Leadership and Ethics: Utilitarianism

Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
Download as pptx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 16

Leadership and Ethics

Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism
What is Utilitarianism?
Utilitarianism
Utilitarianism:
◦ The moral philosophy that actions derive their
moral quality from their usefulness as means to
some end, especially as means productive of
happiness or unhappiness.
◦ Applied to civics and politics, the greatest
happiness of the greatest number should be the
sole end and criterion of all public action.
Utilitarianism
Who was Jeremy Bentham?
Utilitarianism
Jeremy Bentham’s Utilitarianism
Recognized as ‘Act Utilitarian’
Right actions result in ‘good or pleasure,’
wrong actions result in pain or absence of
pleasure.
‘Max pleasure/min suffering morality
criticized as “pig-philosophy”
Hedonic Calculus
Utilitarianism
Some have argued lecture, that “the
ends cannot justify the means” in moral
choices.

Would a utilitarian say that the ends can


justify the means?
Utilitarianism
“Hedonic Calculus:” measuring pleasure
and pain using what amounts to a formula
(for a group, it measures intensity,
duration, certainty, propinquity, fecundity,
purity, and extent.). This calculation
allows a utility based decision to be made
on virtually any subject.
Utilitarianism
Who was John Stuart Mill?
Utilitarianism
John Stuart Mill’s Utilitarianism
A more sophisticated form of
Utilitarianism.
Concerned with quality of pleasure
and quantity of people who enjoy it.
Recognized higher and lower types of
human pleasure.
Utilitarianism
John Stuart Mill’s Utilitarianism
Lower pleasures: eating, drinking,
sexuality, etc.
Higher pleasures: intellectuality,
creativity and spirituality.
‘Better to be Socrates dissatisfied than
a fool satisfied’
‘Rule’ Utilitarian?
Utilitarianism
“Society and the Bomb”

Who was Henry L. Stimson?


Why did he advise President Truman to
drop the bomb?
Utilitarianism
“Society and the Bomb”

Iskilling the innocent always wrong, no


matter what the consequences?
Would you have advised President
Truman to drop the bomb?
Medical Triage

1 2 3

Will D ie witho ut W ill live Mig ht save if they


Extraordinary -- do n’t treat now Get Medical attention
meas ures
Utilitarianism
Your military strategists have targeted a significant
munitions factory located next to a children’s hospital.
Obliterating the factory is crucial to the success of your
overall campaigning. Any hit on the factory will impact
the hospital.
How would you decide what to do using Utilitarian
principles?
Do you find the Utilitarian recommendations morally
satisfactory?
Utilitarianism
The Chief Executive Officer of large
corporations often earn from 18 to 30 times
more per year as the average employee in
those corporations.
Can you think of a Utilitarian defense for
this “salary pyramid”?
Can your think of some objections that a
Utilitarian might raise to this radically
unequal distribution of economic
benefits?
Utilitarianism
“Society and the Bomb”
Do you agree that in some
circumstances the use of nuclear
weapons is morally permissible?
A tenet of Utilitarianism is that each
person counts for one and only one.
On this view then is there a difference
between the moral worth of the lives
of a civilian and a combatant? In light
of this, ought there to be a
difference?

You might also like