Appendix C Experimental Verification Tables

for Response-2000

C-1
Appendix C: Data used in experimental database for Response-2000
Total number of beams: 534

Prestressed beams: 155

Reinforced beams: 379

Beams with axial Load: 57

No axial load: 477

Beams with stirrups 300

No stirrups 234

Shape Codes: R Rectantular 270 tests

I I beam 163 tests
T Tee-beam 90 tests
C Circle 9 tests
INTER Interlocking Spiral Column 2 tests
PC Precast beam

Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
Kani 43 152 137 150 2.75 5.93 R 0.00 28.0 1 28.7 18.1 23.5 1.586 1.221
Reference 45 52 152 137 150 2.73 3.93 R 0.00 25.0 1 28.6 17.2 26.6 1.663 1.075
55 152 137 150 2.80 3.02 R 0.00 25.0 1 32.7 16.8 28.7 1.946 1.139
83 305 270 156 2.74 3.00 R 0.00 27.0 1 65.1 36.8 55.6 1.769 1.171
84 305 270 151 2.84 4.00 R 0.00 27.0 1 55.4 35.6 50.4 1.556 1.099
93 305 270 155 2.66 6.46 R 0.00 30.0 1 53.6 38.6 45.3 1.389 1.183
63 610 543 156 2.77 4.00 R 0.00 26.0 1 93.1 71.3 98.5 1.306 0.945
74 610 543 156 2.77 3.12 R 0.00 27.0 1 107.8 69.1 106.0 1.560 1.017
79 610 543 156 2.72 6.84 R 0.00 26.0 1 84.6 72.3 79.1 1.170 1.070
3043 1219 1090 154 2.71 3.00 R 0.00 27.0 1 164.4 144.8 177.7 1.135 0.925
3044 1219 1090 152 2.72 3.98 R 0.00 30.0 1 158.0 150.9 157.7 1.047 1.002
3046 1219 1090 155 2.70 7.00 R 0.00 27.0 1 153.6 145.9 135.2 1.053 1.136

270 305 270 152 0.50 1.98 R 0.00 17.0 0 41.4 28.1 37.5 1.473 1.104
266 305 270 152 0.50 2.48 R 0.00 17.0 0 32.5 28.1 31.4 1.156 1.035
268 305 270 152 0.50 2.98 R 0.00 17.0 0 27.2 27.3 27.2 0.997 1.000
267 305 270 152 0.50 3.53 R 0.00 17.0 0 24.5 23.1 23.4 1.060 1.046

246 305 270 152 0.50 3.47 R 0.00 28.0 0 25.4 24.0 24.6 1.057 1.031
248 305 270 152 0.50 2.40 R 0.00 28.0 0 37.2 34.7 36.2 1.071 1.026
251 305 270 152 0.50 1.97 R 0.00 28.0 0 41.9 36.0 40.6 1.163 1.032

179 305 270 152 0.50 2.57 R 0.00 35.0 0 33.6 32.4 35.2 1.037 0.954
180 305 270 152 0.50 3.52 R 0.00 35.0 0 24.9 23.6 24.7 1.056 1.009
177 305 270 152 0.50 4.91 R 0.00 35.0 0 18.6 17.0 17.4 1.093 1.068

143 305 270 152 0.80 3.96 R 0.00 17.0 0 30.2 28.1 30.7 1.076 0.985
144 305 270 152 0.80 5.02 R 0.00 17.0 0 27.3 25.5 24.6 1.072 1.112
147 305 270 152 0.80 2.36 R 0.00 17.0 0 42.3 28.1 38.1 1.506 1.110
149 305 270 152 0.80 2.50 R 0.00 17.0 0 43.7 28.1 37.1 1.555 1.177
150 305 270 152 0.80 2.49 R 0.00 17.0 0 46.2 28.1 38.1 1.644 1.212
151 305 270 152 0.80 2.48 R 0.00 17.0 0 35.6 28.1 39.2 1.268 0.909
152 305 270 152 0.80 3.02 R 0.00 17.0 0 32.5 28.1 35.4 1.156 0.918
153 305 270 152 0.80 2.99 R 0.00 17.0 0 32.8 28.1 36.0 1.168 0.912

102 305 270 152 0.80 2.02 R 0.00 26.0 0 48.8 34.7 46.7 1.405 1.045
103 305 270 152 0.80 2.98 R 0.00 26.0 0 38.8 34.7 41.8 1.117 0.928
104 305 270 152 0.80 4.03 R 0.00 26.0 0 33.6 31.8 31.3 1.058 1.075
105 305 270 152 0.80 2.50 R 0.00 26.0 0 41.5 34.7 43.7 1.196 0.951
106 305 270 152 0.80 2.53 R 0.00 26.0 0 44.6 34.7 47.1 1.285 0.948
107 305 270 152 0.80 5.08 R 0.00 26.0 0 25.7 25.2 24.8 1.018 1.034
110 305 270 152 0.80 5.05 R 0.00 26.0 0 27.9 25.3 23.9 1.104 1.168
111 305 270 152 0.80 2.49 R 0.00 26.0 0 43.3 34.7 43.8 1.247 0.989
112 305 270 152 0.80 2.49 R 0.00 26.0 0 39.4 34.7 44.1 1.134 0.893
114 305 270 152 0.80 2.01 R 0.00 26.0 0 61.4 34.7 47.5 1.768 1.293
115 305 270 152 0.80 2.50 R 0.00 26.0 0 45.3 34.7 43.7 1.305 1.037
116 305 270 152 0.80 3.01 R 0.00 26.0 0 39.3 34.7 38.5 1.131 1.021
117 305 270 152 0.80 3.96 R 0.00 26.0 0 32.6 32.3 30.0 1.009 1.087

Ghannoum N220-l 220 190 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 102.7 73.8 82.5 1.392 1.245
Reference 55 N220-h 220 190 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 121.8 73.8 97.3 1.651 1.252
N350-l 350 313 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 156.0 121.5 123.8 1.283 1.260
N350-h 350 313 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 176.5 121.5 151.3 1.452 1.166
N485-l 485 440 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 183.6 170.9 162.3 1.074 1.131
N485-h 485 440 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 211.4 170.9 204.6 1.237 1.033
N960-l 960 889 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 349.7 345.2 274.1 1.013 1.276
N960-h 960 889 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 34.2 0 369.2 345.2 312.4 1.070 1.182

H220-l 220 190 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 104.9 96.6 96.7 1.086 1.085
H220-h 220 190 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 134.4 96.6 115.4 1.392 1.165
H350-l 350 313 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 155.2 159.1 144.4 0.975 1.075
H350-h 350 313 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 187.6 159.1 178.6 1.179 1.050
H485-l 485 440 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 194.5 223.7 189.5 0.869 1.026

C-2
Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
H485-h 485 440 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 195.0 223.7 240.8 0.872 0.810
H960-l 960 889 400 1.20 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 299.9 451.9 317.3 0.664 0.945
H960-h 960 889 400 2.00 2.50 R 0.00 58.6 0 320.6 451.9 359.8 0.710 0.891

