L=

20 m

Assignment No. 5 - Analysis o

Building

Story

Story
Height

Frame
Wind load
Inertia
per story
(Ii)

m4

kN

53

1.6

40

4.5

52

1.6

80

7.5

51

1.6

80

10.5

50

1.6

80

49

1.6

80

48

1.6

80

47

1.6

80

46

1.6

80

45

1.6

80

44

1.6

80

43

1.6

80

34.5

42

1.6

80

37.5

41

1.6

80

40.5

40

1.6

80

43.5

39

3.2

80

46.5

38

3.2

80

49.5

37

3.2

80

36

3.2

80

35

3.2

80

34

3.2

80

33

3.2

80

32

3.2

80

16.5
19.5
22.5
25.5
28.5
31.5

52.5
55.5
58.5
61.5
64.5

3rd Zone: 27-39 Stories

13.5

4th Zone: 40-53 Stories

1.5

3rd Zone: 27-3

3.2

80

30

3.2

80

73.5

29

3.2

80

76.5

28

3.2

80

79.5

27

3.2

80

82.5

26

4.8

80

85.5

25

4.8

80

88.5

24

4.8

80

23

4.8

80

22

4.8

80

21

4.8

80

20

4.8

80

19

4.8

80

18

4.8

80

17

4.8

80

112.5

16

4.8

80

115.5

15

4.8

80

118.5

14

4.8

80

121.5

13

80

124.5

12

80

127.5

11

80

130.5

10

80

80

80

80

80

80

80

151.5

80

154.5

80

157.5

80

110

0.011

70.5

91.5
94.5
97.5

Seni

100.5

0.076

103.5
106.5
109.5

133.5
136.5
139.5
142.5
145.5
148.5

2nd Zone: 14-26 Stories

31

1st Zone: 1-13 Stories

67.5

Moment
160.0

140.0

Story Height

120.0

100.0

80.0

60.0

40.0

20.0

0.0
0

50000

100000

150000

200000

M (kN--m)

160.0

140.0

120.0

Story Height

100.0

80.0

Drift

Story Height
60.0

40.0

20.0

0.0
0.00

200.00

400.00

600.00

800.00 1000.00 1200.00

Fluxural Drift (mm)

160.0

140.0

120.0

Story Height (m)

Shear Drift
100.0

80.0

60.0

40.0

20.0

0.0
0.0

2.0

4.0

6.0

8.0

10.0

Shear Drift (mm)

160.0

140.0

Story Height (m)

120.0

100.0

80.0

60.0

40.0

20.0

0.0
0.000

nment No. 5 - Analysis of Braced Frame Tall Building

i =hiMi/EIi

Mi

if

kN-m

rad/E

60

Story drift

Total Drift

Total Drift (Fluxural)

if =if.hi

nf = if

nf

rad/E

(m/E)

(m/E)

(m)

(mm)

