This was such a unique and fun read! I can't place it in any genre, really! It's a rom com but with a sci-fi-ish (or fantasy depending on your perspecThis was such a unique and fun read! I can't place it in any genre, really! It's a rom com but with a sci-fi-ish (or fantasy depending on your perspective) twist! And what a twist.
I won't tell you what the twist is, just that It's about two people who accidentally connect online but when they decide to meet they find out something very unexpected - it's impossible to be together (it's in the title).
It's a forbidden love story of a unique type, and I loved that! I get bored reading too realistic contemporary books (with focus on work stress, friends & family problems... it gets tedious and not enough escapism for me) - I need that extra layer to pull me in! And this book definitely had that.
It also had everything you find in other contemp romances if you enjoy that! (Btw just cuz I mentioned sci-fi, don't expect aliens or anything too out there!)
My one issue is that the book is longer than it has to be. It's way over 400 pages, and I feel like it would have worked better if it was shorter. Still, I flew through it, and it was a gripping from start to finish....more
I had the best time reading this! It promised full on adventure, archeological and mythological exploration, a vivid historical setting - and it delivered that in plenty! More so, it gave me two immensely lovable and fun characters! And a swoon worthy slow burn romance. This book really had everything I wanted!
Set in the 19th century, when women didn’t have a place in science, our protagonist Ellie Malory stumbles on a map to a civilization lost to time and myth. In order to escape a criminal set upon stealing it, she takes the map where it leads her on an adventure into the forests and mountains of Mesoamerica. And after a startling first impression, she is joined by the last person she would’ve chosen as a guide, the surveyor general Adam Bates.
From then on it’s a banter filled and exciting journey - with greedy villains, ghostly secrets, terrifying creatures, hazardous terrain, mysterious discoveries, and everything in between - for the two of them!
The book does also touch on issues of colonialism and sexism in line with the historical events of that time and before it. I can’t judge how well researched the book is but it felt that way, and it sparked my interest is Mesoamerican history/archeology!
I adored the characters, and there was never a dull moment in this book for me, despite it being more than 500 pages. With daring adventure, lovely and banter-filled slow-burn romance, an immersive setting, and non stop suspense and wonder - I fully recommend this book. I can’t wait for the sequel for more adventures with Ellie and Adam! ...more
"It's never up to you what happens. Your only choice is what to do when it does. What kind of per
My rating: 3.5/5 stars (rounded up to 4).
"It's never up to you what happens. Your only choice is what to do when it does. What kind of person will you decide to be?”
Sequels are always best when they take what worked in the first book and expand on it - add depth to it. This book accomplished that in some ways, and in other ways it fell a bit short.
I'll start with what I liked:
--In the The Girl from Everywhere, we know the characters can travel through history and more interestingly - through myth and legend. We saw them stop in Hawaii during the 1880's, where the events took place. And for a brief time, there was that journey to a mythical tomb. But this time -- most of the book revolves around their time in a mythical city called "Ker Ys", (which I'd never heard of before but found interesting) - that is set to drown by the end of the myth. The most interesting part about this is that the entire journey is made for the purpose of answering the question that every good time travel story asks - is changing the past and altering your fate possible? The mystery that came with this definitely made this sequel come on top of the first one.
--But what made the story so intense is that this time it's not Nix's mother's fate they're trying to fix but Kashmir's. Nix's worse fears are coming true. In the first book, she held back on admitting to her feelings for Kashmir because she did not want to love the way her father did - too fiercely and unable to face loss. But now her father tells her that it's her fate to "lose the one she loves to the sea" and to be heartbroken as a result. Does Nix learn from having watched her father obsess to near madness her whole life? No - it's because of what she's seen in him that her fears are already so deep set.
“You’ve fought me for years, but now that it’s about Kashmir—” "What did you really expect, Slate?” My voice shocked me—the anger in it. “After all this time watching you, what did you think I would do?” "I don’t know!” he shouted, flinging his arms into the air. “Maybe learn from my mistakes?” "I did,” I shot back. “Just not the lessons you thought. And now I have the chance to learn from experience.”
I really liked this part of the book - her struggles with her father becoming an internal conflict with herself now. Nix's anxiety wasn't just about saving Kashmir but about saving herself. She was even afraid of things like depression being hereditary after watching her father fall deeper and deeper into it for years.
Looking at Slate, his bent shoulders, his hollow eyes—I knew I could not let it happen to me. I would not end up like my father.
Even though her actions seem over the top at times, the book shows how she learns through her own mistakes and choices. It was a necessary journey and character growth for Nix.
--Another thing I liked is how the author, again, takes pieces of history and weaves them with myth to shape her own story. The "villain" of this story, Donald Crowhurst, is based on an actual person (read author's note) who had set out to travel around the world but then disappeared, leaving ramblings in his logbook that made people conclude he'd lost his sanity. But here in the book, Crowhurst, is a 'navigator' like Nix and her dad, who claims to have found all the secrets to their shared ability. And when he offers to teach Nix by showing her how he altered a myth, she takes the risk to go to him there for answers - to save Kashmir from his fate.
--In the first book, I said my favorite part was Kashmir and that I hoped for more insight into his character in the sequel - and I got my wish! This time, he gets chapters in his point of view and they do not disappoint (even though they were too few). We see more depth here. Kashmir (who comes from a fantasy world) starts to question his own reality. He starts to wonder if he is even real -- questioning his past, his memories, his emotions. The idea of never having been an actual part of the world bothers him much more than the thought of leaving it.
