Recycled Brazil
Recycled Brazil
Recycled Brazil
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO – SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Adnan Qadir
Associate Professor of Department Civil Engineering
NED University of Engineering and Technology,
Karachi-75270, PAKISTAN
[email protected]
Paper 017-01 1
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
ABSTRACT
Municipal solid waste (MSW) typically comprises of 7-13%(1,2,3), plastic materials, largely
polyethylene (PE - HDPE & LDPE). In urban centres of developing countries, for instance in
Karachi, plastic waste is being generated mostly in the form of shopping bags which is not
collected for subsequent recycling due to having waste characteristics (such as, lightness and
accumulation of dirt) which makes it inappropriate for effective pre-processing required for
recycling. It is therefore, left unmanaged in the urban environment as ‘unwanted waste material’
having zero scrap value. The environmental problems caused by this particular waste are not
only of aesthetic nature but also causes failure of sewerage systems. It has remained ever since a
daunting challenge for environmentalists and in particular to waste managers who are yet been
unable to come up with a sustainable solution for its ultimate safe disposal. This study is a part of
doctoral research investigating into the possible use of plastic waste into a form of ‘aggregate’
material (recycled plastic waste aggregate – RPWA). The source of raw material is mainly waste
polyethylene bags that are transformed into an aggregate form by extrusion process. The RPWA
is subsequently used as a partial substitution material with mineral / natural aggregate (NA) in
asphalt mix design for wearing course of pavement structure. Preliminary tests indicate that
stability, flow (Marshall Test) and volumetric characteristics of new mix such as bulk specific
gravity having RPWA as a partial substitution material for natural aggregate yielded improved
mix design. Initial tests were carried out replacing 15% (coarse and fine) aggregate with crushed
RPWA (ranging in between 3/8”-1/8”) showed that the Marshall stability of the new mix
increased up to 40% when compared to the control (blank) mix. Unit weight and bulk specific
gravity of prepared mixes fell well within the specified range of conventional asphalt mix for
light traffic load. With the preliminary testing, it is envisaged that use of RPWA as a partial
replacement or substitution material for natural aggregate in conventional asphalt mix design will
improve the performance of pavement (resistance to shoving and rutting) and hence provide a
sustainable solution for ultimate safe disposal of plastic bags waste.
KEY WORDS
Pavement material, partial substitution or replacement material, plastic waste recycling, recycled
plastic waste aggregate
Paper 017-01 2
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
INTRODUCTION
With the advent of latest technologies in packaging and packaging materials the production of
waste related to this industries has increased several folds over the past few decades. Use of
plastics due to its lightness, strength and durability as a packaging material has been well
established and has taken over completely thereby making other conventional materials obsolete.
This is not only restricted to packaging but also introduction of plastics as a replacement material
for metal and wood, etc. has been also observed which has markedly changed the trend for use of
natural raw material. The unprecedented production of plastic material and subsequent
manufacturing of products (having comparatively very short useful life) resulted in generation of
substantially large and unmanageable quantities of plastic waste. Plastics being non-degradable
have limited recycling options also due to its material characteristics, which deteriorate on
recycling and problems in collection, segregation, etc. Plastics in landfill are not a sustainable
solution and similarly incineration is also not environment friendly due to toxic emissions, which
require strict control and monitoring. A sustainable solution for the disposal of plastic waste may
be either total recycling or it should be utilised in such a manner that it may be completely
removed from the waste stream and hence ultimately disposed off in an environmentally
acceptable manner. One such possible solution may be the use of plastic waste in construction,
particularly in roads and pavement, which on one hand would eliminate plastics from solid waste
stream and on the other hand would improve the quality and durability of the road surfaces and
pavement structure. Attempts have been made to investigate the possible use of plastic waste as a
supplement or additional road paving material. It may be either be used as a part of asphalt
binder (4), (mixing and blending into asphalt cement material) or as ‘aggregate’ material in the
asphalt mix design. The following investigation has been focused on the use of plastic waste
particularly the waste obtained form the plastic bags transformed into aggregate material and as
partial substitution or replacement material in the conventional asphalt mix.