112.5

3223121.25

9669363.75

359416916.3

1.797

1797.085

300

562.5

3223008.75

9669026.25

349747552.5

1.749

1748.738

780

1462.5

3222446.25

9667338.75

340078526.3

1.700

1700.393

1500

2812.5

3220983.75

9662951.25

330411187.5

1.652

1652.056

2460

4612.5

3218171.25

9654513.75

320748236.3

1.604

1603.741

3660

6862.5

3213558.75

9640676.25

311093722.5

1.555

1555.469

5100

9562.5

3206696.25

9620088.75

301453046.3

1.507

1507.265

6780

12712.5

3197133.75

9591401.25

291832957.5

1.459

1459.165

8700

16312.5

3184421.25

9553263.75

282241556.3

1.411

1411.208

10860

20362.5

3168108.75

9504326.25

272688292.5

1.363

1363.441

13260

24862.5

3147746.25

9443238.75

263183966.3

1.316

1315.920

15900

29812.5

3122883.75

9368651.25

253740727.5

1.269

1268.704

18780

35212.5

3093071.25

9279213.75

244372076.3

1.222

1221.860

21900

41062.5

3057858.75

9173576.25

235092862.5

1.175

1175.464

25260

23681.25

3016796.25

9050388.75

225919286.3

1.130

1129.596

28860

27056.25

2993115

8979345

216868897.5

1.084

1084.344

32700

30656.25

2966058.75

8898176.25

207889552.5

1.039

1039.448

36780

34481.25

2935402.5

8806207.5

198991376.3

0.995

994.957

41100

38531.25

2900921.25

8702763.75

190185168.8

0.951

950.926

45660

42806.25

2862390

8587170

181482405

0.907

907.412

50460

47306.25

2819583.75

8458751.25

172895235

0.864

864.476

55500

52031.25

2772277.5

8316832.5

164436483.8

0.822

822.182

Story inclination
i = hiMi/Eii

60780

56981.25

2720246.25

8160738.75

156119651.3

0.781

780.598

66300

62156.25

2663265

7989795

147958912.5

0.740

739.795

72060

67556.25

2601108.75

7803326.25

139969117.5

0.700

699.846

78060

73181.25

2533552.5

7600657.5

132165791.3

0.661

660.829

84300

79031.25

2460371.25

7381113.75

124565133.8

0.623

622.826

90780

56737.5

2381340

7144020

117184020

0.586

585.920

97500

60937.5

2324602.5

6973807.5

110040000

0.550

550.200

104460

65287.5

2263665

6790995

103066192.5

0.515

515.331

111660

69787.5

2198377.5

6595132.5

96275197.5

0.481

481.376

119100

74437.5

2128590

6385770

89680065

0.448

448.400

126780

79237.5

2054152.5

6162457.5

83294295

0.416

416.471

134700

84187.5

1974915

5924745

77131837.5

0.386

385.659

142860

89287.5

1890727.5

5672182.5

71207092.5

0.356

356.035

151260

94537.5

1801440

5404320

65534910

0.328

327.675

159900

99937.5

1706902.5

5120707.5

60130590

0.301

300.653

168780

105487.5

1606965

4820895

55009882.5

0.275

275.049

177900

111187.5

1501477.5

4504432.5

50188987.5

0.251

250.945

187260

117037.5

1390290

4170870

45684555

0.228

228.423

196860

73822.5

1273252.5

3819757.5

41513685

0.208

207.568

206700

77512.5

1199430

3598290

37693927.5

0.188

188.470

216780

81292.5

1121917.5

3365752.5

34095637.5

0.170

170.478

227100

85162.5

1040625

3121875

30729885

0.154

153.649

237660

89122.5

955462.5

2866387.5

27608010

0.138

138.040

248460

93172.5

866340

2599020

24741622.5

0.124

123.708

259500

97312.5

773167.5

2319502.5

22142602.5

0.111

110.713

270780

101542.5

675855

2027565

19823100

0.099

99.116

282300

105862.5

574312.5

1722937.5

17795535

0.089

88.978

294060

110272.5

468450

1405350

16072597.5

0.080

80.363

306060

114772.5

358177.5

1074532.5

14667247.5

0.073

73.336

318300

119362.5

243405

730215

13592715

0.068

67.964

330780

124042.5

124042.5

372127.5

12862500

0.064

64.313

Moment
50

160.0

45

140.0

40
120.0

25
20

Story Height

30

Story level

35
100.0

80.0

60.0
15
40.0

10
5

200000

250000

300000

20.0

0
350000

0.0
0

50
45
40
35
30
25

Story level

Drift

20000

40000

Story level

25
20
15
10
5
0
1200.00 1400.00 1600.00 1800.00 2000.00

Drift (mm)

160.0
50
140.0

45

120.0

40

ear Drift

25
20
15

Story Height (m)

30

Story level

35

100.0

80.0

60.0

40.0

10
20.0
5
0
10.0

rift (mm)

12.0

14.0

16.0

0.0
0

500

1000

1500

Drift Comparision
Fluxural Drift

Shear Drift

Total Drift

160.0
50
140.0

45
40

120.0

35
30
80.0

25
20

60.0

15

40.0

10
20.0

0.0
0.000

5
0
200.000 400.000 600.000 800.000 1000.000 1200.000 1400.000 1600.000 1800.000 2000.000
Shear (kN)