“You won’t find Vaadi Al-Maas on any modern maps.” "Because it was a myth.” I bit my lip. “Yes.” "Then what am I?” "Kashmir—” "If you can create a myth, why not a man? Am I merely a figment of some cartographer’s imagination? Or did you make me up when you arrived?” "No, Kash. I . . . No. Don’t say that. You are . . . you’re very real to me.” But it wasn’t what he needed to hear. He shook his head. “I need to be more than what is reflected in your eyes. Otherwise . . .” For a moment, he was at a loss for words, and the confusion of it made him look so young. "Otherwise what?” "Otherwise what am I without you?”
--I really liked how Nix and Kashmir's relationship played out in this book. For a while, their internal struggles come between them -- Nix still holds back from Kashmir, while he wants to hold onto what they already have. (Who doesn't like some well written angst?)
“So I should do nothing? You want to be lost?” "Of course I don’t! But I don’t want to lose you either.” "You won’t.” "I already am.” His voice was bitter; he kicked at a bottle cap. “There’s a wall around you now, amira. You built it with your father. I don’t know who holds the key.”
But they have such beautiful moments in this book. I love how their problems are resolved, so there's absolutely no worries there!
--And like the first book, this one is emotional and bittersweet, and that depth to the characters and their relationships is the story's biggest strength.
Now onto what I didn't really like:
--One of the things I was hoping for in the sequel is to get clearer answers on how the time traveling works. This book's main plot revolved around the question of what would happen if you try to change the past or alter history/myth. Basically, every theory is thrown in here - there's the one about alternate realities resulting from every different choice, and on the other hand there's the idea of only one timeline that shifts to fit the changes. But it kind of remained open to interpretation. (Best to read the next spoiler only if you've read the book) (view spoiler)[Some clues we got (like how memories are replaced with new ones when change is forced, but the original events become dreamlike memories - except to Navigators who remember how it actually was) made me lean more towards the theory of it being one world that is altered by the navigators choices. But that brings me to two questions:
-Kashmir has dreams (or rather an altered "memory") of being executed instead of joining Nix's crew -- so, if her arrival prevented that fate, then doesn't that already answer the big question about whether it's possible to safely change the past? -Second question -- the book's ending basically proves that no matter how you try to make changes to escape your fate, it finds a way to play out anyway. So is change really possible?
It feels contradictory in a way.
I actually have more questions - (hide spoiler)] That's my gripe here, the more answers we got, the more questions followed. It got frustrating going in circles, which made me almost lose interest at some points.
--And we still don't know why and how Navigators exist. It wasn't really discussed.
--Regarding Nix's decision to go to Ker Ys (Only if you've read the book)-- (view spoiler)[Nix wants to save the person she loves from drowning and she takes him to a mythical city that drowns by the end of its story. Even though she's told that the ending has been changed -- still, think: "Lost to the sea" + drowning city = ?? ... I get Nix's desperation for answers, but still. Not the smartest move. (hide spoiler)]
((All that said, I really liked the ending and outcome - and was totally satisfied by it. ))
--Oh, and I did not like Blake. I had hopes that he would be a fun addition to the crew, and yeah he and Kashmir became friends of a sort, but he ended up being a disappointment. There's no annoying love triangle this time, since now Nix has admitted her feelings for Kashmir - and she and Blake hadn't ended things on good terms in the last book. But mostly, Blake's true love is the paradise he lost in Hawaii - and just like Nix is fighting to save her love by learning how to change the past, Blake feels the same way.
All in all -- I really liked the book. Time travel, myths, unhinged villains, swoon-worthy male character and romance - and most of all: great character development overall! And it added to my appreciation of duologies -- there's enough time to develop story and character without dragging the plot unnecessarily. If you've read and liked the first book, you will definitely find a lot to like about this book!
-------
And if you love time travel stories as much as I do, I also recommend Passenger (and its sequel, Wayfarer). It's a duology as well, and it might not include fascinating mythical worlds (or Kashmir!), but the time travel system/origin is pretty impressive, with very few holes (if any) in the explanation....more
Actual rating: 4.5/5 rounded up to five magical stars!
"But why settle for a story, when I could start a legend?"
What to say when the bActual rating: 4.5/5 rounded up to five magical stars!
"But why settle for a story, when I could start a legend?"
What to say when the book itself floors you with its mesmerizing and beautiful words! This is the kind of book that feels enchanting, comforting, funny, endearing, romantic - and will leave you with a huge smile on your face! [image]
This book is a companion novel to the previous book by Roshani Chokshi, The Star-Touched Queen - so, it's not exactly a sequel. The main characters of "A Crown of Wishes" are different ones - they have appeared or were mentioned briefly in the first book, but I don't think you need to read that first novel to read this. "A Crown of Wishes" can stand alone. But there are a few things that come up that might need having some kind of background info on the other book.
I have to admit, I wasn't a fan of the first book, "The Star Touched Queen." I still don't know why that book didn't work for me - I stopped halfway. But this one clicked with me in so many ways the first didn't.
Plot summary:
"Play the game and you may yet win your kingdom, not just the husk of its name."
A story about a prince and princess of enemy kingdoms, who have to become partners to compete in a magical tournament to fulfill each of their wishes to truly gain the thrones to their respective kingdoms. Even through facing magical tricks and demonic creatures, there's also the challenge of getting along - and their personal journey together throughout this enchanting and terrifying world is what makes this novel so special!
World-building:
"What was magic anyway, but the world beheld by someone who chose to see it differently?"
