International Communism and The Cult of The Individual: Leaders, Tribunes and Martyrs Under Lenin and Stalin 1st Edition Kevin Morgan (Auth.)
International Communism and The Cult of The Individual: Leaders, Tribunes and Martyrs Under Lenin and Stalin 1st Edition Kevin Morgan (Auth.)
International Communism and The Cult of The Individual: Leaders, Tribunes and Martyrs Under Lenin and Stalin 1st Edition Kevin Morgan (Auth.)
com
https://textbookfull.com/product/international-
communism-and-the-cult-of-the-individual-leaders-
tribunes-and-martyrs-under-lenin-and-stalin-1st-
edition-kevin-morgan-auth/
DOWLOAD NOW
https://textbookfull.com/product/making-martyrs-the-language-of-
sacrifice-in-russian-culture-from-stalin-to-putin-yuliya-minkova/
https://textbookfull.com/product/biota-grow-2c-gather-2c-cook-
loucas/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-sage-handbook-of-
personality-and-individual-differences-origins-of-personality-
and-individual-differences-1st-edition-virgil-zeigler-hill/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-vampire-of-the-opera-the-
skylark-and-the-eagle-1-1st-edition-morgan-de-guerre-de-guerre-
morgan/
Cult of glory: The Bold and Brutal History of the Texas
Rangers 1st Edition Doug J. Swanson
https://textbookfull.com/product/cult-of-glory-the-bold-and-
brutal-history-of-the-texas-rangers-1st-edition-doug-j-swanson/
https://textbookfull.com/product/the-rights-and-aspirations-of-
the-magna-carta-1st-edition-elizabeth-gibson-morgan/
https://textbookfull.com/product/william-s-burroughs-and-the-
cult-of-rock-n-roll-casey-rae/
Alone of All Her Sex: The Myth and Cult of the Virgin
Mary Marina Warner
https://textbookfull.com/product/alone-of-all-her-sex-the-myth-
and-cult-of-the-virgin-mary-marina-warner/
https://textbookfull.com/product/child-soldiers-and-the-defence-
of-duress-under-international-criminal-law-windell-nortje/
International
Communism
and the Cult of
the Individual
Leaders,Tribunes and Martyrs
under Lenin and Stalin
KEVIN
M O R GA N
International Communism and the Cult
of the Individual
Kevin Morgan
International
Communism and the
Cult of the Individual
Leaders, Tribunes and Martyrs under Lenin
and Stalin
Kevin Morgan
Sch of Social Sci Politics
University of Manchester
Manchester, United Kingdom
This book draws on research into communist history going back over
many years and it is impossible to register all the debts I have accumu-
lated here. Nevertheless, a number of these must be recorded dating from
the period I spent working specifically on this project in 2013–2015. For
this opportunity I must first acknowledge the support of the Arts and
Humanities Research Council (award AH/J005975/1: ‘Communism and
the cult of the leader’) supported by sabbatical leave from the University
of Manchester and the cover provided by my colleagues in Politics. I was
very fortunate to have the assistance of Francis King while researching in
the Moscow archives and for guidance on diverse translation issues. Unless
otherwise stated, translations from Russian sources are by Dr King. I am
also grateful to Julie Johnson and Norman LaPorte for help with trans-
lations from the German and diverse other matters, to José Neves and
Stephen Parker for help with original texts which I had read in French and
to Gavin Bowd and Gareth Price-Thomas for their comments on other
translation issues. I must also thank Lynda Morris for assistance in locat-
ing the Picasso images, and owe special thanks to Aldo Agosti for the
translation of the letter of Togliatti cited in Chaps 2 and 3, and for assis-
tance with a number of other queries.