Moody A-A1 305 270 178 2.07 3.06 R 0.00 30.3 0 60.1 43.9 53.7 1.367 1.119
Viest A-A2 305 270 178 2.15 3.00 R 0.00 31.0 0 66.8 44.4 58.9 1.502 1.133
Elstner A-A3 305 270 178 2.22 2.99 R 0.00 31.0 0 75.7 44.4 63.6 1.702 1.189
Hognestad A-A4 305 270 178 2.37 2.96 R 0.00 31.5 0 71.2 44.8 66.9 1.590 1.064
Reference 46 A-B1 305 270 178 1.62 3.00 R 0.00 21.2 0 56.3 36.7 50.8 1.533 1.108
A-B2 305 270 178 1.63 2.99 R 0.00 21.6 0 60.1 37.1 49.2 1.621 1.221
A-B3 305 270 178 1.60 2.96 R 0.00 19.2 0 55.6 35.0 49.1 1.589 1.133
A-B4 305 270 178 1.66 2.95 R 0.00 23.7 0 55.6 38.8 55.1 1.434 1.010
A-C1 305 270 178 0.79 2.58 R 0.00 6.3 0 20.0 20.0 24.3 1.000 0.824
A-C2 305 270 178 0.83 2.57 R 0.00 6.1 0 24.5 19.7 25.7 1.242 0.952
A-C3 305 270 178 0.79 2.58 R 0.00 6.9 0 25.4 21.0 28.3 1.210 0.896
A-C4 305 270 178 0.83 2.58 R 0.00 6.8 0 25.1 20.8 29.2 1.209 0.861
B-B1 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 36.7 0 57.9 41.3 53.5 1.402 1.081
B-B2 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 16.7 0 35.6 27.8 40.3 1.279 0.883
B-B3 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 25.8 0 52.3 34.6 47.3 1.511 1.105
B-B4 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 15.4 0 40.5 26.7 39.0 1.516 1.038
B-B5 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 30.7 0 52.1 37.7 50.3 1.380 1.035
B-B6 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 15.8 0 34.5 27.1 39.4 1.274 0.875
B-B7 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 30.9 0 51.2 37.9 50.5 1.351 1.013
B-B8 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 12.2 0 31.2 23.8 35.4 1.309 0.880
B-B9 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 41.2 0 53.4 43.7 55.7 1.222 0.959
B-B10 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 24.0 0 49.0 33.4 46.1 1.467 1.062
B-B11 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 38.1 0 60.1 42.1 54.2 1.428 1.108
B-B12 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 20.2 0 47.2 30.6 43.3 1.540 1.089
B-B13 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 37.8 0 55.6 41.9 54.0 1.328 1.030
B-B14 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 22.6 0 43.2 32.4 45.1 1.334 0.957
B-B15 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 37.4 0 51.2 41.7 53.8 1.229 0.951
B-B16 305 270 152 1.89 3.41 R 0.00 16.3 0 37.8 27.5 39.9 1.373 0.948

Adebar ST1 310 278 360 1.57 5.50 R 0.00 52.5 0 127.2 121.0 127.8 1.051 0.995
Reference 56 ST2 310 278 360 1.57 5.50 R 0.00 52.5 0 118.3 121.0 127.5 0.978 0.928
ST3 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 49.3 0 107.9 94.0 110.5 1.148 0.976
ST8 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 46.2 0 139.3 91.0 108.1 1.531 1.289
ST9 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 46.2 0 70.1 42.0 89.7 1.672 0.782
ST10 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 46.2 0 65.6 27.2 74.5 2.415 0.881
ST11 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 46.2 0 48.5 16.0 59.9 3.038 0.810
ST12 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 46.2 0 46.7 8.8 44.1 5.330 1.060
ST13 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.00 51.5 0 65.6 16.1 61.9 4.071 1.060
ST16 210 178 290 3.04 5.50 R 0.00 51.5 0 74.3 62.0 73.1 1.198 1.016
ST17 410 378 290 1.43 5.50 R 0.00 51.5 0 118.9 131.0 146.3 0.908 0.813
ST23 310 278 290 1.00 5.50 R 0.00 58.9 0 89.9 103.0 101.4 0.873 0.887
ST25 310 278 290 1.00 5.50 R 0.00 58.9 0 81.8 61.9 89.7 1.321 0.912
ST26 310 278 290 1.00 5.50 R 0.00 58.9 0 60.2 44.2 72.3 1.362 0.833
ST4 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.11 49.3 0 158.2 135.0 164.8 1.172 0.960
ST6 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.28 49.3 0 230.1 199.0 246.9 1.157 0.932
ST7 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.28 49.3 0 275.1 199.0 246.9 1.382 1.114
ST18 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.20 49.8 0 246.3 182.0 240.3 1.353 1.025
ST19 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.20 49.8 0 201.4 182.0 240.3 1.106 0.838
ST20 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.20 49.8 0 178.0 129.0 161.8 1.380 1.100
ST21 310 278 290 1.95 5.50 R 0.20 49.8 0 190.6 144.0 193.5 1.324 0.985

Taylor A1 1000 930 400 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 30.9 1 358.4 345.3 336.1 1.038 1.066
Reference 41 A2 1000 930 400 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 27.0 1 328.4 322.8 305.4 1.017 1.075
B1 500 465 200 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 28.9 1 104.3 83.5 94.7 1.249 1.101
B2 500 465 200 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 26.4 1 87.3 79.8 90.3 1.093 0.966
B3 500 465 200 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 34.0 1 85.3 90.6 94.9 0.942 0.899
C1 250 233 100 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 27.2 1 22.5 20.3 26.9 1.109 0.836
C2 250 233 100 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 27.2 1 24.0 20.3 26.0 1.183 0.923
C3 250 233 100 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 28.0 1 27.5 20.6 26.7 1.336 1.030
C4 250 233 100 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 22.1 1 22.5 18.3 24.2 1.230 0.930
C5 250 233 100 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 23.8 1 27.0 19.0 24.8 1.422 1.089
C6 250 233 100 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 30.6 1 27.5 21.5 30.3 1.278 0.908
D1 150 139 60 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 34.0 1 11.6 8.1 11.3 1.428 1.027
D2 150 139 60 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 34.0 1 12.1 8.1 11.3 1.490 1.071
D3 150 139 60 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 34.0 1 10.6 8.1 11.3 1.305 0.938
D4 150 139 60 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 34.0 1 11.4 8.1 11.3 1.404 1.009

Collins SE100A-45 1000 920 295 1.03 2.50 R 0.00 50.0 1 200.0 318.7 241.9 0.628 0.827
Vegh SE100A-45R 1000 920 295 1.03 2.50 R 0.00 50.0 1 235.7 318.7 241.9 0.740 0.974
Reference 57 SE100B-45 1000 920 295 1.03 2.50 R 0.00 50.0 1 312.0 318.7 297.3 0.979 1.049
SE100B-45R 1000 920 295 1.03 2.50 R 0.00 50.0 1 315.8 318.7 297.3 0.991 1.062
SE50A-45 500 445 169 1.03 2.72 R 0.00 53.0 1 68.6 93.4 77.7 0.734 0.883
SE50A-45R 500 445 169 1.03 2.72 R 0.00 53.0 1 80.5 93.4 77.7 0.862 1.036
SE50B-45 500 445 169 1.16 2.72 R 0.00 53.0 1 86.5 93.4 84.7 0.926 1.021

SE100A-83 1000 920 295 1.03 2.50 R 0.00 86.0 1 303.2 374.4 266.5 0.810 1.138
SE100B-83 1000 920 295 1.36 2.50 R 0.00 86.0 1 364.8 374.4 341.7 0.974 1.068
SE100B83R 1000 920 295 1.36 2.50 R 0.00 86.0 1 364.1 374.4 341.7 0.972 1.066
SE50A-83 500 445 169 1.03 2.72 R 0.00 91.0 1 92.9 107.0 90.6 0.868 1.025
SE50B-83 500 445 169 1.16 2.72 R 0.00 91.0 1 100.8 107.0 95.7 0.942 1.053
SE100A-M-69 1000 920 295 1.03 2.50 R 0.15 71.0 0 516.3 569.8 499.3 0.906 1.034
Se100B-M-69 1000 920 295 1.36 2.50 R 0.15 75.0 0 583.2 569.8 642.9 1.024 0.907

