4G Americas Rysavy LTE and 5G Innovation
4G Americas Rysavy LTE and 5G Innovation
4G Americas Rysavy LTE and 5G Innovation
Mobile Broadband
August 2015
Summary
A previously fragmented wireless industry has consolidated globally on LTE.
LTE-Advanced
Provides Dramatic
Advantages
5G Research and
Development Gains
Momentum
Internet of Things
Poised for Massive
Adoption
5G will be designed to integrate with LTE networks, and many 5G features may
be implemented as LTE-Advanced extensions prior to full 5G availability.
IoT, also called machine-to-machine (M2M) communications, is seeing rapid
adoption and expected in tens of billions of devices over the next ten years.
Drivers include improved LTE support, other supporting wireless technologies,
and service-layer standardization such as OneM2M.
2
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Summary
Spectrum remains a precious commodity for the industry; its value was
demonstrated by the recent Advanced Wireless Services (AWS) auction that
achieved record valuations.
Forthcoming spectrum in the United States includes the 600 MHz band planned
for auction in 2016 and the 3.5 GHz small-cell band that the Federal
Communications Commission (FCC) is in the process of deploying.
Unlicensed Spectrum
Becomes More Tightly
Integrated with
Cellular
Mobile Computing
Overtakes the
Desktop
5G spectrum will include bands above 30 GHz, called mmWave, with the
potential of ten times as much spectrum as is currently available for cellular.
Radio channels of 1 GHz or more will enable multi-Gbps peak throughput.
The industry has developed increasingly sophisticated means for Wi-Fi and
cellular networks to interoperate, making the user experience ever more
seamless.
The industry is also developing versions of LTE that can operate in unlicensed
spectrum.
The number of mobile users globally now exceeds the number of desktop users.
3
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Summary
Operators have begun installing small cells. Eventually, millions of small cells
will lead to massive increases in capacity.
Network Function
Virtualization (NFV)
Emerges
The industry is slowly overcoming challenges that include site acquisition, selforganization, interference management, and backhaul.
New network function virtualization (NFV) and software-defined networking
(SDN) tools and architectures are enabling operators to reduce network costs,
simplify deployment of new services, and scale their networks.
Some operators are also virtualizing the radio-access network, as well as
pursuing a related development called cloud radio-access network (cloud RAN).
4
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
5
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
5G Data Drivers
Source: Cisco, Cisco Visual Networking Index: Global Mobile Data Traffic Forecast Update,
February 16, 2013.
Cisco Visual Networking Index: Global Mobile Data Traffic Forecast Update, 2014-2019, February 2015.
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Ericsson, Ericsson Mobility Report on the Pulse of the Networked Society, February 2053.
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Deployments as of 2Q 2015
9
Source: Ovum June 2015 Estimates
4G Americas, 2015
10
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
11
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
1G to 5G
Generation
Requirements
Comments
1G
No official requirements.
2G
Analog technology.
No official requirements.
Digital technology.
3G
4G (Initial
Technical
Designation)
4G (Current
Marketing
Designation)
5G
12
13
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Network Transformation
14
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
15
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
16
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Description
Benefit
LTE uses OFDM, but other potential multi-carrier schemes Lower latency on uplink transmission due to lower
include Filter-Bank Multi-Carrier (FBMC) transmission,
synchronization requirements.
Universal Filtered Multi-Carrier (UFMC) transmission, and
Potentially better suited for spectrum sharing because
Generalized Frequency-Division Multiplexing (GFDM).
the transmission operates in more confined spectrum.
Non-Orthogonal Multiple
Transmission
17
Description
Benefit
Multi-Radio-AccessTechnologies
Device-to-Device
Communication
Wireless
Access/Backhaul
Integration
Flexible Networks
18
Carrier Aggregation. Already in use, operators can aggregate radio carriers in the
same band or across disparate bands to improve throughputs (under light network
load), capacity, and efficiency. Carrier aggregation can also combine FDD and TDD,
as well as licensed and unlicensed bands.
