 composite electrodes for lithium-ion batteries. J.
Power Sources 210, 276–285 (2012)
23. Kim, G.-Y., Dahn, J.R.: Effects of electrode density on the safety of NCA positive
electrode for Li-ion batteries. J. Electrochem. Soc. 160(8), A1108–A1111 (2013)
A Review of the Five Common Types of Lithium-ion Batteries Used in EVs 211
42. Andersson, A.S., Kalska, B., Häggström, L., Thomas, J.O.: Lithium extrac-
tion/insertion in LiFePO4: an x-ray diffraction and mössbauer spectroscopy study.
Solid State Ionics 130(1–2), 41–52 (2000)
43. Barker, J., Saidi, M.Y., Swoyer, J.L.: Lithium iron (ii) phospho-olivines prepared
by a novel carbothermal reduction method. Electrochem. Solid-State Lett. 6(3),
A53–A55 (2003)
44. Shin, H.C., Cho, W.I., Jang, H.: Electrochemical properties of the carbon-coated
LiFePO4 as a cathode material for lithium-ion secondary batteries. J. Power
Sources 159(2), 1383–1388 (2006)
45. Huang, Y., Ren, H., Yin, S., Wang, Y., Peng, Z., Zhou, Y.: Synthesis of LiFePO4/C
composite with high-rate performance by starch sol assisted rheological phase
method. J. Power Sources 195(2), 610–613 (2010)
46. Ferg, E., Gummow, R.J., De Kock, A., Thackeray, M.M.: Spinel anodes for lithium-
ion batteries. J. Electrochem. Soc. 141(11), L147–L150 (1994)
47. Belharouak, I., Koenig Jr., G.M., Amine, K.: Electrochemistry and safety of
Li4Ti5O12 and graphite anodes paired with LiMn2O4 for hybrid electric vehicle
Li-ion battery applications. J. Power Sources 196(23), 10344–10350 (2011)
48. Lai, C., Dou, Y.Y., Li, X., Gao, X.P.: Improvement of the high rate capability of
hierarchical structured Li4Ti5O12 induced by the pseudocapacitive effect. J. Power
Sources 195(11), 3676–3679 (2010)
49. Battery Universtiy. Bu-205: Types of lithium-ion. http://batteryuniversity.com/
learn/article/types of lithium ion. Accessed 01 Apr 2018
50. Levy, S.C., Bro, P.: Battery hazards and accident prevention of cell components
with the thermal behavior of a complete cell (1994)
51. Xia, Y., Zhou, Y., Yoshio, M.: Capacity fading on cycling of 4 V Li/LiMn2 O 4
cells. J. Electrochem. Soc. 144(8), 2593–2600 (1997)
52. Wang, Q., Sun, J., Chen, C.: Thermal stability of delithiated LiMn2O4 with elec-
trolyte for lithium-ion batteries. J. Electrochem. Soc. 154(4), A263–A267 (2007)
53. Bodenes, L., et al.: Lithium secondary batteries working at very high temperature:
capacity fade and understanding of aging mechanisms. J. Power Sources 236, 265–
275 (2013)
54. Golubkov, A.W., et al.: Thermal-runaway experiments on consumer li-ion batteries
with metal-oxide and olivin-type cathodes. RSC. Adv. 4(7), 3633–3642 (2014)
55. Wen, J., Yan, Y., Chen, C.: A review on lithium-ion batteries safety issues: existing
problems and possible solutions. Mater. Express 2(3), 197–212 (2012)
56. Andrey, W., et al.: Thermal runaway of commercial 18650 Li-ion batteries with
LFP and NCA cathodes-impact of state of charge and overcharge. RSC. Adv.
5(70), 57171–57186 (2015)
57. Belharouak, I., Wenquan, L., Vissers, D., Amine, K.: Safety characteristics of Li
(Ni0. 8Co0. 15Al0. 05) O2 and Li (Ni1/3Co1/3Mn1/3) O2. Electrochem. Commun.
8(2), 329–335 (2006)
58. Yoon, W.S., Chung, K.Y., McBreen, J., Yang, X.Q.: A comparative study on struc-
tural changes of LiCo1/3Ni1/3Mn1/3O2 and LiNi0. 8Co0. 15Al0. 05O2 during first
charge using in situ XRD. Electrochem. Commun. 8(8), 1257–1262 (2006)
59. Bak, S.M., et al.: Structural changes and thermal stability of charged lini x Mn y
Co z O2 cathode materials studied by combined in situ time-resolved XRD and
mass spectroscopy. ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 6(24), 22594–22601 (2014)
60. Chen, K., Li, X.: Accurate determination of battery discharge characteristics-a
comparison between two battery temperature control methods. J. Power Sources
247, 961–966 (2014)
A Review of the Five Common Types of Lithium-ion Batteries Used in EVs 213
61. Zhang, Y., Wang, C.-Y., Tang, X.: Cycling degradation of an automotive LiFePO4
lithium-ion battery. J. Power Sources 196(3), 1513–1520 (2011)
62. Dubarry, M., et al.: Identifying battery aging mechanisms in large format Li ion
cells. J. Power Sources 196(7), 3420–3425 (2011)
63. Mayza, A.B., et al.: Thermal characterization of LiFepO4 cathode in lithium ion
cells. ECS Trans. 35(34), 177–183 (2011)
64. Huang, P., et al.: Experimental and modeling analysis of thermal runaway propa-
gation over the large format energy storage battery module with Li4Ti5O12 anode.
Appl. Energy 183, 659–673 (2016)
65. Berckmans, G., Messagie, M., Smekens, J., Omar, N., Vanhaverbeke, L., Van
Mierlo, J.: Cost projection of state of the art lithium-ion batteries for electric
vehicles up to 2030. Energies 10(9), 1314 (2017)
66. Deng, D.: Li-ion batteries: basics, progress, and challenges. Energy Sci. Eng. 3(5),
385–418 (2015)
67. Mekonnen, Y., Sundararajan, A., Sarwat, A.I.: A review of cathode and anode
materials for lithium-ion batteries. In: SoutheastCon, 2016, pp. 1–6. IEEE (2016)
68. Smekens, J., et al.: Influence of electrode density on the performance of Li-ion
batteries: experimental and simulation results. Energies 9(2), 104 (2016)
69. Pillot, C.: The rechargeable battery market and main trends 2014–2025. In: 31st
International Battery Seminar & Exhibit (2015)
70. Lebedeva, N., De Periso, F., Boon-Brett, L.: Lithium ion battery value chain and
related opportunities for europe. European Commission, Petten (2016)
A Large-Scale Manufacturing Method
to Produce Form Stable Composite Phase
Change Materials (PCMs) for Thermal Energy
Storage at Low and High Temperatures
Abstract. High performance Phase Change Materials (PCMs) play a vital role
in Thermal Energy Storage (TES) technologies. A cost-effective and easy-
controllable fabrication process by mix-sintering method is an effective
approach to produce composite PCMs at a large scale. In this work, a series of
form stable composite PCMs with different phase change temperatures were
prepared by mix-sintering method. These composite PCMs could be applied in a
cascading manner in thermal storage system. DSC measurements and analyses
show that the cascading system has an energy storage density of 1068.96 J/g
within a working temperature range from 50 °C to 550 °C. Besides, an SEM
study shows homogenous microstructure of the prepared composite PCMs.
1 Introduction
Renewables have been intensively studied in recent years as they play a vital role in a
less carbon-intensive and more sustainable energy system [1]. However, the intermit-
tency nature of renewable has become the main bottleneck for obtaining continuous
and stabilized energy. Therefore, thermal energy storage (TES) technology which
could store and release thermal energy according to requirements could be regarded as
an effective method to address the intermittency issue of the renewable [2]. High
performance TES material is the key challenge for TES technology. Phase change
material (PCM) which presents a relatively high energy density and an easy-
controllable heat charging and discharging property has attracted growing attention in
decades. Nowadays, PCM has been applied in heat recovery, solar power generation
system, electricity peak load shifting [3], intensive cascading energy storage system
[4], etc. Encapsulation of phase change materials (PCMs) is an effective way of pre-
venting leakage during phase change process and solving possible chemical incom-
patibility with the surroundings. Different encapsulation methods have been studied to
obtain a structural stabilized composite PCM, for instance, physical, physic-chemical,
and chemical methods. When the fabrication method is verified in lab scale and needs
to be scaled up for pilot or industrial application, the costs of encapsulation method and
the controllability of the fabricating process are the most important issues need to be
considered.
Mix-sintering method is a mature process which has been used in sintering metallic
and ceramics powders a long time ago. In the late 1980s, it has been firstly used to
prepare form-stable composite PCMs, when Randy and Terry [5–7] used 80 wt%
NaCO3-BaCO3 as phase change material and 20 wt% MgO as supporting material to
prepare a composite PCM. This composite PCM had been thermal cycled 22 times and
showed good stability with only 1% mass loss and 1% decrease in density. In the
1990s, Gluck [8] and Hame [9] compressed Na2SO4 and silica mixtures at 70 MPa and
sintered for 2 h at 1000 °C to fabricate PCM bricks for high temperature heat storage.
Their work showed that heat storage capacity of the ceramic brick compromising 20 wt
% inorganic salts increased by 2.5 times than that of the pure ceramic in the same
volume. In the 21st century, mix-sintering process has been widely used to prepare
form-stable PCMs. Gokon [10] used mix sintering method to fabricate the composite
materials of molten alkali-carbonate/MgO ceramics. They had tested the composite
PCM in a catalyst bed which revealed a good thermal storage property of the composite
PCM. Ye [11] mixed multi-walled carbon nanotubes (MWCNTs) into Na2CO3/MgO
form-stable composite and found that the thermal conductivity of the composite had
increased significantly with increasing addition of MWCNTs. Zhu [12] mix-sintered
porous calcium silicate with quaternary nitrates LiNO3–NaNO3–KNO3–Ca(NO3)2 to
get a mid-low temperature composite PCM. This composite shows high thermal
conductivity and thermal stability than the other organic PCMs.
Although mix-sintering method has been applied in preparing composite PCM a
long time ago, most of the previous work is based on lab scale. A large-scale fabri-
cation process by mix-sintering differs from lab scale preparation. In this work, a large-
scale fabrication process was introduced to prepare composite PCMs with different
working temperature range. These composite PCMs can be used in a cascading manner
in thermal storage system with a relatively high energy storage capacity.
2.1 Materials
KNO3 (98%), MgO (99%), Li2CO3 (99%), Na2CO3 (99%), Graphite powders (99%)
were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich company. The diatomite is a kind of mineral with
natural porous structure, which was bought from JJS Minerals company. Vermiculite is
a porous phyllosilicate mineral purchased from Dupreminerals company. The
Erythritol is a kind of surgar which was purchased from Naturtotal company. Three
different form stable composite PCMs were prepared by the following formulation
shown in Table 1.
216 Z. Jiang et al.
Performance
KNO3/Diatomite cPCM with a heating rate of 5 °C/min and a purge of 100 ml/min N2
gas. Meanwhile, a simultaneous thermal analyzer (STA 449F3 Jupiter®, Netzsch,
Germany) was used to characterize the phase change process of Na2CO3-K2CO3/
MgO/Graphite cPCM with a heating rate of 10 °C/min and a purge of 50 ml/min N2
gas. A scanning electron microscopy coupled with an energy-dispersive X-ray spec-
troscopy (SEM&EDS, Hitachi TM-3030) was used to study the microscopic mor-
phology and element distribution of the material.
The phase transition temperature and enthalpy for each composite PCM are shown in
Table 2. As can be seen that the composite PCMs have melting points of 119.8 °C,
335.3 °C, and 500.2 °C respectively, which can be used in a cascading manner in
intensive energy storage system [4] within temperature range from 50 °C to 550 °C.
Therefore, the thermal storage energy density of each composite PCM can be
calculated. The energy density of composite PCM should consider both sensible heat
and latent heat. From T0 to T1 , the energy density can be calculated as the following:
TZm TZ 1
Q¼ Cp;s dT þ DH þ Cp;l dT
T0 Tm
where Q is the total thermal energy stored in a unit mass of the composite PCM,
Cp;s , Cp;l are heat capacities of composite PCM in solid state and liquid state respec-
tively. T0 , T1 and Tm denote the lower bound temperature, upper bound temperature and
the melting temperature of the PCM, respectively. DH represents the latent heat of PCM.
The heat capacity and the calculated energy density of each cPCM at a certain
application temperature range are shown in Table 3. Therefore, integrating the prepared
composite PCMs in a cascading manner in thermal storage system, a total energy
storage density of the system can reach 1068.96 J/g from 50 °C to 550 °C.
3.3 SEM
The microstructure of the fabricated composite PCMs has been studied by SEM.
Besides, EDS mapping shows the elements distribution of the composite PCM has
been investigated and displayed in Fig. 5. One can see that each composite PCM
presents a different microstructure. The Erythritol/Vermiculite/GraphitecPCM has a flat
structure and some localized macro-pores. From the EDS mapping, particles of graphite
and vermiculite are distributed uniformly. In terms of the KNO3/Diatomite cPCM,
220 Z. Jiang et al.
4 Conclusions
A series of composite PCMs have low and high melting temperature was manufactured
by a large-scale preparation method in this work, which is aiming for cascading thermal
energy storage. These composite PCM normally contains a phase change material and a
skeleton material. Graphite could also be used as an additive to enhance the overall
thermal conductivity of the composite material. The composite PCMs prepared by mix-
sintering method are characterized preliminarily in this work and could be summarized
as follow:
• Mix-sintering method is a fabrication method which can be applied both in lab scale
and pilot scale. Composite PCMs prepared by this method in lab or pilot scale both
display a great shape stabilization property without any deformation and leakage
after sintering over its melting point.
• The prepared composite PCMs show melting points of 119.8 °C, 335.3 °C, and
500.2 °C respectively, which could be used in a cascading manner in thermal
energy storage system.
• The stored energy density of the cascading thermal storage system can reach as high
as 1068.96 J/g within a temperature range from 50 °C to 550 °C.
• The microstructure of each composite PCM has been studied by SEM and EDS,
which shows a homogeneous distribution of all the components.
A Large-Scale Manufacturing Method 221
Acknowledgments. The authors gratefully acknowledge the financial supports from SGRI of
China State Grid under Project: Establishment of research capability in thermal energy storage
SGRI-DL-71-16-017.
References
1. Hasan, R., Mekhilef, S., Seyedmahmoudian, M., Horan, B.: Grid-connected isolated PV
microinverters: a review. Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev. 67, 1065–1080 (2017)
2. Li, Y., Jin, Y., Huang, Y., Ye, F., Wang, X., Li, D., et al.: Principles and new development
of thermal storage technology. Energy Storage Sci. Technol. 2, 69–72 (2013)
3. Farid, M.M., Khudhair, A.M., Razack, S.A.K., Al-Hallaj, S.: A review on phase change
energy storage: materials and applications. Energy Convers. Manag. 45, 1597–1615 (2004)
4. Michels, H., Pitz-Paal, R.: Cascaded latent heat storage for parabolic trough solar power
plants. Sol. Energy 81, 829–837 (2007)
5. Claar, T.D., Ong, E.T., Petri, R.J.: Composite salt/ceramic media for thermal energy storage
applications. In: Proceedings of the Intersociety. Energy Conversion Engineering. Confer-
ence (United States), vol. 4, pp. 2043–2048 (1982)
6. Petri, R.J., Claar, T.D., Ong, E.T.: High-temperature salt/ceramic thermal storage phase-
change media. In: Proceedings of the Intersociety. Energy Conversion Engineering.
Conference (United States) (1983)
7. Petri, R.J., Ong, E.T., Marianowski, L.G.: High-temperature composite thermal energy
storage for industrial applications (1985). https://www.osti.gov/scitech/biblio/6071974
8. Glück, A., Tamme, R., Kalfa, H., Streuber, C., Weichert, T.: Development and testing of
advanced TES materials for solar central receiver plants (1991)
9. Hame, E., Taut, U., Grob, Y.: Salt ceramic thermal energy storage for solar thermal central
receiver plants. In: Proceedings of the Solar World Congress (1991)
10. Gokon, N., Nakano, D., Inuta, S., Kodama, T.: High-temperature carbonate/MgO composite
materials as thermal storage media for double-walled solar reformer tubes. Sol. Energy 82,
1145–1153 (2008)
11. Ye, F., Ge, Z.: Multi-walled carbon nanotubes added to Na2CO3/MgO composites for
thermal energy storage. Particuology 15, 56–60 (2014)
12. Jiang, Z., et al.: Form-stable LiNO3–NaNO3–KNO3–Ca(NO3)2/calcium silicate composite
phase change material (PCM) for mid-low temperature thermal energy storage. Energy
Convers. Manag. 106, 165–172 (2015)
13. Jurado-Lasso, F., Jurado-Lasso, N., Ortiz, J., Jurado, J.F.: Thermal dielectric and Raman
studies on the KNO3 compound high-temperature region. DYNA 83, 244 (2016)
Power System Analysis
Research on Smart Grid Comprehensive
Development Level Based on the Improved
Cloud Matter Element Analysis Method
1 Introduction
The shortage of traditional energy and the problem of environmental pollution are the
greatest challenges faced by the continuous development of human society. In order to
solve the energy crisis and environmental issues, various low-carbon technologies are
rapidly developing and will be applied on a large scale [1–3].
