Martines Krista Sum2015
Martines Krista Sum2015
Martines Krista Sum2015
PERFORMANCE
By
Krista M. Martines
A Project Presented to
Committee Membership
July 2015
Abstract
PERFORMANCE
Krista M. Martines
personal financial situation has an effect on their job performance. There is a significant
amount of research showing that employees with poor financial situations do not perform
as well as employees who do not have poor personal financial situations. The link
between personal finance and job performance is the level of stress that a poor financial
situations causes. Employees who experience high levels of stress from their personal
financial situations are less productive at work because they are more focused on their
personal financial problems. This literature review also looks at financial education
programs that employers have put in place to improve their employee’s personal financial
ii
Acknowledgements
encouragement have pulled out the best in me. It was he who saw the flyer for the MBA
program in the Humboldt State engineering building, and called me while I was in
I also want to thank my mom for speaking life into me since I was little. She
always believed in me and has said for years that I will be a great, fair leader. There were
I feel extremely blessed for the financial provision I’ve had throughout my
college career. My grandparents, parents and husband have all sacrificed so much for me
iii
Table of Contents
Abstract ............................................................................................................................... ii
Introduction ......................................................................................................................... 1
Productivity..................................................................................................................... 3
Conclusions ....................................................................................................................... 18
References ......................................................................................................................... 21
iv
1
Introduction
affect productivity are: poor health and the company leader’s attitudes. The one factor
An employee’s personal life has an impact on how they perform at work. There
are many factors in an employee’s personal life that affect how they perform at work,
such as conflicts between work and home life and stressful events such as divorce or the
death of a spouse. This review will focus on employee debt and how it affects their
productivity at work.
lives. Many factors affect people’s financial situations. Some of these factors include:
financial situation affects their personal lives and their work lives. This review will focus
This review will also look at the effectiveness of financial education programs in
the workplace and perform a cost-benefit analysis of these programs. The results of this
cost-benefit analysis are significant to managers for determining whether it’s valuable to
Research Question
performance?
stress will be studied to determine if finances are a factor. Further research will be done
research point will be to find studies done on financial research education, to determine if
this is beneficial to employees and employers in decreasing personal debt and increasing
employee productivity.
3
Review of Literature
The purpose of this literature review is to examine the effects of personal debt on
employee job performance and also to discover the most effective ways that have been
found to educate employees about financial budgeting. The sections that this review will
debt, a financial stress study, financial education and a financial wellness study.
Ultimately, it is very valuable to managers that their employees are productive. It’s
important to know if personal financial debt has an effect on productivity. It’s also
Productivity
The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines productivity as: the rate at which goods
are produced or work is completed. There are many factors that affect productivity in the
workplace. Some of these factors are as follows. The behavior style of leaders is a factor.
The attitude and the way leaders conduct themselves (Hacıtahiroğlu, 2012). An
There are many factors that affect productivity. The factor that this review will
focus on is employee personal financial stress. The following section will review the
An employee’s personal life has an impact on how they perform at work. There
are many factors in an employee’s personal life that affect how they perform at work.
According to Konrad (2000), conflicts between work and home life can lead to employee
withdrawal and turnover. Employee withdrawal can lead to decreased effort at work,
tardiness and absenteeism. Stressful life events, such as divorce or the death of a spouse
also impact employee productivity. These events can be costly, take up a lot of time and
There are many parts of an employee’s personal life that can affect how they
perform at work. This review will focus solely on employee debt and how it affects their
productivity at work.
employer productivity. Employees who are financially well off in their personal lives are
your best employees. Financially unwell employees waste at least twenty hours a month
dealing with their personal financial issues, while they are at work. This author likens
employees with poor personal financial situations to sharks that swim around the
workplace and take bites out of the bottom line. Employees who are financially unwell in
lives. This affects their personal lives and their work lives. Personal debt can directly
affect whether a person can get a loan for their home, car or child’s education Dean, Joo,
Gudmunson, Fischer, & Lambert, 2013). Personal debt can even have effects that go as
far as causing people to have anxiety and depression. Some people with a significant
amount of debt that they are having trouble repaying experience thoughts of suicide
There are many ways that personal debt affect people’s lives. This following
section will focus on how personal financial management and debt affects people at
According to Dean et al. (2013), personal debt is not determined by race, sex or
even income. People with higher levels of income have even higher debt, especially when
it comes to automobile debt. This review is relevant to employees across all income
levels. Personal financial debt is more the result of attitudes and behaviors than it is the
result of not having enough money. The findings show that having debt leads to acquiring
more debt.