Coordinated Multi Point. Expected in the 2015-2016 timeframe, CoMP is a process
by which multiple base stations or cell sectors process a UE signal simultaneously, or
coordinate the transmissions to a UE, improving cell-edge performance and network
efficiency. Initial usage will be on the uplink because no changes are required to user
equipment (UE).
HetNet Support. Also expected in the 2015-2016 timeframe, HetNets integrate
macro cells and small cells. A key feature is enhanced intercell interference
coordination (eICIC), which enhances the ability of a macro and a small cell to use
the same spectrum. This approach is valuable when the operator cannot dedicate
spectrum to small cells. Operators are currently evaluating eICIC, and at least one
operator has deployed it.
Self-Organizing Networks. With SON, networks can automatically configure and
optimize themselves, a capability that will be particularly important as small cells
begin to proliferate. Vendor-specific methods are common for 3G networks, and trials
are now occurring for 4G LTE standards-based approaches.
19
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Initial Self-Optimization/
Organization for Auto
Configuration
Higher Capacity/Throughput
and/or Efficiency
Wider Radio Channels: 20 MHz
Carrier Aggregation: up to 100 MHz
Advanced Antenna Configurations
More Advanced MIMO (Higher Order, MultiUser, Higher Mobility)
Coordinated Multipoint Transmission
Hetnets (Macrocells/Picocells/Femtocells)
Hetnet Self Optimization/Organization
More Intelligent and Seamless Offload
Greater Capabilities
Voice Widely Handled in the Packet Domain
Policy-Based Quality of Service
Characteristics of 3GPP
Technologies
Technology
Name
Type
Characteristics
HSPA
WCDMA
HSPA+
WCDMA
LTE
OFDMA
LTE- Advanced
OFDMA
Typical
Downlink
Speed
1 Mbps to
4 Mbps
1.9 Mbps to
8.8 Mbps
in 5+5 MHz
3.8 Mbps to 17.6
Mbps with dual
carrier in 10+5
MHz
Typical Uplink
Speed
500 Kbps
to 2 Mbps
1 Mbps to
4 Mbps
in 5+5 MHz or in
10+5 MHz
21
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Evolution of CDMA
and OFDMA Systems
22
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Release 7: Completed. Provides enhanced GSM data functionality with Evolved EDGE.
Specifies HSPA+, which includes higher order modulation and MIMO. Performance
enhancements, improved spectral efficiency, increased capacity, and better resistance to
interference. Continuous Packet Connectivity (CPC) enables efficient always-on service
and enhanced uplink UL VoIP capacity, as well as reductions in call set-up delay for Pushto-Talk Over Cellular (PoC). Radio enhancements to HSPA include 64 Quadrature
Amplitude Modulation (QAM) in the downlink and 16 QAM in the uplink. Also includes
optimization of MBMS capabilities through the multicast/broadcast, single-frequency
network (MBSFN) function.
Release 10: Completed. Specifies LTE-Advanced that meets the requirements set by
ITUs IMT-Advanced project. Key features include carrier aggregation, multi-antenna
enhancements such as enhanced downlink eight-branch MIMO and uplink MIMO, relays,
enhanced LTE Self-Organizing Network capability, Evolved Multimedia Broadcast Multicast
Services (eMBMS), HetNet enhancements that include eICIC, Local IP Packet Access, and
new frequency bands. For HSPA, includes quad-carrier operation and additional MIMO
options. Also includes femtocell enhancements, optimizations for M2M communications,
and local IP traffic offload.
Release 11: Completed. For LTE, emphasis is on Coordinated Multi Point (CoMP), carrieraggregation enhancements, devices with interference cancellation, development of the
Enhanced Physical Downlink Control Channel (EPDCCH), and further enhanced eICIC
including devices with CRS (Cell-specific Reference Signal) interference cancellation. The
release includes further DL and UL MIMO enhancements for LTE. For HSPA, provides
eight-carrier on the downlink, uplink enhancements to improve latency, dual-antenna
beamforming and MIMO, CELL_Forward Access Channel (FACH) state enhancement for
smartphone-type traffic, four-branch MIMO enhancements and transmissions for HSDPA,
64 QAM in the uplink, downlink multipoint transmission, and noncontiguous HSDPA carrier
aggregation. Wi-Fi integration is promoted through S2a Mobility over GPRS Tunneling
Protocol (SaMOG). An additional architectural element called Machine-Type
Communications Interworking Function (MTC-IWF) will more flexibly support machine-tomachine communications.