The immediate idea for writing the book came from editing the inau-
gural issue of Twentieth Century Communism on ‘Communism and the
leader cult’ in 2009. I must therefore record my debt to those who con-
tributed to that issue and to my fellow journal editors. I also derived
much benefit from the Manchester seminar on the cult of the individual
in December 2013, and would like to thank Balázs Apor, John Bulaitis,
v
vi Acknowledgements
Sarah Davies, Mario Kessler, Norman LaPorte, Marietta Stankova and all
who contributed to a stimulating day. I also appreciated the opportunity
to present parts of this research at events organised by the Society for
the Study of Labour History and the Communism Group of the Political
Studies Association, and at the ESSHC and Historical Materialism confer-
ences held respectively in Vienna and London in 2014. A final presenta-
tion at the University of Bern provided the occasion for comments on the
introduction from Brigitte Studer which I found particularly helpful.
The broader treatment offered here would have been impossible
without the stimulus and intellectual generosity of colleagues work-
ing on communism and left movements internationally. In addition to
those already mentioned, those who helped through discussion, feed-
back, sources or advice on specific points include Kasper Braskén, John
Callaghan, Madeleine Davis, Jean-François Fayet, Mike Jones, Anastasia
Koukouna, Carl Levy, Adriá Llacuna, Stuart Macintyre, John Manley,
Emmet O’Connor, Bernard Pudal, Ole Martin Rønning, James G. Ryan,
Andrew Thorpe, Stephen White, Serge Wolikow and Matthew Worley. I
am particularly grateful to those who read over sections of the text dealing
with matters in which they have particular expertise, namely John Bulaitis,
Romain Ducolombier, José Gotovitch, Norman LaPorte, Lars T. Lih,
Silvio Pons, Tim Rees and Tauno Saarela. Given our published collabora-
tions in the field, I owe it to Norry LaPorte in particular to point out that
I alone am responsible for the interpretations presented here.
On many occasions in the past I have already had to record my thanks
to colleagues at the Working Class Movement Library, the Labour History
Archive and Study Centre and other research libraries in Britain. As well
as further research at RGASPI in Moscow, I must now also acknowledge
the assistance I received from libraries and archives in Paris including the
departmental archives of Seine-Saint-Denis; the Bibliothèque de docu-
mentation internationale contemporaine at Nanterre; the archives of the
PCF; the Archives nationales; and the Centre d’Histoire Sociale du XXe
siècle. I must also thank the Centre des Archives Communistes en Belgique
for assistance with visual materials; and for permission to consult sections
of the Thorez deposit in the Archives nationales in Paris I must thank the
Thorez family. My special thanks as always to Julie, Sam and Jane.
The usual caveats apply, and for both the judgements offered here and
any errors or misunderstandings I am alone responsible.
December 2015
Contents
3 Cult Variations 71
3.1 Integrating and Enkindling 71
3.2 A Unifying Concept 80
3.3 ‘By Desert and Accident’: The Enkindling Figure 93
3.4 Capital and Charisma103
4 Leader Cults 127
4.1 A Leader Made of Filth127
4.2 Maurice Thorez’s Party140
4.3 Office Boys and Lifelong Fighters158
5 Cults of Circumstance 185
5.1 Comintern People185
5.2 Writers in Arms203
5.3 The Red and the Grey221
vii
viii Contents
6 Cult Representations 257
6.1 Remembering Stalin’s Pipe257
6.2 The Impossible Cult Biography277
6.3 The Cult of the Individual in History293
Select Bibliography339
Index349
Abbreviations
ix
x Abbreviations
In Notes
A Note on Terminology
Over the period covered here, several of the parties discussed went through
at least one change of name. Where there was basic organisational conti-
nuity, the most familiar of these names is used here for simplicity’s sake.
Thus, although the Communist Party of Great Britain became the British
Communist Party in the 1940s, the more familiar acronym CPGB is used
throughout; and similarly the most familiar acronyms for other parties
with a continuous history are also employed generically here, e.g. PCF and
PCI. The nomenclature of party offices and committees has also to some
extent been standardised, for example referring to the German Zentrum as
central committee. In the case of widely transliterated names and terms, I
have tended to follow the conventions of contemporary English-language
sources, except, at the obvious risk of some inconsistency, where common-
sense or familiarity suggested otherwise.