The number one cause of stress for Americans is worrying about money (Prawitz
& Cohart, 2014). Debt problems cause stress and anxiety that reduces employee
productivity (Zimmerman, 2006). Gurchiek (2008) states that thirty million employees in
the United States are financially distressed. Personal finance causes five times more
Poor financial behaviors have a negative effect on people’s lives both at home and at
work. Personal financial problems surface first in the workplace. Some of the costs that
fighting with other employees and managers, reduced employee productivity, lowered
employee morale, loss of revenue from sales not made, accidents and increased risk
taking, lack of employee focus on employer’s goals, thefts from employers and company
use of time to deal with personal financial issues. As the number of poor financial choices
primary sources low employee productivity that is a result of stress. Employee stress
A survey was given to 301 employees of IDS Financial Services. The findings
showed that the job performance of one-third of the workforce is affected by personal
financial stress. Thirty-eight percent of the employees surveyed said that their job
Many employees with financial problems end up taking time off work to face
their struggles. An example of this is when an employee takes company, when they could
be productive, to talk with their co-workers or supervisors about their financial problems.
7
People with financial stress also take longer breaks at work to deal with their financial
stress. Other employees call in sick to work to deal with their financial problems.
absenteeism, where the employee shows up to work, but mentally they are not available
to do their job. Financially unwell employees are passive and not engaged at work
(Gurchiek, 2008). When an employee is focused on their financial problems, they are not
focused on their work. They may be able to still perform at some level, but they are not
employee. Some additional costs to unscheduled absenteeism include: lower morale from
other employees who must pick up the extra work, lost revenue because of less sales,
losing customers to other companies with a better reputation and better customer service.
While not all absenteeism is due to financial stress, the cost of absenteeism is between
$25 and $35 billion in the United States. This cost is from lost employee productivity.
Other estimations say the cost is over $300 billion per year (Garman & et al., 1996).
Financial Education
finances will not perform well today. Personal financial health has an impact on physical
health, mental health and job performance. In 1999, academics did a study for the
8
Association Financial Counseling and Planning Education (AFCPE). The study included
178 employees. The employees were asked questions about the financial health, physical
health and their most recent job reviews from their bosses. The results were that
employees who received better performance reviews also had better financial and
physical health. There were measureable results from the study. 100 out of the 178
much more confident than the 78 employees who did not participate in a financial
education program. Both groups responded to the question, “I worry about how much
money I owe.” The 100 employees, who participated in the financial education program,
were less likely to be concerned about debt than the 78 who did not attend.
Another benefit that the 100 employees showed, is that after attending the
financial education program, they were not only more confident, but also more proactive.
In the following section, a financial wellness study will be explored. This study
This study, from Verne (2014), set goals for employers in 2015. In the recent past,
companies have incorporated programs that increase the health of their employees. These
programs include resources for healthy eating, exercise, and mental health. The reason
company’s are investing in the health of their employees is because healthy employees
more productive, because they are happier. Healthy employees also cost their employers
9
less. The last aspect of health that companies are starting to focus on is the financial
wellness of their employees. When financial stress is reduced in employees, both the
Finances are at the root of people’s greatest stress in America. A large number of
Americans make just enough money each month to pay their bills. Most Americans also
have a large amount of debt but don’t possess the skills needed to make better financial
decisions. These factors have a large impact on productivity. In order for companies to
have happy, healthy and productive employees, financial wellness programs need to be
part of the company’s benefits. Financial stress should be every company’s concern
One in three Americans have been late in paying their debts. It’s hard to get out of
debt once you are in it. It becomes a vicious cycle. People don’t make the best decisions
for themselves once they are in debt, and they usually get into debt worse. People who
have more debt are more likely to have health problems. They also show more irritability,
anger and fatigue. Financial stress is also connected with headaches, stomach pain,
ulcers, sleeplessness, muscle tension and heart attacks. People with financial stress are
also more likely to start behaviors that are not healthy for them. These unhealthy
behaviors include: smoking, alcohol and drug abuse and weight gain.
performance. When employees experience high levels of stress, they are less motivated
and less efficient at work. They are also less creative and they produce a lower quality of
10
work. Fifteen percent of American employees have a level of financial stress that directly
There is a link that researchers have found between financial stress and missing
work. People who are stressed about their finances spend more time at work dealing with
their finances. 24% of employees say that personal financial stress distracts them while
they are at work. Of that 24%, 39% spend a minimum of 3 hours each week, either
thinking about or facing their financial issues. Gallup reports that financial distractions
Financial stress has been found to have an impact on behavior and cognitive
function. A book entitled Scarcity was released in 2013 by authors Sendil Mullainathan
and Eldar Shafir, professors at Harvard and Princeton respectively. What they found is
that people getting by with less than they need has significant effects. They say that
scarcity reduces people’s self-control and prevents them from learning. The books also
says that scarcity increases anger, impatience and also causes people to be impulsive, and
make poor decisions which causes them to stay in a vicious cycle. The bottom line is that
people with limited resources tend to make decisions that will ultimately be worse for
them.