25
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Characteristics
Wide-area coverage. LTE supports cells up to 100 km in range, but typical
distances are .5 to 5 km radius. Always installed outdoors.
Microcell
Covers a smaller area, such as a hotel or mall. Range to 2 km, 5-10W, and 256512 users. Usually installed outdoors.
Picocell
Indoor or outdoor. Outdoor cells also called metrocells. Typical range 15 to 200
meters outdoors and 10 to 25 meters indoors, 1-2W, 64-128 users. Deployed by
operators primarily to expand capacity.
Consumer Femtocell
Indoors. Range to 10 meters, less than 50 mW, and 4 to 6 users. Capacity and
coverage benefit. Usually deployed by end users using their own backhaul.
Enterprise Femtocell
Indoors. Range to 25 meters, 100-250 mW, 16-32 users. Capacity and coverage
benefit. Deployed by operators.
Wi-Fi
Super Wi-Fi
Name used by some people for white-space technology. Not true Wi-Fi. Better
suited for fixed wireless than mobile wireless.
27
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
28
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Characteristics
Wi-Fi only.
29
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Mobile Experts on behalf of the Small Cell Forum, Small Cells Deployment Market Status Report, June 2015.
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
30
Technology
Coverage
Characteristics
GSM/GPRS
Wide area.
Huge global
coverage.
Wide area. Huge
global coverage.
3GPP
LTE
Wide area.
Increasing global
coverage.
3GPP
Wi-Fi
ZigBee
Bluetooth Low
Energy
LoRa
Local area.
Local area.
Personal area.
Wide area.
Emerging
deployments.
IEEE
IEEE
Bluetooth Special Interest
Group
LoRa Alliance
Sigfox
Wide area.
Emerging
deployments.
Sigfox
OnRamp
Wireless
Wide area.
Emerging
deployments.
Weightless
Wide area.
Expected
deployments.
HSPA
31
32
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Attributes
Wi-Fi
33
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
34
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
35
4G Americas
36
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
37
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
RF Capacity Versus
Fiber-Optic Cable Capacity
Achievable Fiber-Optic Cable Capacity Per Cable (Area Denotes Capacity)
Additional
Fiber Strands
Readily
Available
Additional
Fiber Strands
Readily
Available
Dimensions of Capacity
Spectral Efficiency of Technology
Amount of Spectrum
39
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Bandwidth Management
More spectrum
Unpaired spectrum
Supplemental downlink
Spectrum sharing
Increased spectral efficiency
Smart antennas
Uplink gains combined with downlink carrier aggregation
Small cells and heterogeneous networks
Offload to unlicensed spectrum
Higher-level sectorization
Off-peak hours
Quality of service management
40
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
41
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
42
42
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Amount of
Spectrum
Comments
700 MHz
70 MHz
850 MHz
64 MHz
1.7/2.1 GHz
90 MHz
1695-1710 MHz,
1755 to 1780 MHz,
2155 to 2180 MHz
65 MHz
1.9 GHz
140 MHz
2000 to 2020,
2180 to 2200 MHz
40 MHz
2.3 GHz
20 MHz
2.5 GHz
194 MHz
FUTURE
600 MHz
Up to 120 MHz
Incentive auctions.
150 MHz
Small-cell
band
unlicensed use.
