Not sure why I came here, but I definitely stayed for the haram.
As a teen, I would've side-eyed the hell out of Shadi. But as an adult, I get it. I toNot sure why I came here, but I definitely stayed for the haram.
As a teen, I would've side-eyed the hell out of Shadi. But as an adult, I get it. I totally get it. People are messy and life is confusing and I don't blame Shadi for her missteps.
Initially, I gave this 3 stars, but I'm bumping it up because I connected with her musings on life, religion, morality, etc. at the end of the book. Mostly because I feel the same way. Guess we're both going to hell. Only God can judge us.
"I’d always seen religion as a rope, a tool to help us grow nearer to our own hearts, to our place in this universe. I did not understand those who would malign, without forgiveness or empathy, others who did not conform to a series of static rules—rules that were never meant to inspire competition, but to build us up, make us better. Such moral superiority was antithetical to the essence of divinity, to the point of faith. It was made clear, time and time again, that it was not our place to exercise harsh, human judgment over those whose hearts we did not know. It was made unequivocally clear in the Qur’an that there should be no compulsion in religion.
J'adore ce petit livre ! J'apprends le langue français et j'ai voulu des livres jeunesse avec diversité ethnique. Ce livre était parfait.J'adore ce petit livre ! J'apprends le langue français et j'ai voulu des livres jeunesse avec diversité ethnique. Ce livre était parfait....more
I had so much fun with this book! Sure, it's very YA, the
"No," he whispered back. "Destroy me."
I am absolutely living for this quote, fam.
I had so much fun with this book! Sure, it's very YA, the FMC has purple--excuse me, mauve--hair (lmfao), every major reveal was pretty obvious, and the schoolkid crushes were ingratiating to the point where my retinas would've detached if I rolled my eyes for the umpteenth time.
But!
Despite all of that, I still loved the characters and the setting! Also, y'all, I love vampires so I'm biased to all hell.
Arthie, Jin, Laith, and Flick each had their own unique personalities and I'd love to be friends with the gang. For a YA novel, everyone actually reads age-appropriate, which, oddly, isn't usually something you find often. (Teens usually read way too young in the YA fantasies I've been reading lately).
I loved how this is unapologetically BIPOC, with a lead FMC from a colonized nation, Ceylan, living in the colonizer's land, Ettenia, and finding success on her own terms by creating and running a teahouse/bloodhouse. I would absolutely love to read a prequel about Arthie's past. I want her as my ride or die, no lie.
I loved the setting! While I would've loved for a unique world that didn't have to rely on terms in our own world (sari, qipao, etc.), it's totally fine. This isn't high or epic fantasy.
I know this book is only about Ettenia, but the inclusion of Arawiya (which is from the author's other series, which I DNF), and learning about Arthie's childhood in Ceylan, makes me wish for more geopolitics on a grander scale.
But despite that, White Roaring reads like a fantasy Victorian London. So, it feels very familiar despite being set in a fantasy world. I'm also a huge fan of fantasy Victorian England settings, so I might be a little biased here.
Actually, this entire world is a thinly veiled colonial era England, complete with its very own British East India Company. So, if you know your world history, it's very easy to draw comparisons.
There are a couple of quotes/excerpts that I really liked that touched on colonialism:
"She'd [Arthie] spun a business out of tea leaves because the Ettenians had found her tiny island of Ceylan and cultivated it to their liking. What lives the Ettenian soldiers in red uniforms hadn't stolen were claimed either by disease or deforestation that spawned landslides and floods in a country unprepared for such wrath, simply because they wanted to make room for crops like rubber and tea."
"They collected trophies for civilizing countries that had never asked for a redefinition of the word."
Anyway, I'm so glad I snagged a signed Waterstones SE before they sold out!
I'm excited to read the next installment!
Thank you to Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR) and NetGalley for this arc....more
This fits The Diverse Baseline February Prompt C: A book by a BIPOC author with found family.
3.5 stars rounded up!
This was a fun beginning to a BIPOC This fits The Diverse Baseline February Prompt C: A book by a BIPOC author with found family.
3.5 stars rounded up!
This was a fun beginning to a BIPOC superhero series that focuses on an ordinary group of people gaining superpowers. The rating is M, but I think this is definitely appropriate for the YA set.
I think this is a great intro to superhero comic books for someone who's looking for a story that isn't Marvel or DC, or anything else steeped in so much lore and history that it's hard to dive in without prior knowledge.
The art is colorful and drawn in the style of cartoon characters (hence why I think this is great for YA readers). What you see is what you get, so nothing is tricky or difficult to interpret.
I really like the Average Jane and found family themes even though they're very cliche. But since this is only the first volume, I'll let it slide since the story and characters are still finding their legs and it serves as a character origin story for a few of the Zodiac heroes.