To achieve communication and cooperation, learn the advantages of smart grids in
different countries, it is essential to conduct a comprehensive assessment of the current
state of smart grid development in various countries. For example, the EU Joint
Research Center and the U.S. Department of Energy cooperated in 2012 to conduct a
comparative study of the European and American smart grids [4].
For comparative study, this article uses the cloud element analysis which can reflect
the randomness and fuzziness to establish evaluation model [5], because the real-time
of the data in the index system cannot be fully guaranteed. The advantage of this
method is that, based on the trend of the development of the index data, it can minimize
time disunity problem of the data by giving index data of a certain interval. However,
there are only two ways to divide the grade interval in traditional cloud element
analysis: artificial division or national standard. In view of the fact that the indicators of
the smart grid have no national standard level for reference, in order to avoid the
subjective impact of artificial division, this paper proposes an objective cloud matter
element method based on cluster analysis. It can divide the grade interval objectively
which theoretically reduce the subjective influence to improve the objectivity and
accuracy; At the same time, the weight is determined by combining subjective method
and objective method to avoid subjective influence.
The cloud model has three important parameters: Expectation, represents the center of
cloud distribution; Entropy, represents the fuzziness of the concept value, the greater
the entropy, the greater the randomness and fuzziness; Hyper-entropy, represents the
dispersion degree of the reaction cloud droplets.
The object element is usually denoted as R ¼ ðN; c; vÞ, which N represents things, c
represents the characteristics of things, and v represents the magnitude of the
characteristics.
As usual, the cloud model is substituted into the matter-element theory [6], and v is
replaced with ðEx ; En ; He Þ. In this paper, the steps of the calculation of correlation
degree are as follows:
(1) Consider the eigenvalues of the cloud model ðEx ; En ; He Þ as a hierarchical
boundary cloud model;
0
(2) Randomly generate a normal random number Ex with the expectation En and the
standard deviation He ;
(3) Consider the sample value of this indicator x as a cloud drop, and calculate the
association of the index value with the hierarchical boundary cloud model [7]:
ðx Ex Þ2
y ¼ exp ð1Þ
2ðEn0 Þ2
Research on Smart Grid Comprehensive Development Level 227
ai1 þ ai
cminðiÞ ¼ ð1\i nÞ ð2Þ
2
ai þ ai þ 1
cmaxðiÞ ¼ ð1\i nÞ ð3Þ
2
The upper limit of the highest level and the lower limit of the lowest level are
determined by the nature of the index. If the index has obvious upper and lower limit
values, then the scale interval does not exceed [1,100]. If the index is purely a quan-
titative indicator and there are no clear upper and lower limits, the formula is:
Among them, cminð1Þ represents the lower limit of the lowest level; cmaxð1Þ repre-
sents the upper limit of the lowest level; cminðmaxÞ represents the lower limit of the
highest level; cmaxðmaxÞ represents the upper limit of the highest level.
228 C. Song et al.
The interval median point represents the expectation of the entire interval Ex , and
the entropy value En is calculated according to the principle of “3En ”, and the hyper-
entropy value is determined by considering the randomness and fuzziness of the
boundary of the constraint:
cmin þ cmax
Ex ¼ ð6Þ
2
cmax cmin
En ¼ ð7Þ
6
He ¼ s ð8Þ
After the expectations, entropy, and hyper-entropy values are determined, they are
considered as a hierarchical boundary cloud model, and then the relevance of the
sample data points to each level of hierarchical boundary cloud model is calculated.
4.2 Hierarchical Boundary Cloud Model of Each Index for the Smart
Grid Comprehensive Development Level
By the literature review, sample data from 16 major countries were collected [11, 12].
According to Eqs. (2)–(5), the level limits are obtained.
According to the Eqs. (6)–(8), this paper calculates the expectation, the entropy to
obtain the hierarchical limit cloud model, as shown in Table 2.
Table 1. The index system of the smart grid comprehensive development level
First-level index Second-level index No.
Energy Use Scale Thermal power installed capacity 1
Hydropower Installed capacity 2
Nuclear Power Installed Capacity 3
Wind power installed capacity 4
Photovoltaic power installed capacity 5
Pumped storage installed capacity 6
Smart Facility Scale UHV AC/DC Transmission Scale (km) 7
Flexible HVDC transmission scale (km) 8
Intelligent distribution network capacity ratio 9
Terminal plug-and-play charging station scale 10
Smart meter application scale (million) 11
Strong and Self-healing Strong grid structure 12
Economic and Efficiency Line loss intelligent optimization capability 13
User power usage 14
Wind Power Access Capability 15
Photovoltaic Access Capability 16
Integration and Compatibility User-side demand response capability 17
Environmentally Friendly Greenhouse gas emission intensity 18
Electrical energy substitution ratio 19
Policies and Regulations Cooperation and mechanism 20
Smart Grid Planning and Support Policy 21
Related special policies and incentives 22
xsi
ai ¼ ; 1in ð9Þ
xoi þ xsi
xoi
bi ¼ ; 1in ð10Þ
xoi þ xsi
ai xsi þ bi xoi
xi ¼ P
n ; 1in ð11Þ
ðai xsi þ bi xoi Þ
i¼1
Table 2. The hierarchical limit cloud model of smart grid comprehensive development level
The hierarchical boundary cloud model ðEx ; En Þ
Excellent Good Medium Qualified Failed
1 (0.15,0.05) (0.41,0.03) (0.572,0.022) (0.71,0.03) (0.89,0.04)
2 (0.81,0.06) (0.55,0.03) (0.371,0.032) (0.20,0.02) (0.07,0.02)
3 (0.67,0.10) (0.27,0.03) (0.151,0.011) (0.328,0.07) (0.27,0.09)
4 (0.58,0.13) (0.14,0.01) (0.086,0.007) (0.05,0.01) (0.02,0.01)
5 (0.58,0.13) (0.14,0.01) (0.077,0.01) (0.03,0.02) (0.01,0.003)
6 (0.53,0.15) (0.07,0.004) (0.041,0.004) (0.02,0.003) (0.01,0.002)
7 (23325,3539) (7321,1795.98) (1508,141.53) (642,147.15) (100.3,33.4)
8 (1227,85) (694.5,92) (311.43,35.69) (143.5,20.3) (41.3,13.77)
9 (0.92,0.02) (0.73,0.041) (0.047,0.047) (0.22,0.04) (0.051,0.02)
10 (18000,1667) (10106,964.58) (4404.2,936.1) (1567.4,9.5) (769.45,256)
11 (18500,2500) (7138.85,1287) (2519.55,253) (1215,181) (334.9,111)
12 (15.17,5.05) (55.80,8.49) (120.875,13) (498.5,112) (1460,207)
13 (0.03,0.01) (0.07,0.01) (0.105,0.007) (0.15,0.008) (0.59,0.14)
14 (12975,466) (10095.9,492.7) (7162,4862) (4365,446) (1514,504.7)
15 (0.95,0.02) (0.86,0.013) (0.782,0.013) (0.55,1.17) (0.18,0.06)
16 (0.92,0.03) (0.80,0.01) (0.72,0.017) (0.49,0.06) (0.15,0.05)
17 (0.52,0.16) (0.03,0.003) (0.022,0.0002) (0.02,0.001) (0.01,0.002)
18 (1.6,0.53) (6.1,0.97) (11.728,0.923) (15.42,0.32) (17.46,0.36)
19 (0.28,0.01) (0.24,0.01) (0.214,0.005) (0.18,0.01) (0.08,0.03)
20 (95.83,1.39) (89.5,0.72) (85.08,0.75) (80.62,0.74) (39.2,13.07)
21 (95.83,1.39) (89.5,0.72) (85.08,0.75) (80.62,0.74) (39.2,13.07)
22 (95.25,1.58) (85.33,1.72) (74.42,1.92) (63.08,1.86) (28.75,9.58)
Note: In this paper, He ¼ 0:002
the composite weights [14]. At the end of the rating process, the level with the highest
degree of association is the final level of assessment [5]:
Among them, Bj ðqÞ represents the q level of the sample j, and Kj represents the
evaluation level of the sample j.
When calculating the associated of cloud droplets with the hierarchical cloud
model, we need to generate a normal random number, so the calculation process has a
large randomness, and its conclusion is always uncertain. In order to avoid the ran-
domness, this article needs to perform multiple calculations.
Because the standard deviation is a measure of the result dispersion, this paper uses
the standard deviation to judge the reliability of the assessment results. After multiple
calculations, the expected and the standard deviation of the final evaluation result can
be calculated [4]:
Research on Smart Grid Comprehensive Development Level 231
k1 þ k2 þ . . . þ kh
Ek ¼ ð13Þ
h
vffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi
u h
u1 X
r¼t ½ ki E k 2 ð14Þ
h i¼1
Among them, h indicates the number of operations, in this article h ¼ 20000. The
smaller the standard deviation, the smaller the dispersion of assessment results and the
more reliable the assessment results.
This paper assesses the level of the smart grid comprehensive development in 16 major
economies. Sample data for 16 countries are shown in Schedule 1 in Appendix.
Through the ANP method, the subjective weights of various indicators are
obtained. Based on the sample data of each country, the objective weights are obtained
using principal component analysis. The final comprehensive weights are calculated
according to Eqs. (9)–(11). The results are shown in Table 3.
After calculating the weights, firstly a normal random number table of 22 5 is
generated. Because there are data from 16 countries, the original sample data to be
evaluated is a matrix of 16 22. According to Eq. (1), the correlation between each
country’s index and each level of the index in the above-mentioned normal random
number table is calculated. Therefore, a three-dimensional matrix of 16 22 5 is
formed to store the relevance. Secondly, weighting the association degree table and
weights to obtain a comprehensive evaluation matrix and calculate to obtain the
assessment level of each country according to Formula (12). Finally, the calculation
process is repeated 20,000 times, and the standard deviation is calculated at the same
time. The assessment result is shown in Table 4:
Based on the above, it can be clearly concluded:
The United States, China, Japan, and Germany are countries with excellent levels.
Italy, South Korea, the United Kingdom, Canada, and France are countries with a good
level. Brazil, India and Australia are countries with a comprehensive level. Argentina
and South Africa are countries with a qualified level, while Russia and Egypt are
countries with unsatisfactory level.
Although China is in second place, but from the data point of view, we can see that
China currently has a lot of work in terms of the intelligence of power transmission and
distribution, and the gap with Europe and the United States is relatively small. China
vigorously develops renewable energy, and the gap with Europe is decreasing. But
compared with Europe and the United States, the theoretical research on improving the
flexibility of power grids is not enough and is limited by various factors, and the
demand response is weak. Therefore, China needs to establish relevant policies and
invest heavily in these areas in order to shorten the gap as soon as possible.
232
C. Song et al.
Table 4. The evaluation result of the smart grid comprehensive development level
Country Level Level a 10−3
Excellent Good Medium Qualified Failed
USA 20000 0 0 0 0 Excellent 0.01
China 20000 0 0 0 0 Excellent 0.06
Japan 20000 0 0 0 0 Excellent 0.20
Germany 20000 0 0 0 0 Excellent 0.49
Italy 0 20000 0 0 0 Good 0.06
Korea 0 20000 0 0 0 Good 0.13
Britain 0 20000 0 0 0 Good 0.19
Canada 0 20000 0 0 0 Good 0.31
France 526 15304 4170 0 0 Good 0.52
Brazil 0 0 20000 0 0 Medium 0.02
India 0 0 20000 0 0 Medium 0.03
Australia 0 0 20000 0 0 Medium 0.76
Argentina 0 0 0 20000 0 Qualified 0.11
South Africa 0 0 0 19843 157 Qualified 0.59
Russia 0 0 607 0 19393 Failed 0.23
Egypt 0 0 0 0 20000 Failed 0.74
6 Conclusion
This paper proposes an objective cloud matter element analysis method based on
cluster analysis. The improved objective cloud matter element method achieves
objectively dividing the hierarchical range of the hierarchical boundary cloud model,
which can significantly improve the objectivity and accuracy of the comprehensive
development level assessment. At the same time, this paper combines the ANP and the
principal component analysis method to determine the weight of the smart grid com-
prehensive development level index, which can make the weight determination more
objective. In order to simplify the analysis of the assessment results, this article cites the
concept of standard deviation to judge the reliability of the assessment results.
Therefore, this paper can not only use the improved objectified cloud matter element
method to evaluate the sample level, but also can use the standard deviation to judge
the sample ranking of the same level. This article uses the smart grid comprehensive
development level assessment case to prove that this method significantly improves the
objectivity and accuracy of the assessment results.
234 C. Song et al.
Appendix
Schedule 1. The raw data of the smart grid system comprehensive development level
No. America China Japan Germany Britain France India Italy
1 68.50% 65.30% 57.10% 42.80% 61.10% 17.00% 68.90% 56.90%
2 8.70% 20.20% 14.30% 5.70% 4.30% 17.70% 14.00% 14.00%
3 8.70% 1.50% 10.50% 6.40% 10.40% 47.00% 2.20% 0.00%
4 5.67% 8.36% 0.93% 18.42% 13.77% 7.08% 8.68% 6.84%
5 1.73% 2.06% 7.61% 17.21% 5.63% 4.39% 0.34% 14.78%
6 2.14% 2.02% 8.80% 10.20% 5.60% 9.00% 2.70% 7.52%
7 300 23325 487.2 0 0 64.5 1800 2.8
8 238 159.7 0 1227 260 60 0 0
9 96.60% 50.00% 100% 96% 90% 90% 21% 71%
10 2.7 19.0599 10.97 2.4667 1.1 1 0.35 0.27
11 6500 18000 8000 162 275 2500 200 3300
12 1.5 15.2 0.3 0.25 1.17 5 63 1.78
13 6.32% 6.64% 4.73% 4.34% 7.64% 7.29% 22.70% 6.38%
14 10408 4078 7701 6815 5156 7125 1100 5050
15 93.70% 83% 85% 87% 88.60% 86.00% 69% 85.60%
16 80.00% 82.00% 78.00% 88.00% 82.00% 85.00% 60.00% 76.00%
17 4.53% 0.45% 1.23% 3.24% 3.10% 2.85% 0.14% 1.68%
18 3.63 16.98 2.64 2.28 1.57 1.3 12.91 1.78
19 21.90% 21.50% 28.00% 19.70% 20.70% 23.70% 14.30% 21.00%
20 95 93 90 94 89 87 88 82
21 97 93 93 95 91 92 85 88
22 92 87 93 89 90 88 75 90
No. Brazil Canada Korea Russia Australia Argentina S.A. Egypt
1 18.90% 23.20% 66.70% 67.80% 74.60% 60.00% 89.90% 88.00%
2 66.50% 57.60% 7.00% 21.90% 11.10% 32.49% 1.50% 8.70%
3 1.40% 10.20% 18.00% 10.20% 0.00% 3.30% 4.10% 0%
4 4.48% 7.28% 0.60% 0.05% 6.25% 0.97% 1.27% 2.16%
5 0.00% 1.29% 2.59% 0.25% 6.38% 3.24% 2.16% 1.25%
6 0% 0.14% 4.93% 0.57% 2.64% 0% 1.07% 0%
7 2092 0 0 1853 0 0 1667 0
8 0 0 0 0 714 0 0 0
9 55% 75% 85% 40% 46% 35% 20% 0%
10 0.55 1.02 2 0.6 1 0.42 0.5 0
11 6350 2500 850 200 150 100 20 5
12 57 48 11.5 18.9 50 108 213 1460
(continued)
Research on Smart Grid Comprehensive Development Level 235
Schedule 1. (continued)
No. Brazil Canada Korea Russia Australia Argentina S.A. Egypt
13 15.73% 9.54% 3.55% 10.94% 5.99% 13.79% 9.53% 10.66%
14 2602 12975 10380 6608 9750 3186 4241 1733
15 88.20% 80% 89.30% 0 86% 78% 72.60% 75%
16 0.00% 74.00% 75.00% 0.00% 70.00% 0.00% 81.00% 0.00%
17 2.90% 2.77% 1% 0 0.32% 0 0 0
18 4.25 3.82 5.52 17.59 4.11 5.61 14.06 15.44
19 18% 20.50% 24.60% 15.20% 21.90% 17.70% 22.40% 21.50%
20 78 84 79 89 76 78 79 74
21 86 89 89 83 84 80 83 78
22 72 76 70 55 75 65 55 55
References
1. Wang, M.J.: Smart grid and smart energy resource grid. Power Syst. Technol. 34, 1–5
(2010). (in Chinese)
2. Xu, X.H.: Smart Grid Introduction. China Electric Power Press, Beijing (2009). (in Chinese)
3. Chen, S.Y., Song, S.F., Li, L.X., et al.: Survey on smart grid technology. Power Syst.
Technol. 33, 1–7 (2009). (in Chinese)
4. Zhang, D.X., Yao, L.Z., Ma, W.Y.: Development strategies of smart grid in China and
abroad. Proc. CSEE. 33, 1–14 (2013). (in Chinese)
5. Xia, F., Fan, L., et al.: A comprehensive evaluation model of power quality based on the
theory of cloud element analysis. Power Syst. Prot. Control 40, 6–10 (2012). (in Chinese)
6. Dai, Z.Y., Zhang, W.L., et al.: The application of cloud matter-element in information
security risk assessment. In: 3rd International Conference on Information Management,
pp. 218–222 (2017)
7. Li, P., et al.: Study on fault diagnosis for power transformer based on cloud matter element
analysis principle and DGA. In: Proceedings of the 9th International Conference on
Properties and Applications of Dielectric Materials, Harbin, pp. 244–248 (2009)
8. Liu, W.: Principle and Application of K-harmonic Mean Clustering Analysis. Shanxi
Medical University (2014). (in Chinese)
9. Wu, Y.H.: Cluster algorithm overview. Comput. Sci. 42, 491–542 (2015). (in Chinese)
10. Wang, Z.H., Li, H., et al.: Smart grid evaluation index system. Power Syst. Technol. 33, 14–
18 (2009). (in Chinese)
11. Liu, Z.Y.: Global Energy Internet. China Electric Power Press, Beijing (2015). (in Chinese)
12. State Grid Energy Research Institute: Global Energy Analysis and Outlook, State Grid
Corporation (2016). (in Chinese)
13. Xu, Q.H.: A Comprehensive Evaluation Study on Intelligent Transmission and Distribution
Network Based on Grey Association and Combination. North China Electric Power
University (2015). (in Chinese)
14. Jiang, H., Zhang, Q.L., Peng, J.C.: Evaluation of wind power quality based on improved
cloud matter model. Power Syst. Technol. 38, 205–210 (2014). (in Chinese)
Distributed Accommodation for Distributed
Generation – From the View of Power System
Blackouts
Abstract. With the rapid increase of the installed capacity and generation
capacity of renewable generation, the topology and structure of modern power
systems get more complicated, which promotes higher requirements for power
system secure and stable operation. However, power system large-scale black-
outs often occur. This paper firstly reviewed 51 major blackouts in history
worldwide. The main causes of blackouts were summarized afterwards. Finally,
distributed accommodation for distributed energy in energy internet was pro-
posed as a key research direction to avoid large-scale blackouts.