The fantastical "Otherworld" in this novel is almost dreamlike in its strangeness. There is a magical forest, and the "Night Bazaar", but mostly the story takes place in "Alaka" - the mythical City of Treasures and Wealth, where the the tournament is held. The place is unpredictable and like something out of a dream, or sometimes a nightmare. I usually like it when there's more structure in a world (and the magic in it) to grasp it clearly. But while I struggled with TSTQ, I think this book struck the right balance between presenting rich and whimsical fantasy settings - and grounding it with strong and gripping character development.
*I really liked all the magical elements and creatures introduced! I'm a huge fan of Indian cinema but the genres rarely ever offer myth and fantasy, so it was fun and fascinating to delve into this world with creatures like the Vanaras (human-sized monkeys), Vetalas (spirits inhabiting dead bodies - icky but strangely quirky in the book), Nagas (half serpent), Yakshas (nature spirits) - and my favorite were the Vishakanyas: courtesan-like women with poison in their blood that can kill a human with a touch. [image]
*And not just the fantasy - I love the feel and hints of Indian culture being more present in this book. My knowledge is very limited of it, but I still enjoyed all the mentions of the food, the clothing, the names and terms, the holidays, and just the entire feel is so inviting! I look forward to more books that present different cultures and settings like this one does so beautifully.
Characters:
“Find the one who glows, with blood on the lips and fangs in the heart.”
[image] My ability to connect with a book is always dependent on how much the characters resonate with me. And this book surprised in the absolute best of ways by being so character-driven!! The characters in this book are the heart and soul of the story.
Gauri, "The Jewel of Bharata" is a warrior princess in every sense.
"Death might be waiting, but I was going to be a queen. I would have my throne if I had to carve a path of blood and bone to get it back. Death could wait."
[image] She is strong and fierce but her armor is one built out of sacrifice and burdens she's had to bear while protecting herself and her people throughout her tyrannical brother's reign. Her mounting guilt, her hesitance to accept weakness, her distrust, her vulnerability - everything about the character made her so easy to feel for, and root for every step of the way.
Vikram, "The Fox Prince", is the clever and cunning prince of Ujijain. Not a blood heir to his empire, he's spent his life trying to prove himself capable of being the empire's true ruler - but is instead is promised to be nothing more than a "puppet king" by the scorning council. But his belief and hope in magic leads him to an invitation to the tournament and the possibility of gaining true acknowledgment in his role as emperor.
"He was raised on a bellyful of want—always kept at a distance, always in sight of everything he wanted and could never sink his teeth into—which only made him that much more attuned to seeing through words and straight to the desires."
Now Vikram is the character that surprised me most! In the absolute best and most amazing ways!!! If you take a look at my status updates, you'll see they are 90% Vikram quotes and moments! In "The Star Touched Queen", the vague mentions of him gave me the impression he would be a brooding warrior. But he turned out to be such an interestingly fun, sly, curious, and all around awesome character - one who depends on his wits rather than muscle to get by. And his wonderful quirks and mischievous antics made him even more likable - there were hilarious moments. Like his confidence and willingness to do whatever it takes - even dress as a courtesan - to get to where and what he wants:
"Once, when he was ten, he attempted to fly by attaching silk scarves to his arms and leaping from a tree. It did not work. When he was fifteen, he dressed like a courtesan to sneak into the harem. He ended up appearing too convincing to a palace guard and was forced to throw off his silks and punch the man. All things considered, this was not the most shameful thing he had endured."
A total darling who will also make you swoon! [image]
((And what else - I googled the character's full name "Vikramaditya" to see if the author used any inspirational figure, and I love what I found. So, apparently "Vikramaditya" is known as a legendary emperor of Ancient India - the capital being "Ujjain" (so, definitely the inspiration for Ujijain!). There seems to be lots of stories and fantastical legends about him (including Vetalas like in this book!), and according to wiki - he's characterized as the "ideal king" and is either inspired by a true historical figure or is purely a mythical character. So, basically, he's kind of like India's own King Arthur!! So cool!))
Vikram and Gauri start as two opposites forced to work together - he with his sunny optimism and she, her no-nonsense wariness of everything. I love how this book strayed from the usual - when in danger, the girl reaches for her weapons while the guy thinks up a scheme. They ended up making such an amazing team! But of course, first, their contrasting personalities resulted in continuous banter, sarcasm, bickering, teasing, -- all entertaining and wonderful things!
“You’re certain that rakshasi fruit is out of your system?” asked Vikram. "Yes?” "Good.” He took a deep breath. “Because, once more, I told you so.” "You do realize that I don’t need the enhancements of demon fruit to knock you to the ground?” "I do. But I concede that some bodily harm from you is inevitable. I’m just trying to minimize the damage.” "How very wise,” I said, rolling my eyes.
One more:
(Vikram): "Have some faith.” (Gauri): "Between faith and distrust, which one is more likely to keep you alive?” "And which one is more likely to let you experience living?” I threw up my hands. “Why is everything so philosophical with you?” He shrugged. “I like thinking.”
They have such a great dynamic - going from enemies, to tentative partners, to friends and then slowly to something so much deeper.
I can't separate talking about The Romance from The Character Development in this book - because the characters grow and connect together throughout the journey. There is such an amazing depth to how the characters each evolve but also a convincingly gradual pace to it. And it's the same perfect balance with their feelings for each other - they get to see and accept one another's own pains, and they influence each other in the best way. The romantic arc is filled with both light and meaningful moments - so perfect!
I didn’t want to cut out my heart. I wanted to give it. Freely and without feeling as if it would be turned into a weapon against me. I wanted freedom to thaw me, to let it break the walls Skanda’s rule had forced me to build. I wanted the privilege of weakness.