I'd be interested to see where this goes!
Thank you to Image Comics and Edelweiss for this arc....more
This fits The Diverse Baseline February Prompt C: A book by a BIPOC author with found family.
4.5 stars rounded up.
Consider me a new fan!
This is a simpThis fits The Diverse Baseline February Prompt C: A book by a BIPOC author with found family.
4.5 stars rounded up.
Consider me a new fan!
This is a simple tale about second chances, finding the goodness in others, and leaving the past behind. There's found family and a badass cyborg FMC who's soft for her new family, yet ruthless when it comes to anyone who threatens them.
The action and fight sequences are great. There was enough blood and violence without being gratuitous.
I love how this is a BIPOC sci-fi written and illustrated by a BIPOC creator. Usually these types of redemption/revenge stories are written by white dudes and geared towards white folks. It's nice to see something different for a change and I welcome this era of inclusivity.
Another thing I loved about this is that the FMC, Meris, isn't sexualized. It's such a breath of fresh air. As a huge Marvel fan who has read a lot of Black Widow comic books, seeing a badass female character sexualized in ridiculously tight clothing while wearing heels to a fight gets exhausting.
Anyway, I'm very excited to read the first part of this story! I'm actually glad this volume is more of a spiritual successor/sequel to Count. You don't need to know anything about that one to read Cyn.
Thank you to Humanoids, Inc. and NetGalley for this arc....more
I really liked this and learned new things about Palestinian culture and traditions. Loved the sections on food and people in the creative arts. I reaI really liked this and learned new things about Palestinian culture and traditions. Loved the sections on food and people in the creative arts. I really want to try knafeh now. I don't live too far from Dearborn so maybe a foodie trip soon? And I also learned about a writer named Sahar Khalifeh and now I really want to check out her books.
But I'm knocking down 1 star because the religion section didn't have Judaism?? Did I miss this or something? I looked several times at my copy. Islam and Christianity were there, but like.... Huh??? Make it make sense!!!...more
This is such a lovely story about a mother's love for her daughter.
I can't personally relate to motherhood at all, which is a testament to the authorThis is such a lovely story about a mother's love for her daughter.
I can't personally relate to motherhood at all, which is a testament to the author's skill in writing and developing the relationship between mother and daughter, Nadine and Layala.
I really enjoyed this take on jinns, along with the death magic and the dead and undead. This was really creative and well done. The settings feel very isolated, which really added to the FMC's feeling of being trapped in her role as Hakawati. While some characters felt one-dimensional (mainly the men, which, tbh, I didn't really care too much about), I did appreciate how the story didn't try to take on more than it could handle. A minimalist setting and a small number of characters were perfect for this story.
The writing is also quite poetic with the ability to get the story across. It strikes the perfect balance between literary fiction and fantasy.
I'd love to read more from this author! Such a great new talent!
Thank you to Hoopoe and Edelweiss for this arc....more
"How does one live in a world that turns away from such injustice for so long? Is this what it means to be Palestinian, Mother?"
The ending made me cr
"How does one live in a world that turns away from such injustice for so long? Is this what it means to be Palestinian, Mother?"
The ending made me cry and the only other book that made me cry was Brokeback Mountain.
Anyway...
I'm not sure what to say other than "Wow." Rarely do novels make me feel speechless, but this is definitely an exception. If there's only one book that you'll ever read about the current situation in Palestine, let this be that book. And if you've been keeping up with the news in Palestine, everything feels so eerily familiar, with the violence being so cyclical that both fictional and real events in this novel will always be relevant.
This novel weaves in a fictional family saga with real events in contemporary Palestinian history, and the author did it so masterfully that I felt like I was reading creative nonfiction or an actual biography about the Abulheja family. By the end of the story, I felt like I knew them as family friends.
I found myself caring about each family member and what happens to them, which usually isn't my m.o. I read and finish books one after the other like it's an assembly line, so actually caring about characters that aren't the MCs isn't usually something I concern myself with.
I'll admit, the back and forth first and third person POV switches took some getting used to, but I can see why the author chose to write certain chapters in certain POVs. I think it worked out well in this instance.
Like I said before, read this if you're interested in the situation in Palestine. If nonfiction intimidates you, this novel actually gives a great overview of the important events in modern Palestinian history, so this could be a great starting point for understanding what's going on right now and the events that led up to it.
There were a number of poignant quotes that I highlighted. Most of them are depressing. But I'll leave this review with a beautiful quote about Amal's love for her daughter, Sara.
"I looked at my daughter and knew, as I know the sun will set and rise again, that I loved her with a longing and depth more profound than time, more profound than God."
