Line and load regulation

Lecture 2. Distortion, regulation and filters

Iline Iload
In this lecture:
• Regulation • Filters fight distortion Vline Power Vload
o Line and load regulation o RC filters supply
o Total harmonic distortion o RL filters
o Phase distortion & power factor o Example: Design a RC
o Other measures of regulation Low-pass filter o All power supplies are themselves supplied with line power
• An Ideal supply looks like o : e.g. a power supply in a P.C. is powered by 230VAC from the
o An absolutely flat DC level, or electricity company.
o A pure sinusoid
o Sometimes the line voltage can dip (brownout) or fail (blackout). In
• Real supplies are usually distorted by response to these fluctuations a power supply’s output voltage (Vload) might
dip a little, or dip a lot!
o unwanted signals: harmonic distortion from the power supply itself,
perhaps o For example, a P.C. with an uninterruptible power supply (UPS) can
often withstand line voltage fluctuations, keeping the supply to the
o the quality of the supply supplying the source P.C. constant.
o in A.C. supplies: the nature of the load, pulling the current out of
phase with the voltage (phase distortion)

• Regulation measures how close a real power supply is to the ideal.

EE301 GB02 page 1 EE301 GB02 page 2

o Line regulation is a measure of how well a power supply can withstand Total harmonic distortion
fluctuations in the line voltage, to provide voltage to the load. Total harmonic distortion is a measure of how distorted an A.C. signal with
harmonic distortion is. It compares the powers at higher-order harmonics to
where the power at the fundamental frequency.
Vload max − Vload min o Vload max = Vload for maximum Vline
Line regulation = ∞ ∞

∑P ∑V Pk is the power in harmonic k

2
Vload nominal o Vload min = Vload for minimum Vline k k
o Vload nominal = Vload for nominal Vline k =1 k =1 where Vk is the voltage magnitude in
THD = =
P0 V0
2 harmonic k

o Load regulation is a measure of how well a power supply can withstand

fluctuations in the load power drawn. In the examples of lecture 1:

o For example a D.C. machine draws much more current when it’s Pure sinusoid: only one harmonic present (the zeroth), so that there are no
starting up than when it’s operating at full speed. A good supply can higher harmonics:
deliver close to nominal voltage under both conditions. 0
THD = 2
=0
Vm
Vload (max line ) − Vload (min line ) Vload (max line) = Vload for maximum Vline
Load regulation =
Vload ( no min al Vload (min line) = Vload for minimum Vline
line ) Two sinusoids: two harmonics:
Vload (nominal line) = Vload for nominal Vline 2
⎛1 ⎞
⎜ Vm ⎟
THD =
P1
= ⎝2 ⎠ = 1
2
P0 Vm 2

EE301 GB02 page 3 EE301 GB02 page 4

Rectified sinusoid: Consider just the first four (even) harmonics, with Phase Distortion in A.C. supplies
amplitudes as shown below.
o An inductive load causes iload(t) to lag vload(t)
Harmonic 0 1 2 3 4
o A capacitive load causes iload(t) to lead vload(t)
Amplitude Vm 0.13Vm 0.08Vm 0.05Vm 0.04Vm
o In both cases some of the energy delivered to the load in each cycle flows
back to the source!
o So the total power delivered is less than V×I. This is a kind of distortion,
called phase distortion. How much less?
Question: calculate the total harmonic distortion of the rectified Consider an A.C. power supply driving a load, with
sinusoid.
v load (t ) = Vm sin ωt
P1 + P2 + P3 + P4
THD = drawing a current that is out of phase with the voltage (could be lagging or
P0 leading the voltage) by a phase angle φ radians, corresponding to a lag or
(0.13Vm )2 + (0.08Vm )2 + (0.05Vm )2 + (0.04Vm )2 lead in time of φ /ω: sec:
=
i load (t ) = I m sin(ωt + φ )
2
Vm
= 16.5%.
(Figure 2.1a). The instantaneous power drawn is

EE301 GB02 page 5 EE301 GB02 page 6

p(t ) = v load (t ) × i load (t ) = Vm I m sin ωt sin(ωt + φ ) So the power also flows in a sinusoidal shape (see Figure 2.1b):

A little trigonometry gives o twice the frequency of the supply voltage

o not centred on 0, but offset by a constant amount.

p(t ) =
Vm I m
[cos(2ωt + φ ) + cos φ ]
2
So what’s the average power drawn by the load over a cycle? It’s a little less
than VmIm.
v(t)=Vmsinωt
Area under curve in one cycle
i(t)=Imsin(ωt-φ)
P=
length of one cycle
t =T ωt = 2π
1 1 Vm I m
[cos(2ωt + φ ) + cos φ ] dωt
T t =∫0 ∫
π 2π 3π ωt = p(t ) dt =
2π ω t =0
2
φ
A little maths eventually gives
p(t)=v(t)i(t)
Vm I m
P= cos φ = Vrms I rms cos φ [Where did I get this?]
2
P=½VmImcosφ

