Edexcel Geography A-level

Migration, Identity and Sovereignty

Detailed Notes

www.pmt.education
 Economic Systems and Labour Flows
Globalisation has led to an increase in both ​internal and international migration​. As of
2014, 230 million people lived in a country that wasn’t their place of birth (approx. 3-4% of
the global population). This is due to the advancement of ​transport networks​ to allow
people to travel easily to other countries to live, work and visit. Also, a rise in ​global trading
has encouraged a recent rise in international migrants, the highest since the collapse of
empires. Most international migration is ​regionalised​, like Mexicans to America or Poland to
Germany.
Uneven economic growth​ may be linked originally to a ​natural advantage​ over other
countries, such as a coastline or raw materials. Initial imbalances have been ​exaggerated
over time​ due to the ​outflow of migrants, resources and investment.
The number of people migrating internationally has risen rapidly and from 1950 to 2015, the
global population grew rapidly from 2.5 billion to 7.3 billion. In the 1990s, international
migration occurred mainly to world destinations like New York and Paris. Now, many cities in
developing countries (e.g. Mumbai and Lagos) have become major hubs for migration.
Different countries have ​different rates of change​ and different ​population structures​ as a
result. This may be due to government​ policy making ​or ​levels of engagement​ within the
globalised world:

Japan Australia Singapore

Japan’s population is Australia’s immigration Singapore’s population
declining​; 27% are aged 65 policy has been based on consists of a very ​high
and over and its working strict​ly based on​ skills and percentage of foreign
age population is expected employment​. 70% of workers​.
to drop to 44 million by immigrants accepted into Among the 5 million people
2037, half of what it was in Australia came to work in living in Singapore, there is
2007. areas with ​skills shortages great ​ethnic diversity​.
In most advanced with most immigrants living It is the world’s 4​th​ largest
economies around 5% of in major cities like financial centre​. Many
people are usually Melbourne. TNCs have the Asia-Pacific
immigrants but this is only On average, immigrants HQs in Singapore.
1.7% for Japan. The UN contribute 10% more per Many ​international
thinks Japan requires ​17 capita than non-immigrants. schools​ have also set up to
million migrants by 2050 Australia has an ageing cater education to migrants,
to make sure population population but as migrants whose first language may
levels don’t drop below 2007 are usually young, the not be Malay (the national
levels ageing population is language).
Migration is limited due to balanced​.
the fact that Japanese isn’t In 2013, only ​190,000
an ​international language​, economic migrants​ were
thus many don’t speak it allowed to enter Australia
outside of Japan, and its
closed-door policies
towards migrants.

www.pmt.education
 Causes of Migration
There can be a variety of reasons for migrants to move, either internally or internationally.
The cause of migration can affect how governments treat them or how the public perceive
them.
International migration can result from a variety of causes:
● Voluntary Economic Migration​ → People relocate to try to improve their wealth and
quality of life.
● Often, an economic migrant’s family may follow them in the aim of ​joining their
family​.
● Refugees​ → People forced to relocate due to war, conflict, persecution.
● Asylum seekers​ →People fleeing for international protection.
● Environmental Refugees​ → People specifically relocating due to tectonic disaster,
natural events (wildfires, flooding) or Climate Change’s impacts (desertification, sea
level rise, etc.)
● International Students​ - ​Within recent years, there has been a large increase in the
volume of young people migrating to study elsewhere.
The flows of international migration will continue to change over time, as ​environmental,
political and economic​ events occur and a country’s ​development​ improves or declines.

Rationale FOR Encouraging Migration

Migration is seen as an efficient way of ensuring that ​economic output​ of a country/place is
optimised​. Workers are integral to a growing economy, migration is a way of growing a
country or place’s workforce. Internal migration (often from rural to urban areas) is mostly
unrestricted, with some countries encouraging international migration within trade blocs and
governmental agreements (for example, the EU has the largest free movement of migrants).
Economic Theory​ suggests that governments will maximise ‘economic efficiency’ - a
productive workforce and a developed financial market - if they allow the ​free movement of
goods, capital and labour​. However, some countries do not agree with the economic
theory or fear they’ll lose their ​national identity​ through unrestricted flows. Therefore flows
aren’t fully unrestricted on a global scale.