Truth be told, I wasn't really a huge fan of this anthology. Nothing seemed concrete or even slightly logical. I did like how creative some of the stories are though.
But Mel said something that made me look at this in a different way. She said that because of the current situation between Israel and Palestine, it might be why a lot of these short stories don't have concrete endings.
I'll take that interpretation.
Below are summaries and reviews of each individual short story:
Introduction by Basma Ghalayini 5/5 stars
Mel is rating the intro, so I guess I'll rate the intro too. After all, there were several poignant quotes I highlighted.
For an intro, the editor really got to the meat and bones of Israeli occupation in Palestine and its influence on Palestinian literature. Ghalayini compares the main themes of SFF, saying that "it is a luxury, to which Palestinians haven't felt they can afford to escape. The cruel present (and the traumatic past) have too firm a grip on Palestinian writers' imaginations for fanciful ventures into possible futures" (Ghalayini 9).
Another passage I love is the second to last paragraph.
"Not that the disguise of science fiction would be that drastic a costume change for Palestinian writers, especially those based in Palestine. Everyday life, for them, is a kind of dystopia. A West Bank Palestinian need only record their journey to work, or talk back to an IDF soldier at a checkpoint, or forget to carry their ID card, or simply look out their car window at the walls, weaponry, and barbed wire plastering the landscape, to know what a modern, totalitarian occupation is--something people in the West can only begin to understand through the language of dystopia" (Ghalayini 11).
Song of the Birds by Saleem Haddad 4/5 stars
Aya sees her dead brother, Ziad, in what might, or might not, be her dreams.
I was originally thinking of giving this 3 stars, but after talking it over with Mel, I'm definitely increasing it to 4 stars. This short story is both intriguing and devastating. Without giving away any spoilers, there are strong hints of The Matrix here. Both Mel and I would love to see this a fully-fledged novel. It's creative with using sci-fi tropes that sci-fi readers might be familiar with.
Sleep It Off, Dr Schott by Selma Dabbagh 1.5/5 stars
Layla, a recorder, is tasked to record illicit conversations between Dr. Kamal and Dr. Schott.
Mel and I had no idea wtf was going on in this short story. We were both frustrated at the lack of a main plotline or the reason for why anything happened.
The only thing I got from this was that Dr. Schott's DNA test showed that he wasn't "Jewish" enough so Israel didn't want him. Dr. Kamal was Palestinian. They were both working on the hyperloop for some kind of Palestinian scientific haven? Dr. Schott worked for Dr. Kamal and he was acting inappropriate towards her, hence why Layla's job was to record their conversations. Schott's behavior was cringe and uncomfortable, and at the end, Kamal implied that she liked him too?
Nothing made sense. Anyway, on to the next one.
N by Majd Kayyal, translated by Thoraya El-Rayyes 3/5 stars
N, the narrator's son, is studying in a parallel Palestine where Israel owns the entirety of Palestine. The narrator, on the other hand, lives in the other Palestine.
I think Mel liked this story better than I did. I didn't really understand what was going on because it read like several viewpoints rambling about their lives in Palestine vs. a parallel universe where Israel owned everything.
The idea was there and the vibes were there, but I'm not sure if it was executed well. I would've preferred a more straightforward narrative.
The Key by Anwar Hamed, translated by Andrew Leber 3/5 stars
The MMC's five-year-old daughter, Edina, keeps hearing the front door being unlocked, even though no one's there.
This started out as a great horror/thriller, but it ended so abruptly. There was no actual conclusion. I did like the creepy, suspenseful vibes though.
A couple of highlighted passages I liked:
"'Such a small country. A slender island in an ocean of hatred!'"
"'Residents of the camps in neighbouring countries are the core problem, however. They want to return to towns and villages that are no longer there. They dream of a world that no longer exists and cannot be restored, even if we agree to the idea, in principle. Even if they return, they will not find what they are looking for. But their stubbornness will not die--they pass it on to their children and grandchildren.'"
"My grandfather collected pictures of them clutching rusty keys to houses that no longer existed. But he wasn't mocking them, like others did. He felt a vague anxiety towards them, though he realised he was powerless to do anything about it. My grandfather feared those photographs of people holding keys more than any arms deal being signed by neighbouring countries."
Digital Nation by Emad El-Din Aysha 4.5/5 stars
Israel's telecom networks are hacked to broadcast in Arabic as Palestinian activists use technology to their advantage.
I think this is my favorite short story in this anthology (so far). Mel and I both really liked this one. It's very sci-fi thriller and kept me reading. I love how this is such a hopeful story despite the subject matter and situation. Is this an example of hopepunk? If so, I might be a convert (speaking as a hardcore grimdark lover).
Personal Hero by Abdalmuti Maqboul, translated by Yasmine Seale 3/5 stars
Abd al-Qadir, a Palestinian Arab nationalist and fighter, rises again.