Literature Review
Considerable work has been done on the use of plastics with asphalt and bituminous binder
having various applications such as utilisation of plastic waste in developing composite
construction material, in production of modified asphalt binder, and as a substitute aggregate or
filler material in cement and bituminous concrete. An application by the name of ‘cold patch’ a
bituminous material obtained from plastics (5) has been developed for specific repairs and / or
patch large cracks and potholes in a paved area. Recycled polyethylene from grocery bags may
find its application in asphalt (bituminous) pavements, resulting in reduced permanent
deformation in the form of rutting and reduced low-temperature cracking of the pavement
surfacing (6). Portland cement, water, sand and various plastics (PVC, LDPE, PP, PS and HIPS)
were mixed in proportions to develop a concrete (Plas-Crete) and its compressive strength with
varying cement content and thickness of plastics was investigated. The results indicated that
Plas-Crete might potentially be used in flooring, sound insulation and roofing panels (7). HDPE-
modified binder showed substantial improvement in Marshall stability (strength) and a Marshall
quotient (resistance to deformation) values. The modified mix showed improved stability
characteristics up to 50% of the blank mix design (8). Processed plastic bags were used as an
additive in bituminous concrete mixes having up to 12% by weight, was blended manually by
Paper 017-01 3
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
heating the bitumen. The average mean stability value of the mix using the modified binder
containing 4.6% bitumen having 8% processed plastic, i.e. 0.4% of the total mix weight, gave a
three fold increase compared to conventional mix design (9). A synthetic lightweight aggregate
(SLA) was manufactured by melt-compounding high concentration of fly ash from coal and
plastics (PVC, LDPE, PP, PS and HIPS). SLA samples by varying fly ash to plastic ratio were
tested for specific gravity, bulk density, absorption potential and LA abrasion values. The result
showed that SLA compounds have a high potential to be used in asphalt pavements (10).
Experiments were carried out using granulated plastic, glass, and fibreglass waste materials by
partially substituting fine aggregate (sand) in concrete composites. The substitution carried out
was in 5, 10, 15, and 20% by volumetric proportion. The composite materials were tested for
their compressive, flexural, and splitting tensile strength. It was concluded that the new material
is reliable for use as a partial volume substitute for sand in concrete mixes (11). Development of
a modified bituminous binder material by using plastic waste was attempted (12,13) and was
discovered that durability and fatigue life of the modified asphalt mix increased in comparison to
conventional mix. Utilisation of processed plastic bags as an additive in bituminous concrete
mixes up to 12% by weight of total mix was possible.
Paper 017-01 4
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Determination of properties of Asphalt Cement
Asphalt grade used was 60-70 penetration grades as recommended for construction of roads and
highways by National Highway Authority (NHA)(14). The grade of asphalt binder was further
verified (ASTM D-5) in the laboratory prior to testing as the material might have deteriorated
during storage. Specific gravity of asphalt binder was also determined (ASTM D-70).
Preparation of Specimen
A number of specimens, half with conventional / natural aggregate and half having RPWA
replacing natural aggregate size retained on #8 and #16 sieve were prepared.
Mix Compacted
US sieve 1" 3/4" 3/8" No 4 No 8 No 16 No 200
designation thickness
50-100 % By wt
Class 100 90-100 56-70 35-50 23-35 5-12 2-8
mm passing
Source: NHA, General Specification 1998
Paper 017-01 5
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Preparation of test specimens
The aggregate mix was taken in sufficient quantity to produce compacted bituminous mix
specimens of approximate thickness of 63.5 mm. Normally, 1200 gm of aggregate and filler is
required to produce a specimen of desired thickness. The aggregate mix was then heated to a
temperature of 150ºC to 165ºC; the compaction mould assembly and rammer were cleaned and
kept pre-heated to a temperature of 100oC to 145oC. The bitumen / asphalt preheated to a
temperature of 121oC to 138oC (5% by total weight of aggregate mix) was added and mixed
thoroughly (manually). The prepared mix was then placed in the mould and compacted with 75
blows with the standard rammer on each side of the mould. The sample was taken out of the
mould after few minutes using sample extractor. Hence controlled (blank) and RPWA specimen
were prepared following the same procedure.