Rationale AGAINST Encouraging Migration

Some governments have more restricted immigration controls to restrict the number of
immigrants coming into their country. It is important to recognise that a government's beliefs
or rationale towards immigrants is due to their ​perception​ of migration. The consequences
of migration may be viewed as both​ positive and negative​ by different players.
National Culture - ​Migration usually leads to changes in the ethnic composition of areas.
Some countries believe that changes to their ​ethnic or cultural composition​ may lead to
cultural diffusion, which could lead to the loss of their national culture or historical
demography.

www.pmt.education
Employment​ - ​Some governments may encourage migrants to fill skills gaps or improve
economic activity. However, especially in areas with high unemployment rates, locals may
blame​ immigrants for the ​loss of job opportunities​ in their area.
National Security - ​Recent events (such as terror attacks on major cities and the so-called
War on Terror) has caused political controversy regarding national security. Many people
fear that freely allowing migrants to enter their country could pose a security risk. Views such
as these have been exacerbated by some media outlets and politicians. The backlash
against unregulated migration has lead to changes within politics such as the election of
Donald Trump, the rise of extreme right-wing political parties and Brexit.
Opportunity to Migrate
The ​ability​ for an individual to migrate depends on the government’s policies and border
control, the physical environment (mountains, seas, etc) and the migrant’s education and
skills. For example:
▪ Migrants to ​Australia​ are restricted to mainly skilled individuals. They require 65 points
under the points based system, which takes into account the demand for a particular
profession in Australia in addition to a migrant’s age, qualifications and competence in
English.
▪ Singapore​’s migration policy is divided into foreign workers and foreign talent. Workers
are predominantly unskilled migrants, mainly working in construction and domestic
services. Talents are mainly people with degrees and are highly knowledgeable.
▪ The rise of ​smugglers​ in recent years means that migrants need money to migrate
illegally across borders. Smugglers only operate across strict international borders, such
as the Mexican-US border or across the Mediterranean Sea (towards Europe).

Nation States
A ​state​ is a territory that no other country has power or ​sovereignty​ over. As of 2016, the
UN recognised ​196 states,​ with South Sudan being the most recent addition. A ​nation
refers to a group of people who ​lack sovereignty​. This includes the Welsh and Scottish
nations as they are part of the sovereign state of the UK. These nations lack full control,
despite having their own ​parliaments​ and language.
Nation states don’t necessarily have a single culture or language, and the borders (both
physical and political) between states are often ​contested​.

Cultural Unity
There can be different languages, dialects, sports teams, music and literature within a single
state. This can result from ​historic migration​, such as in the USA, where the descendents
of European settlers have vastly outnumbered the descendents of indigenous tribes.
Alternatively, some states have a single ethnic group (​ethnic and cultural unity​) due to its
physical location​ (e.g. Iceland) or ​political forced isolation​ (e.g. North Korea – the
government restricts interactions with foreign countries).

www.pmt.education
Establishing National Borders
Borders between states are highly important in establishing governance for a region and to
avoid conflict. However, there are still tensions and contest over borders and islands to this
day. National borders may be created naturally or through social intervention:
Natural borders​ – Physical features such as lakes, mountains or rivers can separate
countries. Often, natural borders are the most successful borders between states because of
their inarguable division. This may be because armies cannot cross these natural borders
unnoticed or that these natural borders create a band of uninhabitable land, easily
separating two states without conflict over residents’ sovereignty.
Colonial or Political Intervention​ - Borders are drafted by the sovereign state, and may
have been influenced by past empire expansion. Borders created by governments may not
take into account differences between religious or ethnic groups, which could lead to conflict
between social groups in the future. Such was the case for Rwanda, where clashing ethnic
groups within one state spiralled into the genocide of 800,000 Tutsis.