C-3
Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
SE50A-M-69 500 445 169 1.03 2.72 R 0.15 74.0 0 138.5 161.3 122.8 0.859 1.128
Se50B-M-69 500 445 169 1.16 2.72 R 0.15 74.0 0 151.8 161.3 148.4 0.941 1.023

Elzanaty CW1 457 373 51 1.43 2.90 I 0.00 76.6 0 138.4 103.8 107.8 1.334 1.284
Nilson CW2 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.00 76.6 0 124.6 108.0 105.5 1.154 1.181
Slate CW3 457 373 51 1.43 5.00 I 0.00 76.6 0 117.5 103.4 106.0 1.136 1.108
Reference 58 CW4 457 373 51 1.03 3.75 I 0.00 78.6 0 127.3 109.7 108.8 1.160 1.170
CW5 457 373 51 3.17 3.75 I 0.00 77.9 0 124.2 108.7 105.0 1.143 1.182
CW7 457 373 51 1.12 3.75 I 0.00 77.6 0 105.9 92.1 92.0 1.150 1.151
CW6 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.00 77.9 0 112.1 93.5 95.1 1.200 1.179
CW9 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.00 61.0 0 101.0 87.0 90.3 1.161 1.119
CW8 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.00 41.4 0 89.9 80.3 83.3 1.119 1.079

CI1 342 290 76 1.57 7.80 I 0.00 76.6 0 77.9 70.8 86.2 1.100 0.903
CI3 342 290 76 1.57 4.00 I 0.00 76.6 0 121.0 103.8 121.0 1.166 1.000
CI2 342 290 76 1.17 5.80 I 0.00 76.6 0 111.3 92.5 104.3 1.203 1.067
CI4 342 290 76 3.35 5.80 I 0.00 78.6 0 108.6 93.8 104.6 1.158 1.038
CI5 342 290 76 1.26 5.80 I 0.00 77.9 0 119.7 93.0 107.1 1.288 1.118
CI7 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.00 77.6 0 81.4 73.4 83.7 1.110 0.973
CI6 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.00 77.9 0 91.2 74.8 89.4 1.219 1.020
CI9 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.00 61.0 0 88.6 71.5 86.6 1.239 1.023
CI8 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.00 41.4 0 86.8 69.0 81.5 1.258 1.065

CW10 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.55 73.1 0 173.6 132.2 143.3 1.313 1.211
CW11 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.55 55.9 0 156.6 125.5 135.3 1.248 1.158
CW12 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.55 40.0 0 140.6 119.3 129.5 1.179 1.086
CW13 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.55 72.4 0 182.5 148.6 153.8 1.228 1.186
CW14 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.79 73.8 0 187.8 167.8 179.3 1.119 1.047
CW15 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.55 70.3 0 150.4 130.4 142.2 1.154 1.058
CW16 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.55 73.1 0 186.9 149.1 156.3 1.254 1.196
CW17 457 373 51 1.43 3.75 I 0.25 69.7 0 142.4 125.5 112.6 1.135 1.265

CI10 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.46 73.1 0 141.5 107.7 127.0 1.314 1.114
CI11 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.46 55.9 0 127.3 104.1 126.6 1.222 1.005
CI12 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.46 40.0 0 122.4 101.5 117.4 1.206 1.042
CI13 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.46 72.4 0 154.9 127.3 143.6 1.217 1.078
CI14 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.73 73.8 0 164.7 150.0 159.6 1.098 1.032
CI15 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.46 70.3 0 121.0 106.4 127.7 1.138 0.948
CI16 342 290 76 3.35 5.80 I 0.46 73.1 0 163.3 128.2 162.1 1.274 1.007
CI17 342 290 76 1.57 5.80 I 0.21 69.7 0 129.5 107.2 110.4 1.207 1.173

Rabbat B1 610 567 305 2.41 3.23 R 0.24 27.1 0 378.3 306.0 357.7 1.236 1.058
Reference 59 B2 610 567 152 4.82 3.23 I 0.48 27.1 0 333.8 229.0 342.8 1.457 0.974

Makwana D1 406 328 406 4.50 2.80 R 0.49 30.1 0 544.0 320.0 497.0 1.700 1.095
Reference 60 D2 406 328 406 4.50 2.80 R 0.49 25.8 0 558.0 330.0 505.6 1.691 1.104

Khalifa SC0 445 356 445 3.82 2.60 C 0.00 23.4 0 326.0 174.0 316.0 1.874 1.032
Reference 47 SC1 445 356 445 3.82 2.60 C 0.10 23.4 0 324.0 241.0 302.1 1.344 1.072
SC2 445 356 445 3.82 2.60 C 0.30 23.4 0 478.0 417.0 462.4 1.146 1.034
SC3 445 356 445 3.82 2.60 C 0.45 23.4 0 578.0 538.0 590.2 1.074 0.979
SC4 445 356 445 3.82 2.60 C 0.30 23.4 0 456.0 380.0 476.2 1.200 0.958

Aregawi EB1 457 366 457 3.78 4.20 C 0.83 39.3 0 358.4 412.0 347.4 0.870 1.032
Reference 61 WB1 457 366 457 3.78 4.20 C 1.11 39.3 0 462.0 463.0 408.4 0.998 1.131
EB2 457 366 457 3.78 4.20 C 0.83 27.6 0 343.0 367.0 310.3 0.935 1.105
WB2 457 366 457 3.78 4.20 C 1.11 27.6 0 433.0 421.0 373.0 1.029 1.161

Podgorniak- B100 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 36.0 1 225.0 276.5 197.5 0.814 1.139
Stanik B100R 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 36.0 1 249.0 276.5 197.5 0.901 1.261
Reference 54 B100D 1000 925 300 1.19 2.92 R 0.00 36.0 1 320.0 276.5 259.3 1.157 1.234
B100H 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 98.0 0 193.0 382.9 256.5 0.504 0.752
BH100E 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 98.0 0 217.0 382.9 256.5 0.567 0.846
B100L 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 39.0 1 223.0 287.8 183.6 0.775 1.215
B100L-R 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 39.0 1 235.0 287.8 183.6 0.817 1.280
B100B 1000 925 300 1.01 2.92 R 0.00 39.0 1 204.0 287.8 197.2 0.709 1.034
BRL100 1000 925 300 0.51 2.70 R 0.00 94.0 0 163.0 384.0 209.4 0.424 0.778

BHD100 1000 925 300 1.19 2.92 R 0.00 99.0 0 278.0 382.9 322.5 0.726 0.862
BHD100R 1000 925 300 1.19 2.92 R 0.00 99.0 0 333.5 382.9 322.5 0.871 1.034
BHD50 500 460 300 1.11 3.00 R 0.00 99.0 0 192.7 186.3 167.5 1.034 1.150
BHD50R 500 460 300 1.11 3.00 R 0.00 99.0 0 204.7 186.3 167.5 1.099 1.222
BHD25 250 225 300 1.31 3.00 R 0.00 99.0 0 111.4 93.1 103.7 1.197 1.074

BH100 1000 925 300 0.76 2.92 R 0.00 99.0 0 193.0 382.9 255.3 0.504 0.756
BH50 500 460 300 0.81 3.00 R 0.00 99.0 0 131.7 186.3 143.8 0.707 0.916
BH25 250 225 300 0.89 3.00 R 0.00 99.0 0 84.8 93.1 87.7 0.911 0.967

BND100 1000 925 300 1.19 2.92 R 0.00 37.0 1 258.0 281.1 248.9 0.918 1.037
BND50 500 460 300 1.11 3.00 R 0.00 37.0 1 162.7 136.8 127.0 1.189 1.281
BND25 250 225 300 1.31 3.00 R 0.00 37.0 1 112.0 68.4 78.8 1.637 1.421