Where:
A = Dry weight of specimen (g)
B = Surface dried weight of specimen (g)
C = Weight of specimen in water (g)
γspecimen = γw Gmb--------------------------(2)
A
Gmm = ---------------------------------(3)
A+ B+C
Where:
A = Weight of Dry Sample (g)
B = Weight of pycnometer completely filled with water (g)
C = Weight of pycnometer filled with water and sample (g)
Void Analyses
The percent air voids, or voids in the total mix (Pa), in the compacted mixtures were determined
(ASTM D 2041). Percent air voids is the air voids in the compacted sample are expressed as a
percentage of the total volume of the sample. Percent air voids was computed as:
G − Gmb
Pa = mm × 100 -----------------------------------(4)
Gmm
Where:
A = Average bulk specific gravity of three specimens
B = Maximum theoretical specific gravity of the mixture
Where:
A = Average bulk specific gravity of compacted mixture
B = Percent by weight of aggregate mixture
C = Bulk specific gravity of combined aggregate
Paper 017-01 7
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
The percent voids filled with asphalt (VFA) are the percentage of the VMA that is made up of
asphalt. The percent voids filled with asphalt was calculated using the following relationship:
VMA − Pa
VFA = × 100 -----------------------------(6)
VMA
MIX DESIGN RESULTS
The summarized results obtained are shown in Table 3 and 4 are shown graphically from Figure
1 to Figure 8
Table 3- Results of Test performed on RPWA samples
% Ac By Wt Of Mix 4
% Ac By Wt Of Aggregate 4.16
Average
Max. theoretical specific gravity, Gmm 2.536
Sample Number 1 2 3 4 5
Bulk Sp.Gr.Comp.Mix Gmb 2.376 2.402 2.422 2.431 2.43 2 .400
Air Voids (%) 6 5 4 4 4 5
Voids in Mineral Agg., % VMA 14.38 12.55 11.82 15.93 11.55 13
Voids Filled with Asphalt, % VFA 56 58 62 74 64 63
Unit Weight, (lbs/cuft) 148.25 149.9 151.15 151.69 151.62 151
Stability (lbs) 2,220 2,097 2,438 2,480 2,045 2256
Flow (x 0.01 inch) 24 22 26 24 26 24
Stability/Flow 92 95 95 103 79 93
Stability Retained 82%
Paper 017-01 8
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Figure 1-Comparison of Bulk Specific Gravity
2.5
2.45
2.4
2.35
BSG 2.3
2.25
2.2
2.1
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
5
Air voids,%
1 RPWA
Controlled sample
0
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
Paper 017-01 9
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Figure 3-Comparison of Voids in Mineral Aggregate (VMA)
16
15
14
VMA,%
13
12
11
RPWA
Controlled Sample
10
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
90
85
80
75
VFA,%
70
65
60
55 RPWA
Controlled Sample
50
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
Paper 017-01 10
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Figure 5-Comparison of Unit Weight
155
Unit Weight, lbs/cu ft
150
RPWA
145
Controlled Sample
140
135
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
4,000
STABILITY, lbs
3,000
RPWA
Controlled Sample
2,000
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
Paper 017-01 11
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Figure 7-Comparison of Flow Value
29
27
25
FLOW, 0.01in
23
21
19
17
Controlled Sample
RPWA
15
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
250
200
STABILTY/FLOW
150
100
RPWA
Controlled Sample
50
0 1 2 3 4 5
Sample Number
Paper 017-01 12
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
COMPARISON OF COSTS
70
60
40
30
20
10
RESULT ANALYSIS
• From Table 5, by comparing the results of controlled and RPWA mix containing only 2.5%
partial substitution plastic waste by weight of the total mix weight has contributed
substantially towards the improvement of engineering characteristics of the pavement mix.
• Increase in the optimum asphalt content required to prepare the modified plastic waste mix
indicates that plastic aggregate require more asphalt content due to increase in nearly 2.5
times of the volume of replaced natural aggregate by its weight percent.
• Decrease in unit weight is advantageous as in terms of haulage cost and lighter bituminous
concrete mix will also enable less workmanship involved in repairs and maintenance work.
• Decrease in air void percentage and subsequent improvement in the percentage of voids
filled with asphalt indicates that mix material has been much consolidated. It also illustrates
that the distribution of binder material has been much effective which ensures better
encapsulation and coating of the aggregate material making the overall mix a more
monolithic in response to external load and uniform deformation.
• The stability value has increased nearly doubled which is a characteristic essentially required
for the improved durability and resistance to rutting and shoving of pavement. Similarly
reduction in flow values is also appreciable and indicates less susceptibility to deformation
that is again a preferred characteristic of the pavement structure particularly of pavement
surface.
