Indigenous Black Women Resistance in COVID Through Ethnography Updated October 02 2020 Autosaved - PPTX (Autosaved)
Indigenous Black Women Resistance in COVID Through Ethnography Updated October 02 2020 Autosaved - PPTX (Autosaved)
Indigenous Black Women Resistance in COVID Through Ethnography Updated October 02 2020 Autosaved - PPTX (Autosaved)
Mothering in Canada
during a global pandemic (Covid-19)
2
Introduction:
Colonization & Whiteness
• Colonialism creates dehumanizing situations and alienates those that are
colonized not only from themselves but from their culture, language and lands.
Colonialism is rooted in domination, self-righteousness, and greed.
• Upon the take-over of Indigenous lands; colonizers enacted laws about trading,
farming and land management that became a way to marginalize and/or
restrict Indigenous people, especially women in Canada (Canon 2011, 89).
3
Introduction:
Colonization & Whiteness
• Indigenous people in Canada, specifically women, are currently at a
social, legal, political and economic disadvantage as they have had to
give up their lands and identities and are forced to live on reserves.
• Canada’s record for protecting the rights of Indigenous people is
abysmal. The systemic inequalities and discrimination that these
communities face create Indigenous people to suffer disproportionately
from Covid-19.
• For example, federal and provincial governments have urged
handwashing and social distancing as the best defense against the
virus. However, many Indigenous communities lack access to clean
water and inadequate funding for on-reserve housing leading to
severe overcrowding, making social distancing difficult. In urban
settings, Indigenous people are overrepresented in populations in
heighted risk of Covid-19 (Burk et.al,. 2020, 04).
4
Introduction:
Colonization & Whiteness
• Throughout colonial history, Black populations were forcefully removed from
their countries and forced into slavery to a nation of whites.
• Going as far back as the late 1700's white British slave traders removed black
populations from Africa in chains. These black populations became part of the
transatlantic slave trade; but more importantly part of the North-American
slave trade.
• Colonialism was about trading bodies for the purposes of labor and monetary
gain. The black body was only valued for how much money it could make for
slave traders.
• The identities of those that were taken from Africa were lost to slavery because
they were forcefully removed from their homes and forced into servitude.
• This reinforces the concept of marginalization because it was those that were
black that were forced into roles of servitude.
5
Introduction:
Colonization & Whiteness
• Forced assimilation is at the core of colonization so that “Black and
Indigenous people are made to interweave better with mainstream society”
(Brock 2017, 08).
• However, even those that have assimilated feel the impact of economic
marginalization as they are still not considered as being equal to those
that are white.
6
Introduction:
Colonization & Whiteness
• Good health is a product of access, social, cultural and economic factors.
Similarly; structural and systemic inequalities are contributors to poor health
outcomes.
• Many Black women in Ontario are unable to access support for their families;
especially during Covid-19. Poverty, food insecurity, isolation and mental health
concerns are aggravated.
• Mothers are front-line workers that keep families functioning during the
pandemic which means they do 50% more domestic labor and childcare
than fathers in isolation.
• Mothers are responsible for engaging in paid labor from home as well as
continuing with children’s education as daycares and schools are closed.
*(YFile-York University-O’Reilly)
8
Introduction:
Indigenous and Black Mothering in Canada
during a global pandemic (Covid-19)-
• Therefore, Covid-19 has impacted Black and Indigenous women in various
communities in Canada in both negative and disproportionate ways.
• The income gap is pervasive in Canada: white women earn more than
Black and Indigenous women. In Ontario, on average, white women earn
about $16,000 more annually than racialized women in various
employment sectors which creates a financial barrier Brock 2017, 119).
9
Introduction:
Theoretical Frameworks & Concepts
• The concept of the subaltern discussed by Antonio Gramscai,
and the concept of the “racialized other” that was discussed by
Frantz Fanon are connected and applicable to both Black and
Indigenous women.