BN100 1000 925 300 0.76 2.92 R 0.00 37.2 1 192.0 204.0 202.1 0.941 0.950
BN50 500 460 300 0.81 3.00 R 0.00 37.2 1 131.7 136.8 116.8 0.963 1.128
BN25 250 225 300 0.89 3.00 R 0.00 37.0 1 72.9 68.4 71.2 1.066 1.024
BN12 125 110 300 0.91 3.07 R 0.00 37.0 1 40.0 33.4 37.6 1.198 1.064

C-4
 Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k

BM100 1000 925 300 1.01 2.70 R 0.09 47.0 0 343.0 424.0 341.0 0.809 1.006
BM100D 1000 925 300 1.20 2.70 R 0.09 47.0 0 462.0 455.0 422.0 1.015 1.095
WM100D 1000 925 1000 0.75 3.00 R 0.04 45.0 0 800.0 1030.0 944.7 0.777 0.847
WM100C 1000 925 1000 0.75 3.00 R 0.04 45.0 0 700.0 1030.0 773.6 0.680 0.905

Kuzmanovic TTC Box 650 615 960 0.71 5.00 R 0.00 45.0 1 347.0 640.0 268.2 0.542 1.294
Reference 62

Shioya Shioya 7 3140 3000 1500 0.40 6.00 R 0.00 24.1 1 1576.9 3667.2 1659.1 0.430 0.950
Iguro Shioya 6 2100 2000 1000 0.40 6.00 R 0.00 28.5 1 840.2 1772.4 774.7 0.474 1.085
Nojiri Shioya 5 1100 1000 500 0.40 6.00 R 0.00 21.9 1 239.1 388.4 237.8 0.616 1.005
Akiyama Shioya 3 660 600 300 0.40 6.00 R 0.00 21.1 0 127.9 137.3 153.8 0.932 0.831
Okada Shioya 2 220 200 158 0.40 6.00 R 0.00 19.7 0 28.9 23.3 32.1 1.239 0.898
Reference 42,43

Kawano A-4 a 2200 2000 600 1.20 3.00 R 0.00 22.2 1 610.5 938.6 588.7 0.650 1.037
Watanabe A-4 b 2200 2000 600 1.20 3.00 R 0.00 23.1 1 560.0 957.4 595.5 0.585 0.940
Ref 63 A-3 a 1050 950 350 1.22 3.00 R 0.00 20.7 0 216.0 251.1 209.5 0.860 1.031
A-3 b 1050 950 350 1.22 3.00 R 0.00 20.6 0 237.5 250.5 208.9 0.948 1.137
A-2 a 570 500 176 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 27.3 0 82.5 76.3 82.1 1.081 1.005
A-2 b 570 500 176 1.35 3.00 R 0.00 27.3 0 101.5 76.3 82.1 1.330 1.236
A-1 a 330 300 105 1.26 3.00 R 0.00 24.8 0 33.5 26.0 31.1 1.286 1.077
A-1 b 330 300 105 1.26 3.00 R 0.00 24.8 0 29.5 26.0 31.1 1.133 0.949

Yoon H1S 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.00 87.0 1 327.0 342.0 333.5 0.956 0.981
Cook N1S 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.00 36.0 1 249.0 246.0 264.3 1.012 0.942
Mitchell M1S 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.00 67.0 1 296.0 336.0 302.3 0.881 0.979
Reference 64 H1N 750 655 375 2.80 2.34 R 0.09 87.0 0 483.0 428.0 435.7 1.129 1.109
H2S 750 655 375 2.80 2.34 R 0.14 87.0 0 598.0 489.0 605.0 1.223 0.988
H2N 750 655 375 2.80 2.34 R 0.23 87.0 0 721.0 628.0 749.9 1.148 0.961
M1N 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.09 67.0 0 405.0 422.0 441.5 0.960 0.917
M2-S 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.13 67.0 0 552.0 459.0 515.8 1.203 1.070
M2-N 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.18 67.0 0 689.0 508.0 636.3 1.356 1.083
N1-N 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.09 36.0 0 457.0 332.0 339.5 1.377 1.346
N2-S 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.09 36.0 0 363.0 332.0 335.9 1.093 1.081
N2-N 750 655 375 2.80 3.23 R 0.13 36.0 0 483.0 369.0 423.8 1.309 1.140

Angelakos DB0530 1000 925 300 0.50 2.70 R 0.00 32.0 1 165.0 262.0 160.0 0.630 1.031
Reference 40 DB130 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.00 30.0 1 185.0 262.0 186.8 0.706 0.990
DB230 1000 925 300 2.00 2.70 R 0.00 32.0 1 272.0 262.0 232.8 1.038 1.168
DB120 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.00 21.0 0 179.0 207.0 167.6 0.865 1.068
DB140 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.00 38.0 0 180.0 282.0 201.2 0.638 0.895
DB165 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.00 65.0 0 185.0 374.0 235.9 0.495 0.784
DB180 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.00 80.0 0 172.0 385.0 241.9 0.447 0.711
DB120M 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.09 21.0 0 282.0 318.0 346.0 0.887 0.815
DB140M 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.09 38.0 0 277.0 393.0 346.0 0.705 0.801
DB165M 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.09 65.0 0 452.0 485.0 415.4 0.932 1.088
DB180M 1000 925 300 1.00 2.70 R 0.09 80.0 0 395.0 496.0 415.2 0.796 0.951
DB0530M 1000 925 300 0.50 2.70 R 0.09 32.0 0 263.0 373.0 244.3 0.705 1.077

Haddadin A1 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.00 29.5 0 116.8 114.5 109.6 1.020 1.066
Mattock A1T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.00 27.9 0 122.4 122.4 97.4 1.000 1.257
Reference 65 C1C 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.00 27.5 0 129.0 118.3 103.4 1.090 1.247
C1 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.00 25.9 0 87.4 85.7 85.1 1.020 1.027
C1T 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.00 29.1 0 73.4 85.3 80.8 0.860 0.908
A2 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.19 29.2 0 194.4 158.0 160.2 1.230 1.213
A3C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 34.0 0 329.4 291.5 263.2 1.130 1.252
A3 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 30.1 0 291.6 249.2 250.7 1.170 1.163
A3T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 29.2 0 244.8 240.0 248.5 1.020 0.985
A4C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.79 28.4 0 389.2 381.6 355.1 1.020 1.096
A4 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.79 28.6 0 342.5 342.5 353.6 1.000 0.969
A4T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.79 29.6 0 345.3 341.9 357.9 1.010 0.965
A5C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.26 27.1 0 467.3 428.7 426.0 1.090 1.097
A5 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.26 26.3 0 387.4 379.8 413.3 1.020 0.937
A5T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.26 27.6 0 405.1 382.2 423.8 1.060 0.956
B3C 470 380 178 3.81 3.40 T 0.42 27.7 0 293.9 264.8 241.6 1.110 1.216
B3 470 380 178 3.81 3.40 T 0.42 27.7 0 271.5 242.4 235.4 1.120 1.153
B3T 470 380 178 3.81 3.40 T 0.42 24.0 0 243.0 231.4 224.9 1.050 1.080