Contested Border Examples

Ukraine and Crimea - ​The population of Crimea consists of 58% ethnic Russians, 24%
ethnic Ukrainians and 12% Tartar Muslims. In 2014, Russia ​annexed​ Crimea (added Crimea
to Russia’s state) from Ukraine on the basis that the majority of the population was
ethnically Russian​, and the Ukraine government wasn’t successfully protecting them. The
international community condemned Russia’s annexation and imposed ​sanctions​ against
Russian trade, but haven’t made much progress in settling the dispute and resolving the
conflict within Crimea.
Taiwan​ - Since 1950, Taiwan has been ​independent​. However, China still claims
sovereignty over it and regards Taiwan as a ​rebel province​. China insists no other countries
should have any relations with Taiwan, but that has not stopped Taiwan from becoming one
of Asia’s ​economic successes​ through the production of computer technology.
Syria and Iraq - ​Conflict in this region may be due to the ​Sykes-Picot line​, a border
between French occupation and the UK’s control in the Middle East. Large Kurdish, Shia
and Sunni populations were divided across this line and ​extremist groups​ (such as Daesh
and Al-Qaeda) have incited conflict between the social groups. The ​UN Security Council
(primarily the US and Russia) is involved, conducting airstrikes against the extremist groups
(perceived as terrorists).

www.pmt.education
19th Century Nationalism & Colonialism
Between 1500 and 1900, many European powers had built ​global empires​. Newly
discovered South America was invaded and colonised by the Spanish whilst the UK, France
and Belgium colonised parts of Asia and Africa.
For example, by 1880 Britain controlled a ​third of the world’s land surface​ and over a
quarter of the world’s population​. British culture spread across South Asia (sports,
language, customs) through local governance and education, controlled by the UK. (As a
result, many previously-colonial states now have the Union Jack within their own flag)
However, the empires ​disintegrated​ following World War 1 because:
▪ The high cost of war had left the UK almost ​bankrupt
▪ There was ​growing resistance​ to foreign rule and the rise of independence political
groups
▪ Rapid population growth​ was a major problem for the UK government
▪ European countries were becoming ​less dependent on raw materials​ from their
colonies
Some independent states (Vietnam, Sudan, etc) were left unable to successfully govern
themselves, which has lead to many ​conflicts and wars​ following the end of the Imperial
Era. The conflict has been costly to their ​development​, natural ​environment​ and in terms of
human fatalities​.
Post-Colonial Migration
In 1948, the ​British Nationality Act​ gave all commonwealth citizens an equal right to legally
settle in the UK. As a result many employers filled ​skills gaps​ with commonwealth migrants,
such as in the London Underground and the NHS. Both skilled and unskilled migrants were
accepted; for example, skilled migrants worked as ​healthcare professionals​ whilst less
skilled workers worked in the ​manufacturing industries​, especially in the textile towns of
Lancashire and Yorkshire.
There was ​cultural clustering​, with commonwealth families moving into the same areas to
share opportunities, create networks of family support and to limit their isolation. This
clustering can be seen today, with the growth of some commonwealth communities
becoming important parts of major cities.

Globalisation’s Effect on Migration & Sovereignty

Economic Impacts of Globalisation
Many TNCS have relocated their headquarters to countries such as Ireland, Switzerland and
Luxembourg due to ​low corporate tax rates​. In 2015, the UK corporation tax rate was
around 20% but it was around 10% in Switzerland. TNCs sometimes also consider the
support​ from the local government, including financial ​bail​, ​infrastructure construction
and ​economic​ ​incentives​ to relocate there.
Some states have become notorious ​tax havens​ (locations which offer massive tax
advantages to individuals and companies). These states tend to be ​politically stable​ and