Story level

100.0

Assignment No. 5 - Analysis of Brace

Story drift

Drift
Height of
building

Story

3rd Zone: 27-39 Stories

4th Zone: 40-53 Stories

ns

kN

mm

mm

53

40

5.11212E-06

0.005

14.360

159.0

52

120

1.53364E-05

0.015

14.355

156.0

51

200

2.55606E-05

0.026

14.340

153.0

50

280

3.57849E-05

0.036

14.314

150.0

49

360

4.60091E-05

0.046

14.278

147.0

48

440

5.62333E-05

0.056

14.232

144.0

47

520

6.64576E-05

0.066

14.176

141.0

46

600

7.66818E-05

0.077

14.109

138.0

45

680

8.69061E-05

0.087

14.033

135.0

44

760

9.71303E-05

0.097

13.946

132.0

43

840

0.000107355

0.107

13.849

129.0

42

920

0.000117579

0.118

13.741

126.0

41

1000

0.000127803

0.128

13.624

123.0

40

1080

0.000138027

0.138

13.496

120.0

39

1160

0.000148252

0.148

13.358

117.0

38

1240

0.000158476

0.158

13.210

114.0

37

1320

0.0001687

0.169

13.051

111.0

36

1400

0.000178924

0.179

12.883

108.0

35

1480

0.000189148

0.189

12.704

105.0

34

1560

0.000199373

0.199

12.514

102.0

33

1640

0.000209597

0.210

12.315

99.0

32

1720

0.000219821

0.220

12.106

96.0

3rd Zone: 27-3

31

1800

0.000230045

0.230

11.886

93.0

30

1880

0.00024027

0.240

11.656

90.0

29

1960

0.000250494

0.250

11.415

87.0

28

2040

0.000260718

0.261

11.165

84.0

27

2120

0.000270942

0.271

10.904

81.0

26

2200

0.000281167

0.281

10.633

78.0

25

2280

0.000291391

0.291

10.352

75.0

24

2360

0.000301615

0.302

10.061

72.0

23

2440

0.000311839

0.312

9.759

69.0

22

2520

0.000322064

0.322

9.447

66.0

21

2600

0.000332288

0.332

9.125

63.0

20

2680

0.000342512

0.343

8.793

60.0

19

2760

0.000352736

0.353

8.450

57.0

18

2840

0.000362961

0.363

8.098

54.0

17

2920

0.000373185

0.373

7.735

51.0

16

3000

0.000383409

0.383

7.361

48.0

15

3080

0.000393633

0.394

6.978

45.0

14

3160

0.000403858

0.404

6.584

42.0

13

3240

0.000414082

0.414

6.181

39.0

12

3320

0.000424306

0.424

5.766

36.0

11

3400

0.00043453

0.435

5.342

33.0

10

3480

0.000444755

0.445

4.908

30.0

3560

0.000454979

0.455

4.463

27.0

3640

0.000465203

0.465

4.008

24.0

3720

0.000475427

0.475

3.543

21.0

3800

0.000485652

0.486

3.067

18.0

3880

0.000495876

0.496

2.582

15.0

3960

0.0005061

0.506

2.086

12.0

4040

0.000516324

0.516

1.580

9.0

4120

0.000526549

0.527

1.063

6.0

4200

0.000536773

0.537

0.537

3.0

M/EI
50
45
40

30
25
20
15
10
5

60000

80000

M/EI (kN/E)

100000

120000

0
140000

Story level

35

50
45
40

Shear

30
25
20
15
10
5

1500

2000

2500

Shear (kN)

3000

3500

4000

0
4500

Story level

35

Analysis of Braced Frame Tall Building

Total Drift
nf
(Fluxural Drift)

ns
(Shear Drift)