Above 5 GHz
Multi GHz
with
spectrum
sharing
and
43
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
44
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Spectrum Harmonization
45
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Unlicensed Cons
Licensed Pros
Licensed Cons
Potential of other
entities using same
frequencies
Huge coverage
areas
Expensive
infrastructure
Difficult to
impossible to
provide wide-scale
coverage
Able to manage
quality of service
46
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
47
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
48
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
49
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Latency of Different
Technologies
50
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Performance Relative to
Theoretical Limits
6
Shannon bound
Shannon bound with 3dB margin
HSDPA
EV-DO
IEEE 802.16e-2005
0
-15
-10
-5
10
15
20
51
Comparison of Downlink
Spectral Efficiency
52
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
53
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
54
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
55
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
58
Uplink
1 x 5 MHz
Downlink
2 x 5 MHz
UE1
1 x 5 MHz
2 x 5 MHz
UE2
59
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
60
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Uplink (Mbps)
Peak Data Rate
14.4
5.76
21.1
11.5
28.0
11.5
42.2
11.5
42.2
11.5
84.0
23.0
168.0
23.0
336.0
69.0
Technology
No operators have announced plans to deploy HSPA in a quad (or greater) carrier configuration.
Three carrier configurations, however, have been deployed.
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
61
61
62
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
63
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
64
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
LTE Capabilities
Downlink peak data rates up to 300 Mbps with 20+20 MHz bandwidth
Uplink peak data rates up to 71 Mbps with 20+20 MHz bandwidth
Operation in both TDD and FDD modes
Scalable bandwidth up to 20+20 MHz, covering 1.4+1.4, 2.5+2.5, 5+5,
10+10, 15+15, and 20+20 MHz
Reduced latency, to 15 msec round-trip time between user equipment
and the base station, and to less than 100 msec transition time from
inactive to active
Downlink (Mbps)
Peak Data Rate
LTE Configuration
Using 2X2 MIMO in the Downlink and 16
QAM in the Uplink, 10+10 MHz
Using 4X4 MIMO in the Downlink and 64
QAM in the Uplink, 20+20 MHz
Uplink (Mbps)
Peak Data Rate
70.0
22.0
300.0
71.0
65
Frequency
User 3
User 4
Time
Minimum resource block consists of
14 symbols and 12 subcarriers
66
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Frequency
Transmit on those resource
blocks that are not faded
67
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Source: 3G Americas white paper MIMO and Smart Antennas for 3G and 4G Wireless
Systems Practical Aspects and Deployment Considerations, May 2010.
68
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
69
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
70
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
AMR
AMR-WB
EVS
8KHz
16KHz
Narrowband
Wideband
Narrowband, Wideband,
Super-wideband, Fullband
Coding capabilities
Optimized for
coding human
voice signals
Optimized for
coding human
voice signals
Number of audio
channels
Frame size
Algorithmic Delay
Mono
Mono
20 ms
20-25 ms
20 ms
25 ms
20 ms
Up to 32 ms
71
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
72
73
74
75
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
76
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Rel8
Rel8
Rel8
Rel8
Rel8
Release 8 UE uses a
single 20 MHz block
Source: "LTE for UMTS, OFDMA and SC-FDMA Based Radio Access,
Harri Holma and Antti Toskala, Wiley, 2009.
77
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
78
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
79
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
80
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
CoMP Levels
81
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
82
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
83
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
LTE-Advanced Relay
Direct Link
Relay Link
Access
Link
84
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
LTE UE Categories
UE Category
Max DL
Throughput
Maximum DL
MIMO Layers
Maximum UL
Throughput
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
10.3 Mbps
51.0 Mbps
102.0 Mbps
150.8 Mbps
299.6 Mbps
301.5 Mbps
301.5 Mbps
2998.6 Mbps
452.3 Mbps
452.3 Mbps
603.0 Mbps
603.0 Mbps
1
2
2
2
4
2 or 4
2 or 4
8
2 or 4
2 or 4
2 or 4
2 or 4
5.2 Mbps
25.5 Mbps
51.0 Mbps
51.0 Mbps
75.4 Mbps
51.0 Mbps
102.0 Mbps
1497.8 Mbps
51.0 Mbps
102.0 Mbps
51.0 Mbps
102.0 Mbps
85
Category 3
10
100
Full
Two
Category 1
11
10
50
20 MHz
20 MHz
Full
Two
Category 0
12
1
1
Category M
13
0.2
0.2
20 MHz
1.4 MHz
Optional half-duplex Optional half-duplex
One
One
Power Save Mode
Coverage
86
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
87
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
89
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
90
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Source: LTE/SAE Trial Initiative, Latest Results from the LSTI, Feb
2009,
http://www.lstiforum.org.