1 Introduction
At 15:48 on March 21, 2018, another major blackout occurred in Brazil, causing
northern and northeastern Brazilian power grids disconnected from the main grid.
Hence 2049 cities in 14 states were severely influenced, accounting for 93% of all cities
in the region. Besides, 9 states from southern, southeastern and middle-western Brazil
were affected at certain extent [1]. Among all 26 states and 1 federal district in Brazil,
there were 85% of states or federal district that were affected by the blackout.
19 760 MW in total was shed in the blackout, which takes up to 25% of the total load
of the Brazilian national power grid. The accident caused the northern and northeastern
grid disconnected from the southern, southeastern and middle-western grid, both grids
went collapsed, and the rest of the grids received minor disturbance.
Preliminary investigation revealed that the accident was caused by the 500 kV AC
bus breaker in the Xingu converter station, which was the sending end of the Belo
Monte ±800 kV DC transmission project Phase I. Because the setting values were
preset at factory, during the day the load increased and the line load current exceeded
the preset value, resulting in overload tripping, and thus made the Xingu converter
station to lose the only 500 kV AC bus power supply while in its trial operating stage,
which triggered bipolar locking. At the same time, since the stability control device in
the trial operating stage did not take the situation that single bus loses its voltage into
account, instead of issuing shutdown command, it judged the signal of the removal of 6
units as an error signal, resulting in the continuance operation of 7 units of the Belo
Monte Hydropower Station. Eventually all units were shut down by its own protection,
and the failure was exacerbated. It is initially judged that the inappropriate structure of
the Brazilian power grid and the inconsistency in the protecting controlling device are
the main causes for this major blackout. Detailed reasons are still under investigation.
Throughout history of power blackouts, the inappropriate grid structure and its
operating method as well as protection control system malfunctioning which leads to
large-scale power flow transfer have always been the main factors that causing a
blackout. The paper firstly reviews major blackouts in global history and describes the
main processes of them. Secondly, main reasons of the blackouts are analyzed and
corresponding countermeasures are put forward. Finally, combined with current hot-
spots of power grid development and research, distributed accommodation for dis-
tributed energy in energy internet was proposed as one of the research directions.
There have been 51 relatively serious blackouts that took place in history, and 20 of
them occurred between 1965 to 2009. The date, location and the cause of the accidents
are shown in Table 1. On the other hand, there have been 22 major blackouts in foreign
countries since 2010, as shown in Table 2. It can be concluded that the frequency of
blackouts is much higher than before. Table 3 lists blackouts happened in China.
Global blackouts have been concentrated in two periods. The first period was from
2003 to 2006, when the electricity market is gradually developing, power trading,
equipment overhaul and several other factors have aggravated the burden of the power
flow of the grid. At this time, relay protection or automatic safety device malfunction or
operating due to overload may trigger large-scale power flow transfer, resulting in
further overloading of lines and transformers that are already overloaded, eventually
leading to chain accidents and major blackouts.
The second period was from 2010 to the present. Although the blackout caused by
chain actions from protection control device malfunctioning has also occurred several
times, more initial failures were caused by natural disasters such as thunderstorms,
strong winds, earthquakes, tsunamis, freezing rain and snow, etc. With the continuous
increase in the level of grid informatization and access to renewable energy, new types
of failure began to emerge. As of Ukrainian power grids suffered blackouts caused by
“BlackEnergy” malware attack on December 23, 2015. This was the first large-scale
blackout accident caused by human deliberately using malicious software or computer
viruses to attack the protection control device of a power grid. On September 28, 2016,
extreme weather such as typhoons and heavy rains hit southern Australia, where owns
very high penetration of renewable energy installation. Weathers triggered a mass
disconnection of renewable energy, and this was the first case of blackout caused by
massive off-grid of renewable energy.
238 B. Liu et al.
Table 1. (continued)
Date Country/Region Blackout cause
complete stop of the substation, which caused another
220 kV substation to stop completely. Power flow
transfer caused multiple lines tripping and multiple
power plants shutdown
Aug. 14, Tokyo, Japan [14] The crane boom of a construction company crane ship
2006 collided with six 275 kV transmission lines across a
river during operation
Sept. 24, Pakistan [14] Transmission system failure led to the blackout
2006
Nov. 4, Western Europe Two heavy-duty high-voltage transmission lines tripping
2006 [15] caused cascading tripping of multiple lines, resulted in
disconnection from grids
Apr. 26, Colombia [16] General power plant technical failure led to the blackout
2007
Nov. 10, Brazil [17] Strong cold air caused hurricanes, heavy rainfall, and
2009 intensive lightning, resulted in short-circuits in three
different phases of different lines. The Itaipu
Hydropower station was shut down, and the system
oscillated and caused a large-scale tripping of the load
center. The high-frequency protection system in the
nuclear power plant malfunctioned further deteriorates
the fault, caused load side low frequency and low
voltage load shedding and power supply side high
frequency shutdown
Table 2. (continued)
Date Country/Region Blackout cause
July 23, Barcelona, A substation cable failed, resulting in cascading failure in
2011 Spain [16] other 6 substations
Sept. 8, San Diego, Manual malfunction resulted in a 500 kV line tripped, and
2011 USA the low-frequency load shedding device mis-tripped,
USA-Mexico leading to the shutdown of the power plant units
Border
[16, 19, 20]
Sept. 15, South Korea Negative deviations in load prediction and lack of backup
2011 [16] generation caused regional blackouts in shift to avoid
nationwide overall blackout
Sept. 24, Central Chile The transmission line vibrated and caused line pressed.
2011 [16] A substation failure occurred at the same time
Oct. 31, Northeastern Due to sudden blizzard, multiple lines tripped
2011 USA [16]
July 30, India [21, 22] A 220 kV line fault caused the power flow transfer. Then
2012 the 400 kV line III sections protection device
malfunctioned, and the system oscillated and disconnected
July 31, India [21, 22] After the generator tripped and power flow transferred, a
2012 220 kV line overload tripping aggravated the flow transfer,
and the 400 kV line III protection device malfunctioned
May 22, Southern A 500 kV line permanently grounded short-circuited caused
2013 Vietnam [23] cascading failure of multiple lines and generators
Nov. 1, Bangladesh DC blocking resulted in low-frequency load shedding
2014 [24]
Aug. 31, Tunisia [25] Critical line short-circuited and tripped
2014
Mar. 27, Holland [26] Substation technical failure caused blackouts
2015
Mar. 31, Turkey [27, 28] A heavy-duty 400 kV line tripping caused a long-distance
2015 parallel line to trip successively and caused disconnection
from the grid
Dec. 23, Ukraine [29, Computer virus attack caused blackout (first time in history)
2015 30]
Sept. 28, Southern Extreme weather such as typhoon and rainstorm caused
2016 Australia [31] large-scale renewable energy sources disconnection (first
time in history)
Mar. 21, Brazil [1] Voltage lost in AC bus bar in the converter station. The
2018 Belo Monte Hydropower station mis-tripped. DC line
bipolar locked
Distributed Accommodation for Distributed Generation 241
The power grid should actively use meteorological big data and weather forecast
information to combine weather forecasting with load prediction and power generation
planning. At the same time, in response to extreme weather conditions, the system
operator should further improve early warning and preventive measures, and improve
the stability control strategy, and ensure that the power grid has sufficient available
spare capacity are effective methods to improve present countermeasures against
blackouts.
From the above discussions, several countermeasures to avoid power system blackouts
are introduced. This section discusses distributed accommodation for distributed gen-
eration in energy internet to avoid large-scale blackouts.
Distributed accommodation for distributed generation means to enhance the con-
trollability and regulation potentiality of controllable load or flexible load from the load
side, to achieve the “source-grid-load-storage” collaborative optimization control and
to accommodate renewable energy. This makes local consumption for local production,
which reduces the power flow in high-voltage transmission grids and promotes the
transmission capacity to accept power flow transfer during faults.
244 B. Liu et al.
5 Conclusion
1. Blackouts may happen again. Judging from the causes and results of the 51 major
blackouts in global history, we have not fully grasped the possibility of blackouts.
The major causes of blackouts are natural factors, equipment failures, manual
malfunctions, and strategic failures.
2. Combining the history of power grids and accidents and the current development of
power grids, the strategies and measures to prevent blackouts can be discussed from
distributed accommodation for distributed generation in energy internet.
Acknowledgement. This paper was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (61703081), and Natural Science Foundation of Liaoning Province (20170520113).
Distributed Accommodation for Distributed Generation 245
References
1. Brazil “Mar. 21” Blackout Report. http://www.sohu.com/a/226390340_793972
2. Friedlander, G.D.: The great blackout of ‘65. IEEE Spectr. 13, 83–88 (1976)
3. Loehr, G.C.: The “Good” blackout: the northeast power failure of 9 November 1965. IEEE
Power Energ. Mag. 15, 84–96 (2017)
4. Sugarman, R.: Power/energy: New York City’s blackout: A $350 million drain: ripple effects
off the July 13, 1977, lightning stroke cost the public dearly in lost property, services, end
income. IEEE Spectr. 15, 44–46 (1978)
5. Kearsley, R.: Restoration in Sweden and experience gained from the blackout of 1983. IEEE
Power Eng. Rev. PER-7, 48 (1987)
6. Guillon, S., Toner, P., Gibson, L., et al.: A colorful blackout: the Havoc caused by auroral
electrojet generated magnetic field variations in 1989. IEEE Power Energ. Mag. 14, 59–71
(2016)
7. Hain, Y., Schweitzer, I.: Analysis of the power blackout of June 8, 1995 in the Israel electric
corporation. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 12, 1752–1758 (1997)
8. Lei, X.: Analysis of the two systemwide disturbances in WSCC system in North American in
1996. Electr. Power Issue 12, 62–67 (1996)
9. El-Werfelli, M., Dunn, R., Redfern, M., et al.: Analysis of the national 8th November 2003
Libyan blackout. In: 2008 43rd International Universities Power Engineering Conference,
pp. 1–5. IEEE Press, New York (2008)
10. Gan, D., Hu, J., Han, Z.: A pondering over several major blackouts in 2003. Autom. Electr.
Power Syst. 28, 1–4,9 (2004)
11. Xue, Y.: The way from a simple contingency to system-wide disaster: lessons from the
eastern interconnection blackout in 2003. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 27, 1–5,37 (2003)
12. Vournas, C.D., Nikolaidis, V.C., Tassoulis, A.: Experience from the athens blackout of July
12, 2004. In: 2005 IEEE Russia Power Tech, pp. 1–7. IEEE Press, New York (2005)
13. Lu, S., Gao, L., Wang, K., et al.: Analysis and inspiration on blackout of Moscow. Relay 34,
27–31,67 (2006)
14. Ren, Y.: Analysis on the major blackouts in foreign countries in 2006. Guangxi Electr.
Power. Issue 2, 11–12 (2007)
15. Li, C., Sun, Y., Chen, X., et al.: Preliminary analysis of large scale blackout in Western
Europe power grid on November 4 and measures to prevent large scale blackouts in China.
Power Syst. Technol. 30, 16–21 (2006)
16. Lin, W., Sun, H., Tang, Y., et al.: Analysis and lessons of the blackout in Brazil power grid
on November 10, 2009. Automat. Electr. Power Syst. 34, 1–5 (2010)
17. Jian, W., Yifeng, D., Fangfang, S.: The enlightenment of foreign large scale blackouts in
2011 to power grid in China. Mod. Electr. Power 29, 1–5 (2012)
18. Lin, W., Tang, Y., Sun, H., et al.: Blackout in Brazil power grid on February 4, 2011 and
inspirations for stable operation of power grid. Autom. Electric. Power Syst. 35, 1–5 (2011)
19. Fang, Y.: Lessons from September 8, 2011 Southwest America blackout for prevention and
control of cascading outages. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 36, 1–7 (2012)
20. Portante, E.C., Folga, S.F., Kavicky, J.A., et al.: Simulation of the September 8, 2011, San
Diego blackout. In: 2014 Winter Simulation Conference (WSC), pp. 1527–1538. IEEE
Press, New York (2014)
21. Liang, Z., Ge, R., Dong, Y., et al.: Analysis of large-scale blackout occurred on July 30 and
July 31, 2012 in India and its lessons to China’s power grid dispatch and operation. Power
Syst. Technol. 37, 1831–1848 (2013)
246 B. Liu et al.
22. Tang, Y., Bu, G., Yi, J.: Analysis and lessons of the blackout in Indian power grid on July 30
and 31, 2012. Proc. CSEE 32, 167–174 (2012)
23. Huy, N.-D., Huy, C.-D., Chien, N.-D., et al.: Simulation of a power grid blackout event in
Vietnam. In: 2015 IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting, pp. 1–5. IEEE Press,
New York (2015)
24. Kabir, M.A., Sajeeb, M.M.H., Islam, M.N., et al.: Frequency transient analysis of
countrywide blackout of Bangladesh power system on 1st November, 2014. In: 2015
International Conference on Advances in Electrical Engineering (ICAEE), pp. 267–270.
IEEE Press, New York (2015)
25. Hasni, A., Khadraoui, H., Bacha, F.: Dynamic stability assessment of a medium size power
system towards large disturbances case study of the blackout of August 2014 of the Tunisian
power system. In: 2017 International Conference on Advanced Systems and Electric
Technologies (IC_ASET), pp. 279–284. IEEE Press, New York (2017)
26. Xiang, M., Zuo, J., Xie, X., et al.: Analysis of Holland blackout on March 27th, 2015 and
revelations to security for Hunan grid. Hunan Electr. Power 36, 31–35 (2016)
27. Shao, Y., Tang, Y., Yi, J., et al.: Analysis and lessons of blackout in Turkey power grid on
March 31, 2015. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 40, 9–14 (2016)
28. Li, B., Li, J., Li, H., et al.: Analysis of Turkish blackout on March 31, 2015 and lessons on
China power grid. Proc. CSEE 36, 5788–5795 (2016)
29. Guo, Q., Xin, S., Wang, J., et al.: Comprehensive security assessment for a cyber energy
system: a lesson form Ukraine’s blackout. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 40, 145–147 (2016)
30. Liang, G., Weller, S.R., Zhao, J., et al.: The 2015 Ukraine blackout: implications for false
data injection attacks. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 32, 3317–3318 (2017)
31. Zeng, H., Sun, F., Li, T., et al.: Analysis of “9. 28” blackout in South Australia and its
enlightenment to China. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 41, 1–6 (2017)
32. Blackout over Taiwan: the most serious one after 1999. http://taiwan.huanqiu.com/roll/2017-
08/11131306.html
33. Tang, S., Zhang, M., Li, J., et al.: Review of blackout in Hainan on September 26th: causes
and recommendations. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 30, 1–7 (2006)
34. Zhou, Y., Chen, Z.: A pondering on the accident of central China (Henan province) grid in
July 1st. Hunan Electr. Power 28, 28–30,47 (2008)
35. Wang, Z.: The treatment process and analysis of liaoning power grid November 7th
blackout. In: 2016 China International Conference on Electricity Distribution (CICED),
pp. 1–5. IEEE Press, New York (2016)
36. Chen, Q., Yin, X., You, H., et al: Review on blackout process in China Southern area main
power grid in 2008 snow disaster. In: 2009 IEEE Power & Energy Society General Meeting,
pp. 1–8. IEEE Press, New York (2009)
37. Pan, L., Zhang, W., Tang, J., et al.: Overview of the extraordinarily serious ice calamity to
hunan power grid in 2008. Power Syst. Technol. 32, 20–25 (2008)
38. Wu, H.: Study on Risk Analysis and Emergency Mechanism of Large Area Blackout in
Taizhou Power Grid. North China Electric Power University, Beijing (2017)
39. Taiwan blackout triggered political storm. http://www.zaobao.com/realtime/china/
story20170816-787664
40. Cui, M., Ke, D., Sun, Y., et al.: Wind power ramp event forecasting using a stochastic
scenario generation method. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energ. 6(2), 422–433 (2015)
A New Out-of-Step Splitting Strategy Based
on Compound Information
1 Introduction
The operating modes and failure modes of AC-DC interconnected power grids are
becoming more and more complex and diverse, and the possibility of out-of-step
oscillation between multiple clusters in the system is increasing [1]. The law of
oscillation center migration based on the two-machine model is no longer applicable in
multi-frequency out-step oscillation scenario [2]. Thus the existing out-of-step splitting
device based on the equivalent two-machine model has the risk of misjudgment.