I don't think I've loved two characters (and a romantic couple!) this much since Arin and Kestrel from the Winner's trilogy! Vikram and Gauri are as unforgettable, and have also set the bar high for other YA couples in the next books I'll read!
Another amazing character is Aasha - the Vishakanya who yearns to know want it's like to be the human she could have been! Aasha is sort of a sad character - her story reminiscent of "The Little Mermaid". And she becomes an ally to Vikram and Gauri. I especially loved the friendship and understanding that develops between her and Gauri - and it's not an easy thing with Gauri's distrusting nature.
The writing:
"I’d almost forgotten the true power of a story … how it lulled you outside your thoughts, let you process the world in a way that was palatable. Not poisonous. Calm rushed through me."
I cannot say enough how absolutely gorgeous the writing is! You need to read the book for yourself to experience it! Just as magical as the fantasy! And I also didn't notice until a while into the book that Gauri's chapters were in first-person point-of-view, and Vikram's in third-person! I don't why, but that worked so well!
* I don't really have any criticisms on the book. Every one I come up with has more to do with my personal preferences than an actual flaw in the book. But I think the book could be a bit more suspenseful - the game itself rarely felt "competitive" (but I think it was supposed to be an unpredictable personal challenge for the characters), or maybe because some elements of the background stories felt elusive or irrelevant (there were a few myths that were strung together vaguely). But then again, I think all that was intentional and part of the book's charm...
Overall -- I wholly recommend this book! If you're looking for an exotic and magical fantasy, you've got it. If you're looking for complex and interesting characters, they're there. If you're looking for a fun and slow-burn romance, look no further. If you're looking for beautiful unforgettable writing, you'll definitely get that! And if you just want a great book to escape into - this is it!
Actual rating: This gets a full 5 "spades and aces and stars!"
How does this happen? How is each book by far better and more exciting than the last??
ThActual rating: This gets a full 5 "spades and aces and stars!"
How does this happen? How is each book by far better and more exciting than the last??
This book is utterly fantastic -- before starting the series I was worried I would take forever to finish this installment with 550 pages, but once I started it, the pages flew by so fast - unless I was rereading my favorite parts. There wasn't a dull moment!
Things get real in this book!
So what to expect? Our favorite gang of characters start where we left them - Wolf and Scarlet joining Cinder, Thorne and Iko - on the Rampion. And now they've cooked up a plan to stop the wedding, and reveal Cinder as Selene and overthrow Levana in one sweep. Of course, it can't be that simple!
But they stop to pick up Cress on the way -- she's our "Rapunzel"; The Lunar Shell held captive and entirely isolated in a satellite by Levana's head thaumaturge, Sybil Mira. She's also an adorable genius hacker, forced to create Levana's spy tech -- but she's also the girl who warned Cinder about Levana's plans, and it turns out she's been the one shielding the Rampion all this time.
I love how she's a very capable computer genius but also emotionally vulnerable and socially awkward. It makes sense. She's been through so much with her captivity but also has this 'dreamer' side to her -- she develops these uplifting fantasies in her head to cope and embolden herself. Once leaving the satellite, I really enjoyed her development because it was a gradual growth for her.
Plot Summary: The book kicks off with a quick series of shocking and dangerous outcomes for the gang:
* Thorne and Cress are sent plummeting down to Earth in a satellite from space, and end up stranded on an endless desert. Oh, and Thorne hits his head and is blinded during the fall. * Wolf gets shot twice. * Scarlet gets kidnapped and taken to Luna as prisoner. * Cinder accidentally pulls Levana's personal guard into the Rampion ship. * And Kai's stuck planning for a wedding that he knows might end with his murder.
Again, that's just how the book starts basically - where it places everyone.
They each kind of have to have their own journey before reuniting.
I like that despite Cress being the title character, her part of the story wasn't the main focus of the book, like Scarlet's was in the second book. Her development is a large and important part, but there is so much plot and character development and action to advance the bigger story. And the book doesn't fall short on any aspect.
That being said - Thorne and Cress's story is my favorite! And the progression of romantic feelings is so well done! Cress starts out with this giant crush on Thorne before even meeting him; she's already built up this heroic and selfless image of him, based on her research alone. To be honest, after reading another book recently (view spoiler)[ACOMAF (hide spoiler)] where an interesting but morally gray character suddenly turned into a saint with all the 'justifications' for his previous actions - I was very scared that Thorne would get the same treatment and turn into a Robin Hood/noble-thief type character. But instead, the Thorne that Cress meets continually shatters her expectations -- and exceeds mine! The first time they meet is one great example:
But all Cress could see were the blue eyes staring back at her, directly back at her, beginning to fill with the same breathless awe she felt. The same wonder. The same enchantment.
“Aces,” Carswell Thorne murmured. Dropping his feet to the ground, he leaned forward to inspect her closer. “Is that all hair?” The bond snapped, the fantasy of one perfect true-love moment disintegrating around her.
He's remains the sarcastic and cocky Thorne we know and love. But another thing I appreciate about Thorne and Cress's slow-burn? It makes each moment between them precious, and brings about great character development for both. Thorne isn't exactly what Cress expected, but he is all of it at the same time - or rather proves to be, in his own way. Cress has to brave, not just the harsh desert, but everything about the world -- while Thorne has to adapt to his blindness and survive that desert. So they rely on each other and gradually form such an endearing bond.