• For example, whiteness deemed Black and Indigenous women the
subaltern, also known as undesirable, racialized and deemed
suitable for tasks such as slavery and/or those that need to be
“excluded, marginalized and eradicated” (Hart 2009, 04 and
Fanon 1967, 111).
• The intersects of race and gender are obvious when examining the
exclusionary procedures that exist due to the discourses of the
“racialized other.”
10
Introduction:
Theoretical Frameworks & Concepts
• These discourses and concepts reflect a white patriarchal
homogenous state that perpetuates gender and racial inequalities.
Power and privilege do not belong to non-white women under
patriarchal regimes.
• Patriarchy normalizes and naturalizes the concept of gender roles
where women are responsible for most of the household duties that
include childcare.
• Patriarchy also normalizes and naturalizes the ideas of whiteness
and the racial discrimination that exists towards both Black and
Indigenous women in Canada. Therefore, under patriarchy the
notion that women, especially Black and Indigenous women, are to be
excluded from affluent employment, post-secondary education,
health care, and social structures are prominent (Dow 2016,182).
11
Introduction:
Theoretical Frameworks & Concepts
• According to Black feminist thought; Black women are oppressed because
they live in a racist and heterogeneous society. This is linked up to the
intersects of race and gender.
12
Introduction:
Theoretical Frameworks & Concepts
• Using both Indigenous and Black feminist theories are necessary to analyze
the violent, racist, and discriminatory practices and policies that exist in
social, political, economic and health care institutions and structures.
• Both Indigenous and Black feminism are important to this paper because first,
they will allow for the examination and the creation of inclusionary spaces for
both of these women; second, they will allow for a resistance towards this
violence and discriminatory practices; third they will create an awareness of
the violence and discrimination that continues to impact Black and Indigenous
women; and fourth create an awareness of the existence of Covid-19
amongst these communities in Canada as well as the impact on women in
these communities due to a lack of access to resources
13
Introduction:
Theoretical Frameworks & Concepts
• Allies are defined as, “the dominant group members who work to
end prejudice in their personal and professional lives and
relinquish social privileges conferred by their group status to give
support of non-dominant groups” (Henry.et.al. 2017, 05-08).
Allies, then, are not fighting someone else’s battle, they are
aligning themselves within a battle (Henry.et.al. 2017, 05).
• Non-racialized female allies can become educated by Black and
Indigenous women in order to understand the experiences of "racial
tensions" and “discriminations” that exist in employment,
education and health care. This education formulates a resistance
against these practices to end barriers (Silman 1987, 08). The
formulation of these alliances will allow for the acceptance of
differences and break down the construction of the "racialized
other".
14
Introduction:
Ethnographic Storytelling
• In this paper there is a focus on the use of ethnographic storytelling by Black and Indigenous
women because it; a) formulates a resistance to colonization & whiteness; b) becomes an
education for non-racialized people on the acceptance of differences rather than their
negative magnification; and c) becomes a way to create awareness of the impact of Covid-19
on women in Black and Indigenous communities in Canada
• This will create a breakdown of the order of the racial and discriminatory structures within
legal, social, political, economic and health institutions. Through education-there can be a
deconstruction of “white mythologies” and the dispelling of the “racialized other” (Davis
1983, 27).
• This can be considered decolonization because it is work towards the promotion of social
cohesion, the overcoming of identities and acknowledging that every individual has a value
to promote good health in these communities ;which will ultimately prevent further spread of
Covid-19.
• This will allow for the creation and reception of equity practices for Black and Indigenous
women in legal, economic, political and social spheres where these women have been
excluded from, because of the ideas of whiteness. Furthermore, this will aid in the creation of
awareness and alleviating the physical, financial and psychological burden on Black and
Indigenous women in Canada-due to the existence of Covid-19 (Burk.et,. 2020, 07).
15
Introduction: Purpose
• This paper is a discussion of the negative and disproportionate ways
that Covid-19 has impacted Black and Indigenous women in various
communities in Canada.