C2C 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.19 27.9 0 202.8 162.2 155.5 1.250 1.304
C2 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.19 27.8 0 173.3 148.2 151.8 1.170 1.142
C2T 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.19 24.0 0 183.6 146.9 155.4 1.250 1.182
C3C 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.42 26.7 0 273.8 253.5 228.1 1.080 1.200
C3C' 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.42 27.3 0 262.1 242.7 227.7 1.080 1.151
C3 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.42 24.1 0 260.3 224.4 216.1 1.160 1.204
C3T 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.42 28.6 0 240.2 237.8 228.9 1.010 1.049
C4C 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.79 26.3 0 309.3 294.6 301.4 1.050 1.026
C4 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.79 25.7 0 310.7 275.0 291.1 1.130 1.067
C4T 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 0.79 27.9 0 289.2 283.6 289.2 1.020 1.000
C5 470 380 178 3.81 4.25 T 1.26 30.4 0 358.4 358.4 337.3 1.000 1.062
D3C 470 380 178 3.81 6.00 T 0.42 29.9 0 226.1 213.3 217.9 1.060 1.038
D3 470 380 178 3.81 6.00 T 0.42 29.3 0 241.1 206.1 209.0 1.170 1.154
D3T 470 380 178 3.81 6.00 T 0.42 26.2 0 216.8 190.2 197.3 1.140 1.099

E2 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.19 15.2 0 169.1 141.0 134.7 1.200 1.256

C-5
Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
E3C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 15.4 0 233.6 253.9 207.2 0.920 1.128
E3 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 13.7 0 189.2 191.1 192.1 0.990 0.985
E3T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 14.7 0 198.6 189.1 168.1 1.050 1.181
E4 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.79 13.4 0 251.4 232.8 255.7 1.080 0.983
E5 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.26 17.1 0 307.5 313.7 341.1 0.980 0.901
F3C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 40.6 0 351.4 297.8 281.6 1.180 1.248
F3 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 44.9 0 329.9 261.8 288.6 1.260 1.143
F3T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 40.0 0 263.5 251.0 271.1 1.050 0.972
G3C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 31.8 0 411.2 345.5 299.9 1.190 1.371
G3 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 26.2 0 332.7 286.8 276.8 1.160 1.202
G3T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 29.4 0 317.3 268.9 284.2 1.180 1.116
G4C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.63 25.2 0 378.9 367.9 359.2 1.030 1.055
G4 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.63 26.8 0 388.8 338.0 340.2 1.150 1.143
G4T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.63 28.1 0 376.1 335.8 346.4 1.120 1.086
G5C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.05 27.9 0 463.0 449.6 450.8 1.030 1.027
G5 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.05 26.1 0 428.0 396.3 431.4 1.080 0.992
G5T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.05 26.7 0 394.8 390.9 433.7 1.010 0.910
H1C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 30.5 0 324.7 275.2 255.6 1.180 1.270
H1 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 29.2 0 283.6 240.4 247.5 1.180 1.146
H1T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 32.3 0 234.6 236.9 249.8 0.990 0.939
H2C 470 380 178 5.72 2.50 T 0.42 30.1 0 324.7 303.5 259.0 1.070 1.254
H2 470 380 178 5.72 2.50 T 0.42 28.2 0 318.7 257.0 247.8 1.240 1.286
H2T 470 380 178 5.72 2.50 T 0.42 31.5 0 256.1 243.9 259.0 1.050 0.989

J3C 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 30.9 0 298.1 266.2 256.7 1.120 1.161
J3 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 30.4 0 263.1 224.8 247.6 1.170 1.062
J3T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.42 28.6 0 187.8 211.1 240.9 0.890 0.780
J4T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 0.79 27.3 0 321.0 248.8 327.0 1.290 0.982
J5 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.26 32.6 0 433.6 333.5 436.3 1.300 0.994
J5T 470 380 178 3.81 2.50 T 1.26 31.7 0 413.5 323.1 430.5 1.280 0.961

Pasley I-1 WE 457 371 191 1.02 T 0.00 31.7 0 67.2 64.5 69.7 1.042 0.964
Gogoi I3-EW 457 371 191 1.00 T 0.00 30.8 0 73.3 77.0 72.0 0.952 1.019
Darwin J1-WW 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.00 31.1 0 64.5 61.9 63.1 1.042 1.023
McCabe J1-WE 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.00 31.1 0 66.8 64.1 63.8 1.042 1.046
Reference 66 J1-EW 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.00 31.1 0 66.3 63.7 63.8 1.042 1.039
J1-EE 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.00 31.1 0 53.4 51.3 62.8 1.042 0.850
J2-EW 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.00 31.0 0 69.0 74.5 65.2 0.926 1.058
I-1 EW 457 371 191 1.02 T 0.00 31.7 0 65.1 61.2 80.3 1.064 0.811
I2-EW 457 371 191 1.00 T 0.08 30.5 0 103.4 122.0 91.0 0.847 1.136
I3-WE 457 371 191 1.00 T 0.08 30.8 0 92.2 95.9 98.5 0.962 0.937
J2-WE 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.08 31.0 0 96.1 93.2 99.7 1.031 0.964
J3-EW 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.08 30.6 0 109.5 135.7 119.1 0.806 0.919
J3-WE 457 371 191 0.88 T 0.15 30.6 0 138.8 151.3 147.1 0.917 0.944

Palaksas #2 457 371 191 0.69 4.14 T 0.00 32.8 0 72.3 67.7 59.0 1.068 1.225
Darwin A00 457 371 191 0.66 3.92 T 0.00 32.7 0 64.8 71.4 61.3 0.908 1.057
Reference 67 B00 457 371 191 0.49 3.88 T 0.00 32.0 0 71.3 71.4 55.9 0.999 1.275
C00 457 371 191 0.94 3.96 T 0.00 29.4 0 59.1 67.3 66.2 0.878 0.893
A25 457 371 191 0.66 3.97 T 0.05 32.5 0 85.8 86.9 80.4 0.987 1.067
#1 457 371 191 0.70 4.18 T 0.36 38.0 0 139.2 126.0 180.0 1.105 0.773
A75 457 371 191 0.66 3.92 T 0.31 32.8 0 142.2 121.3 146.2 1.172 0.973
A50 457 371 191 0.66 3.96 T 0.24 26.3 0 115.4 101.4 111.1 1.138 1.039
A50A 457 371 191 0.66 3.94 T 0.24 26.3 0 109.7 104.5 113.3 1.050 0.968
A25A 457 371 191 0.67 4.00 T 0.05 32.5 0 92.4 86.7 80.9 1.066 1.142
B25 457 371 191 0.49 3.93 T 0.10 30.8 0 78.6 86.0 82.8 0.914 0.949
B50 457 371 191 0.50 3.96 T 0.25 30.3 0 107.0 107.1 112.6 0.999 0.950
C25 457 371 191 0.95 3.98 T 0.10 28.3 0 83.0 82.1 87.0 1.011 0.954
C50 457 371 191 0.94 3.94 T 0.25 29.7 0 134.2 107.1 122.4 1.253 1.096
C75 457 371 191 0.93 3.92 T 0.33 29.4 0 133.6 117.0 151.2 1.142 0.884

Ozcebe ACI56 360 311 150 3.46 5.00 R 0.14 58.0 0 93.6 78.6 87.9 1.191 1.065
Ersoy THS56 360 311 150 3.46 5.00 R 0.14 63.0 0 103.5 84.3 101.1 1.228 1.024
Tankut TS56 360 311 150 3.46 5.00 R 0.24 61.0 0 129.2 91.8 120.5 1.407 1.072
Reference 68 ACI59 360 311 150 4.43 5.00 R 0.14 82.0 0 96.5 90.9 96.5 1.062 1.000
TH59 360 311 150 4.43 5.00 R 0.19 75.0 0 119.3 93.4 113.9 1.277 1.047
TS59 360 311 150 4.43 5.00 R 0.28 82.0 0 125.4 107.4 147.8 1.168 0.848
ACI36 360 311 150 2.59 3.00 R 0.14 75.0 0 105.3 87.8 97.5 1.199 1.080
TH36 360 311 150 2.59 3.00 R 0.17 75.0 0 140.9 91.1 108.6 1.547 1.297
TS36 360 311 150 2.59 3.00 R 0.24 75.0 0 155.9 99.5 134.6 1.567 1.158
ACI39 360 311 150 3.08 3.00 R 0.14 73.0 0 111.8 88.2 96.5 1.268 1.159
TH39 360 311 150 3.08 3.00 R 0.17 73.0 0 142.9 96.4 125.1 1.482 1.142
TS39 360 311 150 3.08 3.00 R 0.27 73.0 0 179.2 104.7 150.1 1.712 1.194