List of Figures
xi
xii List of Figures
(i)
In December 1949, millions across the world took part in one of the
defining public rituals of the twentieth century. Cold War tensions were
reaching their height. Germany’s division had been sealed, NATO formed,
and the first of a new wave of show trials held in eastern Europe. In China,
communism’s second great revolution had prevailed, while on the Korean
peninsula tensions would soon break out in open warfare. Overseeing all
from the Kremlin, on 21 December the Soviet leader Stalin marked his
70th birthday with a demonstration of personal power that arguably had
had no historical parallel. In the sky above Red Square, searchlights picked
out his giant profile, suspended from balloons. In the Soviet daily Pravda,
every line of every page was given over to Stalin’s accomplishments. Plays
were staged, films released, songs composed and presents received—so
many presents that a special museum was needed to display them. The
‘stream of greetings’ would feature in Pravda for more than a year; if any
quality was mentioned more than the others, it was Stalin’s modesty.
Stalin was not the only dictator to relish such performances. What was
of a different order was the promotion and reproduction of his cult on an
international scale. Not only from Stalin’s newly extended eastern bloc,
but from both sides of the iron curtain offerings arrived in truckloads.
In Paris alone, some four thousand gifts were assembled. These included
not only the products of diverse handicrafts, trades and professions, but
also the revolver of resistance hero Colonel Fabien; a baby’s bootees kept
culminating after several days in a firework display and the releasing of car-
rier pigeons.3 In the journal of modern rationalism, Thorez was equated
with the century that bore his imprint, while a popular anthem added the
note of his ubiquity: ‘for everywhere that we are, he is’.4
The French are sometimes said to have a penchant for the providential
or otherwise exalted leader.5 Thorez’s biographers ponder the significance
4 K. MORGAN
(ii)
This is a book about the meaning of such claims and how they came to
be made. It explores the communist cult phenomenon from its earliest
manifestations under Lenin to its condemnation in 1956 by Stalin’s suc-
cessor Nikita Khrushchev. It draws on what is already an extensive litera-
ture, including accomplished studies of the Lenin, Stalin and other ruling
party cults. The focus here, however, is on communism as an interna-
tional movement embracing parties of every conceivable legal status, from
the monopoly of power to outright persecution. Respectively in Europe,
Latin America and Asia, figures like Togliatti, Gottwald, Prestes and Mao
were the focus of cultlike practices that were clearly interlinked and shared
common features, but according to varying political imperatives and the
most disparate political circumstances. Having originated in the USSR,
the internationalisation of the cult phenomenon can be traced from the
first continuous promulgation of Stalin’s own cult in the early 1930s.
Nevertheless, it was a complex, spasmodic and in some respects uncer-
tain process which was properly formalised only in the period of ‘high
stalinism’ in which Stalin’s 70th birthday fell. It is this uneven and often
INTRODUCTION 5
c ommunist systems that were doubly closed, as Rees puts it, ‘both domes-
tically and in their relations to the outside world’.23 Intriguingly, it is not
in Stalin’s case but Mao’s that a global history of the Little Red Book has
been produced by scholars from a wide range of areas and subject special-
isms.24 Considering the ever-burgeoning literature on Stalin, it is symp-
tomatic of the iron curtain which Clark alluded to that works of similar
scope have not so far been devoted to either his or Lenin’s cult.
In approaching the subject as a historian of international communism,
the differences to be accommodated are in part ones of periodisation.