I'm not quite sure how I feel about this story. I think Mel liked it a lot more than I did. The beginning and middle made no sense until the ending (which was very hopepunk and pretty cool). But by then, I was too confused to actually absorb the hopepunk vibes and take it all in.
'I kept hearing about you, reading about you. I heard that, as a child, you bought a gun and paid for it yourself. That you ripped up your diploma as soon as you received it from the head of the American University in Cairo, in front of all the important people. I remember what you said: “I have no need of a diploma from your school, a colonial and missionary institution. I have won it, but it has not won me.”'
Vengeance by Tasnim Abutabikh 5/5 stars
Ahmed gets a job working for Yousef Abdulqader, who fixes futuristic prosthetics. But unbeknownst to Yousef, Ahmed has nefarious motives.
This story is pretty simple and the backbone isn't anything we've never seen before, but oh boy, I ended up loving this! The futuristic sci-fi twist with the addition of Palestinian familial history really sealed the deal for me. I love it when authors use their knowledge and experiences with tropes we're all familiar with as readers.
Application 39 by Ahmed Masoud 4/5 stars
Ismael and Rayyan play a prank: apply to the IOC on behalf of Gaza to host the Olympic Games.
I love the hopepunk vibes in the beginning here, but man, the ending... It reads so realistic. Like reality, the story was fun and then it wasn't.
The Association by Samir El-Youssef, translated by Raph Cormack 3/5 stars
Zaid, a journalist with the Daily Diwan, investigates the death of a historian, Professor Omar Hijazi, in a futuristic Israel/Palestine where studying the past is illegal.
Loved the premise (Israel and Palestine pass an agreement to "forget" the past and move on, and studying the history of the war is forbidden). It started out as an interesting murder mystery that felt like it was slowly building on the premise, but it ended too abruptly for me to give this story any more than a passing thought.
Commonplace by Rawan Yaghi 3/5 stars
Adam, a drug dealer in futuristic Palestine, deals with the aftermath of his sister's torture and subsequent coma.
I'm not really sure how I feel about this one. On one hand, it's a bittersweet story about sibling love, but it also ends on a strange note that's very open-ended. Depending on your outlook on life, it's either hopeful or depressing.
Final Warning by Talal Abu Shawish, translated by Mohamed Ghalainey 3/5 stars
Residents in Ramallah and settlers in a nearby Israeli settlement come together when everything electronic goes dark.
This was a take on a classic sci-fi movie/book trope where aliens tell humans to do x, y, z, or else the aliens will kill them. I'm not sure if I really liked this, but I do like the hopepunk vibes though.
The Curse of the Mud Ball Kid by Mazen Maarouf, translated by Jonathan Wright 3/5 stars
What the hell was this long short story??? Something about an irradiated Palestinian living in a cube being watched over by a hitman with diabetes and a dude who's obsessed with his grandfather and his grandfather's Luger??
Mel and I were so lost. It read like the writer was either tripping on acid or drank multiple cans of old school 4loko.
Anyway, I was weirdly intrigued and amused by the whole thing....more
While this needs a hell of a lot of copy editing, proofreading, and formatting (and even some developmental editing near the end)3.5 stars rounded up.
While this needs a hell of a lot of copy editing, proofreading, and formatting (and even some developmental editing near the end), I still enjoyed the story and its characters!
I'm usually a pretty harsh reviewer when it comes to readability issues (anything that needs extensive edits is usually either a DNF or gets a low score), but I actually really liked this story. If there was a significant overhaul and this indie novel came out polished instead of in its current raw state, I'd gladly give it a higher rating.
Rukhsaar and Masih were compelling characters. I ended up liking the flashbacks to Rukhsaar's childhood, and I'm speaking as someone who dislikes back and forth flashbacks in general since they distract me. It was really cool to immerse myself in a different society with different values. The misogyny and patriarchy were portrayed so well to the point where I was really irritated and uncomfortable with what was happening to Rukhsaar.
The author also did really well with writing parts of the story from a child's POV. You could feel emotions such as confusion, shame, and wonder that comes with seeing the world through a child's eyes. But I gotta say though, for a kid, Masih was lucky as hell.
Other than the editing problems, I only had a couple of issues with this novel. I wished the setting was described more fully. I had to Google Kabul and various mentioned places to fully understand what I was reading about.
And like other reviewers have mentioned, the last few chapters where Masih reads Arvin's journal felt out of place. It needed developmental edits to really integrate the journal entries and poetry into the actual story itself.
I also wanted more out of Masih's situation since Arvin didn't quite feel fully developed to me.
Overall, this was a quick read and kept me enthralled from beginning to end....more