Total

Total
Manual

mm

mm

mm

mm

1797.085

14.360

1811.445

1811.44

2.000067

2000.07 10.4128206

1748.738

14.355

1763.093

1763.09

1.951599

1951.6

1700.393

14.340

1714.732

1714.73

1.902932

1902.93 10.9754675

1652.056

14.314

1666.370

1666.37

1.854074

1854.07 11.2642532

1603.741

14.278

1618.019

1618.02

1.805042

1805.04 11.5587409

1555.469

14.232

1569.701

1569.7

1.755859

1755.86 11.8594732

1507.265

14.176

1521.441

1521.44

1.706558

1706.56 12.1672045

1459.165

14.109

1473.274

1473.27

1.657173

1657.17 12.4823167

1411.208

14.033

1425.241

1425.24

1.60775

1607.75 12.8055186

1363.441

13.946

1377.387

1377.39

1.558339

1558.34 13.1373119

1315.920

13.849

1329.769

1329.77

1.508997

1268.704

13.741

1282.445

1282.45

1.459789

1459.79 13.8285834

1221.860

13.624

1235.484

1235.48

1.410785

1410.79 14.1888352

1175.464

13.496

1188.960

1188.96

1.362063

1362.06 14.5591644

1129.596

13.358

1142.954

1142.95

1.313707

1313.71 14.9395806

1084.344

13.210

1097.554

1097.55

1.265631

1265.63 15.3137575

1039.448

13.051

1052.499

1052.5

1.21773

1217.73 15.6989213

994.957

12.883

1007.839

1007.84

1.170057

1170.06 16.0955771

950.926

12.704

963.629

963.629

1.122666

1122.67 16.5039094

907.412

12.514

919.926

919.926

1.075617

1075.62 16.9242327

864.476

12.315

876.791

876.791

1.028973

1028.97 17.3566649

822.182

12.106

834.288

834.288

0.9828

SAP U1
mm

1509

982.8

%age
Dfference
%
10.6918037

13.4781672

17.801058

780.598

11.886

792.484

792.484

0.937166

937.166 18.2567815

739.795

11.656

751.450

751.45

0.892144

892.144 18.7229706

699.846

11.415

711.261

711.261

0.84781

847.81

660.829

11.165

671.994

671.994

0.804243

804.243 19.6801167

622.826

10.904

633.730

633.73

0.761528

761.528 20.1660346

585.920

10.633

596.553

596.553

0.719747

719.747 20.6509099

550.200

10.352

560.552

560.552

0.67878

678.78

21.0913428

515.331

10.061

525.392

525.392

0.63849

638.49

21.5264915

481.376

9.759

491.135

491.135

0.598941

598.941 21.9503734

448.400

9.447

457.848

457.848

0.5602

416.471

9.125

425.597

425.597

0.522336

522.336 22.7303003

385.659

8.793

394.452

394.452

0.485418

485.418 23.0613496

356.035

8.450

364.486

364.486

0.449521

449.521

23.330182

327.675

8.098

335.772

335.772

0.41472

414.72

23.512328

300.653

7.735

308.388

308.388

0.381092

381.092 23.5756601

275.049

7.361

282.411

282.411

0.348718

348.718 23.4789592

250.945

6.978

257.923

257.923

0.317679

317.679 23.1681627

228.423

6.584

235.007

235.007

0.28806

288.06

207.568

6.181

213.749

213.749

0.259946

259.946 21.6127441

188.470

5.766

194.236

194.236

0.233059

233.059 19.9874726

170.478

5.342

175.820

175.82

0.207102

207.102 17.7918225

153.649

4.908

158.557

158.557

0.182131

182.131 14.8677946

138.040

4.463

142.503

142.503

0.158202

158.202

123.708

4.008

127.716

127.716

0.135376

135.376 5.99766921

110.713

3.543

114.256

114.256

0.113712

113.712

-0.4758736

99.116

3.067

102.183

102.183

0.09927

99.27

-2.8505519

88.978

2.582

91.559

91.5593

0.088115

88.115

-3.7618205

80.363

2.086

82.449

82.4487

0.075311

75.311

-8.6571774

73.336

1.580

74.916

74.9159 0.0680921 68.0921

-9.1085933

67.964

1.063

69.027

69.0269

0.060019

60.019

-13.049835

64.313

0.537

64.849

64.8493

0.055644

55.644

-14.194874

560.2

19.198164

22.3551441

22.5749744

11.016663

Comparision with SAP200

140.0

120.0

Story Height (m)

100.0

80.0

60.0

40.0

20.0

0.0
0.000

500.000

parision with SAP2000.v12 with Manual calc.

SAP Drift
50

40

30

20

10

500.000

1000.000

1500.000

Shear (kN)

2000.000

0
2500.000