Paper 017-01 13
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
Table 5 - Summary of the experimental investigations performed with controlled and RPWA mix
Voids in Mineral
13 14 +7.69%
Aggregate (VMA%)
Marshall Quotient
93 184 +97.85%
lb/inch*
CONCLUSION
The preliminary investigations have indicated that the use of recycled plastic waste in the form
of aggregate by partial substitution; in the pavement mix design is quite remarkable in
improving its engineering characteristics. Though initially very little quantity by weight has
been experimented but the results are unexpectedly significant and positive. It is proposed that
quantities of RPWA may be increased further to exploit maximum utilisation of plastic waste
(particularly plastic bags) in order to have a sustainable, ultimate safe disposal solution. On
the basis of result analysis the following conclusions may be drawn:
• Substitution of RPWA may be advantageous in reducing the cost of haulage, as unit
weight of mix used in the pavement is reduced.
• RPWA (modified) mix results in higher stability values, and also higher Marshall
quotient, which is a desirable characteristic of pavement mix that may reduce rutting
problem.
Paper 017-01 14
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16
• Plastic waste modified mix has improved ratio of stability retained in comparison to
controlled sample, which is a positive characteristic indicating good water-resistant
quality
• RPWA is likely to provide a sustainable solution for disposal of plastic waste.
REFERENCES:
1. http://www.dnr.state.wi.us/org/aw/wm/publications/recycle/summarywastecharacterization2002.pdf
2. http://www.ciwmb.ca.gov/WasteChar/
3. http://www.zerowaste.co.nz/default,341.sm
4. Schroeder R L; 1994, "The use of recycled materials in highway construction", Journal
Public Roads, Vol. 58, No. 2 (1994)
5. Conigliaro A; et al. 2000, “Determining the best formulation for a unique asphalt cold patch
product made with #3-7 rigid plastic aggregate”, Technical Report #14, January 2000.
Chelsea Center for Recycling and Economic Development, Technical Research Program,
University of Massachusetts, Lowell, USA Hinislioglu S; and Agar E; 2004, “Use of waste
high density polyethylene as bitumen modifier in asphalt concrete mix”, Turkey Materials
Letters, January 2004, vol. 58, no. 3, pp. 267-271(5)
6. Flynn L; 1993, "Recycled plastic finds home in asphalt binder", Journal Roads and Bridges,
March 1993
7. Hooper F; 2000, “Plas-crete: a lightweight, portland cement concrete product manufactured
from discarded mixed no. 3–7 plastics”, Technical Report # 42, JULY 2002. Chelsea Center
for Recycling and Economic Development, Technical Research Program, University of
Massachusetts, Lowell, USA
8. Hinislioglu S; and Agar E; 2004, “Use of waste high density polyethylene as bitumen
modifier in asphalt concrete mix”, Turkey Materials Letters, January 2004, vol. 58, no. 3, pp.
267-271(5)
9. Justo C G et al.; 2002, "Utilisation of plastic bags in bituminous mix for improved
performance of roads” (unpublished), Centre for Transportation Engineering, Bangalore
University, Bangalore, India.
10. Mohsen G Kashi; 2000, “Fly ash / plastic synthetic aggregate for construction material”,
Technical Report # 45, August 2002, Chelsea Center for Recycling and Economic
Development, Technical Research Program, University of Massachusetts, Lowell, USA
11. Shehata I.; Varzavand S; El Sawy A; and Fahmy M; 2002, “The use of solid waste materials
as fine aggregate substitutes in cementitious concrete composites”, Department of Industrial
Technology, University of Northern Iowa, USA
12. Zoorob, S E; and Suparma L B; 2000, "Laboratory design and investigation of proportion of
bituminous composite containing waste recycled plastics aggregate replacement
(Plastiphalt)”, CIB Symposium on Construction and Environment Theory into Practice, Sao
Paulo, Brazil (November 2000)
13. Zoorob S E; and Suparma L B; 2000, "Laboratory design of improved continuously graded
asphaltic concrete containing recycled plastic aggregates (Plastiphalt)", 2nd Eurasphalt &
Eurobitumen Congress, 20-22 September 2000, Barcelona, pp. 708-717.
14. National Highway Authority, Pakistan (NHA), General Specification 1998
Paper 017-01 15
2005 INTERNATIONAL SYMPOSIUM ON
PAVEMENT RECYCLING
SÃO PAULO ● SP – BRAZIL - MARCH 14 – 16