Levi RC 30 A1 1050 933 120 3.50 4.20 I 0.84 25.0 0 676.0 544.0 673.1 1.243 1.004
Marro RC 30 A2 1050 933 120 3.50 4.20 I 0.84 25.0 0 688.0 544.0 673.1 1.265 1.022
Reference 69 RC 60 A1 1050 933 120 4.00 4.20 I 0.84 47.0 0 990.0 578.0 859.2 1.713 1.152
RC 60 A2 1050 933 120 4.00 4.20 I 0.84 47.0 0 938.0 578.0 859.2 1.623 1.092
RC 60 B1 1050 933 120 5.30 4.20 I 1.25 50.0 0 1181.0 807.0 1107.8 1.463 1.066
RC 60 B2 1050 933 120 5.30 4.20 I 1.25 50.0 0 1239.0 807.0 1107.8 1.535 1.118
RC 70 B1 1050 933 120 5.30 4.20 I 1.25 60.0 0 1330.0 820.0 1194.9 1.622 1.113

Roller N1 635 559 356 1.53 2.50 R 0.09 120.0 0 297.0 425.0 326.8 0.699 0.909
& Russel N2 681 559 356 3.01 2.50 R 0.44 120.0 0 1098.0 777.0 947.4 1.413 1.159
Reference 70 N3 719 559 356 4.56 2.50 R 0.89 120.0 0 1655.7 1212.0 1754.4 1.366 0.944
N4 719 559 356 4.56 2.50 R 1.27 120.0 0 1940.0 1578.0 1947.5 1.229 0.996

C-6
 Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
N5 744 564 356 6.59 2.50 R 1.94 120.0 0 2233.9 1886.0 2410.2 1.184 0.927
N6 871 763 457 1.52 3.00 R 0.09 72.4 0 665.6 628.3 616.1 1.059 1.080
N7 871 763 457 1.65 3.00 R 0.16 72.4 0 788.2 750.0 847.2 1.051 0.930
N8 871 763 457 1.65 3.00 R 0.09 125.0 0 483.0 779.6 606.9 0.620 0.796
N9 871 763 457 2.06 3.00 R 0.16 125.0 0 749.8 907.4 928.6 0.826 0.807
N10 871 763 457 2.53 3.00 R 0.21 125.0 0 1172.3 1034.1 1165.2 1.134 1.006

Benzoni INTER4 - push 610 457 406 2.00 4.10 INTER 0.20 37.0 0 376.0 367.6 1.023
Reference 49 INTER4 - pull 610 457 406 2.00 4.10 INTER 0.20 37.0 0 677.0 635.3 1.066

Arbesman CF1 610 560 152 0.40 3.00 I 0.60 38.6 0 465.9 437.5 1.065
Conte
Reference 71, 5

Arbesman SA1 610 584 305 0.85 3.00 R 0.21 48.0 0 374.0 346.0 425.2 1.081 0.880
Reference 72 SA2 610 564 152 0.85 3.00 I 0.43 48.0 0 324.0 235.0 366.8 1.379 0.883
SA3 610 549 152 3.30 3.00 I 1.17 40.0 0 730.0 478.0 730.5 1.527 0.999

Rangan S1-1 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 63.6 0 228.3 163.0 233.5 1.401 0.978
Kong S1-2 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 63.6 0 208.3 163.0 233.5 1.278 0.892
Reference 73 S1-3 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 63.6 0 206.1 163.0 233.5 1.264 0.883
S1-4 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 63.6 0 277.9 163.0 233.5 1.705 1.190
S1-5 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 63.6 0 253.3 163.0 233.5 1.554 1.085
S1-6 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 63.6 0 224.1 163.0 233.5 1.375 0.960
S2-1 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.11 72.5 0 260.3 145.0 186.1 1.795 1.399
S2-2 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.13 72.5 0 232.5 154.0 213.7 1.510 1.088
S2-3 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 72.5 0 253.3 167.5 245.0 1.512 1.034
S2-4 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 72.5 0 219.4 167.5 245.0 1.310 0.896
S2-5 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.21 72.5 0 282.1 188.0 290.4 1.500 0.971
S2-6 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.26 72.5 0 359.0 210.0 313.8 1.709 1.144
S3-1 350 297 250 1.40 2.50 R 0.10 67.4 0 209.2 149.3 172.2 1.401 1.215
S3-2 350 297 250 1.40 2.50 R 0.10 67.4 0 178.0 149.3 172.2 1.192 1.034
S3-3 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.10 67.4 0 228.6 147.3 192.7 1.552 1.186
S3-4 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.10 67.4 0 174.9 147.3 192.7 1.187 0.908
S4-4 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 87.3 0 258.1 167.5 242.5 1.541 1.064
S4-6 250 198 250 2.80 2.53 R 0.16 87.3 0 202.9 113.2 162.6 1.792 1.248
S5-1 350 293 250 2.80 3.01 R 0.16 89.4 0 241.7 167.5 241.9 1.443 0.999
S5-2 350 293 250 2.80 2.74 R 0.16 89.4 0 259.9 167.5 259.0 1.551 1.003
S5-3 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 89.4 0 243.8 167.5 247.8 1.455 0.984
S7-1 350 293 250 4.50 3.30 R 0.11 74.8 0 217.2 145.6 204.0 1.492 1.065
S7-2 350 293 250 4.50 3.30 R 0.13 74.8 0 205.4 154.4 231.1 1.331 0.889
S7-3 350 293 250 4.50 3.30 R 0.16 74.8 0 246.5 167.5 263.4 1.471 0.936
S7-4 350 293 250 4.50 3.30 R 0.20 74.8 0 273.6 185.1 305.0 1.478 0.897
S7-5 350 293 250 4.50 3.30 R 0.22 74.8 0 304.4 196.1 326.6 1.552 0.932
S7-6 350 293 250 4.50 3.30 R 0.26 74.8 0 310.6 210.0 352.6 1.479 0.881
S8-1 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.11 74.6 0 272.1 145.6 211.2 1.869 1.288
S8-2 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.13 74.6 0 250.9 154.4 240.8 1.625 1.042
S8-3 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 74.6 0 309.6 167.5 264.6 1.848 1.170
S8-4 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.16 74.6 0 265.8 167.5 264.6 1.587 1.005
S8-5 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.20 74.6 0 289.2 183.7 301.7 1.575 0.959
S8-6 350 293 250 2.80 2.50 R 0.22 74.6 0 283.9 196.1 310.3 1.448 0.915

Rangan I-1 615 570 74 3.20 2.48 I 2.70 36.5 0 453.1 208.9 454.9 2.169 0.996
Reference 74 I-2 615 570 74 3.20 2.48 I 1.50 30.5 0 371.0 190.0 358.7 1.953 1.034
I-3 615 570 63 3.20 2.48 I 3.20 31.2 0 369.1 164.4 345.0 2.245 1.070
I-4 615 570 64 3.20 2.48 I 1.80 35.7 0 416.0 178.7 364.7 2.328 1.141