• This paper then has a three-fold purpose with the use of ethnography
alongside Black and Indigenous feminism:
16
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Methods of Storytelling~
• Settler colonialism put Indigenous women first in residential schools and Indian
hospitals; then in laborious jobs and then on reserves out of the desire to eradicate,
marginalize and assimilate all in the name of colonialism.
17
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Indigenous and Black Mothering in Canada during a global pandemic (Covid-19)~
• Across Canada, public health officials are optimistic in their efforts to contain Covid-19
however, Indigenous communities are at risk. Systemic inequalities and discrimination that
is faced by various Indigenous communities create a disproportionate number of Indigenous
people that are contracting Covid-19.
• Government and public health officials have urged handwashing and social distancing as
the greatest defense against the virus. Many Indigenous communities, especially those in the
Northern regions of Canada, lack access to clean water and inadequate funding for on-
reserve housing leading to severe overcrowding which makes social distancing impossible.
• Many Indigenous people also face discrimination in accessing health care services. For
example, in Northern Indigenous communities nursing stations are ill-equipped and
understaffed. Travel to medical centres is expensive and challenging due to travel restrictions
• Furthermore, these Northern reserve communities, do not have access to the personal
protective equipment they need (gloves, masks & sanitizers). These communities may also
suffer from food insecurity especially since many rely on long-distance deliveries to replenish
food stocks.
18
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Indigenous and Black Mothering in Canada during a global pandemic (Covid-19)~
• Indigenous women (biological mothers or not) are responsible for community welfare
which has become stressful during the Covid-19 pandemic.
• The experience of Roxanne Moonias, mother to an infant with a chronic illness, must
deal with having no access to clean water in the Neskantaga First Nations in
Ontario. Roxanne and her child are at high risk for Covid-19 as they do not have access
to clean water for washing-which is what is deemed necessary to prevent the spread of
the virus. (*)
• It has further been reported by other members of Roxanne’s community that due to
Covid-19; access to Diabetes needles and/or clinics is limited which has left them
vulnerable.
• As retold by many older generations in Roxanne’s reserve community, where women are
responsible for care, there are higher rates of underlying health issues that are
exasperated by Covid-19. Indigenous people who have diabetes and tuberculosis-require
care in the form of administering medicine via needles and/or attending treatment clinics
where there are limited access to medical equipment and physical attendance at clinics.
(*)
* (Systemic Inequities Increase Covid-19 Risk for Indigenous People in Canada).
19
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Methods of Storytelling~
• Ethnographies and auto-ethnographies from Black female leaders across Ontario, that
have worked in the community health sector, have shed light on the factors that impact
health outcomes for Black populations in the province. (*)
• In health care; Black community members must contend with a lack of access to
health care based on race. Due to the existence of Covid-19 increasing pressure on health
infrastructure means service providers can and will make life and death decisions about
who can/cannot access care. (*)
20 * (Statement from Black Health Leaders on COVID-19’s impact on Black Communities in Ontario)
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Indigenous and Black Mothering in Canada during a global pandemic (Covid-19)~
• Across Ontario, Black people, especially women are counted amongst the working poor-
as many have lost employment as a result of the pandemic and therefore lost access to health
benefits
• Ontario’s Anti-Racism Directorate's (2020): cited that Black people face more barriers in
gaining employment in the formal sector. Therefore, high numbers of Black people working
in the informal sector or belong to the “gig-economy” that has been disrupted by Covid-19.
This has created difficulties in accessing social, financial, and health relief for low income
households (Race Data Collection 2017-2020).
• Further research conducted on Black workers, particularly on women, during the pandemic
has yielded the result that Black women are overrepresented in front facing service provider
roles (PSW, RPN). (*)
• This information is troublesome because many of these women provide essential services
to others, yet they are unable to access essential support for their families during Covid-
19. This will aggravate poverty, food insecurity, isolation and mental health. (*)
21
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Indigenous and Black Mothering in Canada during a global pandemic (Covid-19)~
• The Covid-19 pandemic has drastically changed our way of life. The adaptation to the
“new normal” has created unprecedented stress and anxiety for many women in Canada.