Although the out-of-step splitting device can locate the out-of-step center position
through offline simulation and parameters setting in a fixed operation mode, once the
operation mode is changed, the out-of-step splitting device parameters cannot continue
to be applied, and the adaptability is greatly reduced. Literature [3] analyzed the
influence of different tunings on oscillation center deviation and the problem of
migration of oscillation center caused by the change of dominant instability mode
Literature [4] proposed three basic factors leading to the oscillation center migration:
the dominant oscillation mode changes, the equivalent potential and the system
impedance ratio changes. Literature [5] shows that the three out-of-step solution criteria
based on the Ucosu trajectory has the risk of misjudgment under multi-frequency out-
step oscillation. Literature [6] proposed a out-of-step splitting criteria based on wide-
area information, but this criterion only considers wide-area frequency information, and
And:
p ¼ k1 þ k2 cosððw2 w1 Þt þ ðd2 d1 ÞÞ þ k3 cosððw3 w1 Þt þ ðd3 d1 ÞÞ
ð1Þ
q ¼ k2 sinððw2 w1 Þt þ ðd2 d1 ÞÞ þ k3 sinððw3 w1 Þt þ ðd3 d1 ÞÞ
j qj
Um ¼ pffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffiffi E1 ð3Þ
1 2p þ p2 þ q2
A New Out-of-Step Splitting Strategy Based on Compound Information 249
Based on the wide-area measurement system (WAMS) to provide bus line voltage
amplitude/phase information at both ends of the line and the Ucosu criteria of the line
out-of-step splitting device, this paper proposes a new out-of-step splitting strategy.
The idea is to determine the system out-of-step condition by using the Wide Area
Measurement System (WAMS) to provide bus line voltage amplitude/phase informa-
tion at both ends of the line and the local out-of-step splitting device Ucosu criterion to
determine the line oscillation center voltage amplitude and position. And out the
specific steps are showed as follows.
(1) Substation side: Line out-of-step splitting device uses the Ucosu criterion to find
the line where the out-of-step oscillation center may be located
(2) Dispatching center side: To calculate the oscillation center position
1k cos d
m ¼ 12k cos d þ k 2 [8] by measuring the amplitude ratio and phase angle difference at
each end of each line through WAMS. Check whether the out-of-step oscillation
center is located on the line
(3) The substation side cooperates with the dispatching center side: If the oscillation
center position satisfies 0\m\1 the out-of-step oscillation center falls on the line,
and then WAMS sends a starting signal to the related out-of-step splitting devices
based on the Ucosu criterion on the line. After the devices receive the starting
signal, the out-of-step splitting devices start. The out-of-step splitting devices
perform the splitting action after detecting the setted out-of-step period; if the
position of the oscillation center does not satisfy 0\m\1, the oscillation center
migrates out of the line, and the WAMS sends the blocking signal to the out-of-step
splitting devices on the line, and after receiving the blocking signal, the out-of-step
splitting device is locked. The out-of-step splitting strategy flow is shown in Fig. 2.
The out-of-step splitting device based on the Ucosu criterion has been added a
signal based on the position information of the oscillation center. Only when the
oscillation center falls on the line where the device is located, the device can perform
the splitting action. Therefore, the proposed out-of-step splitting strategy can avoid the
misoperation of the out-of-step splitting device based on the traditional local infor-
mation criterion and accurately determine the out-of-step center position.
4 Simulation
Fig. 3. The voltage phase difference between the two ends of three lines
When T = 37.5 s, 172.5 s, 307.5 s, and 397.5 s, the out-of-step center falls on line
1. When T = 94.3 s and 248.6 s, the out-of-step center migrates to line 3.
The simulation results in the Ucosu and the location of the oscillation center of the
three lines, as shown in Fig. 4.
It can be seen from Fig. 4 that Ucosu measured on line 1 at T = 0–57 s, 138–
206 s, 290 s–350 s passes through at least 4 areas step by step, and it satisfies the zero-
sum condition of Ucosu and 0\m\1, so there are four out-of-step cycles; Line 2 does
not satisfy the condition and out-of-step center does not fall on the line; Line 3 satisfies
the condition at t = 80–110 s, 230–262 s, and there are two out-of-step cycles. The
results obtained by this strategy matches the actual out-of-step center distribution on
each line and splitting action can be correctly made after the out-of-step splitting device
detects the setted out-of-step cycles.
From the above, we can see that because the proposed strategy contains Ucosu
zero-crossing and oscillation center position conditions, the proposed strategy can
reflect oscillation center migration under multi-frequency out-of-step scenario. It can
A New Out-of-Step Splitting Strategy Based on Compound Information 251
Fig. 4. Ucosu and location of oscillation center of the three lines in mode 1
accurately locate out-of-step oscillation center position and out-of-step period, which is
not affected by the migration of oscillation center.
5 Conclusion
In this paper, based on the equivalent three-machine system model, a new strategy
based on compound information for out-of-step splitting strategy is proposed and
simulated. The results show that the out-of-step splitting strategy based on compound
information in multi-frequency out-step oscillation scenario can accurately capture the
out-of-step oscillation center and detect the out-of-step oscillating cycle, which has a
good adaptability to migration of oscillation center under multi-frequency out-step
oscillation scenario.
Acknowledgement. The authors would like to gratefully acknowledge the support of project of
Multi-frequency Out-of-step Oscillation in Yunnan Power Grid.
References
1. Xue, Y.: Space-time cooperative framework for defending blackouts part I: from isolated
defense lines to coordinated defending. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 30(1), 8–16 (2006)
2. Liu, F., et al.: Out-of-step oscillation center change rules and its location under multi-
frequency oscillation. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 38(20), 68–73 (2014)
252 Y. Xiao et al.
3. Liu, F., et al.: Multi-frequency oscillation under the out-of-step oscillation center change law
and positioning. Power Syst. Autom. 38(20), 68–73 (2014)
4. Liu, F., et al.: Basic factors and sensitivity analysis of oscillation center migration. Proc.
CSEE 37(06), 1695–1702 (2017)
5. Xia, C., et al.: Applicability analysis of out-of-step solution criterion under multi-frequency
oscillation. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 40(04), 26–31 (2016)
6. Tang, F., et al.: Research on the oscillation center of interconnected area power grids based on
voltage frequency characteristics. High Volt. Eng. 41(03), 754–761 (2015)
7. Gao, P., et al.: Study on oscillation center. In: Proceedings of the CSU-EPSA (2005)
8. Hou, J., et al.: An oscillation center identification method and application in electro-mechanic
transient simulation. Proc. CSEE 33(25), 61–67 (2013)
Risk Assessment of Voltage Limit Violation Based
on Probabilistic Load Flow in Active Distribution
Network
Abstract. This paper mainly investigates risk assessment of voltage limit viola‐
tion in active distribution network with integration of wind generation (WG),
photovoltaic generation (PVG) and electric vehicles (EVs). Firstly, to avoid addi‐
tional peak load caused by random EV charging, a controlled EV charging and
discharging strategy is designed. Then, for the correlations of spatially near WGs
and PVGs, Nataf transformation and orthogonal transformation (OT) are inte‐
grated to solve the problem, and this provides a path for point estimate method
(PEM) based probabilistic load flow (PLF) to obtain steady-state voltage of active
distribution network. Furthermore, based on the voltage results, a model for
quantifying the risk of voltage limit violation is developed by considering loss of
load caused by voltage limit violation, which is different from the previous risk
indices calculated by possibility and severity of voltage limit violation. Finally,
the proposed model is tested on the modified IEEE 33-bus system. Simulation
results confirm that the effective EV charging/discharging strategies and pene‐
tration increment of WG and PVG help to decrease operation risk of active distri‐
bution network.
1 Introduction
would likely have negative impacts on distribution network and potentially increase
risks [1].
To explore the impacts of WG, PVG, and EVs on the power system security and
quantify the risk, risk assessment has been used widely [2, 3]. For example, based on
risk calculation, voltage security assessment is accomplished by accounting for uncer‐
tainties in power system and consequences associated with voltage collapse and viola‐
tion of limits [4]. For a PV integrated power system [5], risk is quantified by computing
over-limit probabilities and severities. Moreover, the temporal and annual indices of
voltage profile and line flow related attributes are introduced to measure the risks of
installing DGs [6]. Considering the correlations of wind generations and loads, a model
for transmission overload risk assessment is proposed [7], while risk associated with
frequency response inadequacy is assessed simultaneously with steady-state voltage and
overload evaluations [8]. Specially, when the voltage at any bus exceeds the allowable
range, the load located at or near the bus is disconnected in small blocks until the viola‐
tion is cleared [8]. However, the above researches did not consider the impact of voltage
limit violation on loss of load. Therefore, how to develop a model for risk assessment
of voltage limit violation in active distribution network considering loss of load is main
motivation of this paper.
To quantify the risk of voltage limit violation, point estimate method (PEM) based
probabilistic load flow (PLF) is employed to obtain the operational state of active distri‐
bution network owing to the uncertainties of WG, PVG, and EVs. Moreover, spatial
correlations of WGs and PVGs should be considered [12]. But PEM requires that input
random variables are independent. Therefore, the correlations should be properly
handled to solve PLF problems using PEM.
To address these problems, this paper aims at evaluating risk of voltage limit viola‐
tion in active distribution network with the integration of EVs while considering spatial
correlations of WGs and PVGs. The main contributions of this paper include: (1) With
Nataf transformation and orthogonal transformation (OT) integrated to deal with spatial
correlations of WGs and PVGs, the PLF problem is solved by the 2 m + 1 scheme of
PEM. (2) Based on voltage results of PLF calculation, a model for quantitative risk
indices is developed accounting for the possibility of voltage limit violation and the
consequent loss of load.
The rest of the paper is outlined as follows. Section 2 presents the problem formu‐
lation. Section 3 provides PLF analysis. The model for risk assessment of voltage limit
violation is presented in Sect. 4. Simulation results are detailed in Sect. 5, followed by
the conclusions in the Sect. 6.
2 Problem Formulation
Quantitative risk can be defined as the product of the occurrence probability of the
undesired event (i.e. voltage limit violation) and the related consequence (i.e. loss of
load). For example, for voltage V , the risk index R(V) can be expressed as
where P(V) is the probability of voltage limit violation, and Pload (V) is the consequent
loss of load. To calculate the risk index R(V), the stochastic characteristics of V are
obtained by employing PEM based PLF while Nataf and orthogonal transformation (OT)
are integrated to handle correlations of WGs and PVGs. The outline structure of risk
assessment of voltage limit violation is shown in Fig. 1.
3 PLF Analysis
where Tc is duration of EV charging, tos is start-time of the off-peak load period, toe is
end-time of the off-peak load period, r is a random number and ranges from 0 to 1.
Considering start-time and duration of EV charging, the charging power Ptc at t can be
calculated by
256 J. Dong et al.
{
0, ts > t&ts + Tc ≤ t + 24, ts + Tc ≤ t,
Ptc = (3)
Pc , otherwise,
The PLF problem can be formulated by the relations between output random variables
and input random variables, i.e.,
V = G(X) (4)
where V is output variables related to voltages, and X is input variables.
To solve the PLF problem in (4) using PEM, Nataf transformation [13] and OT [14]
are combined to deal with the correlations of input random variables. For the sample
matrix X , it is divided into three parts: the correlated non-normal vectors XW of wind
speed and XS of light intensity, the correlated normal vector XL of load, and the inde‐
pendent vector XEV of EV. The specific procedures of the proposed method are as
follows:
(1) XW and XS are transformed to the correlated standard normal random vector ZW and
ZS with Nataf transformation, respectively. XL is normalized to the standard normal
vector ZL.
(2) ZW , ZS, and ZL are transformed to the independent standard normal random vector
YW , YS, and YL by OT, respectively.
(3) XEV is normalized to the standard normal vector YEV .
(4) Based on Y composed of YW , YS, YL, and YEV , compute the locations and corre‐
sponding weights to construct the 2 m + 1 vectors Y ′.
(5) Y ′ is divided to four parts: wind speed YW′ , light intensity YS′ , load YL′ , and EV YEV
′
.
′ ′ ′ ′ ′
YW , YS, and YL are remapped to the correlated standard normal vectors ZW , ZS, and
ZL′ by employing inverse OT, respectively.
(6) YW′ and YS′ are transformed to XW′ and XS′ by inverse Nataf transformation, respec‐
tively. YL′ is transformed to the correlated normal vector XL′ .
′ ′
(7) ZEV is transformed to XEV in original space.
(8) XW , XS, XL, and XEV are combined as X ′. Based on X ′, the PLF problem in (4) is
′ ′ ′ ′
Based on the voltages obtained by PLF calculation, the probability and consequent loss
of load are determined. Then, the model for risk assessment of voltage limit violation
can be established.
Based on the voltage results, the worst voltage state is employed to quantify the severity
of voltage limit violation, which can be expressed as
( ) | |
⎧ Sev V = | Vmi − Vimax |, V > V
| V | mi imax ,
( ) ⎪ i
| imax |
Sev Vi = ⎨ ( ) | V − Vimin || (6)
⎪ Sev V i = || mi |, V < Vimin ,
⎩ | Vimin | mi
| |
( ) ( )
where Vmi is the most severe deviation value of the limits, Sev V i and Sev V i represent
the severity index of the voltage over limits and below limits, respectively.
When voltage is out of allowable range, load shedding schemes will automatically
trip the load to maintain systemic stability. The load will be totally cut off once the
voltage exceeds the over-voltage protection limit, which is set as 1.2 p.u.. Similarly, the
under-voltage protection limit is set as 0.8 p.u..
( ) ( )
The relationship between loss of load Pload Vi and severity Sev Vi can be described
as Fig. 2.
258 J. Dong et al.
1 1
Remark 1 As shown in Fig. 2(a), when the voltage Vi exceeds the over-voltage protec‐
tion limit, the severity( is )|(1.2 − 1.07)∕1.07| = 12.15%, and the load is totally cut off,
( )
i.e., Pload Vi = Pload Vi = 1. Similarly, as shown in Fig. 2(b), the severity corre‐
sponding to the under-voltage
( ) protection
( ) limit is |(0.8 − 0.93)∕0.93| = 13.98%, and the
loss of load is Pload Vi = Pload V i = 1.
∑
N
( )
RE = R Vi (8)
i=1
5 Simulation Results
The proposed method for risk assessment was tested on the modified IEEE 33-bus
system shown in Fig. 3. The parameters of the system are listed as follows.
(1) EV. It is assumed that there are 150 EVs in the distribution network and one EV
charging station is located at bus 7. The responsiveness of EV users is set as 50%.
Daily charging/discharging power by one EV is shown in Fig. 4.
(2) WG. Three wind farms are connected to buses 15, 25, and 30, respectively. Each
wind farm consists of two doubly fed induction generators with rated power of
Risk Assessment of Voltage Limit Violation Based on Probabilistic Load Flow 259
100 kW. Daily wind speed profile is shown in Fig. 5. The correlation coefficient
matrix of the three wind farms [6] is
5 14
12
Wind speed (m/s)
3
10
Power (kW)
1 8
-1 6
4
-3
2
-5 0
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Hour Hour
⎡ 1 0.88 0.87 ⎤
𝜌 = ⎢ 0.88 1 0.85 ⎥ (9)
⎢ ⎥
⎣ 0.87 0.85 1 ⎦
(3) PVG. Four photovoltaic systems are connected to buses 8, 9, 27, and 28, respec‐
tively. Each system consists of one photovoltaic generator with rated power of 100 kW.
Figure 6 shows daily light intensity profile. The correlation coefficient matrix of four
photovoltaic systems is
260 J. Dong et al.
700 1.1
Light intensity (kW/m )
2
600 1
500 0.9
400
Ratio
0.8
300
0.7
200
100 0.6
0 0.5
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Hour Hour
(4) Load. The ratio of mean to maximum in different periods is defined to describe
daily load. The correlation coefficient of loads between two buses is set as 0.9.
Figure 7 illustrates daily load curve.
0.1
0.08
Risk index
0.06
0.04
0.02
0
33
30
27 24
24
21 20 22
18
15 14 16 18
Bus 12 12
9
6 8 10
3 2 4 6 Hour
0 0
the proposed EV charging and discharging strategy, the risk indices of all buses in
different time periods are shown in Fig. 8.