II-1 615 570 64 2.23 2.48 I 1.90 45.0 0 460.9 266.7 436.0 1.728 1.057
II-2 615 570 63 2.23 2.48 I 3.20 31.5 0 378.8 225.2 367.2 1.682 1.032
II-3 615 570 73 2.23 2.48 I 1.70 44.6 0 489.2 298.8 458.5 1.637 1.067
II-4 615 570 74 2.23 2.48 I 2.70 43.0 0 479.4 297.7 533.1 1.610 0.899

III-1 615 570 66 1.80 2.50 I 1.84 40.0 0 368.0 296.2 414.1 1.242 0.889
III-2 615 570 66 1.80 2.50 I 3.00 37.0 0 390.5 274.0 404.2 1.425 0.966
III-3 615 570 77 1.80 2.50 I 1.60 39.0 0 396.5 336.9 440.9 1.177 0.899
III-4 615 570 73 1.80 2.50 I 2.80 37.0 0 453.0 303.1 450.6 1.495 1.005

IV-1 615 570 62 0.89 2.50 I 3.20 37.1 0 375.0 246.1 407.0 1.524 0.921
IV-2 615 570 64 0.89 2.50 I 1.90 33.0 0 337.8 226.0 365.5 1.495 0.924
IV-3 615 570 72 0.89 2.50 I 2.80 36.0 0 464.8 277.3 373.5 1.676 1.244
IV-4 615 570 72 0.89 2.50 I 1.70 28.7 0 390.6 221.1 359.8 1.767 1.086

MacGregor AD.14.37A 305 258 152 6.00 3.55 R 0.00 18.6 0 29.4 40.5 0.725
Reference 48 AD.14.37B 305 258 152 6.00 3.55 R 0.00 18.6 0 42.3 40.5 1.044
AW.14.39 305 215 152 6.00 4.22 R 0.26 37.7 0 62.3 71.8 0.868
AW.14.76 305 215 152 6.00 4.25 R 0.26 19.1 0 49.4 54.6 0.905
AW.24.48 305 215 152 6.00 4.25 R 0.26 33.8 0 64.1 61.6 1.041
AW.24.68 305 217 151 5.95 4.22 R 0.26 17.3 0 53.8 53.5 1.006
B.14.34 305 262 79 3.10 3.50 I 0.00 21.3 0 39.6 36.9 1.072
B.14.41 305 254 76 3.00 3.60 I 0.00 20.7 0 42.3 42.7 0.990
BD.14.18 305 257 72 2.83 3.56 I 0.00 44.1 0 49.0 46.3 1.058
BE.14.19 305 259 74 2.90 3.53 I 0.00 46.3 0 49.4 46.7 1.057
BD.14.23 305 257 76 3.00 3.56 I 0.00 29.0 0 24.9 28.0 0.889
BD.14.26 305 264 76 3.00 3.46 I 0.00 21.8 0 28.5 31.6 0.901
BD.14.27 305 257 76 3.00 3.56 I 0.00 26.6 0 42.3 36.5 1.159
BD.14.28 305 257 76 3.00 3.56 I 0.00 29.2 0 44.1 39.2 1.125

C-7
Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
BD.14.34 305 260 76 3.00 3.52 I 0.00 18.8 0 38.7 30.7 1.261
BD.14.35 305 257 75 2.95 3.56 I 0.00 18.0 0 28.9 31.2 0.929
BD.14.42 305 257 74 2.90 3.56 I 0.00 20.6 0 44.1 38.7 1.138
BD.24.32 305 257 76 3.00 3.56 I 0.00 21.3 0 39.2 32.5 1.205
BV.14.30 305 257 75 2.95 3.56 I 0.28 29.0 0 54.3 44.1 1.232
BV.14.32A 305 257 72 2.85 3.55 I 0.32 29.0 0 59.2 45.4 1.304
BV.14.32B 305 257 72 2.85 3.55 I 0.32 29.0 0 65.0 45.4 1.431
BV.14.34 305 258 76 3.00 3.55 I 0.30 26.2 0 56.5 47.2 1.198
BV.14.35 305 259 74 2.92 3.53 I 0.40 23.0 0 54.3 48.1 1.130
BV.14.42 305 258 73 2.88 3.55 I 0.35 21.3 0 56.1 43.6 1.286
BW.14.20 305 266 75 2.95 3.44 I 0.10 19.6 0 35.6 28.9 1.231
BW.14.22 305 257 76 3.00 3.56 I 0.28 38.1 0 61.0 50.7 1.202
BW.14.23 305 253 77 3.02 3.61 I 0.15 37.0 0 62.3 50.7 1.228
BW.14.26 305 257 73 2.86 3.56 I 0.22 28.8 0 49.4 43.2 1.144
BW.14.31 305 257 76 3.00 3.56 I 0.29 22.0 0 56.5 47.6 1.187
BW.14.32 305 259 73 2.86 3.53 I 0.14 19.6 0 45.4 36.5 1.244
BW.14.38 305 257 75 2.95 3.56 I 0.19 19.9 0 57.4 43.6 1.316
BW.14.39 305 257 74 2.90 3.56 I 0.40 21.5 0 57.9 51.2 1.130
BW.14.41 305 258 75 2.95 3.55 I 0.28 21.0 0 52.5 46.3 1.135
BW.14.42 305 258 75 2.96 3.55 I 0.28 19.8 0 53.0 46.3 1.144
BW.14.43 305 257 75 2.95 3.56 I 0.40 20.1 0 54.3 52.5 1.034
BW.14.45 305 257 76 3.00 3.55 I 0.26 21.4 0 53.4 46.3 1.154
BW.14.58 305 253 74 2.91 3.61 I 0.20 23.4 0 67.2 52.5 1.280
BW.14.60 305 253 73 2.89 3.61 I 0.20 18.8 0 63.6 50.7 1.254
BW.15.34 305 258 76 3.00 4.73 I 0.19 25.0 0 42.3 37.8 1.118
BW.15.37 305 257 76 3.00 4.74 I 0.28 22.8 0 42.3 40.9 1.033
BW.16.38 305 255 76 3.00 5.37 I 0.19 26.2 0 36.9 35.6 1.038
BW.18.15 305 258 76 3.00 6.90 I 0.14 50.1 0 34.3 33.9 1.009
BW.18.27 305 258 76 3.00 6.90 I 0.39 32.1 0 32.9 33.3 0.988
BW.19.28 305 258 80 3.15 7.68 I 0.37 30.5 0 29.4 29.7 0.988
BW.28.26 305 259 77 3.05 6.86 I 0.32 22.1 0 26.3 23.7 1.107
BW.28.28 305 259 75 2.95 6.88 I 0.35 23.2 0 25.8 23.3 1.106
C.13.23N 305 264 45 1.79 2.60 I 0.00 23.9 0 23.1 29.4 0.788
C.13.23S 305 264 45 1.79 2.60 I 0.00 23.9 0 30.3 29.4 1.030
CD.13.24N 305 268 45 1.77 2.56 I 0.00 26.6 0 32.9 29.8 1.104
CD.13.24S 305 268 45 1.77 2.56 I 0.00 26.6 0 32.0 29.8 1.075
CD.13.25 305 266 46 1.82 2.58 I 0.00 20.8 0 36.0 29.4 1.227
CD.14.34 305 260 44 1.75 3.52 I 0.00 18.3 0 24.0 26.3 0.915
CW.13.28 305 255 44 1.75 2.79 I 0.95 26.6 0 77.0 62.3 1.236
CW.13.38 305 255 46 1.80 2.79 I 1.09 22.7 0 72.5 63.6 1.140
CW.14.14 305 255 44 1.72 3.58 I 0.35 46.4 0 62.7 55.2 1.137
CW.14.15 305 267 43 1.70 3.43 I 0.98 19.0 0 34.7 37.1 0.936
CW.14.16 305 266 44 1.75 3.44 I 0.26 21.9 0 34.3 27.1 1.262
CW.14.17 305 266 45 1.76 3.43 I 0.16 19.8 0 33.8 24.5 1.382
CW.14.18 305 267 43 1.70 3.43 I 1.35 20.3 0 35.6 36.9 0.964
CW.14.19 305 266 45 1.78 3.44 I 0.32 19.8 0 35.6 32.0 1.111
CW.14.20 305 266 43 1.70 3.43 I 0.34 20.3 0 35.6 31.2 1.143
CW.14.21 305 267 43 1.70 3.42 I 0.24 17.8 0 33.8 25.8 1.310
CW.14.22 305 258 43 1.71 3.55 I 0.67 32.1 0 60.1 49.8 1.205
CW.14.23 305 266 44 1.75 3.44 I 0.24 19.3 0 33.8 25.8 1.310
CW.14.24 305 266 44 1.75 3.44 I 0.37 20.0 0 34.3 31.2 1.100
CW.14.25 305 258 46 1.80 3.55 I 0.92 37.4 0 61.4 62.3 0.986
CW.14.26 305 267 43 1.70 3.43 I 0.49 16.7 0 34.7 32.5 1.068
CW.14.35 305 256 44 1.75 3.58 I 0.80 22.5 0 55.2 53.0 1.042
CW.14.36 305 257 47 1.86 3.56 I 0.84 22.6 0 57.9 54.7 1.057
CW.14.37 305 257 43 1.70 3.56 I 0.49 30.8 0 55.6 42.7 1.302
CW.14.39 305 257 44 1.75 3.56 I 0.33 23.2 0 47.2 38.7 1.218
CW.14.40 305 258 44 1.75 3.55 I 1.19 21.0 0 56.5 57.7 0.979
CW.14.42 305 257 43 1.70 3.56 I 0.68 21.9 0 56.1 49.0 1.145
CW.14.45 305 257 42 1.65 3.55 I 1.01 21.8 0 50.3 51.2 0.983
CW.14.47 305 258 43 1.70 3.55 I 0.67 18.2 0 51.6 43.2 1.196
CW.14.50 305 258 44 1.75 3.55 I 0.89 16.9 0 52.1 47.2 1.104
CW.14.51 305 252 46 1.80 3.63 I 0.45 24.2 0 56.5 42.7 1.323
CW.14.54 305 253 45 1.78 3.61 I 0.46 24.1 0 58.7 44.9 1.307
CW.18.15 305 257 44 1.73 6.93 I 0.35 46.3 0 46.7 33.5 1.395
CW.28.26 305 256 45 1.78 6.94 I 0.68 26.9 0 23.6 23.5 1.004
CW.28.28 305 259 47 1.84 6.88 I 0.68 21.9 0 23.6 23.3 1.010
FW.14.06 305 312 44 1.75 2.93 I 1.04 22.9 0 81.0 71.6 1.130
FW.14.07 305 312 47 1.85 2.93 I 1.06 27.8 0 87.9 85.0 1.034