The psychological, physical and financial impact on Indigenous and Black women in
various communities in Canada is obvious. (*)
• Adjusting to being at home all day with their families while working remotely, running a
household and undertaking the educator role to school-aged children with significantly
less resources is a frequent situation for many racialized households. This is the third
shift where mothers must take on more-especially in racialized communities. (**)
• The actual hands- on work has not changed however, there are many women (mothers)
in racialized households that cannot afford to outsource education (via tutoring) or
meals (uber/takeout) due to a lack of financial resources. As we have seen earlier in
the presentation-white women earn more than Black and Indigenous women.
• They must deal with remembering homework due dates, work deadlines, but also deal
with children’s fatigue, health, boredom, and anxiety which takes its toll
psychologically. (*)
*(YFile-York University-O’Reilly)
**(Statement from Black Health Leaders on COVID-19’s impact on Black Communities in Ontario)
22
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Indigenous and Black Mothering in Canada during a global pandemic
(Covid-19)~
• “It is this type of work-that has been downloaded that is the ‘real labour’
that is not recognized but expected which therefore causes mental stress to
women and can lead to unhealthy home life.
* (YFile-York University-O’Reilly)
**(Statement from Black Health Leaders on COVID-19’s impact on Black Communities in Ontario)
23
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Black & Indigenous Feminism~
• Black & Indigenous feminist theories argue that social change can be made by
telling a story. Without telling the story then we as the reader cannot see the
problems in society in order to produce the solution to the problem. The
ethnographer attempts to incur change by presenting the inherent conflicts that exist
within various communities.
• According to Black feminist thought; Black women are oppressed because they live
in a racist and white heterogeneous society. This framework outlines the intersects
of race and gender.
24
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Black & Indigenous Feminism~
• The connections to feminism are important to review because only until recently
has it been acceptable for Black and Indigenous women to stand up for
themselves and create resistance towards colonialism. Using ethnography to
examine feminism and resistance towards colonialism has allowed for Black
and Indigenous communities to be brought closer together and reinforce
connections.
• “Feminism has worked to remove the binary definitions that are given to both
Black and Indigenous women that were/are based on white colonial attitudes”
(Stevenson 2011, 46).
25
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Theories & Concepts~
• For the purposes of the essay I have made a direct correlation to the racialization of
Indigenous and Black women under colonialism that perpetuates the negative and
disproportionate impact of Covid-19. I have used scholars such as Hage, Roedgiger,
Davin, Bogues, Sommerville and Seshadri-Crooks as references. Race is determined and
categorized by those that are white to marginalize, infantilize, ghettoize, and even eradicate
groups of people from white societies.
• As indicated by Davin, whiteness categorizes the identities of those that are non-white in
order to establish superiority and exert power over those that are defined as different. Davin,
who shares similar sentiments to Lacan and Foucault, indicates the construction and
development of race-based identities. Visual differences, are defined based on the idea of
accentuating differences rather than accepting differences.
• Definitions of the racialized other are based on what people look like in order to determine
exclusionary and inclusionary procedures. Discourses of race penetrate social
consciousness in order to enhance the “practice of visibility” (Seshadri-Crooks 2000, 06).
• Through the practice of visibility, the ideas of racial difference construct the symbolic order.
The symbolic order is based on the way that race is socially constructed to build upon the fact
that it is acceptable to discriminate and exclude various subjects, which usually end up being
racialized/Black/Indigenous subjects, from a population.
26
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Theories & Concepts~
• This symbolic order is usually developed usually by those that are white that are in
power to “fix the notion of superiority” (Roedigiger 2007, 17). By “fixing the notion
of superiority” thus fixes the symbolic order that perpetuates a system that induces the
social and legal validation of race as a natural order and discourse.