There was one experiment done, proving that an employee’s ability to work is
affected more negatively by financial stress than by a lack of sleep. Basically, someone
who is financially stressed performs much worse at work than someone who is sleep
deprived. This case makes the conclusion that financial stress is bad for both employees
and their employers. It states that financial education programs are very helpful in
11
helping employees reduce their level of financial stress and gain valuable tools for stay
debt free in the long term. This study says that the root cause of financial stress is
financial illiteracy. Low financial literacy leads to higher personal debt. This is what
that included 437 publicly traded companies. The respondents of the study included 58
different industries that had incomes ranging from one million to 65 million. They also
had a range of employees from 10 to 312,000. Two hundred and five companies
implemented programs that rewarded employee who increased their job performance.
This also improved the company’s finances. Two hundred thirty two of the companies
did not implement programs, showed lower company financial performance than their
counterparts. The study measured the following areas: profitability, cash flow, value of
stock and productivity. Profitability includes the return on assets, the profit margin and
the profits of each employee. The cash flow measures the real return on investment, along
with cash flow. Stock market performance is measured by the shareholder return and the
stock return based on the market index. The value of stock is the price to book value of
capital ratio. Finally, productivity is measured by examining the sales of each employee.
set goals and measure their results based on their goals. Managers set expectations for
12
budgeting salaries and bonuses. Financial rewards are all based on financial performance.
5. Programs should be custom designed to fit the needs of each individual company.
The results also encouraged collaboration between human resources and senior
management when deciding on the objective of the performance program (Baliga, 1995).
Financial Wellness programs can be offered in a variety of ways. There are free
these free programs can be effective, while others are just sales pitches. It’s important to
colleges. There are also vendor programs that are usually eight to twelve weeks long, and
The total cost of a financial wellness program can vary from $10,000 a year to
$500,000 a year (Sammer, 2012). The size of the company is a factor, as well as the
Benefit-Cost Analysis
place for a while, then the results of the program can be evaluated. A benefit-cost ratio is
used to measure all the benefits and costs using dollars. For example, a 7:1 benefit-cost
ratio says that there is a $7 return on every dollar that is invested in the education
program. Time spent developing the program should also be factored into the cost.
Another way to measure the financial return is through the Return on Investment (ROI).
This is calculated using the benefits and costs in dollar form. The ROI is displayed as a
percentage. A higher percentage is a better ROI. One thing to consider when measuring
dollars. One of the benefits that can be hard to measure is the increase in productivity
(Pinkerton, 2004).
2012). Researchers from the Personal Finance Employee Education Foundation have
studied the program at McLeod Health, and figured out the return of investment based on
470 employees who had completed the program. The return on investment was $6.60 for
every dollar that was invested. The total return on investment from McLeod Health’s
financial wellness program was $569,133. The areas of return were from improved job
performance, reduced turnover, reduced absenteeism and reduced work time lost (Figure
1).
14
Work time
lost
3% Other
Absenteeism 7%
4%
Turnover
43%
Job
Performance
43%
Figure 1. The total return on investment from McLeod Health’s financial wellness
program was $569,133. The areas of return were from improved job performance,
reduced turnover, reduced absenteeism and reduced work time lost (Sammer, 2012).
These examples have been provided as a tool for managers looking to implement
financial programs in their own companies. These examples give mangers an idea of
programs that are successful. Managers can take parts of successful programs and make
modifications where they see fit, for their own companies. The first example is McLeod
McLeod Health’s program started off with meetings once a week, on a business
day, for 2 hours (Sammer, 2012). The program lasted for 12 weeks. The program has
adapted and changed many times. One change was making the classes on every other
Saturday, and including the employee’s family and spouses. Another change was creating
and online tutorial blended with a lunchtime class, for a 12-week period.
McLeod Health agrees to pay for the whole program, on the condition that the
employee completes the entire program. The employee will incur all the program fees if
they do not complete the program in its entirety. This deduction will be make from their
wages and each employee agrees to this condition in a signed contract before the program
begins.
McLeod offers these programs on a regular basis. There are about 5,100
employees in this organization, and more than 650 have participated in their financial
wellness program.
Therm-O-Disc’s Program
period, twenty percent of their 4,000 employees have gone through their financial
wellness program. The result is that their average class pays off $10,000 in personal debt
waiting list in place to take these classes. Both salaried and hourly employees attend
16
these classes. A side benefit from these classes is that employees are building
relationships and improving teamwork across departments that don’t normally interact.