As shown in Fig. 8, risk of voltage limit violation is relatively severe for the end load
points during the period (11:00–18:00). To verify the effectiveness of the proposed
controlled EV charging and discharging strategy (case 3), its impacts on risk index are
compared with those of disordered charging (case 1) and controlled charging (case 2).
The risk indices of voltage limit violation of the entire system and bus 18 are shown in
Table 1.
Table 1 shows that, compared with case 1, the risk of voltage limit violation decreases
notably especially from 15:00 to 18:00 in cases 2 and 3, because EV charging load is
shifted to 0:00–7:00 to avoid increasing risk of voltage limit violation in peak load
periods. From 11:00 to 14:00, the risk index in case 3 is obviously lower than that in
case 2, because EVs are controlled to discharge to raise voltage level in the active distri‐
bution network. It can be concluded that the proposed EV charging and discharging
strategy is effective to decrease risk of voltage limit violation in active distribution
network.
In active distribution network, the operation condition is also closely related to pene‐
tration level of renewable energy. In this section, risk assessment with different pene‐
tration rates of WG and PVG is accomplished. Figure 9 illustrates the risk index of
voltage limit violation of the entire system with different penetration rates of WG and
PVG.
262 J. Dong et al.
1.2
8%WG+0%PVG
16%WG+0%PVG
16%WG+10%PVG
0.9
16%WG+20%PVG
Risk index
0.6
0.3
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24
Hour
Figure 9 shows that the risk index decreases as the penetration rates of WG and PVG
increase. Specially, with the integration of PVG, the risk of voltage limit violation
declines dramatically from 10:00 to 12:00, because output power of PVG is high during
the period. Moreover, WG has a larger impact on risk indices than PVG especially from
15:00 to 17:00 due to low light intensity and large wind speed. Therefore, the penetration
increment of renewable energy in a certain range is helpful for decreasing operation risk
of distribution network, and WG and PVG forms a mutual complementary relationship
in a way.
6 Conclusions
This paper has proposed a method for assessing the risk of voltage limit violation in
active distribution network with the integration of EVs. Firstly, a controlled EV charging
and discharging model is developed to achieve peak load shifting. Then, with Nataf
transformation and OT combined to deal with spatial correlations of WGs, PVGs, and
loads, the PLF problem is solved by the 2 m + 1 scheme of PEM. Furthermore, based
on the voltage results obtained by PLF calculation, the quantitative risk indices can be
calculated by combining possibility of voltage limit violation and loss of load. The
proposed method has been verified on the modified IEEE 33-bus system. The results
show that the EV charging and discharging strategy can effectively decrease risk of
voltage limit violation in peak load periods. Moreover, WG and PVG are mutually
complementary in time scale, and the increasing penetration rates of WG and PVG
within a certain range contributes to operation risk decrement in active distribution
network.
Acknowledgments. This work was supported in part by the national Science Foundation of China
under Grant No. 61773253, and project of Science and technology Commission of Shanghai
Municipality under Grants No. 15JC1401900, 14JC1402200, and 17511107002.
Risk Assessment of Voltage Limit Violation Based on Probabilistic Load Flow 263
References
1. Procopiou, A., Quiros-Tortos, J., Ochoa, L.: HPC-based probabilistic analysis of LV networks
with EVs: impacts and control. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 8(3), 1479–1487 (2017)
2. Liu, X., Shahidehpour, M., Li, Z., Liu, X., Cao, Y., Li, Z.: Power system risk assessment in
cyber attacks considering the role of protection systems. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 8(2), 572–
580 (2017)
3. Yu, S., Hou, H., Wang, C., Hao, G., Hao, F.: Review on risk assessment of power system.
Procedia Comput. Sci. 109, 1200–1205 (2017)
4. Wan, H., Mccalley, J.D., Vittal, V.: Risk based voltage security assessment. IEEE Trans.
Power Syst. 15(4), 1247–1254 (2015)
5. Prusty, B.R., Jena, D.: An over-limit risk assessment of PV integrated power system using
probabilistic load flow based on multi-time instant uncertainty modeling. Renew. Energy
116, 367–383 (2017)
6. Akbari, M.A., et al.: New metrics for evaluating technical benefits and risks of DGs increasing
penetration. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 8(6), 2890–2902 (2017)
7. Li, X., Zhang, X., Wu, L., Lu, P., Zhang, S.: Transmission line overload risk assessment for
power systems with wind and load-power generation correlation. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid
6(3), 1233–1242 (2015)
8. Negnevitsky, M., Nguyen, D.H., Piekutowski, M.: Risk assessment for power system
planning with high wind power penetration. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 30(3), 1359–1368
(2015)
9. Cao, Y., Zhang, Y., Zhang, H., Shi, X., Terzija, V.: Probabilistic optimal PV capacity planning
for wind farm expansion based on NASA data. IEEE Trans. Sustain. Energy 8(3), 1291–1300
(2017)
10. Liu, Z., Wen, F., Ledwich, G.: Optimal siting and sizing of distributed generators in
distribution systems considering uncertainties. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 26(4), 2541–2551
(2011)
11. Pouladi, J., Sharifian, M.B.B., Soleymani, S.: Determining charging load of PHEVs
considering HVAC system and analyzing its probabilistic impacts on residential distribution
network. Electr. Power Syst. Res. 141, 300–312 (2016)
12. Saunders, C.S.: Point estimate method addressing correlated wind power for probabilistic
optimal power flow. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 29(3), 1045–1054 (2014)
13. Zhou, Y., Li, Y., Liu, W., Yu, D., Li, Z., Liu, J.: The stochastic response surface method for
small-signal stability study of power system with probabilistic uncertainties in correlated
photovoltaic and load. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 32(6), 4551–4559 (2017)
14. Li, X., Chen, H., Lu, P., Du, D.: Space transformation-based interdependency modelling for
probabilistic load flow analysis of power systems. J. Donghua Univ. 33(5), 734–739 (2016)
Power Consumption Strategy
in Smart Residential District with PV Power
Based on Non-cooperative Game
1 Introduction
X
qPV ¼ t þ qF;t
qPV PV
ð2Þ
t2T pV
where qPV PV
t is the portion of PV power that supplies directly to the customers; qF;t is the
portion of PV power that supplies directly to grid; qPV is the total amount of PV power;
266 C. Li et al.
pPV
t is the incentive price that customers pay for PV power; pft is the on-grid price of
PV power; and pst is the subsidy for PV supply financed by government.
In low temperature or solar radiation states, PV generation outputs are small. To
ensure that the customers loads have a high-quality and stable power supply, the
amount of PV power supply directly to the customer should be zero, which indicates
that the load extracts all electricity from the grid, as shown in (3)–(5):
qPV
t ¼0 ð3Þ
X
t þ qF;t \
qPV ð4Þ
PV
qnmust;t
n2N
X X
qnt ¼ qnmust;t þ qncontrol;t ¼ qGRID
t ð5Þ
n2N n2N
where qnmust;t , qncontrol;t and qnt are the electricity of uncontrollable electrical appliances,
controllable electrical appliances, and total demand of customer n at moment t re-
spectively; qGRID
t is the electricity purchased from the grid, and N is the set of cus-
tomers in SRD.
On the contrary, in high temperature or solar radiation states, PV outputs are large.
In these cases, the customers can select either the PV power or the grid to supply the
loads, as shown in (6) and (7):
X
qnt ¼ qPV
t þ qt
GRID
ð6Þ
n2N
X
t þ qF;t
qPV ð7Þ
PV
qnmust;t
n2N
pft \pPV
t \pt
GRID
ð8Þ
where pGRID
t is the price that customers purchase electricity from the grid, known as
retail price. It should be noted that the prices above are all real-time prices.
Power Consumption Strategy in Smart Residential District with PV Power 267
where x0i;t and x0j;t are the original operation state of electrical appliances i and j at time
t respectively; xi;t and xj;t are the optimized operation state of electrical appliance i and
j.
Due to the mismatch between PV output and customers loads in SRD, it is necessary to
develop an incentive PV price in order to consume as much PV as possible, as well as
encouraging customers to transfer their loads.
A non-cooperative game of smart power utilization for customers in SRD with
distributed PV power is expressed as G ¼ Q1 ; . . .; QN ; u1 ; . . .; uN , which the details
are described as follows:
Player. All customers who participate in the scheduling in the SRD, regarded as
n 2 C ¼ f1; 2; . . .; N g.
Strategy. Every customer selects the electricity plan Qn ¼ qnt jt 2 T PV in accor-
dance with their requirements, where qnt represents the electricity demand of the
electrical appliances which is obtained from the corresponding smart power utilization
model in Sect. 3.
Payoff. Pay off function is expressed in (11)–(12).
X
un ðqn ; qn Þ ¼ F ¼ t qt
pPV n
ð11Þ
t2T PV
!
X
pPV
t ¼ck qPV
t þ qPV
F;t qnt ð12Þ
n2N
Power Consumption Strategy in Smart Residential District with PV Power 269
5 Case Studies
The 3 customers of Type A have low power consumption that can be ignored. For
simplicity, only customers of Type B, C, D and E are considered in the following
section.
algorithm based on game theory, the results of PV output and SRD load demands are
shown in Fig. 3(b).
Figure 3(a) shows that customers arrange the operation periods of the electrical
appliances arbitrarily without optimal scheduling. So the degree of matching between
load demand and the PV output is very low. For instance, during the period from 11:00
to 16:00, PV output is much greater than the customer’s load demand, and during other
time period PV output is much lower than the load demand. While in Fig. 3(b), most of
PV output can be consumed by the customers.
PV Incentive Price. The PV incentive price is the same as the grid price for Case I
without optimal scheduling, which indicates that customers do not have additional
benefits. In order to maximize their own interests, they prefer to purchase electricity
from the grid. Thus, all the PV power goes on grid through the inverter.
For case II, an incentive price, which is between the PV on-grid price and the retail
price, is obtained using the non-cooperative game model, and is provided to customers
to stimulate the consumption of PV power. Through the game between customers and
PV power, the Nash Equilibrium is reached. The final PV incentive price is shown in
Fig. 4. When the PV output is high, such as the period from 11:00 to 16:00, PV
incentive price is significantly lower than the retail price, so that the customer will
choose to use PV electricity in order to minimize the electricity payment. Meanwhile,
solar energy has been absorbed perfectly.
Comprehensive Income Analysis. The comprehensive incomes for both cases are
shown in Table 2. The PV income comes from the generation in Case I. There is no PV
incentive price, so all the customers in the SRD absorb electricity from the grid.
In Case II, the PV power supplier can achieve higher benefits after optimization. PV
power is consumed by customers in SRD, meanwhile, customers can also cut down
their electricity payments by consuming PV power at a lower price. Compare with
Case I, the income of PV supply increase 7.8% and the payments of customers for
Type B, C, D and E decrease 9.6%, 13.1%, 12.8% and 14.0% respectively.
Power Consumption Strategy in Smart Residential District with PV Power 271
6 Conclusion
In this paper, the power consumption optimization is conducted from two levels.
Firstly, the PV incentive price, which is closely related to PV output and customer
demand, is established to optimize smart power utilization. Secondly, by seeking the
Nash Equilibrium point, the minimum balance is achieved between the maximum
benefit of PV power and the customer electricity payments. The customer selfishness is
considered when making the electricity plans. In addition, the PV incentive price
guides the customer to optimize the distribution of power consumption, motivating
customers to participate in the PV power consumption.
References
1. Paterakis, N.G., Tascikaraoglu, A., Erdinc, O., et al.: Assessment of demand-response-driven
load pattern elasticity using a combined approach for smart households. J. IEEE Trans. Ind.
Inf. 12(4), 1529–1539 (2006)
2. Shakeri, M., Shayestegan, M., Abunima, H., et al.: An intelligent system architecture in
home energy management systems (HEMS) for efficient demand response in smart grid.
Energy Build. 138(1), 154–164 (2017)
3. Killian, M., Andrew, K.: Residential load modeling of price-based demand response for
network impact studies. IEEE Trans. Smart Grid 7(5), 2285–2294 (2016)
4. Li, H., Zang, C., Peng, Z., et al.: Optimal home energy management integrating random PV
and appliances based on stochastic programming. In: Control and Decision Conference,
Yinchuan, pp. 429–434. IEEE Press (2016)
5. Joo, I.Y., Choi, D.H.: Optimal household appliance scheduling considering consumer’s
electricity bill target. IEEE Trans. Consum. Electr. 63(1), 19–27 (2017)
6. Anvari-Moghaddam, A., Monsef, H., Rahimi-Kian, A.: Optimal smart home energy
management considering energy saving and a comfortable lifestyle. J. IEEE Trans. Smart
Grid 6(1), 324–332 (2017)
7. Abushnaf, J., Rassau, A., Górnisiewicz, W.: Impact on electricity use of introducing time-of-
use pricing to a multi-user home energy management system. Int. Trans. Electr. Energy Syst.
26(5), 993–1005 (2016)
8. Kaveh, P., Alessandra, P., Henrik, S., et al.: Demand response for aggregated residential
consumers with energy storage sharing. In: 2015 54th IEEE Conference Decision and
Control, Osaka, pp. 2024–2030. IEEE Press (2015)
9. Mu, L., Yu, N., Huang, H., et al.: Distributed real-time pricing scheme for local power
supplier in smart community. In: 2016 IEEE 22nd International Conference on Parallel and
Distributed Systems (ICPADS), Wuhan, pp. 40–47. IEEE Press (2016)
10. Fadlullah, Z.M., Quan, D.M., Kato, N., et al.: GTES: an optimized game-theoretic demand-
side management scheme for smart grid. IEEE Syst. J. 8(2), 588–597 (2014)
11. Li, C., Luo, H., Yang, Q.: Smart power consumption strategy considering satisfaction of
residential users in the process of utilizing electricity. J. South China Univ. Technol.(Nat.
Sci. Ed.) 44(8), 60–66 (2016)
12. Zhang, S., Liu, J., Zhao, B., et al.: Cloud computing-based analysis on residential electricity
consumption behavior. Power Syst. Technol. 37(6), 1542–1546 (2013)
Design of Low-Resonance Fast Response DC
Filter for Enhancing Voltage Quality of DC
Distribution Network
Abstract. A bidirectional filter with low ripple and fast response is designed to
solve the problem of low frequency fluctuating in DC distribution network of
DC side. Firstly, the matched filter design method is used to optimize the filter
order and passband frequency. After that, the voltage transfer function of DC
side filter network is derived and its voltage transfer characteristic is analyzed.
For the resonance problem of the filter network, the parameter selection method
of suppressing the peak value of the resonance point is given, and the effect of
actual parameter deviation is further analyzed. The simulation model of double-
ended and single-ended radiation DC distribution network was built in
MATLAB/Simulink, and the experimental platform of single-ended DC distri-
bution network was established.
1 Introduction
With the development of new technologies such as new energy power generation,
power electronics and flexible distribution, the distribution network is also trans-
forming from AC grid to AC-DC hybrid grid [1, 2]. With high power quality, power
supply and electricity efficiency and other advantages, DC distribution network is
becoming a hot research spot around the world [2]. In the background of continuous
maturity of power electronics, the scope of DC power distribution network application
is constantly expanding, whereas DC power distribution network becomes the reason
of increasingly prominent power quality issues [3–5]. Compared with the power quality
issues of AC power grid, the power quality issues of DC power distribution network
have their unique characteristics such as their different causes and propagation range.
The DC voltage is used to power the sensitive load on the DC side through the DC
power distribution network, but the DC voltage deviation, low frequency ripple, etc.
will affect the normal operation of the DC equipment [5, 6]. Therefore, the DC voltage
iL1 L1 iL 2 L2
iC1 iC2
Vi C1 C2 V0
Rm Rn
The selection of component parameters adopts the most matching response algo-
rithm. The essence of matching algorithm is that the equivalent impedances of two
coupled systems are equal. And the difference between matching algorithm and non-
matching algorithm is only a fixed flat decay value. According to the flattest response
algorithm, the normalized filter parameters km can be calculated as follows,
1 p
km ¼ ½2 sinð2m - 1) ð1Þ
C 2n
Where: m is a natural number, when m is odd, km for the capacitance value; when
m is even, km for the inductance value. From (4) shows, the need to take filter auxiliary
parameters C. According to Eq. (5) find C = 1, where ap = 3 dB.
ap
C 2 ¼ 10 10 1 ð2Þ
The voltage and the connection impedance of load side of DC filter determines the
filter parameters directly, set the grid side of the equivalent impedance R1, the load side
of the equivalent impedance R2, the filter reference resistance R0, the reference
inductance L0, the reference capacitance C0. Select the system’s reference voltage as
10 kV, the reference capacity as 100 MVA, the system’s equivalent impedance as 1X.