Disregarding minor discrepancies as to their dating, every authoritative
account of the Soviet cult of Stalin identifies two distinct phases culmi-
nating respectively in the pre-war period of the Moscow trials and the
post-war period of high stalinism. Internationally speaking, the same dis-
tinction broadly holds, with a ‘turn to the individual’ that is clearly trace-
able from 1934 and becomes more emphatically projected onto the figure
of the leader with the onset of the Cold War. In France, for example, Annie
Kriegel’s periodisation of the Thorez cult corresponds closely to Stalin’s
own, with a first phase in 1936–1938 and a second in 1947–1953.25
Though both Kriegel and Stéphane Sirot note that there was an intensifi-
cation of the cult in the second of these periods, no significant distinction
is drawn between them, as if there were the same basic continuity of pur-
pose and effect that is evident in the USSR itself.26
The premises of the present account are different. In respect of the
communists’ envisaged cult community the differences are very simple. In
the first of these phases of cult-building, as it recovered from the shock of
Hitler’s victory in Germany, international communism was a movement
whose effectiveness and even survival depended on reaching out to new
constituencies and mobilising them under the banner of anti-fascism. In
the second of these phases, on the other hand, communism was a move-
ment far more firmly established even in the West, but subject as if under
siege to the intense external pressures of the Cold War. Despite the obvi-
ous elements of synchronicity between national and international devel-
opments, the relevance to these situations of a system of exclusive sacral
rites was clearly not the same. The Soviet cult of Stalin, according to those
who allowed it some functionality, had gained traction as a device to draw
together a heterogeneous population around the ‘concrete living figure’
at its centre.27 Though the rationale in this case was that of a party already
holding power, there was at least a basic congruence between these esoteric
practices of a formalised cultic hierarchy and the turning in upon themselves
8 K. MORGAN
— En ole kuullut siitä mitään, sanoi hän. — Mutta eikö ne etsi teitä
nyt… tavoita joka paikasta?
Anna Mari kertoi tarkoin, kertoi kuolinyön ja mitä äiti oli sanonut.
— Sanoi.
— Ne.
Updated editions will replace the previous one—the old editions will
be renamed.
1.D. The copyright laws of the place where you are located also
govern what you can do with this work. Copyright laws in most
countries are in a constant state of change. If you are outside the
United States, check the laws of your country in addition to the
terms of this agreement before downloading, copying, displaying,
performing, distributing or creating derivative works based on this
work or any other Project Gutenberg™ work. The Foundation makes
no representations concerning the copyright status of any work in
any country other than the United States.
1.E.6. You may convert to and distribute this work in any binary,
compressed, marked up, nonproprietary or proprietary form,
including any word processing or hypertext form. However, if you
provide access to or distribute copies of a Project Gutenberg™ work
in a format other than “Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other format used in
the official version posted on the official Project Gutenberg™ website
(www.gutenberg.org), you must, at no additional cost, fee or
expense to the user, provide a copy, a means of exporting a copy, or
a means of obtaining a copy upon request, of the work in its original
“Plain Vanilla ASCII” or other form. Any alternate format must
include the full Project Gutenberg™ License as specified in
paragraph 1.E.1.
• You pay a royalty fee of 20% of the gross profits you derive
from the use of Project Gutenberg™ works calculated using the
method you already use to calculate your applicable taxes. The
fee is owed to the owner of the Project Gutenberg™ trademark,
but he has agreed to donate royalties under this paragraph to
the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive Foundation. Royalty
payments must be paid within 60 days following each date on
which you prepare (or are legally required to prepare) your
periodic tax returns. Royalty payments should be clearly marked
as such and sent to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive
Foundation at the address specified in Section 4, “Information
about donations to the Project Gutenberg Literary Archive
Foundation.”
• You comply with all other terms of this agreement for free
distribution of Project Gutenberg™ works.
1.F.
1.F.4. Except for the limited right of replacement or refund set forth
in paragraph 1.F.3, this work is provided to you ‘AS-IS’, WITH NO
OTHER WARRANTIES OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED,
INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO WARRANTIES OF
MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR ANY PURPOSE.
Please check the Project Gutenberg web pages for current donation
methods and addresses. Donations are accepted in a number of
other ways including checks, online payments and credit card
donations. To donate, please visit: www.gutenberg.org/donate.
Most people start at our website which has the main PG search
facility: www.gutenberg.org.