ωt

Figure 2.1. (a) Load voltage and current out of phase. (b) some of the energy flowing into
the load flows out again in each cycle.
EE301 GB02 page 7 EE301 GB02 page 8
o So the average load power (sometimes called the active power) is smaller 2. Temperature Variation is a measure of the output voltage variation
than the apparent power S=VrmsIrms by a factor cosφ. This factor is called due to temperature, as components heat up or cool down.
the power factor, and is always less than or equal to 1.
• Important: circuits heat up as power is dissipated; this can change
o P=V.I.cosφ is called the active power the performance of the circuit itself

o Q=V.I.sinφ is called the reactive power. This is the power that is bounced • For example: resistors decrease in value with rising temperature
out of the load back to the supply.

o The electricity company usually objects if your power factor is too low
Filters fight distortion
• for instance, if your load is a large machine (looks like an inductor!)
Two common solutions to the harmonic problem:
• too much reactive power bouncing back at their power stations!
1. Produce less distortion! Design better supplies that minimize switching
• So sometimes power factor correction is built into your power supply. harmonics – use specialised components

2. Filter the rest: Eradicate unwanted harmonics and noise using filters

Other measures of regulation The two simplest filter types:

1. Long-Term drift is a useful measure of the variation in the supply 1. RC filters – resistors + capacitors
output over long periods, such as hours, days or even weeks.
2. RL filters – resistors + inductors

More sophisticated filters use combinations of these.

EE301 GB02 page 9 EE301 GB02 page 10

How do inductors and capacitors smooth things out? Low-pass RC filter

1. Capacitors resist voltage change Recall: a low-pass RC filter looks like

• VC changes slowly, stiffening the supply voltage. R R

• Connect in parallel with the load

vin(t) vout(t) Vin(jω) 1 Vout(jω)
C jωC
2. Inductors resist current change

• IL changes slowly, smoothing out current supplies.

• Connect in series with the load Using phasor analysis, the transfer function turns out to be
These effects are extremely useful in filters. Vout ( jω ) 1
T ( jω ) = =
Vin ( jω ) ω
1+ j
ωp

1
where ω p = is called
RC

• pole frequency, or

• 3dB frequency, or

• cutoff frequency.
EE301 GB02 page 11 EE301 GB02 page 12
To filter out unwanted high-frequency signals using an RC filter, simply Low-pass RL filter
choose R and C such that the cutoff frequency is comfortably below the
lowest harmonic frequency. Recall: a low-pass RL filter looks like

L jω L

But look out! The lower the cutoff frequency we want, the larger R and C
have to be! vin(t) R vout(t) Vin(jω) R Vout(jω)

• A larger R causes larger power (I R) losses in the filter

2

• A larger C is pretty expensive!

Using phasor analysis, the transfer function turns out to be
• The best solution is usually a tradeoff between
Vout ( jω ) 1
o Cost and T ( jω ) = =
Vin ( jω ) ω
1+ j
o effectiveness. ωp

where this time the cutoff frequency is given by

R
ωp = rad/s
L

Inductors are rather expensive and bulky compared to capacitors, so RL

filters are not used nearly as often as RC filters.
EE301 GB02 page 13 EE301 GB02 page 14

Example: Design a RC Low-pass filter At this frequency, the magnitude of the output voltage looks like

Design a low-pass RC filter to attenuate an unwanted 100Hz harmonic from a Vout ( jω h ) 1 1 1

T ( jω h ) = = = = = 0.45.
DC voltage source. Vin ( jω h ) ⎛ω ⎞
2
⎛ 200π ⎞
2
5
1+ ⎜ h ⎟ 1+ ⎜ ⎟
The unwanted component is at fh=100 Hz. This corresponds to an ⎜ω
⎝ p
⎟
⎠ ⎝ 100π ⎠
angular frequency ωh=2π×100=200π.
So if we put ωp at 50 Hz, then the 100 Hz harmonic will be attenuated to
Where to put ωp? Let’s try a few possibilities. about 45% of its original amplitude. A little better.

1. Try ωp= ωh = 200π. Now we have decided ωp = 100π rad/s, How to choose R and C?
At this frequency, the magnitude of the output voltage can be got from 1
• We must choose R and C so that ω p = , so we have a little freedom.
the transfer function: RC
But remember, a good supply does not itself dissipate much power!
V ( jω h ) 1 1 1
T ( jω h ) = out = = = = 0.707.
Vin ( jω h ) 2 2
2 • A large series R dissipates large i2R power – bad idea!
⎛ω ⎞ ⎛ωp ⎞
1+ ⎜ h ⎟ 1+ ⎜ ⎟
⎜ω ⎟ ⎜ω ⎟ • So increase C – better idea.
⎝ p ⎠ ⎝ p ⎠

So if we put ωp equal to ωh, then the harmonic at ωh will only be • Choose R=10 Ω
attenuated to 0.707 of its original amplitude. Not very good!
• Then C turns out to be about 318 µF. (Work it out yourself, then hit the
2. Try ωp=½ωh = =2π×50=100π.rad/s. forum.)

EE301 GB02 page 15 EE301 GB02 page 16

Questions
1. By how much will the 100Hz harmonic be attenuated if we choose the
pole frequency to be 10Hz?

2. If we wanted an attenuation of at least 90% (the 100Hz harmonic

attenuated to 10% or less) what pole frequency would we choose?

• Can’t figure it out? Check the forum for tips.

END OF LECTURE

EE301 GB02 page 17