And there's so much character development for everyone - especially Cinder! She really starts growing into her role as a leader. And she's facing more of that darker side of her Lunar gift. Some scenes are pretty intense for her. Cinder really gets tested in this book. She still gets much needed guidance from Dr. Erland, when she lands her ship in Africa along with who's left on her team at that point - an injured Wolf, Iko, and Sybil's former guard, Jacin Clay who cryptically says he's only loyal to his "princess", rather than the queen.
I loved the scenes in Africa where we see how Lunar refugees have integrated with humans, and we learn more about the Letumosis disease, and Cinder gains more supporters.
As for Jacin, he is an interesting character, having been resigned to being a controlled guard to the queen, hiding all thoughts of his own. We get hints of why and how. He's overall reserved and kind of indifferent (and skeptical) towards everything Cinder is trying to recruit him into -- he has this dry and biting sarcasm that adds an interesting dynamic to the group. His bickering banter with Iko is hilarious! And now that I'm reading more of his story in a prequel novella, I'm really liking him more and more.
And there's another (smaller) appearance of a new character. (view spoiler)[Princess Winter. And it's not really a big surprise (or a spoiler), although she seems like an intriguing and eccentric character! (hide spoiler)]
The group dynamics in this book and the banter and camaraderie is fantastic. The part when the team unexpectedly reunites in a coincidental mix up of incidents cracked me up so much! I like how the friendships and loyalties are just as significant as the romantic relationships.
Oh, and Iko gets another interesting make over in this book! It allows her to be fully part of the team.
Okay, okay, so I gotta talk about Kai! This novel made my adoration for this character increase in leaps and bounds! He makes some big decisions, and again I have to appreciate how his character growth in his role as leader parallels Cinder's. Although, I was more proud of Kai's choices in this one than Cinder's. But then when they finally got the chance to be alone together, you see just how much they needed each other and can understand one another better than anyone -- of course this is after shooting and yelling and throwing accusations at each other. They are perfect. End of story.
The last act of the book was something out of a heist/action/spy movie -- and I don't want to spoil what their objective to 'steal' was. It was serious business but I found it all so much fun! The book of course has its share of danger, heartbreak and twists. Dr. Erland finds Cress and discovers an important bond between them, and Wolf's reaction to finding out that Scarlet was kidnapped is pretty sad.
The book left me on the edge of my seat - it just upped the suspense and the threats are just getting bigger and I have no clue what's going to happen -- except that I am 100% onboard.
Anyway, my thoughts are all over the place. In short, I loved this book. It's entertaining, suspenseful, funny, and easily my favorite of the three books so far -- and it's made the Lunar Chronicles one of my top favorite series.
Okay, so I enjoyed reading this! Which was kind of a happy surprise. I read the 1st book two years ago and I thought itActual Rating: 3.8/5 stars 🌟🌟🌟✨
Okay, so I enjoyed reading this! Which was kind of a happy surprise. I read the 1st book two years ago and I thought it was okay, and then I read so many discouraging reviews about this one when it came out, then I waited so long to read it, got spoiled thoroughly on every twist and plot point (by accident!) — and yet... I still enjoyed this!
At first it was a bit slow, the world dark, a bit depressing (and Helene’s POV bored me - not a big Helene fan 🤷🏻♀️) - but then, it got intense, suspenseful, and even though I knew what the twists were, that actually made it more fun? It was cool catching all the clues leading up to the reveals! Haha. So maybe this is a good book to reread for you guys?
Elias was great, Laia grew on me more and more, and I liked all the new minor characters - except the villains, of course. I’ve never hated book villains more than these before (which I guess is a compliment? 🤔☹️🖤)
Now I get to be excited with you all for “Reaper at the Gates” - yay! 😍...more
What fan of romance doesn't enjoy a unique and captivating slow burn love story? And if you are a fan of Fantasy as well (lActual rating: 3.7/5 stars.
What fan of romance doesn't enjoy a unique and captivating slow burn love story? And if you are a fan of Fantasy as well (like me), then you won't be able to resist this book.
And it is refreshing not just because of the fascinating fantasy it is, but because as a "romance", it depics a beautiful and mutually respectful relationship that you can admire. (Sadly some books in the genre fall short of that). The depth of the two characters' connection is based on understanding and a sweet friendship that pulls you in as it develops into a wonderful love story.
Ildiko and Brishen are such endearing characters. Their story starts with a politically arranged wedding between them. But it is truly unique because the conflict is not really in a marriage of strangers but a marriage of people of different species! (Or two different races of creatures - not sure how to describe it.)
Ildiko is human and Brishen is from an older race of people (once magically powerful) called the Kai, and they have gray skin, sharp teeth and claws. But the Kai people find humans just as repulsive looking as the humans find them. and Brishen and Ildiko are not an exception to that perspective. Brishen and Ildiko's first meeting is one of my favorite scenes in the book!
“You find me ugly, don’t you?” He clenched his teeth, prayed he wouldn’t start a war with their newest ally and answered honestly. “Hideous,” he said. “A hag of a woman.”
“And you,” he said. “You don’t think me a handsome man?” “Had you crawled out from under my bed when I was a child, I would have bludgeoned you to death with my father’s mace.”
But it is not a hate-to-love relationship. It's one that builds on honesty and friendship and finding the beauty in each other despite their differences. Everyone pities them for their marriage but they build something wonderful that's all their own. As characters, they are very likable. ildiko is a strong and patient character in the face of all the changes she has to make in her life. And Brishen is understanding, sweet, and protective without being overbearing.