www.pmt.education
have ​secure banking and legal systems​. In 2015, it was reported that American
companies held $2 trillion overseas in tax havens. Tax havens also become the homes for
wealthy expatriates​, who would rather migrate than face extortionate ‘millionaire’ taxes.
Tax havens can have large ​economic consequences​ for other states. The taxes paid by
businesses are crucial for governments to fund healthcare, education and other public
services. As a result, there are significant impacts if companies use transfer pricing or tax
havens, which could stunt a state’s development and attractiveness to migrants. Many
companies have been targeted by ​citizen-led protests​ (e.g Starbucks, Google) which has
led to voluntary tax contributions by TNCs to try to recover ​public confidence​.
However some companies do not relocate to reduce their tax rates; a TNC may want to
maintain a certain ​public perception​ regarding the product’s manufacturing. Instead of
relocating, many TNCs choose to use ​transfer pricing​ - when profits are diverted through
subsidiary companies​ based in low tax countries which in turn reduces the corporate tax
bill for a company.
Many industrialised countries have adopted the ​Washington Consensus​, the belief that
economic efficiency can only be achieved by ​removing financial regulations​. In the 1970s
and 80s, deregulation became very common as state intervention of the ​markets reduced​.
As a result of deregulation, capital could flow anywhere in the world easily and quickly, which
has helped to accelerate globalisation. However, financial deregulation contributed heavily to
the 2008 financial crisis.

Alternative Economic Models

Leaders (many from South American countries) have moved from an open-market economy
to a ​socialist approach​. Many reasons to argue against capitalism include:
- In 2016, 62 of the richest people owned the same wealth as the bottom 3.5 billion.
- The global financial crisis in 2008 and the growing inability of Western countries to
reduce inequality shows the limitations of deregulated open markets.
- Ongoing failure of countries to reduce the impacts of climate change rather than
accumulate their wealth.
To adopt a more ​sustainable economic system​, governments (such as Bolivia or Ecuador)
must:
● Limit​ imports​ of essential resources, such as food, water and raw materials.
● Ensure ​energy security​ (often using renewable sources)
● Reduce TNCs, instead promoting ​local businesses​ to secure employment
opportunities and tax generated.

Inter-Government Organisations in the Post-1945 World

IGOs have grown in significance and influence since World War 2. They can provide
political guidance and judgement​ over a state government or ​economic support​ for
developing countries.

www.pmt.education
The United Nations
In 1944, the UN’s aims, structure and roles were agreed by the USA, UK, USSR and China
(who form the only permanent members of the security council, along with France). Its aims
include:
▪ Maintaining international ​peace and security
▪ Promoting ​sustainable​ development
▪ Protecting ​human rights
▪ Upholding ​international law
▪ Delivering humanitarian ​aid
However, the UN is ​not​ unbiased since​ national disputes​ often influence ​UN policy
making​.
The ​Syrian conflict​ was an example of such unbiased judgement; Russia and China
wanted (to an extent) to support the Assad regime whereas the USA, UK and France
support the rebels. All decisions regarding the Syrian conflict were based from the states’
opinions, which could arguable have caused the conflict to escalate.
The ​Security Council​ (arguably the most important aspect of the UN) meets to respond to
threats to national and international security. The UN can introduce ​economic sanctions
against countries or can carry out ​direct military intervention​:
▪ Arms embargoes​ – banning weapons and military supplies
▪ Trade embargoes​ – banning certain imports and exports from and to certain countries
▪ Restrictions on ​loans
▪ Freezing assets
▪ Travel restrictions​ – for high profile people like politicians and business people
The success of UN intervention is mixed. States can act ​cooperatively​ and can share
resources and information​ to reduce loss of life. However, the UN has no hard-power
methods to police countries. Countries can ignore advice from the UN. For example. Russia
ignores the UN’s advice in relation to its ongoing conflict with the Ukraine.
The World Bank & IMF
The World Bank and International Monetary Fund (IMF) both have headquarters in
Washington, USA. They were established to try and ​stabilise global finance markets​ after
the ​Great Depression​ and ​post-WWII​, which caused many countries to become nearly
bankrupt.
Many ​Western countries​ agreed on the policies of the World Bank and IMF, including a
fixed exchange rate for any loans or financial assistance, based on the US dollar and gold.
The USA had a ​disproportionate influence​ at Bretton Woods (a conference in 1944) over
how the world economic system was to be designed. This was because only the USA was
left with a large amount of financial resources after the wars, whilst the UK and other
European states were left almost ​bankrupt​. As these institutions were created and are
regulated by Western countries, they can often favour developed countries over developing
countries in terms of the help they offer.