Shahawy A0-00-R N 1118 995 152 1.00 2.17 I 0.96 58.5 0 1392.9 1023.5 1045.8 1.361 1.332
Batchelor A0-00-R S 1118 995 152 1.00 2.17 I 0.96 58.5 0 1228.2 1023.5 1045.8 1.200 1.174
Ref 75, 76 A1-00-R/2 N 1118 996 152 1.00 2.60 I 0.42 49.0 0 738.7 636.4 774.3 1.161 0.954
A1-00-R/2 S 1118 997 152 1.00 3.16 I 0.38 49.0 0 769.9 574.1 787.7 1.341 0.977
A1-00-R N 1118 996 152 1.00 2.60 I 0.83 49.1 0 934.5 898.9 961.2 1.040 0.972
A1-00-R S 1118 997 152 1.00 3.16 I 0.75 49.1 0 925.6 729.8 905.6 1.268 1.022
A1-00-3R/2 N 1118 996 152 1.00 2.60 I 1.25 52.4 0 921.2 890.0 1059.1 1.035 0.870
A1-00-3R/2 S 1118 997 152 1.00 3.16 I 1.13 52.4 0 1023.5 867.8 913.8 1.179 1.120
A2-00-2R N 1118 996 152 1.00 2.60 I 1.66 48.5 0 1143.7 1174.8 1101.0 0.973 1.039
A2-00-3R N 1118 996 152 1.00 2.60 I 2.50 50.3 0 1143.7 1210.4 1101.0 0.945 1.039
A2-00-3R S 1118 995 152 1.00 2.17 I 2.86 50.3 0 1388.4 1201.5 1272.7 1.156 1.091
A4-00-0R(1) N 1118 998 152 1.00 2.29 I 0.00 52.4 0 417.9 449.5 364.9 0.930 1.145
A4-00-0R(1) S 1118 998 152 1.00 2.29 I 0.00 52.4 0 434.3 449.5 364.9 0.966 1.190
B0-00-R N 1118 1004 152 1.10 2.58 I 0.83 51.4 0 979.0 863.3 912.3 1.134 1.073
B0-00-R S 1118 1003 152 1.10 3.14 I 0.38 51.4 0 916.7 716.5 922.4 1.280 0.994
B0-00-2R N 1118 1004 152 1.10 2.58 I 1.66 49.9 0 992.4 1179.3 1094.2 0.842 0.907

C-8
Researcher Beam Depth d Width Long. ρ a/d ratio Shape Trans. ρ fc ' Used in Test V ACI V R2k V Exp/ Exp/
Name (mm) (mm) (mm) (%) (%) (MPa) Fig 10-1 (kN) (kN) (kN) Pred-ACI Pred-R2k
B0-00-2R S 1118 1003 152 1.10 3.14 I 1.25 49.9 0 961.2 987.9 900.0 0.973 1.068
B0-00-3R N 1118 1004 152 1.10 2.58 I 2.50 53.0 0 1028.0 1241.6 1121.4 0.828 0.917
B0-00-3R S 1118 1003 152 1.10 3.14 I 2.25 53.0 0 1050.2 1210.4 922.4 0.868 1.138
C0-00-R N 1118 1010 152 1.00 3.57 I 0.31 51.6 0 783.2 654.2 766.8 1.197 1.021
C0-00-R S 1118 1010 152 1.00 3.32 I 0.63 51.6 0 801.0 712.0 824.9 1.125 0.971
C1-00-R N 1118 1010 152 1.00 3.57 I 0.31 51.2 0 787.7 654.2 766.8 1.204 1.027
C1-00-R S 1118 1010 152 1.00 3.32 I 0.63 51.2 0 872.2 712.0 824.9 1.225 1.057
C1-00-3R/2 N 1118 1010 152 1.00 3.32 I 0.47 49.8 0 854.4 876.7 824.9 0.975 1.036
C1-00-3R/2 S 1118 1010 152 1.00 3.17 I 0.73 49.8 0 898.9 881.1 864.1 1.020 1.040

Count 534 534 534 534 521 534 534 534 534 448 534 448 534
Average 516 452 198 2.15 3.44 0.32 42 0 243 258 236 1.20 1.05
Minimum 125 110 42 0.40 1.97 0.00 6 0 11 8 11 0.42 0.71
Maximum 3140 3000 1500 6.59 7.80 3.20 125 1 2234 3667 2410 5.33 1.43
Coefficient of Variation 32.1 12.0

C-9