The world building is interesting with hints of magic and political conflicts that threaten the couple's safety - not to mention Brishen's evil mother and her dark plans. But this is mostly a Romantic Fantasy that focuses on the two main character's personal journey together. So there aren't that many epic battles or strategizing wars you'd find in High Fantasy, for example. But still, there is brewing danger in political schemes, and some brutal action at critical points. Also, the book introduces unresolved threats and even greater new ones (political and magical) that I think will be a huge part of the sequel's plot.
The supporting characters are also very likable and important without taking the spotlight from the main characters or being pushed to the background. I really like Brishen's fierce and loyal lieutenant and cousin/best friend, Anhuset. She's a great female character! And Serovek, his friend and ally from an enemy country. I think there will be more focus on the two of them in the upcoming books!
I had only one issue with something in the book (but it bothered me till I had to get over it) and it's why I took down my own rating instead of giving this a full 4 or 4.5/5 (like I wanted to). To mention it would be a spoiler, though, and it's really just one thing that didn't happen how I wanted. So, maybe no one else will be bothered by it.
But overall, this book is a delight! And a page turner despite the lack of epic action. I always hope to find some good Adult or New Adult Romantic Fantasy books (I read YA mostly) but am always wary of how the romance and male characters are written. This one is a wonderful find, that is captivating and memorable as a love story and a quick and easy read overall. ...more
Actual rating: firm 4 stars as the finale to the trilogy. But on its own, I would give it 3.5 stars.
I have no clue how to start this review. My thoughActual rating: firm 4 stars as the finale to the trilogy. But on its own, I would give it 3.5 stars.
I have no clue how to start this review. My thoughts are all over the place, my feelings are swirl of mixed emotions, and since I've never reviewed the previous books, I don't know where to start!
Warning: This review might feel like it was written by two different people. I am that torn about how I feel about this book!
I'll start by saying that I loved this trilogy from the first book. I know some readers took time to get into the series, but the very first chapter of book one was a hook-in for me. The Winner's Curse and The Winner's Crime consumed all my time (and thoughts) for the four days it took me to finish them a few months ago. I could not put them down. So I was expecting the same experience (and more) from the final book.
I wish I could say this book was the same for me as the first two. I really do. But honestly (and I know this is an unpopular opinion), it wasn't exactly.
--I'll start with what I LIKED about the book (because there is a lot to like):
The characters: In this series, it's always the characters that come first for me. Arin and Kestrel are amazing characters that develop beautifully and tragically throughout the series. In this book, the wounds they've suffered from the previous books are more apparent than ever. I think that's what the book is more about - exploring what the war has done (and is doing) to the main characters more than just the event of the war itself. Both characters are haunted by what they've each lost. They've been through hell apart and together, and now they are both facing their darkest challenges inside themselves and around them. But they're stronger together and for each other; they're equals in every way. I love that about them, and that important aspect of their characterization and relationship is very much there in the book.
Kestrel and Arin are not the only main characters in this final installment. There is Roshar, the Dacran Prince, who has allied his army's forces with the Herrani in this war against the Valorions. I did not expect to love Roshar so much but I'm dangerously close to saying a lot of his scenes made the book for me - or parts of the book! He had the best lines. His banter with Arin was so refreshing amidst the seriousness of war. There is a real depth to their friendship that surprised me. And Roshar is hardly the comic relief. There's a lot more to him that he hides under his wit and smugness. I wouldn't mind a novella or something from Roshar's POV.
I also have to mention Verex (still so adorable) and Risha. They don't appear until later in the book (unfortunately) but they still have their parts to play in the story - especially Risha.
The Writing:I don't remember being so in awe by the author's way with words in the first two books. Or maybe I was too immersed in the story to notice. But wow, is this book beautifully written! The subtle way the use of imagery can paint the strength of the character's emotions and state of mind... Subtle but also evocative. Maybe, not all the book was completely engrossing for me, but when it counted, it really did make me feel. One example is (view spoiler)[the way this book handled Kestrel's relationship with her father. She goes through a long journey to come to terms with her feelings, and so I expected a huge confrontation with her father when they meet. But like the majority of this book, the most intense scenes are still so... quiet. Despite that, this one scene felt powerful to me. It made me cry - which I don't remember happening with a book in years. (hide spoiler)]
One more thing I loved: The ending! I won't spoil it but I am totally and completely satisfied and happy with how this trilogy ends. The last 20% or 15% of this book was an emotional ride. One that left me either smiling or in tears - or both.
--What I DIDN'T LIKE:
As you can see there was a lot for me to love. But - and unfortunately this is a pretty strong "but" - there are also aspects of the book I didn't totally enjoy.
Truthfully - it just didn't have the same magical hold over me as the previous two books. Not nearly.
Yes, the characters are amazing, the writing was overall gorgeous (and impactful when it counted), and the conclusion was all I wished for...
But then why was it so easy for me to put down the book and get distracted from it? Why is that for 60% or 70% of this book - I can't believe I'm using this word for this series - I was bored.
The books starts and ends very strongly. But the in-between felt to me like I was drifting in and out of the same events. For a book set during a war, there was a lot of downtime. They would strategize for the battles, hang around the camp, talk, strategize some more, actually have one brief battle or two before retreating - then repeat (minus the action). I was waiting for the suspense to build or come to a head... I really had to wait. I actually thought I would enjoy the character's strategizing and show of cleverness (and I did to an extent) but the scenes lacked excitement and thrill.