The best way to promote financial wellness programs is through manager and
supervisor involvement (Sammer, 2012). This is because leaders are able to see when
employees are struggling with personal finances. Managers and supervisors can make
employees aware of financial wellness programs and even share their personal
It’s easier to encourage employees to participate when the programs are offered at
no cost to the employee. There are other ways to promote financial wellness programs, in
information booths where employees can sign up for upcoming classes, putting success
stories into company newsletters, and encouraging people who have ben through the
There are ways for managers to make their resources go farther when investing in
financial wellness programs for their company. The following are tips for getting a
1. Pay for the employees to complete the program, but only pay for the employees
2. Start with a small class and a small investment. Monitor interest in the program
3. Initially invest in just a small number of employees. Set a budget for what should
be spent on the employees in the program, and choose a class size that will allow
4. Target employees with the greatest need for financial education. This will allow
5. Measure the impact of the financial wellness program in your company. Some
These are just some of the helpful tips to consider when planning on implementing a
Conclusions
money than employees who don’t participate. Better planning and an increase in savings
Employers are seeing the value in having healthy employees, not just physically
with medical coverage through benefits, but mentally with classes to educate employees
Reducing debt and managing finances well, allows employees’ to be more productive at
work.
cost-benefit analysis has also been provided. This is what managers can use to determine
financial education programs and compare them to other programs. This would be
beneficial when employers are choosing a program for their own company. They want to
know which program is the most effective by seeing the financial benefits.
decreases creativity at work. There was a brief mention by Verne (2014), that financial
stress causes employees to be less creative at work and produce a lower quality of work.
Creativity enhances organizations and allows them to stay ahead of their competitors
(Parjanen, 2012). According to Zhou & George (2003), creativity releases useful ideas
and solutions. Creativity requires focus (Amabile, Hadley & Kramer, 2002). All of the
findings about how creativity affects productivity are very brief. Additional studies are
needed to measure creativity and determine its impact on productivity in the workplace.
Research is also needed to distinguish between stress from finances and stress
from other factors. It is clear that stress affects job performance. However it would be
beneficial to have more in-depth studies that show the effects of stress that is solely from
personal finances.
Research is also needed to determine how important personal finances are to the
employee being examined. Some employees are less burdened by financial stress than
20
programs that have already been used. A comparative analysis of multiple financial
education programs would be very valuable to employers to see what programs are the
most successful in increasing employee productivity. This analysis would include the
benefit-cost ratio or ROI on each financial program so that managers can determine how
much of an impact each program has. Further research needs to be done to evaluate and
assess financial education programs more closely. It’s important to know how each one is
References
Amabile, T. M., Hadley, C.N., & Kramer, S.J. (2002). Creativity under the gun. Harvard
Business Review, 80(8), 52-61.
Andrews, L. (2005). Coping with divorce: Help maintain your employees’ workplace
productivity during a personal crisis. HR Magazine, 50(5), 58.
Baliga, W. (1995). Want higher profits? Try managing job performance. Journal of
Accountancy, 179(4), 13.
Dean, L., Joo, S., Gudmunson, C., Fischer, J., & Lambert, N. (2013). Debt begets debt:
Examining negative credit card behaviors and other forms of consumer debt. Journal
of Financial Service Professionals, 67(2), 72-143.
Garman, E. T., Leech, I.E., & Grable, J. E. (1996). The negative impact of employer poor
personal financial behaviors on employers. Financial Counseling and Planning,
7, 157-168.
Konrad, A. M., & Mangel, R. (2000). The impact of work-life programs on firm
productivity. Strategic Management Journal, 21(12), 1225-1237.
Lenneman, J., Schwartz, S., Giuseffi, D., & Wang, C. (2011). Productivity and health: an
application of three perspectives to measuring productivity. Journal of Occupational
and Environmental Medicine, 53(1), 55-61.
Meltzer, H., Bebbington, P., Brugha, T., Jenkins, R., McManus, S., & Dennis (2011).
Personal debt and suicidal ideation. Psychological Medicine, 41(4), 771.
Prawitz, A. D., & Cohart, J. (2014). Workplace financial education facilitates improvement
in personal financial behaviors. Journal of Financial Counseling and
Planning, 25(1), 5-26.
22
Pruter, R. (2001). Financial education can improve employee financial well-being, employer
profitability. Employee Benefit Plan Review, 55(9), 32-36.
Verne, J. (2014). Financial wellness programs to reduce employee stress. Compensation &
Benefits Review, 46(5-6), 304-308.