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
91
92
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
93
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
94
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Enhanced Intercell
Interference Cancellation
95
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
96
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
97
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
98
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Dual Connectivity
99
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
100
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
101
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Priority
Resource
Type
GBR
(Guaranteed
Bit Rate)
GBR
Delay
Budget
100 msec.
150 msec.
10
GBR
50 msec.
10
GBR
300 msec.
10
Non-GBR
100 msec.
10
Non-GBR
300 msec.
10
Non-GBR
100 msec.
10
Non-GBR
300 msec.
10
Non-GBR
300 msec.
10
Packet Loss
10
Examples
-2
Conversational
voice
-3
Conversational
video (live
streaming)
Real-time gaming
-3
-6
-6
-6
-3
-6
-6
Nonconversational
video (buffered
streaming)
IMS signaling
Video (buffered
streaming), TCP
Web, e-mail, ftp,
104
105
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Approach
Radio
LTE-U
LTE-LAA
LTE
LTE
LWA
Wi-Fi
CoExistence
Duty cycle
Listen
Before Talk
802.11
Bands
Downlink/ Standards
Uplink
5 GHz
DL
None
5 GHz, 3.5 GHz DL
3GPP
Release
under
13
consideration
2.4 GHz, 5 GHz DL and UL
3GPP
Release
13
106
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Bidirectional-Offloading Challenges
107
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
108
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
109
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
IP Multimedia Subsystem
SIP Application
Server
IMS
Home Subscriber
Server (HSS)
SIP
Media Resource
Function Control
DIAMETER
Call Session Control Function (CSCF)
(SIP Proxy)
4G
DSL
Media Resource
Gateway Control
Wi-Fi
Software-Defined Networking
and Cloud Architectures
111
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
112
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Fully Centralized
Partially Centralized
Transport
Requirements
Multi-Gbps, usually
using fiber
20 to 50 times less
Applications
Supports centralized
scheduling
Complexity
High
Lower
Benefit
Capacity gain
113
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
GPRS/EDGE Architecture
Mobile
Station
Mobile
Station
Mobile
Station
Base
Transceiver
Station
Base
Transceiver
Station
Circuit-Switched
Traffic
Base
Mobile
Station
Switching
Controller
Center
Home
Location
Register
IP
Traffic
GPRS/EDGE Data
Infrastructure
Public Switched
Telephone Network
Serving
GPRS
Support
Node
Gateway
GPRS
Support
Node
External Data
Network (e.g., Internet)
115
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Example of GSM/GPRS/EDGE
Timeslot Structure
4.615 ms per frame of 8 timeslots
Possible BCCH
carrier configuration
Possible TCH carrier
configuration
577 mS
per timeslot
0
BCCH
TCH
TCH
TCH
TCH
PDTCH
PDTCH
PDTCH
PBCCH
TCH
TCH
PDTCH
PDTCH
PDTCH
PDTCH
PDTCH
BCCH: Broadcast Control Channel carries synchronization, paging and other signalling information
TCH: Traffic Channel carries voice traffic data; may alternate between frames for half-rate
PDTCH: Packet Data Traffic Channel Carries packet data traffic for GPRS and EDGE
PBCCH: Packet Broadcast Control Channel additional signalling for GPRS/EDGE; used only if needed
116
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper
Conclusion
5G will be designed to integrate with LTE networks, and many 5G features may be
implemented as LTE-Advanced extensions prior to full 5G availability.
The future of mobile broadband, including both LTE-Advanced and 5G, is bright,
with no end in sight for continued growth in capability, nor for the limitless
application innovation that mobile broadband enables.
117
Rysavy Research, 2015 White Paper