And to my disappointment I felt that way a little about the romance. There is no doubt Arin and Kestrel are absolutely perfect together here. In this book, they have to rebuild things within themselves and together - it's a slow burn all over again but also with the same depth they had before present. But the subtle growth (or regrowth) of their relationship in this book.... It didn't work for me. I understood it. Unlike the first two books, the surrounding danger here didn't threaten their relationship directly, there was no reason for more angst between them... I get that. The lack of drama is not what bothered me. I liked that they finally found each other. But that old spark they had... It was really softened here. Only once or twice I felt completely gripped during their moments together. And those were moments I'd already been anticipating since the previous book's end. Nothing really surprised me here. For readers who (unlike me) were never big fans of the romance that was center in the first book, this probably won't be an issue.
I can truly appreciate the book for what it is - a beautifully written and satisfying conclusion. It's just not the same for me as the other two books. It just felt very different. I liked it but I didn't LOVE it like the other two. And I can't help comparing it to them, because it is the third and final book. I expected more. Everything was tempered down and even the lovely writing made it all feel slow and dreamlike at times. Which isn't always a good thing.
---I might have contradicted myself in this review more than once. That's what happens when my thoughts and emotions are so conflicted - I make very little sense. I almost didn't post this review, because of that. I reeeally wanted to love this as much as almost everyone did. :(
All the disappointment and expectations aside, this trilogy as a whole is really unforgettable and it stands out among YA novels with characters that will make other books have a lot to compete with. ...more
So I finished reading this terrific book yesterday and I'm finding it hard to move on to another book so easily. Is it what they call a book hangover?So I finished reading this terrific book yesterday and I'm finding it hard to move on to another book so easily. Is it what they call a book hangover? Maybe. That's my I need to get some of my thoughts down here!
I loved this book! I finished it in less than three days which is fast for me. It's when I spend a week or more on a book that I know something isn't totally working for me. That's been happening this year more than I like, even with good books. And granted, Starflight is a fun and adventurous sci-if journey that is not overly long, so it didn't need all my time and focus - it still had my complete and total attention and I did not want it to end even as I reached the final page.
World building: The world building is awesome. It's a bit more show than tell. What's told is very well explained and easy to understand. No crazy terminology to hit you on the head. Basically, humas have spread out across the galaxy, dividing it into colonized and terraformed planets, tourist spaces, ore mines, prisons, and the fringe, which we learn of as we go through the journey with the characters. Earth is where the main governmental base is, though. I've never seen Firefly (which is the show it's compared to) and I'm not that big a fan of dystopian books, but this one was pretty cool. It had its fair share of dangers and challenges but wasn't all gloom and doom.
Summary: The above being said, life isn't easy for our main girl in the story, Solara. The story starts with her trying to hitch a ride to the fringe of the galaxy; lawless lands (planets) where no one will care about the tattoos on her hands that won't allow her escape from past mistakes. To her luck, the only person who lets her on a ship as his servant is Doran Spaulding, the rich boy whose dad's company is the main fuel supplier in the whole galaxy, and who's resented her since their time in school (for his own stupid reasons). And he only does it to make her life hell. In short, they don't like each other. At all. So things happen (not spoiling but it's his fault), which lead them to jump on a worn-out space ship, named the Banshee, with this ragtag crew of people, each with secrets of their own and reasons to be on the run. So everyone's after them from the law, to pirates, to this terrifying and mysterious group of assassins called the Daeva. You learn "why" as the story unfolds with its twists and turns.
Characters: All the characters are so likable. Solara is an orphan, a strong character who's had to struggle through life but still retains her kindness and compassion. Doran, who starts as a spoiled and arrogant dickhead (but clearly with issues of his own) is hard to like at first. But I dare you not to warm up to him and even love him as he faces temporary amnesia, space pirates, false but major indictments, and of course, "eargasm" inducing mushrooms. You love him as he and Solara start to trust each other. What I'm trying (and failing) to say is that he does not remain a jerk. He definitely changes and evolves throughout the story, and comes through again and again, proving himself a character to really root for. What else can I say except that I loved Doran! I loved all the characters on the ship. There's Kane (the flirt) and Cassie (loud but lovable), who have this obvious bond but are at each other's throats most of the time. There's also the kleptomaniac but sweet first mate, Renny, and of course, the captain Rossi who has taken them all in. It's not always easy to get along and trust each other, but despite that, friendships and family-like bonds are made, which I really enjoyed.
Romance: The romance between Solara and Doran is a slow burn that's so well done and believable that I basically swooned the first time the word "friend" was mentioned between them. It's hate to love at its finest (with some humorous bickering and having to share a room on the ship, of all things), while still being fresh and unique to the characters' development together and apart. I liked them as friends, as a couple, as a team - they really don't disappoint. The romance was no doubt my favorite part of the book.
I definitely recommend this if you're looking for an adventure-filled, fun, uplifting, and romantic book. It's light but it's got a little of everything, and a lot to enjoy.
4.5 stars
--------------------------
One last thing. (Could be spoilery)
I don't have anything to complain about, except that I read this thinking it had a sequel. It turns out the second book is more of a companion novel that picks up where this one left off, but with the focus being on characters who we knew as supporting characters in this book. That's sounds like fun. But while Starflight does not end on a cliffhanger and the main obstacles are resolved and conquered (I loved how it ended), there's still a little bit of Doran's story I expected to be resolved or even expanded on. It's not a big thing, since I can picture how things could play out based on what was revealed at the end. Still, the second book is a sequel in its own way, so I'm sure we'll get all the answers and more then. Maybe I'm just not prepared for the focus to shift from Doran and Solara. :p...more
"How sad for them, she thought, that they had grown up without any thorns with which to protect themselves."
It Actual Rating: exactly 4/5.
"How sad for them, she thought, that they had grown up without any thorns with which to protect themselves."