www.pmt.education
Impacts of IMF and World Bank
The IMF and World Bank only agreed to help struggling countries if they agreed to
Structural Adjustment Policies (SAPS)​. SAPS are often policies which countries have to
implement if they want to receive a loan. They are designed to help open up the developing
countries to trade and production to grow their economy and help them develop. SAPS can
include:
▪ Open up domestic markets​ to allow private investment
▪ Reduce the role of government​ by privatising industries and services
▪ Remove restrictions on capital​ so there are no limits on international investments
▪ Reduce government spending​ by cutting infrastructure and welfare spending
▪ Devalue currency​ ​to make exports cheaper
Critics argue that as the loans are reliant on a country implementing these policies their
government are forced into them. The policies are not always beneficial to the country that
implements them.
In the 1980s, ​global interest rates increased very rapidly​. This caused substantial interest
to be added to loans which ​increased global debts​. Developing countries were mainly
affected since the loan became unaffordable and quickly accumulated. Countries were
struggling to pay off the interest of these loans and were ending up in further debt, which
was not beneficial to their economy. In 2005, £30bn of debt of the eighteen poorest countries
in the world was written-off thanks to a deal brokered by the G7 countries.

The Highly Indebted Poor Countries Initiative (HIPC)

In 1996, the IMF and the World Bank introduced the ​HIPC initiative​, following criticism over
the spiralling debts of developing countries and ​lack of fair assistance​ from the IMF and
World Bank. HIPC aimed at reducing the national debts of developing countries by writing
them off in return for ​Structural Adjustment Policies​. The HIPC initiative affected 36 of the
world’s least developed countries with the greatest debts.
By 2000, many NGOs (e.g. Oxfam) began demanding more action to reduce the debt
burden of the most indebted countries. In 2008, all debts owed to the World Bank and IMF
by ​18 HIPC ​were cancelled on condition that:
- Each country showed ​financial management​ and a lack of ​corruption
- National government ​spent any savings​ on poverty reduction, education and
healthcare

World Trade Organisation (WTO)

Membership of financial IGOs is almost universal, with WTO members accounting for 96.4%
of world trade and 96.7% of global GDP. The WTO was established to create ​fair, free
global trading​. There are now several single market where there is free movement of
goods, services and people between allied nations. However, a global single market is still
unachievable.
Due to the ​failure of the WTO​, many ​trade blocs​ between nations have emerged, often
more influential than WTO (e.g. EU, NAFTA, ASEAN). Businesses can benefit from

www.pmt.education
economies of scale​ when operating within trade blocs because they have access to larger
markets therefore they can ‘scale up’ production, manufacturing bulk quantities, which in turn
helps them to reduce their unit costs and earn more profits.
Decisions to join trade blocs should be taken cautiously by governments as local markets
could become ​flooded​ by cheap products from another country within the bloc, which can
damage local businesses and the nation’s economy. All countries within a trade bloc may
not be equal beneficiaries​, with some countries taking political or economic leadership of
the bloc.