In the matching algorithm to meet R1 = R2 = R0, the actual inductance and capacitance
values meet Lm ¼ L0 L m ; Cm ¼ C0 Cm . The actual filter parameters are as follows:
R0 1
L0 ¼ ¼ ¼ 3:183 mH ð3Þ
2pfc 2p50
1
C0 ¼ ¼ 3:183 mF ð4Þ
R0 2pfc
Design of Low-Resonance Fast Response DC Filter 277
iL1 ¼ iL2
R þ iC1 ð5Þ
:
V0 ¼ C11 iC1 dt L2 didtL2
U0 1
GðsÞ ¼ ¼ ð6Þ
U1 L1 L2 C1 C2 S4 þ ðL1 C1 þ L2 C2 þ L1 C2 ÞS2 þ 1
Using MATLAB to draw the DC side of the filter network voltage transmission
characteristics, as shown in the red line in Fig. 2. As can be seen from the voltage
transfer characteristics, the network has two resonance points. In the first-order filter
resonance frequency, there is s2 ¼ 1=L1 C1 , at this time the size is:
C1
P1 ¼ jGðj2Pf1 Þj ¼ ð7Þ
C2
-150
101 102 103 104
Frequency (rad/s)
In the second-order filter resonance frequency f2 , there are s2 ¼ 1=L2 C2 , then the
size of GðsÞ is:
L2
P2 ¼ jGðj2Pf2 Þj ¼ ð8Þ
L1
278 J. Liao et al.
Since the harmonic content at the resonant frequency is generally very small (taking
the parameters of Table 1 as an example, the two resonant frequencies are about
173 Hz and 35 Hz, respectively), which has less impact on the safety of the power grid.
The resonance characteristics of DC filter network mainly affect the response speed of
the filter itself [18], if you can suppress the resonance peak can speed up the filter
response speed. This paper considers both lossless and lossy methods. It can be seen
from Eqs. (7) and (8) that limiting the resonance peak at both resonance points to a
negative value (attenuation) can satisfy C1 =C2 \1; L2 =L1 \1 when selecting the filter
parameters, and the voltage transfer characteristic curve of the resulting filter shown in
Fig. 2 (black line). It can be seen that this method down-shifts the filter stop-band
characteristics, but has less effect on the resonance peak.
Consider increasing the damping component of the filter capacitor branch in Fig. 1.
Suppose the added resistance is Rm ; Rn respectively. Derive the voltage transfer
function of the network as shown in Eq. (9). The voltage transfer characteristics curve
shown in Fig. 2 (blue line), which shows that the increase of damping can eliminate the
resonance.
U0 ðsÞ ð1 þ sR2 C2 Þ
¼
Ui ðsÞ 1 þ L1 L2 C1 C2 s4 þ ðL1 C1 C2 R2 þ L1 C1 C2 R1 Þs3
ð9Þ
ð1 þ sR1 C1 Þ
ðL1 C1 þ L2 C2 þ L1 C2 þ R1 R2 C1 C2 Þs2 þ ðR1 C1 þ R2 C2 Þ
Therefore, the damping resistor makes the original filter pole shift left. However,
the method of suppressing the resonance without damping makes the original matching
filter become a non-matching filter, which is characterized by moving the pole
Design of Low-Resonance Fast Response DC Filter 279
downward. The two kinds of changes are shown in Fig. 3. The physical meaning of a
pole shift to the left is attenuating the passband frequency of the filter while the
dominant resonant frequency generally falls outside of the passband frequency and the
attenuation at the resonant frequency increases. When the damping resistor and
capacitor inductance parameters are configured, the offset poles
P0 ððx þ X2 dÞ=ð1 þ X2 d 2 Þ; y=ð1 þ X2 d 2 ÞÞ are shifted to the position under meeting the
formula (11), so as to achieve the effect of suppressing the resonance peak resonance
point of the filter. As can be seen from Fig. 2, increasing the damping resistance
deteriorates the high-frequency characteristics of the filter, but the stop-band attenua-
tion characteristic is still superior to the LC filter (violet line).
3 Simulation Verification
On the rectifier side, the single-terminal radial DC distribution model established in this
paper is 6 pulse rectifiers and PWM inverters on the inverter side (Fig. 4). The model
parameters are shown in Table 2. The characteristic harmonics on the DC side are
6 k times (k = 1,2,3…n), and non-characteristic harmonics are three times harmonic,
even orders harmonic, and the modulating harmonics of switching times which fre-
quencies are N + 1 (N = 0, 1, 2, … n) switching times.
6 Pulse Rectifier
PWM
AC/abc +
...
Filter PWM
-
Equivalent Load
The designed filter is compared with the LC filter. The parameters of the LC are
200 uH inductor and 5 mF capacitor (the passband cut-off frequency is 160 Hz). The
simulation condition is to set the 3-phase unbalance to 2%. The results are shown in
Figs. 5 and 6. The results show that the designed filter has a better effect on suppressing
low-frequency ripple caused by three-phase unbalance than the LC filter.
280 J. Liao et al.
600
Voltage/V
400
200
0 0. 05 0.1 0. 15 0.2
Time/s
(a) DC side voltage waveform
DC = 478 , THD = 1. 15%
Harmonic Content/%
0.6
0.2
0 0 10 20 30 40
Harmonic order/n
(b) DC side voltage spectrum
300
100
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2
Time/s
(a) DC side voltage waveform
DC = 479 . 7 , THD = 0. 28 %
Harmonic Content/%
0.25
0.15
0.05
0 0 10 20 30 40
Harmonic Order/n
(b) DC side voltage spectrum
4 Experiment Verification
5 Conclusion
In this paper, the structure of the filter network proposed aims at improving the quality
of the DC voltage of the DC distribution network. In additional, a bidirectional filter
with low ripple and fast response is proposed. Through simulation and physical model
experiments, the following conclusions are drawn:
(1) The parameter optimization method based on the pole round can reduce the res-
onant peak of resonance point and speed up the response speed of the filter;
(2) Considering investment cost, floor space, filtering effect and response speed, the
filter designed in this paper has advantages in improving the voltage quality of DC
distribution network compared with other filters, which is suitable for the DC side
filtering of DC distribution network.
Acknowledgements. This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (51577018) and Chongqing Science & Technology Commission (cstc2015jcyjBX0033).
References
1. Jung, T.H., et al.: Voltage regulation method for voltage drop compensation and unbalance
reduction in bipolar low-voltage DC distribution system. IEEE Trans. Power Deliv. 33(1),
141–149 (2017)
2. Zadeh, M.K., et al.: Discrete-time modelling, stability analysis, and active stabilization of
DC distribution systems with constant power loads. In: Applied Power Electronics
Conference and Exposition, pp. 323–329. IEEE (2015)
Design of Low-Resonance Fast Response DC Filter 283
3. Gecan, C.O., Chindris, M., Bindiu, R.: Power capability in low voltage DC distribution
systems. Interdisc. Eng. 2, 109–114 (2009)
4. Kakigano, H., Miura, Y., Ise, T.: Low-voltage bipolar-type DC microgrid for super high
quality distribution. IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 25(12), 3066–3075 (2010)
5. Mariscotti, A.: Methods for ripple index evaluation in DC low voltage distribution networks.
In: Proceedings of the Instrumentation and Measurement Technology Conference, IMTC.
IEEE, pp. 1–4 (2007)
6. Prabhakaran, P., Agarwal, V.: Mitigation of voltage unbalance in a low voltage bipolar DC
microgrid using a boost-SEPIC type interleaved DC-DC compensator. In: Power Electronics
Conference, pp. 1–6 IEEE (2017). Gallo, D., Landi, C., Luiso, M.: AC and DC power
quality of photovoltaic systems. In: Instrumentation and Measurement Technology
Conference, pp. 576–581. IEEE (2012)
7. Wang, M.H., et al.: Hybrid-DC electric springs for DC voltage regulation and harmonic
cancellation in DC microgrids. IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 33(2), 1167–1177 (2018)
8. Dey, P., Mekhilef, S.: Current harmonics compensation with three-phase four-wire shunt
hybrid active power filter based on modified D–Q, theory. IET Power Electron. 8(11), 2265–
2280 (2014)
9. Lee, T.L., Wang, Y.C., Li, J.C., et al.: Hybrid active filter with variable conductance for
harmonic resonance suppression in industrial power systems. IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron. 62
(2), 746–756 (2015)
10. Somlal, J., Rao, M.V.G.: Power conditioning in distribution systems using ANN controlled
Shunt Hybrid Active Power Filter. In: International Conference on Smart Electric Grid.
IEEE, pp. 1–5 (2014)
11. Beres, R.N., et al.: A review of passive power filters for three-phase grid-connected voltage-
source converters. IEEE J. Emerg. Sel. Top. Power Electron. 4(1), 54–69 (2016)
12. Kang, W., Zhang, L., Liu, C.: Output filter design method in current-source PWM
converters. Trans. Chin. Electrotech. Soc. 27(6), 83–89 (2012)
13. Yang, L., et al.: Second ripple current suppression by two band-pass filters and current
sharing method for energy storage converters in DC Microgrid. IEEE J. Emerg. Sel.
Top. Power Electron. 5(3), 1031–1044 (2017)
14. Meehan, P., et al.: Varactor-based passive ripple filter with automatic tuning for low-noise
power supply systems. IEEE Trans. Power Electron. 32(6), 4741–4752 (2017)
15. Li, K., et al.: Novel load ripple voltage-controlled parallel DC active power filters for high
performance magnet power supplies. IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 53(3), 1530–1539 (2006)
16. Bo, C., Zeng, X., Yao, X.: Three tuned passive filter to improve power quality. In:
International Conference on Power System Technology, Powercon, pp. 1–5. IEEE (2006)
17. Wei, K., et al.: Research on the Matched DC Filter Design in the Power Accumulator Battery
Testing System. In: International Conference on Electrical and Control Engineering
(ICECE), pp. 4157–4160 (2010)
18. Fadloullah, I., Mechaqrane, A., Ahaitouf, A.: Butterworth low pass filter design using
evolutionary algorithm. In: International Conference on Wireless Technologies, Embedded
and Intelligent Systems (WITS), pp. 1–6 (2017)
Analysis for the Influence of Electric Vehicle
Chargers with Different SOC on Grid Harmonics
Abstract. In this paper, analysis for the influence of electric vehicle (EV)
chargers on grid harmonics is conducted. The simulation model of the power
distribution network with vehicle-mounted chargers is established, and the
harmonic feature of the charger is analyzed. Considering different State of Charge
(SOC) of the chargers and the relationship between harmonic current and initial
SOC values of the EVs is established. To reduce the harmonic current caused by
EV chargers, an optimization model of coordinated charging has been developed
and the optimal solution is obtained by using the PSO algorithm. The validity of
the proposed optimal charging schedule is verified through the simulation results.
1 Introduction
With the rapid development of electric vehicle (EV), the large number of grid connected
chargers will result in the harmonic current into the electric grid [1]. It is necessary to
study the influence of EV chargers on grid harmonics and take the corresponding meas‐
ures to reduce the harmonic current.
The variation of the non-linear resistance was used to replace the variation of
charging power in all periods [2]. The influence of the harmonics generated by EVs via
charging to the grid was analyzed [3], and it was also pointed out that as the continual
promotion of large-scale EVs, it needed to establish the management facility of large-
scale EVs, and it could reduce the harmonic influence. The influence of the disordered
charging for the EVs on power system was analyzed [4], and the corresponding solutions
were performed, thus the power quality of the grid was increased.
To sum up, all the above research was done on the harmonic analysis with same
initial SOC value for the EVs, and the high-frequency power vary circuit of the charger
is mostly equivalent to the time varying resistor, the dispersing processing was also
conducted. But the continuity and time-varying behavior of the charging curve for the
battery power of the EVs were not exemplified.
In this current paper, the charger model of continual charging was established in
Simulink. In addition, the charging process curve of the EVs was simulated more accu‐
rately. Afterward, the harmonic analysis was conducted on the charging process of EVs
with different initial SOC, and the relation model between the SOC value of the EVs
and harmonic current was fitted. Finally, the optimized charging model of orderly access
for EVs was established, and it aimed to reduce the harmonic current based on above
model.
The Fig. 1 demonstrates the structure of the high frequency charger. The three-phase
bridge rectifier is used to rectifier the three-phase AC current. In addition, this current
passes through the filtering circuit which is composed by capacitor and resistor. The
DC-DC power converter is used to convert the power. Finally, the output power passes
through the output filtering circuit to recharge the EVs as verified by [5, 6].
DC-DC I0
Rf Lf I1
Ua Power Outpt
Cf conve- U0
Ub
rsion Filter
Uc
The most widely used power batteries for EVs are lithium-ion batteries [7]. The built-
in lithium-ion battery of MATLAB is taken as power battery of the EVs in this proposed
paper. The model of the single charger is established in Matlab/Simulink according to
the structure chart of the charger as shown in Fig. 2.
It can be seen from Fig. 2 that two-way Buck-boost converter is used for the power
conversion of the charger, and it can transform the output DC voltage to the ideal
286 Q. Sheng et al.
charging voltage [8, 9]. When the EVs are charged, the DC/DC converter works in the
buck voltage-reduction mode. The switch VT1 is works at the constant switch frequency,
and the switch VT2 maintains the cut-off state. In last, the power passes from the Udc to
the battery and required charging voltage or current can be obtained through adjusting
the duty cycle of VT1.
The battery charging current Ibat and voltage Vbat waveforms are shown in Figs. 5
and 6 on the initial level of the SOC = 0%. These waveforms proved that the above
charging control method of constant current and voltage has capability to run in the
predefined manner.
20 325
Battery voltage (A)
Battery current (A)
19
320
18
315
17
310
16
15 305
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
When the number of EVs reaches a certain level in distribution networks, the corre‐
sponding harmonic current amplitude sizes are measured, and compared with the
permitted value of harmonic current in the Power Quality Public Grid Harmonics. The
obtained limit table is shown in Table 1. It can be seen from Table 1 that when the
number of EVs increases to 20, the 5th and 7th harmonic currents exceed the permitted
value. It indicates that they are more likely to exceed the standard limits.
3.1 The Simulation Analysis of the EVs in the Same Initial State
The variation rule of the effective value for all harmonic currents is mainly analyzed in
the charging process. The charging time in the simulation curve is uniformly set at 5 h
to facilitate the comparative analysis and it conforms to the conventional charging time
for EVs in actual life. The initial SOC value is taken as the distinction condition of the
EVs. When the initial SOC is the same, the 5th and 7th harmonic currents generated by
EVs of different number is firstly analyzed as shown in Fig. 7.
30 20
25
15
20
15 10
10
5
5
0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Charging time (h) Charging time (h)
It can be seen from the above figures that when the charging number of EVs increases,
the both 5th and 7th harmonic current values are also increased. However, it is not the
algebraic sum of the harmonic current generated by all EVs in stand-alone condition.
Therefore, it indicates that the harmonic currents are offset. The total change trend of
all the harmonic currents is similar [13]. So, when multiple EVs of different initial SOC
value are charged, the harmonic currents are also offset.
The 20 EVs are taken as the example and the simulation analysis of the charging is
conducted in two different initial states which are given below:
(1) The initial SOC value of the 20 EVs to be charged at 0%;
(2) The 20 EVs are divided into 5 groups and 4 in each group. The initial SOC of the
power battery in each group of EV is set as 0%, 20%, 30%, 50% and 80%.
No load is added after the charging. The simulation analysis on the variation of the
effective value of harmonic currents is conducted in these two charging combination
and the result is shown in Fig. 8.
Analysis for the Influence of Electric Vehicle Chargers 289
30 30
25 25
Harmonic current (A)
15 15
10 10
5 5
0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Charging time (h) Charging time (h)
Fig. 8. Harmonic current change curve at the same and different initial charge
Where Ih.i is effective value of the hth harmonic current of the harmonic source i; Ih
is the effective value of the hth total harmonic current.
The overall charging period of the EV is set at 5 h to facilitate the research and each
hour is divided into 10 periods namely t = 0, 1, 2, 3…50 with 51 points in the time. The
total harmonic current generated by the charging of N EVs at the t point in time can be
expressed as follows:
√
√ N
√∑
Ih.t = √ (Ihi.t (Si.t ))2 (3)
i=1
Where Si.t is the SOC of the EVs in the tth point in time and N is the number of the
EVs; Ihi.t (Si.t) is the effective value of the harmonic current generated by the ith EV at
the tth point in time. Because the Si.t of EV is increasing during charging and the Ihi.t
(Si.t) also changes with Si.t. The value of Si.t variation in each charging period needs to
be determined by SOC real time estimation.
Since the initial SOC of the EV is defined in the proposed paper. The rated capacity
and charge current of the battery are also defined in the real time simulation. The
following formula can be used to calculate the SOCs of the next charging time point by
using the ampere-hour integration method combined with the open-circuit voltage
method.
Since the initial SOC of the EV is predefined in this paper. The rated capacity of the
power battery and the real time change value of the charging current are also imple‐
mented. So, the ampere-hour integration method combined with the open-circuit voltage
method [14] which can be used to calculate the SOC of the next charging time point.
The formula is as follows:
t
∫0 KIdt
SOC = SOC0 − (4)
Qc
Where SOC0 indicates the initial SOC of the power battery; K is a constant related
to temperature; I is the charge and discharge current of the power battery (the charge
current is negative and the discharge current is the positive); Qc indicates the power
battery rated capacity and t is charging time.
Therefore, we can calculate the value of Si.t change at each charging time by using
Eq. (4), and then take it into Eq. (3) to get the total harmonic current value produced by
N EVs at time t.
To sum up, the maximum value of the 5th harmonic current generated by multiple
EVs can be expressed as max[Ih.t (Si.t)]. If the maximum value tends to be the minimum,
the overall trend of the total harmonic current generated by the charging is also towards
the minimum. Therefore, by minimizing the maximum harmonic current generated by
the EV as the objective function which is given below:
[ [ ]]
f = min max Ih.t (Si.t ) (5)
Analysis for the Influence of Electric Vehicle Chargers 291
The initial SOC of each EVs is different and the time required for fully charging is
different. The range of charge and the remaining charge time must be taken into account.