• The article written by Bogues, entitled “Black Jacobins and Black Reconstruction:
Writing Heresy and Revisionist Histories,” was an examination of Black history and
slavery as a way to unpack and re-write the historical knowledge that exists about Black
slavery especially in Canada and the United States.
• Bogues examines racial oppression by using Gramscai’s concepts of social order and
hegemony. Those who do not fit the mould of hegemonic whiteness are usually not
calculated into the social order of society.
27
The Sovereign Tales of Distinct Populations
~Theories & Concepts~
• Those that are racialized are oppressed and placed into subordinate roles in
society. “Slavery, racial segregation and discriminations are predicated not
only on the ideas of Social Darwinism and survival of the fittest,” but on
the notion that those that are non-white are to be dominated by those that are
white (Bogues 2014, 160).
28
Allyship & Equity Practices & Policies
• Both Black and Indigenous women can counter the white hegemonic
perspective and oppositional standpoint against the ideas of privilege,
subordination and domination by using ethnographic storytelling.
• Allies, especially white allies, need to learn from the specific auto-
ethnographies of Black and Indigenous women that depict their racialized
human experiences at the core of their oppression.
29
Allyship & Equity Practices & Policies
• When Black and Indigenous women are overt about their oppression this becomes
an education for non-racialized allies about racially discriminatory practices that
exist in a white hegemonic society that are reinforced in employment, health and
social infrastructures.
• This will promote allies to use their power and privilege to fight colonialism and
end the ideas of what is thought to be an “inferior race” (Canon 2011, 197).
White allies will be able to examine a governmental institutional structure;
such as the health care system in order to dismantle the racial and
discriminatory practices that do not consider Black and Indigenous women as
equal members of society.
• As part of the concept of free speech, white allies, need to “listen to the voices
of racialized and Black and Indigenous women” (Henry and Dua.et.al. 2017,
115). By giving attention to the free speech that is expressed by Black and
Indigenous women using ethnographic storytelling, white allies can influence
changes where there is a need for equal representation of both of these women.
30
Allyship & Equity Practices & Policies
• Allyship is an important part of this discussion because those that are non-
racialized align themselves with those that are racialized for the creation and
reception of equity practices for Indigenous and Black women in social, legal,
economic, health and political spheres of society.
• Allyship leaves room for the development to express views about racism without
having that expression be dismissed as “angry and/or too emotional” (Henry. Et.
al 2017, 111)
• “Women of color and/or Indigenous women who talk about these things carry a
different weight than someone who is not a person of color and/or Indigenous
talking about those things. Women of color and/or Indigenous women have no
choice but to stand up for themselves. After all, having a choice is itself a
privilege” (Suzack 2013, 99).
• Those that are white can become allies with Black and Indigenous people to evoke
inclusionary spaces. Those that occupy white privileged spaces need to stand
up to create change.
31
Conclusion
• In conclusion, in this paper we have had a discussion of the negative and
disproportionate ways that Covid-19 has impacted Black and Indigenous women
in various communities in Canada.
• Exclusionary procedures come into play for these women in health care
structures which has created the negative impact of Covid-19 on these women in
these communities. When we look at the intersects of race and gender, we
cannot help but notice that a white patriarchal homogenous state prohibits
equality especially when it comes to giving access to financial, physical and
psychological resources for Indigenous and Black women to deal with Covid-
19.
32
Conclusion
• By sharing their life experiences, through ethnographic storytelling, Black and
Indigenous women attempt to expand upon their lived experiences as well as those
in their communities to be able to build a resistance against colonialism to create
equality.
• Allyship is vital to this research paper because alliances between Black and Indigenous
women and allies are reinforced to ignite change. By providing an education for non-
racialized women, Black and Indigenous women will create decolonization
movements socially, legally, politically and economically.
• Being a white ally that listens to the ethnographic/auto-ethnographic stories that are told
by Black and Indigenous women there is the recognition and the taking of
responsibility in creating decolonial movements that will work towards making
change regarding systemic and institutional racism and discrimination that
perpetuates inequality, lack of access of resources and oppression.
33