IGO’s Actions for the Environment

Within the last few decades, IGOs have initiated many ​environmental agreements and
protocols​ between governments. This may be to​ ​protect endangered species or
landscapes, reduce Greenhouse emissions or sovereignty over seas surrounding a state.
Climate change​ was first raised as an important issue in 1992 at the ​UN East Summit
Conference​. There has been ​uncertainty​ over evidence and disagreements between
countries as to who should be held responsible for emissions. This has meant that
international cooperation​ on climate change has been very slow. Many pledges have been
created (e.g. Montreal Protocol, Kyoto Protocol, 2012 Paris Agreements), each successively
receiving ​more member signatures​ and having ​stricter targets​ set. However, critics still
say that IGO’s agreements don’t go far enough and don’t have strict enough consequences
for nations who don’t follow them.
Alternatively, the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea has been more successful than
Climate Change agreements in resolving governmental disputes over sea rights. 157
countries have signed the agreement, which:
● Declares ownership of a state’s seas 20 nautical miles from their land.
● Gives landlocked countries entitlement to seas near them, enabling them to trade.
● Aims to protect marine biodiversity and ocean environments.
Despite clarifying most sea disputes, UNCLOS has lead to ​increased tensions​ over
disputes over new found islands, which lay claim to ​untapped natural resources​ and
military expansion opportunity​. Such is the case over many islands in the ​South China
Sea​ - which China, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea all argue over - and some ​Arctic Islands​ -
causing conflict between USA, Denmark, Canada & Russia due to its proximity to the Arctic.
Finally, IGOs may become ‘peacekeepers’ between nations over ​transboundary water
sources and the ​Antarctic​. With rapid population growth and the ​rising demand ​for water,
conflict​ between nations over who owns a river and how best to manage it will escalate.
The Antarctic (currently ​protected for science​) is protected by many IGOs and NGOs, who
wish to preserve it against modern ​pollution and rubbish​ (especially the ‘tide’ of plastic
waste) and to ​protect endangered species ​from humans as well as Climate Change.

www.pmt.education
 National Identity
The idea of ​nationalism​ can be a powerful force, with many governments intent to maintain
a sense of nationalism through:
▪ Education​ – the curriculum areas of history and citizenship are important as they play a
cultural and political role in nation-state building, whilst introducing a government’s
ideology from a young age. Students may learn about legal and human rights, as well as
their responsibilities to their country.
▪ Sport and Culture​ ​– You are likely to support your nation’s sports team in international
competitions such as the Olympics and Paralympics. People dress up and paint their
faces which strengthens national identity.
▪ Political parties ​– Government have used policies to reinforce national values and
ideals for many years. A party’s agenda can be strongly associated with a country’s
identity to gain more members and votes.
Examples of nationalism include:
▪ National flags​ can be found in schools across the world.
▪ In the USA, students are strongly encouraged to sing the ​national anthem​ and national
flags dominate during national celebrations.
▪ Since 2014, English schools have been legally required to ​promote British Values​:
o Democracy – being able to vote at the age of 18.
o The rule of law – right to trial by jury.
o Individual liberty – right to choose where to live.
o Mutual respect and tolerance of people of different faiths, backgrounds and
ethnicities.
▪ In 2005, there were ​widespread protests​ in South Korea and China because Japan
approved ​new textbooks​ which would promote nationalist ideas of Japan and described
WWII conflict from the Japanese point of view.
▪ In many European countries, there has been a rise in ​extreme right-wing parties​. In the
UK, membership of UKIP has grown rapidly since 1991 as people want to restrict UK
borders and adopt anti-migration policies.
▪ Particular ​environments​ can also be identified with a state. Rural life and the English
countryside have become symbolic of English identity and lifestyle.
Identity can often be associated with ​citizenship​ and an individual’s ​right to live​ within a
state:
▪ Many US citizens find a common focus for identity in the rights and freedom they have
according to the ​US Constitution​. The 1st Amendment guarantees freedom of speech
and the 2nd Amendment guarantees the right to self defense which includes the right to
own firearms.
▪ Cultural cohesion in France relies on the shared belief in the importance of freedom. In
2009, a ​ban on the Niqab​ was introduced in France and the President’s rationale for the
ban was that he believed that it was oppression against women.
▪ The UK’s ​Magna Carta​ is viewed as the foundation of British laws, liberties and
principles.
▪ Japan allows ​little inward migration​ because it wants to protect its culture and the
homogeneity