The following technical constraints are established to check the capability.
(1) Initial electric quantity constraint:
The users often charge the EVs during 80% or below of the SOC according to the
actual situation which is given as under:
0 ≤ Si ≤ 80 (6)
vt+1
i
= 𝜔ti + c1 r1 (pti − xit ) + c2 r2 (ptb − xit ) (9)
In the equation, c1 and c2 are the learning factors; r1 and r2 indicate the random
t t
number of the interval (0, 1); ω indicates the inertia weight factors; vi and xi are the speed
t t
and position corresponding to the ith particle in the tth iteration process; pi and pb are
the personal best and the global best of the particle.
Population size m = 100; particle dimension D = 20, namely the total number of
EVs to be charged in the charging station; learning factors c1 = c2 = 1.5; the maximum
and minimum of the inertia weight are respectively ωmax = 0.9, ωmin = 0.4; the maximum
iteration time is set at 200.
The optimization model is solved when the number of EVs to be charged at 20. The
solution set of the optimal initial SOC for whole charging period is given below:
S = [2.15;73.70;68.24;44.93;63.24;74.12;57.65;78.93;72.96;1.63;
38.13;51.96;18.95;9.37;22.33;74.70;19.56;3.22;42.09;79.66]
The SOC value is set for the EV according to above optimization result and simu‐
lation experiment is conducted in the distribution network. The optimized change curve
of the harmonic current is shown in Fig. 9.
30 40
25 35
Harmonic current (A)
30
20
25
15 20
15
10
10
5
5
0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5
Charging time (h) Charging time (h)
Fig. 9. Optimized harmonic current change Fig. 10. The influence of optimization model
curve on the access of large scale electric vehicle
It can be clearly seen from the Fig. 9 that the overall harmonic current generated by
the charging in the orderly combination selected for the EV is much less than that in
disordered charging. Therefore, it can satisfy the limit value of the harmonic current in
the national standard.
In actual charging, the number of EVs to be charged in the charging station on a large
scale not only 20, but also can be solved by this optimization model. The EVs that accord
with the optimal initial SOC can be selected for coordinated charging. In this way, the
harmonic content injected into the power network can be reduced more economically
without adding additional filter devices.
Based on the coordinated charging optimization model, the PSO algorithm is used
to solve the optimal coordinated charging SOC of each EV when the particle dimension
D is 5, 10, 20, 50, and 100 respectively. The optimized SOC of EV under different
dimensions is introduced into the coordinated charging optimization model and the
Analysis for the Influence of Electric Vehicle Chargers 293
5 Conclusion
In this paper, the charger model of the EVs is established and charging control strategy
for EVs at constant voltage and current is completed. It is also verified via simulation
results that the charging mode of constant voltage and current can be realized in the
established model.
The simulation analysis is conducted in the distribution network through the estab‐
lished charger model and the change curve of the harmonic current for EVs in different
initial states is obtained. It is also obtained that the effect of the harmonic current can
be reduced when the EVs are charged at different initial SOC. The optimization model
of orderly access of the EV to reduce the harmonic current is established based on this
and the model is solved through PSO algorithm. Finally the effectiveness of the control
strategy to reduce the harmonic current is verified in this paper through the simulation
experiment. At the same time, the optimization model is applied to show that the more
number of EVs, the better the harmonic control effect of the coordinated charging
strategy.
References
1. Zhang, J.: Design on high efficiency power DC/DC converter used by electric vehicle. Modern
Instruments (2012)
2. Na, L., Mei, H.: Analysis on harmonics caused by connecting different types of electric vehicle
chargers with power network. Power Syst. Technol. 35(1), 170–174 (2011)
3. Sourkounis, C., Broy, A., Ni, B.: High power charging of electric vehicles in distribution
grids. In: Power Generation, Transmission, Distribution and Energy Conversion, pp. 1–6.
IET (2010)
4. Liu, X., Li, S., Yu, H.: Coordinated charging optimization mode of electric vehicles in the
residential area. Trans. China Electrotech. Soc. 30, 238–245 (2015)
5. Zhou, J., Ren, G., Chen, W.: Harmonic analysis of electric vehicle AC charging spot and
research on harmonic restriction. Power Syst. Prot. Control 45(5), 18–25 (2017)
6. Rahman, M.H., Xu, L., Yao, L.: Protection of large partitioned MTDC networks using DC-
DC converters and circuit breakers. Prot. Control of Modern Power Syst. 1(1), 19 (2016)
7. Guo, X.W., Kang, L.Y., Wen-Biao, L.I.: Research on SOC estimation based on SOH and
off-line data segmented correction. Chin. J. Power Sources (2017)
294 Q. Sheng et al.
8. Wang, M., Ye, T., Li, T.: Study of bidirectional DC-DC converters applied to energy storage
system. Trans. China Electrotech. Soc. 28(8), 66–71 (2013)
9. Tong, Y.B., Wu, T., Jin, X.M.: Study of bi-directional DC/DC converter. In: Proceedings of
the CSEE (2007)
10. Qiu-Sheng, H.E., Lei, X.U., Xue-Xue, W.U.: Review of lithium battery charging technology.
Chin. J. Power Sources (2013)
11. Liu, W., Wu, H., He, Z.: A multistage current charging method for Li-Ion battery considering
balance of internal consumption and charging speed. Trans. China Electrotech. Soc. pp. 1401–
1406 (2017)
12. Liu, Y.X., Wang, T.Y., Yang, Y.Y.: Modeling and simulation of electric vehicles’ charge and
discharge system. Power Syst. Prot. Control 42(13), 70–76 (2014)
13. Liu, G.H., Wei, M.Y., Chen, Z.L.: Study on harmonics suppression mechanism of electric
vehicle charging. Power Electron. 45(12), 11–13 (2011)
14. Deng, T., Sun, H.: Research on real time estimation method of new SOC ampere hours integral
for lithium ion battery. J. Chongqing Univ. Technol. 1, 020 (2015)
15. Bing, Y., Wang, L., Liao, C.: Effects of uncertainty charging habits on electric vehicles’
charging load demand and the charging load regulation. Trans. China Electrotech. Soc. 30(4),
226–232 (2015)
Generation Capacity Planning with Significant
Renewable Energy Penetration Considering
Base-Load Cycling Capacity Constraints
1 Introduction
With the increasing shortage of fossil energy resources, intermittent renewable energy,
notably wind power, is expected to play an increasing role to the sustainable devel-
opment in the near future [1]. Because of the inverse peak-regulation characteristics in
wind power output, large scale penetration of wind power will increase the daily peak-
valley difference of net loads, which will result in base-load cycling capacity (BLCC)
shortage problem [2, 3]. The BLCC shortage problem will pose an adverse impact on
secure operation of power systems. The ability to mitigate the BLCC shortage problem
only by operational dispatch of conventional plants is very limited [4, 5]. It is critical to
guarantee adequate BLCC at the capacity planning level. However, as the BLCC
constraint is generally considered in the daily operation in power systems, it has been
ignored currently at yearly planning stage. As such, it is vital to meet the BLCC
constraints in the planning level.
Nowadays, many research works [6, 7] have focused on ensuring the BLCC by
operational dispatch of conventional plants. These researches are short-term solutions
with great limitations although they can improve the BLCC to a certain extent. In [8],
an optimal capacity-allocation method was proposed for large-scale energy storage
systems to relax peak-regulation. Ref. [9] proposed a capacity planning model based on
screening curves method to describe the efficient plants portfolio. Ref. [10, 11]
developed a new system planning model taking into account technical operational
constraints such as the maintenance parameters and transmission interconnection.
However, the BLCC constraints haven’t been considered for power systems. Therefore,
research gaps exist in yearly generation capacity planning considering BLCC con-
straints. This paper addresses the problem by screening curves method. Screening
curves method [12, 13] is a useful approach to compute the optimal generation capacity
for a target year.
Based on the screening curves method, a yearly generation capacity planning model
considering the BLCC constraints is proposed in this paper. With this model, an
optimal mix of generation capacity can be obtained. Through dispatching conventional
plants of the optimal mix, the BLCC constraint of each day in the planning year can be
satisfied. Then the impacts of cost parameters and renewable energy integration scale
on the ‘base-load’ technology capacity and ‘peak-load’ technology capacity are theo-
retically analyzed. Numerical examples are presented to verify the reasonableness and
effectiveness of the proposed model. The optimal mix with and without BLCC con-
straints are compared. The impacts of renewable energy integration scale on the
optimal mix are examined.
The screening curves method is a simple way to use annual load shape information and
costs of competing power plant technologies to find a least-cost generation mix solu-
tion for a given load shape. The bottom half in Fig. 1 is the annual generation cost
curve, the investment cost is its intercept and the operation cost is its slope. Let u1 be
the technology with the highest investment costs per capacity unit and u3 with the
lowest investment costs ðcinv;3 \cinv;2 \cinv;1 Þ. However, operating costs are highest for
u3 and lowest for u1 ðcop;1 \cop;2 \cop;3 Þ. Then refer to u1 as ‘base-load’ technology
and to u2 as ‘intermediate load’ technology and to u3 as ‘peak-load’ technology.
The generation cost curve determines the optimal operating duration for each
technology. The minimum cost is the lowest piece-wise linear function of firing hours
(as shown in the red line in Fig. 1). The points of the intersections on the horizontal
axis separate technologies, and the intervals of these points determine the annual firing
duration of those technologies. The load-duration curve gives a one-to-one relationship
between firing duration and generation capacity. Thus, the optimal generation capacity
K1, K2, K3 and the optimal generation quantity in a given year can be calculated.
Generation Capacity Planning 297
where L(t) is the load level at time t, PRES ðtÞ is the output of renewables generation. The
net load was rearranged in decreasing order to obtain the net load-duration curves.
Figure 1 shows that after renewable energy penetration, the peak-valley load difference
increases, which leads to a heavier pressure of base-load cycling. Also, the renewable
energy penetration will change the load duration curve, which results in a different
optimal mix.
X
N
Ki li ðdÞ ¼ Rmax ðdÞ d 2 ½1; 365 ð3Þ
i¼1
298 J. Ma et al.
where, Ki is the installed capacity of technology i, li ðdÞ is the ratio of the startup units’
capacity to the installed capacity of technology i at day d. The minimum output limit of
the startup units at day d is:
X
N
PGmin ðdÞ ¼ Ki li ðdÞgi ð4Þ
i¼1
where, ηi is the ratio of the minimum output to the installed capacity of technology i,
g1 g2 . . . gN . Since the cycling capacity of each technology is not the same, the
different type of startup units will result in different minimum output limit. The min-
imum output limit of day d reaches its maximum, when the generation units are
dispatched so as to minimize generation cost, i.e.
X
N
max PGmin ðdÞ ¼ Ki li ðdÞgi ; lN ðdÞ lN1 ðdÞ . . . l1 ðdÞ ð5Þ
li ðdÞ
i¼1
The minimum output limit of day d reaches its minimum, when the generation units
are dispatched in order to maximize BLCC, i.e.
X
N
min PGmin ðdÞ ¼ Ki li ðdÞgi ; lN ðdÞ lN1 ðdÞ . . . l1 ðdÞ ð6Þ
li ðdÞ
i¼1
If the minimum load of day d is greater than max PGmin ðdÞ, the system can be
li ðdÞ
dispatched most economical at day d, and has a certain BLCC margin. If the minimum
load of day d Rmin ðdÞ 2 ½min PGmin ðdÞ; max PGmin ðdÞÞ, the BLCC constraint can be
li ðdÞ li ðdÞ
satisfied through dispatching conventional plants of the optimal mix at day d. If the
minimum load of day d is smaller than min PGmin ðdÞ, the BLCC constraint cannot be
li ðdÞ
satisfied through dispatching conventional plants of the optimal mix at day d.
where t1, t2, t3 denoting the operating hours of u2, u3, u4 respectively. The BLCC
constraints are as follows:
Construct the Lagrange function to solve the number of operation hour t1d ; t2d ; t3d .
Then the optimal generation capacity for each technology type can be obtained by
Eqs. (10). The Lagrange function can be written as follows.
300 J. Ma et al.
n ¼ cinv;1 Rðt1d Þ þ cinv;2 ðRðt2d Þ Rðt1d ÞÞ þ cinv;3 ðRðt3d Þ Rðt2d ÞÞ þ cinv;4 ðRmax Rðt3d ÞÞ
Z T Z td Z td Z td
1 1 2
þ cop;1 ð RðtÞdt RðtÞdt þ t1d Rðt1d ÞÞ þ cop;2 ð RðtÞdt t1d Rðt1d Þ RðtÞdt
0 0 0 0
Z t2d Z t3d Z t3d ð15Þ
þ t2 Rðt2 ÞÞ þ cop;3 ð
d d
RðtÞdt t2d Rðt2d Þ RðtÞdt þ t3 Rðt3 ÞÞ þ cop;4 ð
d d
RðtÞdt
0 0 0
t3d Rðt3d ÞÞ bd ðRmin ðdÞ Rðt1d Þðg1 g2 Þ Rðt2d Þðg2 g3 Þ Rðt3d Þðg3 g4 Þ
Rmax ð1Þg4 þ DPðdÞg1 Þ
@f @f @f
0 ? t1d 0; d 0 ? t2d 0; d 0 ? t3d 0 ð16Þ
@t1d @t2 @t3
@f
0 ? bd 0 ð17Þ
@bd
@f
Condition (17) allows two possible solutions with respect to bd : If @b d \0, b has to
d
be zero by complementary slackness. At this point, the system have a certain BLCC
margin, the BLCC constraint does not work, which will result in
@f
t1d ¼ t1d1 ; t2d ¼ t2d1 ; t3d ¼ t3d1 . If @b d ¼ 0, b [ 0 by complementary slackness, which
d
means Rmin ðdÞ [ ðK1d þ K2d DPðdÞÞg2 þ K3d g3 þ K4d g4 ), bd ¼ 0. The BLCC con-
@f
straint does not work, which will result in t1d ¼ t1d1 ; t2d ¼ t2d1 ; t3d ¼ t3d1 . If @b d ¼ 0
4 Numerical Analysis
Fig. 2. The net load duration curves after the linearization fitting
conventional plants of the optimal mix in 3 days during the planning year. After
considering BLCC constraints, the system can be dispatched most economical in 178
days. And all of the 365 days’ BLCC demand can be satisfied through dispatching
conventional plants of the optimal mix.
Fig. 4. Impact of BLCC constraints on the BLCC adequacy of the planning year
5 Conclusions
References
1. Baldick, R.: Wind and energy markets: a case study of Texas. IEEE Syst. J. 6(1), 27–34
(2012)
2. Troy, N., Denny, E., O’Malley, M.: Base-load cycling on a system with significant wind
penetration. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 25(2), 1088–1097 (2010)
3. Batlle, C., Rodilla, P.: An enhanced screening curves method for considering thermal
cycling operation costs in generation expansion planning. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 28(4),
3683–3691 (2013)
Generation Capacity Planning 305
4. Coester, A., Hofkes, M.W.: E. Papyrakis.: An optimal mix of conventional power systems in
the presence of renewable energy: a new design for the German electricity market. Energy
Policy 116, 312–322 (2018)
5. Babrowski, S., Jochem, P., Fichtner, W.: How to model the cycling ability of thermal units in
power systems. Energy 103, 397–409 (2016)
6. Xu, L., Ruan, X., Zhang, B., Mao, C.: An improved optimal sizing method for wind-solar-
battery hybrid power system. Proc. Chin. Soc. Electr. Eng. 32(25), 88–98 (2012)
7. Castronuovo, E.D., Lopes, J.A.P.: Optimal operation and hydro storage sizing of a wind
hydro power plant. Int. J. Electr. Power Energy Syst. 26(10), 771–778 (2004)
8. Yan, G., Feng, X., Li, J.: Optimization of energy storage system capacity for relaxing peak
load regulation bottlenecks. Proc. Chin. Soc. Electr. Eng. 32(28), 27–35 (2012)
9. Steffen, B., Weber, C.: Efficient storage capacity in power systems with thermal and
renewable generation. Energy Econ. 36, 556–567 (2013)
10. De Jonghe, C., Delarue, E., Belmans, R., D’haeseleer, W.: Determining optimal electricity
technology mix with high level of wind power penetration. Appl. Energy 88, 2231–2238
(2011)
11. Belderbos, A., Delarue, E.: Accounting for flexibility in power system planning with
renewables. Int. J. Electr. Power Energy Syst. 71, 33–41 (2015)
12. Zhang, T., Baldick, R., Deetjen, T.: Optimized generation capacity expansion using a further
improved screening curve method. Electr. Power Syst. Res. 124, 47–54 (2015)
13. Zhang, T., Baldick, R.: Consideration of existing capacity in screening curve method. IEEE
Trans. Power Syst. 32(4), 3038–3048 (2017)
A Multiple Model Control Method
of Coal-Fired Power Plant
SCR-DeNOx System
1 Introduction
Poblubny has five adjustable parameters and is more flexible than traditional PID
controller [7]. Reference [8] presented a sliding mode control method to control the
NOx emission for a denitration system applied in thermal power units. Multiple model
strategy, which has attracted much attention, is generally regarded as a feasible
approach to dealing with complex systems. The characteristics of power plants are very
complicated in terms of uncertainties, nonlinearities, time-varying and changing
operating points. Therefore, combining the IMC-FOPID control strategy presented in
reference [9] with the multiple model method, a multiple model IMC-FOPID controller
is utilized to optimize NOx emission of power plants in this paper.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2, an SCR-DeNOx system is
briefly introduced. The main control scheme is then developed in Sect. 3. Consequently,
simulation results are given in Sect. 4. Finally, some conclusions are drawn in Sect. 5.