It's kind of hard to write a review for a sequel when I never did for the first one. (For a great review of book one, you can read my friend Shahad's review of Passenger. So well put, and mirrored my thoughts on it exactly!)
But I am so happy to say that Wayfarer turned out to be a wonderful conclusion to Passenger. And that ending...
[image]
There is so much I love about this duology. Alexandra Bracken wrote such a detailed and wonderfully emotional story. It's as much about time travel as it is about family-ties and heartbreak, love and revenge.
((BTW, if you've read Passenger but have trouble remembering the events-- and yeah how the time travel works exactly -- there's a really cool and very helpful recap! https://static1.squarespace.com/stati...))
I love time travel stories! And I love the explanation for the characters' time traveling ability here. We get a satisfying idea of how it works in the first book. But in this sequel, the origins behind the astrolabe and the four families is revealed. And the war between the travelers intensifies as they all hunt after the astrolabe. There's the Thorns on one side, Rose on another, Etta, and Nicholas, Cyrus Ironwood, the Shadows and an old sinister threat they never saw coming. Every single one has their own agenda and reason for it.
I loved the world-traveling to different points in history that Etta and Nicholas took in the first book. There's even more traveling here! But better yet, in this book, the travelers' actions actually severely impact and shift world events as a result of everyone fighting for their own version of the timeline. And so, Etta and Nicholas are each faced with hard questions and choices, and not one easy option. So, the plot is definitely exciting!
Before I talk about the wonderful characters and relationships in this book, I'm going to mention the writing - or rather its pace. The writing is beautiful -- but, in other ways, because of the slow pace, it's also the book's biggest flaw. This book is definitely an improvement on Passenger in terms on pacing, but it still moves a bit slowly at some points with the long descriptions, and also too-long inner monologues every time a character decides on something new. Sometimes you want things to move just a bit faster. Especially, Nicholas and Sophia's journey. I found Etta's parts moving along quicker.
But it's worth it to be patient because we get great character development and there's enough action, especially during that explosive climactic part. Still, could have been 50 pages shorter or more, maybe.
(If you haven't read Passenger yet, below are a couple of big spoilers for the first book. But don't worry, no big spoilers for Wayfarer).
This time, Etta and Nicholas are separated for most of the book, (after the final events in Passenger took Etta away from him). And while I love their romance and partnership and waited for their reunion, that didn't bother me. It gave opportunity for each to move the same story forward with their own journey - Etta meets her father, Henry Hemlock, leader of the Thorns. And Nicholas gets caught up in a deadly deal while trying to find Etta.
But the best part about this were the new partnerships and character dynamics this provided! And amazing character development for everyone! I wasn't a fan of Sophia in the first book, but in this one, she is a lot more fleshed out and sympathetic, and so badass! She and Nicholas made awesome from-hate-to-friendship partners. It provided some funny moments:
He was yanked back by his collar before he could swim closer. "Would you stop making eyes at that bloody ship? It’s a siege,” Sophia grated at him. “If they catch us, they won’t just kill us; they’ll make a whole show of it. Use our decapitated bodies to boost morale.” Right. Yes. Siege.
They go from despising each other and death-threats to being partners who could relate, and friends who become very protective of each other.
As much as Etta was his heart’s helpmate, Sophia was the sword at his side on the expedition he undertook now.
A new character Li Min - a fellow traveler and female pirate - joins and helps them too. She has a heavy and dark past, but she's a great ally to Sophia and Nicholas. And there's even a bit of romance between her and Sophia. And though it's subtle, it works very well, showing a bit more of Sophia's softer side.
Nicholas wondered briefly if it was his destiny to be surrounded by women possessing varying degrees of murderous intent.
And Etta gets to know her father, Henry Hemlock, who she's never met, and his side of the traveler family, which make up "The Thorns". And it leads her to learn more about her mother, Rose, and her secrets. (Rose is, btw, an amazingly complex anti-herione that deserves more page time --and even her own book).
But also she meets Nicholas's spoiled and carefree half-brother, Julian Ironwood who (as was hinted at the end of Passenger) is not dead, and turns out to be a very fun addition to the story! And Etta gets stuck with him on her side of things, and they make a hilarious mismatched pair!
"You’re rather handy, Linden-Hemlock-Spencer,” he said. “That was some brilliant teamwork, if I do say so myself.” "I’m not sure you know what that word means,” Etta managed, her teeth clenched. “You’re the brawn, I’m the brains, kiddo,” he told her. “You don’t need my help with this.”
And some more later - I loved this line:
She blinked. “That was… surprisingly useful.” "As I like to say, always aim to disappoint in life,” Julian said. “That way you’ll never fail to be a delightful surprise when you don’t.”
And, like with Sophia, there's some great character development for Julian!
But safe to say - absolutely no love triangles in this! Etta and Nicholas's romantic arc is just as strong even with them apart for so long. But the family dynamics and friendships are just as impactful in this book which was my favorite part.
I do wish that the characters that were separated for most of the book and only met near the end had more scenes together - like Henry and Rose (can I get their love story please - I need that special Target edition with their novella!), Nicholas and Julian (I would have liked more resolution there), and a little more of Sophia and Nicholas after everything. But I just want more of these characters because they were all so likable and complex and just wonderful!
Overall, I'm happy with this book and conclusion to the story. And I would love for novellas to start appearing showing us what happens next to the characters and more of their journeys! And even if not - the ending of this book was perfect enough!
And if you're hesitant to read this because Passenger felt a bit slow-paced then just remember the fun parts of that book (when it started to pick up with the time-traveling), because this book has a lot more of that, and just overall more surprises....more