www.pmt.education
 Challenges to National Identity
Ownership of Foreign Businesses and Land
In many countries, there have been many ​inward flows​ of investment and ideas (through
globalisation). Many assets in the UK are now ​foreign owned​, such as:
- American TNC Kraft bought Cadbury in 2010.
- The UK’s car industry is now almost completely foreign owned.
- Foreign governments have also bought assets here e.g. the Qatari Sovereign Wealth
Fund who own Harrods.
- The Chinese government bought a major stake in Heathrow Airport and in many
nuclear plants including Hinkley Point (which could potentially threaten the UK’s
energy security​)
Businesses provide jobs for people so their ownership many not be concerning to
employees. However, foreign owned companies don’t need to pay taxes here so the UK
government loses out. For example, Italian-owned Boots moved their HQ to Switzerland
reducing their tax bill from £89m to £9m.
Growing ​foreign ownership of properties​ and land in the UK is also seen as a major threat
to national identity. London property can be especially lucrative, mainly due to the demand
from ​international wealthy migrants​. In 1980, 8% of the City of London was owned by
migrants; this value rose and exceeded 50% in 2011. Foreign ownership of land has caused
a lot of anger amongst locals due to a ​lack of housing​ (especially ​affordable​) and a surge
in prices has made buying a first home very difficult.
On the other hand, many UK citizens are responsible for changing place identities in coastal
areas of France, Spain and Italy. There has been ​outward migration​ of British retirees and
entrepreneurs abroad, replacing the cultural landscape of many tourist areas as a result.
Some ​TNCs​ have altered the way of life in many countries they have invested in. They can
offer different ​employment opportunities​, new ​products and lifestyle ​changes.

Disunity within nations

There has been an increasing number of independence parties and demonstrations for
nations within recent years. The most prominent examples of disunity would be Catalonia
(currently experiencing intense protests) and Scotland (following the UK’s decision to leave
the EU):

Catalonia Scotland
Located in North Eastern Spain. Its capital In 2014, a referendum was held in which
is Barcelona. 45% of voters voted for independence
whilst the remaining 55% voted against
The Catalan people have their own
independence from the UK.
language and customs and is the
wealthiest region in Spain; producing 20% This has caused great division between the
of Spain’s wealth. population, especially regarding politics.

www.pmt.education
 Many Catalonians want independence from Scotland’s income predominantly comes
Spain. In 2017, the Catalonian government from oil and gas in the North Sea but as oil
held a referendum in which more than 90% prices are very low, independence may be
of voters wanted independence. However, very costly as the Scottish wouldn’t have
the vote was seen as illegal by the Spanish reliable sources of government revenue.
government and thus wasn’t recognised
Support for another referendum is rising
officially.
since Brexit

Rising Tensions in Emerging Nations

Globalisation has created many ​winners and losers​. Emerging nations have great
inequality​ between the wealthy elites and extremely poor. ​Nationalism​ has increased in
countries where globalisation has created tensions
Brazil​ - Brazil’s hosting of the World Cup in 2014 and then the Olympics exposed serious
divisions in Brazilian society. More than $22 billion was spent on preparing for the world cup;
protests took place as people believed the money spent on the world cup could be spent
solving some of Brazil’s problems (poor public services, high food prices and widespread
corruption amongst politicians)
Russia​ - Russia is the world’s largest country and it is home to many ethnic groups, some
residing far from Moscow. Nomadic herders are also found in Russia, wandering across the
Northern altitudes. There is rising tensions of the government’s protection of ethnic groups
within and outside Russia’s borders.
India​ - There have rising tensions between Muslims and Hindus since India gained
independence; Many Muslims in Kashmir support breaking away from India as a separate
state or joining Pakistan. Furthermore, more than 500 million Indian people live in extreme
poverty and lack access to healthcare and education (mostly living in rural areas) and so
there is resentment from the inequality in benefits from globalisation.
China​ - China’s Hukou system means that many rural migrants cannot benefit from
globalisation i.e. by working in factories suppling TNCs. There are more than 300 million
rural migrants, many of whom suffer from poverty, famine and illness from living close to
polluting factories.

Failed States
In failed states, there are vast differences between wealthy ​political elites​, ​foreign
investments groups​ and the general population. A failed state is where the political and
economic systems are very weak and the government can no longer maintain ​control and
order​. The following are usually common in failed states:
- Low life expectancy
- Social unrest
- Poor education
- Poor healthcare system

www.pmt.education
 - Widespread poverty
- High inequality
Often, failed states can be created from ​war and conflict​ (e.g. Syria), which damages any
remaining infrastructure and services, resulting in dire living conditions and drastic outward
migration.

www.pmt.education