At present, SCR denitration technology is most widely applied among many denitration
methods. This method is characterized by explicit chemical reactions, no by-products
and no secondary pollution. Correspondingly, it has some advantages in terms of high
reliability, simple structure and high denitration rate (above 80%). The SCR denitration
unit is usually installed between the economizer and the air preheater so that the
catalytic reduction reactions occur in the suitable temperature range (300–400 °C).
A diagram concerning a denitration unit of a 600 MW sub-critical unit in a power plant
is depicted in Fig. 1.
The chemical reactions occur under the effect of catalyst and dominant reaction
insides is 4NO + 4NH3 + O2 ! 4N2 + 6H2O, which achieves the objective of deni-
tration mostly.
308 J. Zhang et al.
In the SCR-DeNOx system, there is a delay of the NOx measurement in the inlet
and outlet of the SCR reactor. Therefore, the characteristics of the SCR-DeNOx system
is complex in terms of large inertia and time delay. For the #1 unit of 600 MW power
plant in Fig. 1, ammonia injection disturbance tests have been conducted under three
typical operating conditions and corresponding transfer functions can be obtained by
identifying dynamic characteristics according to experimental data [8].
3 Control Scheme
In this paper, we will present a kind of multiple model control strategy on SCR
denitration cascade system. And some preliminaries are introduced as follows.
As shown in Fig. 2, r and u are the set point of outlet NOx concentration and the
output of the primary controller respectively. y is actual value of outlet NOx concen-
tration, GNH3 ðsÞ is the ammonia flow transfer function and GSCR ðsÞ represents the
transfer function of outlet NOx concentration.
Recently, many researchers have studied FOPID and proposed different tuning meth-
ods. For the sake of convenience of application and control, we apply the approach in
the literature [8] into tuning the parameters of FOPID controller for SCR denitration
control systems. The tuning procedure is roughly summarized as follows (Fig. 3).
(a)
(b)
Let Gm ðsÞ be the reference model of an linear time-invariant integer order system.
Step 1. Based on the IMC controller design, Gm ðsÞ must be factorized as follows:
where G þ
m ðsÞ is the non-singular part of Gm ðsÞ, Gm ðsÞ stands for the singular part
which contains all time delays and right-half plane zeros, and its steady-state gain must
be equal to one.
Step 2. The IMC controller is specified as
1
GIMC ðsÞ ¼ fðsÞ ð2Þ
G
m ðs)
where f(s) represents a low pass filter with a steady-state gain of one, its form is
where the time constant and non-integer are chosen by the phase margin and the
crossover frequency of the closed-loop by
p um
a¼ 1 ð4Þ
p=2
1
sc ¼ ð5Þ
xac þ 1
310 J. Zhang et al.
CIMC ðs)
CðsÞ ¼ ð6Þ
1 CIMC ðs)Cm ðs)
1
The transfer function of PI controller in inner loop are 0:4 1 þ 0:625
1
s under three
typical conditions. As the inner loop is tuned properly, the whole inner loop can be
regarded approximately as a plant whose gain is one. Then let it cascade with GSCR ðsÞ
together. Then the combination becomes GrðsÞ shown in Fig. 2. Next, the primary
controller can be designed in accordance with above-mentioned step 1 to step 3.
The usual form of GSCR ðsÞ is:
kehs
Gm ðsÞ ¼ ð7Þ
ð1 þ T1 sÞð1 þ T2 sÞ
ehs ¼ 1 hs ð8Þ
Substituting the time delay approximation in Gm ðsÞ and using (2), the IMC con-
troller is obtained by
ð1 þ T1 sÞð1 þ T2 sÞ
CIMC ðsÞ ¼ ð9Þ
kð1 þ sc sa þ 1 Þ
ð1 + T1 s)(1 + T2 s)
C(s) ¼
k(hs + sc sa þ 1 Þ
ð10Þ
1 T1 + T2 1 T1 T2
¼ sc a ½1 þ þ s]
1þ h s kh ðT1 + T2 Þs T1 + T2
4 Simulation Results
In this section, IMC-FOPID controller is applied to every GrðsÞ in three typical oper-
ating conditions. As described in Fig. 2, the total output of the primary controller u is the
weighted sum of ui which corresponds to three typical operating conditions such that
X
3
u¼ w i ui ð11Þ
i¼1
Method of Coal-Fired Power Plant SCR-DeNOx System 311
Where wi is the weight of ui , its value is directly related to the quality of system
switching. In practice, the weights of ui under two operation points, which are close to
the current load L, are not zero respectively. The weights can be calculated by
jL L1 j jL L 2 j
w1 ¼ ; w2 ¼ ð12Þ
L2 L1 L2 L1
Where L1 , L2 are two loads which are nearest the current load L. The experimental
results of the unit load at operating point 1 (load 400 MW) and operating point 2 (load
500 MW) respectively are indicated as follows.
Figures 4 and 6 show the manipulated variables at 400 MW and 500 MW respec-
tively. Figures 5 and 7 indicate the controlled output signal using PID cascade control
(dot-dash line) and proposed method in this paper (solid line) at 400 MW and 500 MW
respectively. It can be observed that the response curve is smoother, the overshoot is
smaller and response is faster than that under traditional PID cascade control.
Method of Coal-Fired Power Plant SCR-DeNOx System 313
5 Conclusion
Considering the coal-fired power plant SCR denitration system, IMC-FOPID controller
based on multiple model strategy is proposed in this paper. The feasibility of this
scheme has been proved by experimental results. Meanwhile, the proposed control
method can achieve better control quality than the traditional PID controller. The
proposed control system plays important role in ensuring economic and safe operation
of SCR denitration system of a coal-fired power plant. In practice, SCR denitration
systems usually operate at varying operating conditions, therefore, the proposed control
strategy should be extended to deal with SCR denitration systems operating over a
wide range in further research.
References
1. Ding, L., Liu, C., Chen, K., Huang, Y., Diao, B.: Atmospheric pollution reduction effect and
regional predicament: an empirical analysis based on the Chinese provincial NOx emissions.
J. Environ. Manage. 196, 178–187 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.03.016
2. Tan, P., Xia, J., Zhang, C., Fang, Q., Chen, G.: Modeling and reduction of NOx emissions
for a 700 MW coal-fired boiler with the advanced machine learning method. Energy 94,
672–679 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2015.11.020
3. Chen, W.X., Zhang, S.P., Li, B.X., Liu, M., Liu, J.P.: Simulation study on 660 MW coal-
fired power plant coupled with a steam ejector to ensure NOx reduction ability. Appl. Therm.
Eng. 111, 550–561 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2016.09.104
4. Ma, L., et al.: Effect of the separated over-fire air location on the combustion optimization
and NOx reduction of a 600 MW FW down-fired utility boiler with a novel combustion
system. Appl. Energy 180, 104–115 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.apenergy.2016.07.102
5. Zhao, H.R., Shen, J., Li, Y.G., Bentsman, J.: Coal-fired utility boiler modelling for advanced
economical low-NOx combustion controller design. Control Eng. Pract. 58, 127–141 (2017).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.conengprac.2016.10.005
6. Stadlbauer, S., Waschl, H., Del Re, L.: SCR ammonia dosing control by a nonlinear model
predictive controller. IFAC Proc. Vol. 47, 3018–3023 (2014). https://doi.org/10.3182/
20140824-6-za-1003.02497
7. Poblubny, I.: Fractional-order system and PIkDl controller. IEEE Trans. Autom. Control 44,
208–214 (1999). https://doi.org/10.1109/9.739144
8. Fu, J.Q.: The application of sliding mode control in the thermal power units denitrification
control system. North China Electric Power University (2016)
9. Maâmar, B., Rachid, M.: IMC-PID-fractional-order-filter controllers design for integer order
systems. ISA Trans. 53, 1620–1628 (2014). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.isatra.2014.05.007
10. Vinopraba, T., Sivakumaran, N., Narayanan, S.: IMC based fractional order PID controller.
IEEE ICIT. 49, 71–76 (2011). https://doi.org/10.1109/icit.2011.5754348
Communication Network Planning with Dual
Network Coupling Characteristics Under
Active Distribution Network
1 Introduction
has good reliability, the whole current active distribution network can run smoothly and
safely. Therefore, it is necessary to study the communication network planning
problem.
To solve the communication network planning problem, the minimum spanning
tree is firstly used to generate the shortest power grid topology in term of the minimum
expense of initial power grid. Considering the constraints of network looping rate and
invulnerability, an economic planning model is established and further solved by using
the particle swarm optimization (PSO) algorithm. Finally, the effectiveness and feasi-
bility of the proposed method are verified by a 29-node distribution network.
Before the planning of optical fiber communication network, a physical power network
need be generated. To minimize the cost of power network planning, the initial span is
generated using the minimum spanning tree. Then the communication network plan-
ning model is established by considering loop rate and network invulnerability.
X
m
Fdcos t ¼ min xðu; vÞ ð1Þ
i¼1
where u and v represent the vertex of the topology of power grid, xðu; vÞ represents the
weight and m represents the number of vertices. To solve this problem, the minimum
spanning tree method is employed to get the network topology as follows:
Step 1: Enter the grid node coordinates, where the vertex set is V and the edge set is E.
Step 2: Initialization Enew ¼ fg and Vnew ¼ fxg. In the minimum spanning tree to
generate the physical network topology, where Enew ¼ fg is the set of edges and
Vnew ¼ fxg is the point set, and x is any node in the set (starting point).
Step 3: In the edge set E, select the edge hu; vi with the smallest weight, where u is
the element in the set Vnew , and v is not in the set Vnew . Add v to the set Vnew , and
add hu; vi to the set Enew ¼ fg. Repeat this step until Vnew ¼ V.
Using the above procedure, the power network topology is obtained and denoted by
Vnew and Enew .
316 Z. Fu et al.
After the topology of power grid is obtained, the model of optical fiber commu-
nication network need be established based on the structure of the graph, network
construction cost and the constraints of network looping rate and invulnerability.
X
m
C¼ ei wi ð2Þ
i¼1
where C is network construction cost, wi is construction cost of the ith cable line, m is
the number of optical fiber lines to be selected, and ei is
1; The ith cable is selected
ei ¼ : ð3Þ
0; The ith cable is not selected
P
m
DðiÞ
i¼1
KðGÞ ¼ P
m : ð5Þ
Dfull ðiÞ
i¼1
P
where Dfull ðiÞ is the sum of the
P degrees of importance of all nodes in the graph of the
fully connected network, and DðiÞ is the sum of the degrees of importance of all
nodes in the real topology graph, and m is the number of nodes.
The node importance DðiÞ is given by
Si
DðiÞ ¼ ; ð6Þ
li
where Si is the edge weight, li is the degree of node position importance, which is given by
Communication Network Planning with Dual Network Coupling Characteristics 317
1 X m
li ¼ lij ; ð7Þ
m j¼1;j6¼i
X 1
Si ¼ : ð8Þ
ði;jÞ2B
xij
i
For the node i, after setting the distance between the edges directly connected to
node i as the distance value of the shortest line in the topology, lij is the shortest path
distance between nodes i and j. xij is the distance connected by nodes i and j if they are
directly connected, otherwise it is unlimited. So Si is the larger, then the closer the node
is to the surrounding nodes, the more important the position in the network is.
The paper is concerned with the constrain of the network invulnerability and loop
rate. Loop rate is not less than 70% and invulnerability is not less than 0.3.
(2) The optical fiber cost. The optical fiber laid along physical network can save the
cost of constructing the tower and excavating the cable ditch. However, when the
communication network is laid along physical network, it may increase the distance of
fiber laying. Therefore, how to lay the communication network need to be optimized.
According to communication network, if there is a path from node i to node j, and
this path exists in the power grid, calculate the total cost of laid along the power grid
(not include the cost of towers or digging cable ditch) Cost 1, and the total cost Cost 2
of direct connection node i and node j. Compare Cost 1 and Cost 2, select the smaller
value as the topological edge of the communication network.
The upper layer is physical network planning by taking into connectivity and radiation
account. The lower layer is communication network planning by considering invul-
nerability and loop rate constrains. Physical power grid is obtained by the minimum
spanning tree, which is stored in an adjacency matrix [11]. The lower layer is solved by
hybrid PSO and Floyd algorithm, and the specific solution process is shown in Fig. 2.
Start
Yes
Total cost of output and communication
network planning
End
5 Simulation Results
5.1 Simulation Introduction
The case used for communication network planning is a 29 nodes system as shown in
Table 1. The installation cost of the optical fiber with supporting facilities is 0.42
million dollar per kilometer, and the cost per kilometer of the grid along the distribution
network is 0.33 million dollar, and the substation node is equipped with optical fiber.
Communication network planning, the substation node number is “1, 7, 14, 20, 27”.
The loop rate is defined as not less than 70% and the invulnerability not less than 0.3.
1.8 11 4 8
18
1.6 9 10
25 19
24
1.4 20
3
1.2 28 15
5 1
1 2
7 12
0.8
29
0.6
27
23 6
13
0.4
26 22
17
0.2 14 16
21
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
1.4 20
1.2
1
1
7
0.8
0.6
27
0.4
0.2 14
0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
1.2 15
1
2
1
7 12
0.8
29
0.6
27
23 6
13
0.4
17
0.2 14 16
0
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
Fig. 5. 14–17 the shortest path of the node (Color figure online)
1.6
25 19
24
1.4 20
1.2 15
1
2
1
7 12
0.8
29
0.6
27
23 6
13
0.4
17
0.2 14 16
0
0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
The topology is selected by calculating cost of optical fiber laying along the
physical network and the supporting facilities. The total cost of the network is 162.3
dollar. The topology of the communication network planning is shown in Fig. 6, and
the mapping of physical network and communication network is shown in Fig. 7.
To ensure the loop rate, it can be seen that the fiber node 1 and node 14 are directly
connected in Fig. 6. If the communication network is laid along 1-2-7-13-14 nodes, the
loop rate only 60%. Then, to reduce the economic costs of communications network
planning, node 7 and node 14 are laid along physical network by comparing Fig. 4
with Fig. 6.
After considering the loop rate and invulnerability constrain, the communications
network invulnerability improved from 0.2738 to 0.4413. The importance of nodes is
shown in Table 2, and the higher the value, the lower the degree of importance. Case 1
is the initial communication network, and case 2 is the importance of the nodes
obtained by the PSO algorithm. The importance of nodes is significantly reduced as is
in Table 2.
6 Conclusions
Acknowledgments. This work was supported in part by the national Science Foundation of
China under Grant No. 61773253, and project of Science and technology Commission of
Shanghai Municipality under Grants No. 15JC1401900, 14JC1402200, and 17511107002. This
work was also supported in part by the Funds of Nantong Applied Basic Research Plan
(GY12017015) and Qing Lan Project of colleges and universities in Jiangsu province.
References
1. Jiang, L., et al.: Growth in wind and sun: integrating variable generation in China. IEEE
Power Energy Mag. 13(6), 40–49 (2015)
2. Koutsoukis, N.C., Georgilakis, P.S., Hatziargyriou, N.D.: Multistage coordinated planning
of active distribution networks. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 33(1), 32–44 (2018)
3. Samuelsson, O., et al.: Active distribution network — demonstration project ADINE. In:
Innovative Smart Grid Technologies Conference Europe, pp. 1–8. IEEE (2010)
Communication Network Planning with Dual Network Coupling Characteristics 323
4. You, Y., et al.: Technology and its trends of active distribution network. Autom. Electr.
Power Syst. 36(18), 10–16 (2012)
5. Bi, P.X., J, L., Zhang, W.Y.: Improved branch switching method for distribution network
reconfiguration. Proc. CSEE 21(8), 98–103 (2001)
6. Ramirez-Rosado, I.J., Bernal-Agustin, J.L.: Genetic algorithms applied to the design of large
power distribution systems. IEEE Trans. Power Syst. 13(2), 696–703 (1998)
7. Zhou, B.X., Liu, X.Y.: Topology analysis method of distribution network based on network
graphics and its application. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 27(16), 67–70 (2003)
8. Pu, T.J., et al.: Analysis and application design of multi-source collaborative optimization
scheduling architecture for active distribution network. Autom. Electr. Power Syst. 40(1),
17–23 (2016)
9. Cheng, K.Q., Li, S.W., Zhou, J.: Evaluation method of network invulnerability based on
edge weight. Comput. Eng. Appl. 46(35), 95–96 (2010)
10. Shi, Y., Guo, S.Y., Qiu, X.S.: Immune algorithm based route planning method for power
communication network. J. Beijing Univ. Posts Telecommun. 2, 14–17 (2014)
11. Ma, W.Y., Mao, G.W.: System hierarchy division based on graph theory and matrix theory.
J. Lanzhou Jiao Tong Univ. 28(6), 150–154 (2009)
Author Index