Chapter 1
Chapter 1
MANAGEMENT
Herman Aguinis
Performance appraisal
Assesses employee
Strengths &
Weaknesses
Once a year
Lacks ongoing feedback
Driven by HR
Contributions of PM
For Employees
The definitions of job and success are clarified
Motivation to perform is increased
Self-esteem is increased
Self-insight and development and enhanced
Contributions of PM
For Managers
Supervisors views of performance are
communicated more clearly
Managers gain insight about subordinates
There is better and more timely differentiation
between good and poor performers
Employees become more competent
Contributions of PM
For Organization/HR Function
Organizational goals are made clear
Organizational change is facilitated
Administrative actions are more fair and
appropriate
There is better protection from lawsuits
Disadvantages/Dangers of
Poorly-implemented PM Systems
for Employees
Lowered self-esteem
Employee burnout and job dissatisfaction
Damaged relationships
Use of false or misleading information
Disadvantages/Dangers of
Poorly-implemented PM Systems
for Managers
Increased turnover
Decreased motivation to perform
Unjustified demands on managers resources
Varying and unfair standards and ratings
Disadvantages/Dangers of
Poorly-implemented PM Systems
for Organization
Tangible returns
Cash compensation
Base pay
Cost-of-Living & Contingent Pay
Incentives (short- and long-term)
Benefits, such as
Income Protection
Allowances
Work/life focus
Intangible returns
Relational returns, such as
Recognition and status
Employment security
Challenging work
Learning opportunities
Degree of Dependency
Low
Low
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
Moderate
High
High
High
Purposes of PM Systems:
Overview
Strategic
Administrative
Informational
Developmental
Organizational maintenance
Documentation
Strategic Purpose
Link employee behavior with organizations
goals
Communicate most crucial business strategic
initiatives
Administrative Purpose
Provide information for making decisions re:
Salary adjustments
Promotions
Retention or termination
Recognition of individual performance
Layoffs
Informational Purpose
Communicate to Employees:
Expectations
What is important
How they are doing
How to improve
Developmental Purpose
Performance feedback/coaching
Identification of individual strengths and
weaknesses
Causes of performance deficiencies
Tailor development of individual career path
Documentational Purpose
Validate selection instruments
Document administrative decisions
Help meet legal requirements
Thorough
All employees are evaluated
All major job responsibilities are evaluated
Evaluations cover performance for entire
review period
Feedback is given on both positive and
negative performance
Practical
Available
Easy to use
Acceptable to decision makers
Benefits outweigh costs
Meaningful
Standards are important and relevant
System measures ONLY what employee can
control
Results have consequences Evaluations
occur regularly and at appropriate times
System provides for continuing skill
development of evaluators
Specific
Concrete and detailed guidance to
employees
whats expected
how to meet the expectations
Reliable
Consistent
Free of error
Inter-rater reliability
Valid
Relevant (measures what is important)
Not deficient (doesnt measure unimportant
facets of job)
Not contaminated (only measures what the
employee can control)
Inclusive
Represents concerns of all involved
When system is created, employees should help
with deciding
What should be measured
How it should be measured
Correctable
Recognizes that human judgment is fallible
Appeals process provided
Standardized
Ongoing training of managers to provide
Consistent evaluations across
People
Time
Ethical
Supervisor suppresses self-interest
Supervisor rates only where she has sufficient
information about the performance dimension
Supervisor respects employee privacy